Abstract
Insider trading has received a bad name in recent decades. The popular press makes it sound like an evil practice where those who engage in it are totally devoid of ethical principles. Yet not all insider trading is unethical and some studies have concluded that certain kinds of insider trading are actually beneficial to the greater investment community. Some scholars in philosophy, law and economics have disputed whether insider trading should be punished at all while others assert that it should be illegal in all cases. This paper explores the nature of insider trading and analyzes the issues to determine the positive and negative aspects of insider trading, and how policy should be changed. The best hope would be for studies to be made that isolate the individuals or groups who are fraudulently harmed by insider trading. If any such groups exist, then clearly worded legislation could be passed to prevent any fraud from being committed against these individuals and groups, while allowing non-fraudulent transactions to be completed without fear of prosecution. Until it can be clearly determined that someone is fraudulently harmed by insider trading, there should be no law or regulation restricting the practice, since such restrictions violate individual rights and will likely have a negative market reaction.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Anderson, W.: 2002, The Attack on Martha (The Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn, AL), June 26. www.mises.org
Anderson, W. L.: 2003a, ‚Martha and the Media’, LewRockwell.com, June 13
Anderson, W. L.: 2003b, Martha Stewart: Political Prisoner (The Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn, AL), June 9, www.mises.org
Aquinas, St. Thomas. Summa Theologica, II-II, Q.77
Bandow, D.: 1988, ‚Curbing Raiders is Bad for Business’, The New York Times, February 7
Barath D. (1960) The Just Price and the Costs of Production According to St. Thomas Aquinas. New Scholasticism 34, 413–430
Bartell E. (1962). Value, Price, and St. Thomas. The Thomist 25(3), 359–360
Bernardo A. E. (2001) Contractual Restrictions on Insider Trading: A Welfare Analysis. Economic Theory 18, 7–35
Bhattacharya U., Daouk H. (2002). The World Price of Insider Trading. The Journal of Finance 57(1), 75–108
Boatright J. R. (1997) Fiduciary duty In: Werhane P. H., R. E. Freeman, (eds), The Blackwell Encyclopedic Dictionary of Business Ethics. Blackwell, Oxford
Boudreaux, D. J.: n.d., ‚Insider-Trading Prohibitions Should Go out of Style’, Future of Freedom Foundation, Fairfax, VA, no date. www.fff.org
Bovard J. (1991) The Fair Trade Fraud. St. Martin’s Press, New York
Brudney V. (1979) Insiders, Outsiders, and Informational Advantage under the Federal Securities Law. Harvard Law Review 93, 322–376
Bubb F. W. (1986) Hostile Acquisitions and the Restructuring of Corporate America. The Freeman, May, 36(5), 166–176
Buttarazzi, J. E.: 1987, ‚Corporate Takeovers: What is the Federal Role?’ Backgrounder 606, The Heritage Foundation, September 29
Carlton D. W., Fischel D. R. (1983) The Regulation of Insider Trading. Stanford Law Review 35(5), 857–895
Central Hudson Gas & Electric Corporation v. Public Service Commission: 1980, 447 U.S. 557
Chiarella v. United States: 1980, 445 U.S. 222
Coffee, J. C., Jr., J. A. Grundfest, R. Romano and M. L. Weidenbaum: 1988, ‚Corporate Takeovers: Who Wins; Who Loses; Who Should Regulate?’ Regulation 88(1), 23–29, 47–51
Crisp R. (1997) Mill on Utilitarianism. Routledge, London and New York
Dalcourt G. J. (1965) The Philosophy and Writings of St. Thomas Aquinas. Simon and Schuster/Monarch Press, New York
Demsetz H. (1969) Perfect Competition, Regulation, and the Stock Market, In: Henry G. Manne (eds.), Economic Policy and the Regulation of Corporate Securities. American Enterprise Institute, Washington, DC
Dirks v. Securities and Exchange Commission, 463 U.S. 646 (1983)
Dooley M. P. (1980) Enforcement of Insider Trading Restrictions. Virginia Law Review 66, 1–83
Dostoevsky, F.: 1952,‚The Brothers Karamazov’, in M. H. Robert, editor in chief, Great Books of the Western World, Vol. 52 (Encyclopedia Britannica, Chicago)
Easterbrook, F. H.: 1981. ‚Insider Trading, Secret Agents, Evidentiary Privileges, and the Production of Information. Supreme Court Review II, 309–365
Engelen, P. J. and L. Van Liedekerke: 2003, An Ethical Analysis of Regulating Insider Trading. Fifth International Conference on Ethics and Environmental Policy, Kyiv, April 2–6. Reprinted at www.fondazionelanza.it/epa/abstract/engelen_full.pdf
Fama, E. and A. Laffer: 1971, ‚Information and Capital Markets’, Journal of Business July, 289–298
Federal Securities Law Reports, No. 1304, Part II, September 21, 1988
Finnerty J. E. (1976) Insiders and Market Efficiency. The Journal of Finance 31(4), 1141–1148
Fleischer, Mundheim and Murphy: 1973, ‚An Initial Inquiry into the Responsibility to Disclose Market Information’, University of Pennsylvania Law Review 121, 798–841
Frey R. G. (eds), (1984). Utility and Rights. University of Minnesota Press, Minnedapolis
Goodin R. E. (1995) Utilitarianism as a Public Philosophy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK and New York
Herzel, L. and L. Katz: 1987, ‚Insider Trading: Who Loses?’ Lloyds Bank Review July, 15–26
Hetherington J. A. C. (1967) Insider Trading and the Logic of the Law. Wisconsin Law Review 1967, 720–737
Jarell G. A., Brickley J. A., Netter J. M. (1988) The Market for Corporate Control: The Empirical Evidence Since 1980. Journal of Economic Perspectives 2(1), 49–68
Jensen M. C. (1984) Takeovers: Folklore and Science. Harvard Business Review 62(6), 109–121
Johnson J. A. (1986–1987) Antitakeover Legislation: Not Necessary, Not Wise. Cleveland State Law Review, 35, 303–348
Kelly W. A., Nardinelli Jr. C., Wallace M. S. (1987) Regulation of Insider Trading: Rethinking SEC Policy Rules. The Cato Journal 7(2), 441–448
Lehmann, J.: 2004, ‚Martha’s Head on a Platter’, New York Post, Florida edition, March 6, pp. 2–3
Leland H. E. (1992) Insider Trading: Should it be Prohibited?. Journal of Political Economy 100(4), 859–887
Lowe v. SEC, 105 S.Ct. 2557 (1985)
Macey J. R. (1988) The SEC’s Insider Trading Proposal: Good Politics, Bad Policy. Policy Analysis No. 101. Washington, DC: Cato Institute, March 31, p. 2
Machan T. (1996) What is Morally Right with Insider Trading?. Public Affairs Quarterly 10(2), 135–141
Manne H. G. (1966a) Insider Trading and the Stock Market. The Free Press, New York
Manne, H. G.: 1966b, ‚In Defense of Insider Trading’, Harvard Business Review November/December, 113–122
Manne H. G. (1970) Insider Trading and the Law Professors. Vanderbilt Law Review 23, 547–590
Manne, H. G.: 1985, ‚Insider Trading and Property Rights in New Information’, The Cato Journal 4(3), 933–943, reprinted in James A. Dorn and Henry G. Manne (eds.), Economic Liberties and the Judiciary. Fairfax, VA: George Mason University Press, 1987, 317–327
Manne, H. G.: 1986, ‚The Real Boesky-Case Issue’, The New York Times, November 25, A-27, column 1
Martin J. K. (1986) Insider Trading and the Misappropriation Theory: Has the Second Circuit Gone Too Far?. St. John’s Law Review 61, 78–112
McDowell, C.: 2003, ‚The Non-Crime of Insider Trading’, June 11. LewRockwell.com
McGee R.W. (1994) The Fatal Flaw in NAFTA, GATT and All Other Trade Agreements. Northwestern Journal of International Law, Business 14(3), 549–565
McMenamin M. (1988) Witchhunt. Reason 20(5), 34–40
McMenamin, M. and W. Gorenc, Jr.: 1983, ‚Subverting the First Amendment’, Reason January, 23–28
Moore J. 1990. What is Really Unethical about Insider Trading?. Journal of Business Ethics 9, 171–182
Morgan R. J. (1987) Insider Trading and the Infringement of Property Rights. Ohio State Law Journal 48, 79–116
Nash, N. C.: 1988, ‚Congress Passes Greater Penalties and Detection on Insider Trading’, The New York Times, October 22, 1, 31
Nozick R. (1974) Anarchy, State, and Utopia. Basic Books, New York
O’Hara P. A. (2001) Insider Trading in Financial Markets: Legality, Ethics, Efficiency. International Journal of Social Economics 28(10, 11, 12), 1046–1062
Ostrowski, J.: 2002, Wanted for Outsider Trading (The Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn, AL), August 26. www.mises.org
Padilla A. (2002a) Can Agency Theory Justify the Regulation of Insider Trading?. The Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics 5(1), 3–38
Padilla, A.: 2002b, ‚The Modern Witch Hunt’, LewRockwell.com, October 22
Peyser, A.: 2004, ‚Arrogant Billionaire Played The Ultimate Fool’, New York Post, Florida edition, March 6, p. 4
Powe Jr. L. A. (1987) American Broadcasting and the First Amendment. University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles
Prychitko, D. L.: 1987, Corporate Takeovers and Shareholder Interests. Issue Alert No. 13 (Citizens for a Sound Economy, Washington, DC)
Qu C. Z. (2001) An Outsider’s View on China’s Insider Trading Law. Pacific Rim Law Policy Journal, 10, 327–352
Ricardo D. (1871/1996) Principles of Political Economy and Taxation. Prometheus Books, Amherst, NY
Rider B. A., Ffrench L. (1979) The Regulation of Insider Trading. Oceana, Dobbs Ferry, NY
Romano R. (1987) The Political Economy of Takeover Statutes. Virginia Law Review 73, 111–199
Ronen J. (1977) The Effect of Insider Trading Rules on Information Generation and Disclosure by Corporations. The Accounting Review 52(2), 438–449
Rothbard M. N. (1970) Man, Economy and State. Nash Publishing, Los Angeles
Salbu S. R. 1992. A Critical Analysis of Misappropriation Theory in Insider Trading Cases. Business Ethics Quarterly 2(4), 465–477
Schoeck H. (1966) Envy. Harcourt Brace and World, New York
Schotland R. A. (1967) Unsafe at Any Price: A Reply to Manne, Insider Trading and the Stock Market. Virginia Law Review 53, 1425–1478
Scott K. E. (1980) Insider Trading: Rule 10b-5, Disclosure and Corporate Privacy. Journal of Legal Studies 9, 801–818
Shaw W. H. (1999) Contemporary Ethics: Taking Account of Utilitarianism. Blackwell, Malden, MA and Oxford
Sheaffer R. (1988) Resentment Against Achievement: Understanding the Assault Upon Ability. Prometheus Books, Buffalo
Smith A. (1776/1953) The Wealth of Nations. Henry Regnery Company, Chicago
Strudler A., Orts E. W. (1999). Moral Principle in the Law of Insider Trading. Texas Law Review 78, 375–438
United States v. Carpenter, 791 F.2d 1024 (1986)
Webster’s New World Dictionary of the American Language: 1964, College edition (Cleveland and New York: World Publishing Co.)
Werhane P. H. (1989). The Ethics of Insider Trading. Journal of Business Ethics 8, 841–845
Wolfson N. (1987) Civil Liberties and Regulation of Insider Trading. In: Dorn J. A., Manne H. G. (eds.), Economic Liberties and the Judiciary. George Mason University Press, Fairfax, VA, (pp. 329–334)
Woodward, S. E.: 1988, ‚How Much Indiana’s Anti-Takeover Law Cost Shareholders’, The Wall Street Journal, May 5
Wu H. K. (1968) An Economist Looks at Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Columbia Law Review 68, 260–269
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Robert W. McGee is a professor at the Andreas School of Business, Barry University in Miami, Florida, USA. He has published more than 50 books and more than 400 scholarly papers in the fields of accounting, taxation, economics, law, philosophy and ethics. He holds doctorates in several fields, including accounting, economics, law and philosophy. He is an attorney and a certified public accountant (CPA).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McGee, R.W. Applying Ethics to Insider Trading. J Bus Ethics 77, 205–217 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9344-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9344-6