Abstract
In the current era, governments are playing smaller roles in regulating workers’ rights internationally, and transnational corporations (TNCs), non-governmental organisations (NGOs) involved in the struggle for workers’ rights, and labour/trade unions have started to fill this governance gap. This paper focuses on the least researched of the relationships among these three actors, the union–NGO relationship, by analysing the ways in which it affects definitions of TNC responsibility for workers’ rights at their suppliers’ factories. Based on a qualitative study of the union–NGO relationship in the Swedish garment industry between 1996 and 2005, we propose that there are six main configurations of union–NGO relationships. By linking these configurations to their effects on TNC responsibility, we propose that co-ordination relationships between unions and NGOs, particularly high-commitment co-ordination relationships, are likely to result in a broadening of the definition of TNC responsibility, while conflictual relationships, both high and low commitment, result in a narrowing of the definition of TNC responsibility. The study indicates that co-operation is generally more beneficial for both unions and NGOs than is any form of conflictual relationship, in terms of broadening the definition of TNC responsibility.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Ählström, J. and N. Egels-Zandén: 2005, ‘The Processes of Defining Corporate Responsibility: A Study of Swedish Garment Retailers Responsibility’, Business Strategy and the Environment (forthcoming).
S. Anderson J. Cavanagh (1996) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Empires’ Multinational Monitor 17 IssueID2 26–27
M. Anner P. Evans (2004) ArticleTitle‘Building Bridges across a Double Divide: Alliances between US and Latin American Labour and NGOs’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 34–47
P. A. Argenti (2004) ArticleTitle‘Collaborating with Activists: How Starbucks works with NGOs’ California Management Review 47 IssueID1 91–116
U. Beck (1992) Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity Sage London
J. Boli G. M. Thomas (Eds) (1999) Constructing World Culture: International Nongovernmental Organizations since 1875 Stanford University Press Stanford, CA
R. Braun J. Gearhart (2004) ArticleTitle‘Who Should Code Your Conduct? Trade Union and NGO Differences in the Fight for Workers’ Rights’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 183–196
A. Chan (1998) ArticleTitle‘Labor Standards and Human Rights: The Case of Chinese Workers Under Market Socialism’ Human Rights Quarterly 20 IssueID4 886–904
A. Chan (2000) ArticleTitle‘Globalization, China’s Free (Read Bonded) Labour Market, and the Chinese Trade Unions’ Asia Pacific Business Review 6 IssueID3–4 260–281
A. Chan R. A. Senser (1997) ArticleTitle‘China’s Troubled Workers’ Foreign Affairs 76 IssueID2 104–117
B. Christerson R. P. Appelbaum (1995) ArticleTitle‘Global and Local Subcontracting: Space, Ethnicity, and the Organization of Apparel Production’ World Development 23 IssueID8 1363–1374 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0305-750X(95)00048-H
P. Christmann G. Taylor (2002) ArticleTitle‘Globalization and the Environment: Strategies for International Voluntary Environmental Initiatives’ Academy of Management Executive 16 IssueID3 121–135
L. Compa (2004) ArticleTitle‘Trade Unions, NGOs, and Corporate Codes of Conduct’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 210–215
T. Connor (2004) ArticleTitle‘Time to Scale Up Cooperation? Trade Unions, NGOs, and the International Anti-Sweatshop Movement’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 61–70
D. Deephouse (1996) ArticleTitle‘Does Isomorphism Legitimate?’ Academy of Management Journal 39 IssueID4 1024–1039
S. J. Deery R. D. Iverson (2005) ArticleTitle‘Labor–Management Cooperation: Antecedents and Impact on Organizational Performance’ Industrial and Labor Relations Review 58 IssueID4 588–609
D. Eade (2004) ArticleTitle‘Editorial Overview’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 5–12
N. Egels-Zandén M. Kallifatides (2005) ‘The Corporate Social Performance Dilemma: Organizing for Goal Duality in Low-Income African Markets’ W. Vissner M. McIntosh C. Middleton (Eds) Corporate Citizenship in Africa: Lessons from the Past, Paths to the Future Greenleaf Publishing Sheffield
M. A. Emmelhainz R. J. Adams (1999) ArticleTitle‘The Apparel Industry Response to ‘Sweetshop’ Concerns: A Review and Analysis of Codes of Conduct’ Journal of Supply Chain Management 35 IssueID3 51–57
S. Frenkel (2001) ArticleTitle‘Globalization, Athletic Footwear Commodity Chains and Employment Relations in China’ Organization Studies 22 IssueID4 531–562
S. Frenkel S. Kim (2004) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Codes of Labour Practice and Employment Relations in Sports Shoe Contractor Factories in South Korea’ Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources 42 IssueID1 6–31 Occurrence Handle10.1177/1038411104041537
S. Frenkel D. Scott (2002) ArticleTitle‘Compliance, Collaboration, and Codes of Labor Practice: The Adidas Connection’ California Management Review 45 IssueID1 29–49
D. Gallin (2000) Trade Unions and NGOs: A Necessary Partnership for Social Development United Nations Research Institute for Social Development Geneva
G. Gereffi (1994) ‘The International Economy and Economic Development’ N. Smelser R. Swedberg (Eds) The Handbook of Economic Sociology Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ 206–233
A. Hale (2004) ArticleTitle‘Beyond the Barriers: New Forms of Labour Internationalism’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 158–162
R. Hamann N. Acutt (2004) ArticleTitle‘How Should Civil Society (and the Government) Respond to ’Corporate Social Responsibility?’ A Critique of Business Motivations and the Potential for Partnerships’ Development Southern Africa 20 IssueID2 255–270
J. Hathcote I. -J. Nam (1999) ArticleTitle‘Advantages of Sourcing Apparel from China, Taiwan, South Korea and Mexico’ International Trade Journal 13 IssueID2 157–185
A. Henriques (2001) ArticleTitle‘Civil Society and Social Auditing’ Business Ethics: A European Review 10 IssueID1 40–44 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8608.00210
M. T. Jones (2005) ArticleTitle‘The Transnational Corporation, Corporate Social Responsibility and the ‘Outsourcing’ Debate’ Journal of American Academy of Business 6 IssueID2 91–97
D. W. Justice (2003) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Social Responsibility: Challenges and Opportunities for Trade Unionists’ Labour Education 130 1–13
A. Kolk R. Tulder Particlevan (2002) ArticleTitle‘The Effectiveness of Self-Regulation: Corporate Codes of Conduct and Child Labour’ European Management Journal 20 IssueID3 260–271 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0263-2373(02)00043-9
D. Korten (2001) When Corporations Rule the World EditionNumber2 Kumarian Press Bloomfield, CT
J. T. Leahy (2001) ArticleTitle‘Making Room for Labor in Business Ethics’ Journal of Business Ethics 29 IssueID1–2 33–43
C. K. Lee (1998) Gender and the South China Miracle: Two Worlds of Factory Women University of California Press Berkely, CA
C. K. Lee (1999a) ArticleTitle‘From Organized Dependence to Disorganized Despotism: Changing Labour Regimes in Chinese Factories’ The China Quarterly 57 44–71
T. W. Lee (1999b) Understanding Qualitative Methods in Organizational Research Sage Thousand Oaks, CA
R. D. Lipschutz (2004) ArticleTitle‘Sweating It Out: NGO Campaigns and Trade Union Empowerment’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 197–209
S. Maguire C. Hardy T. B. Lawrence (2004) ArticleTitle‘Institutional Entrepreneurship in Emerging Fields: HIV/AIDS Treatment Advocacy in Canada’ Academy of Management Journal 47 IssueID5 657–679
C. Marshall G. B. Rossman (1995) Designing Qualitative Research Sage Thousand Oaks, CA
J. W. Meyer B. Rowan (1977) ArticleTitle‘Institutional Organizations: Formal Structures as Myth and Ceremony’ American Journal of Sociology 80 IssueID2 340–363
J. W. Meyer W. R. Scott (1983) ‘Centralization and the Legitimacy Problem of Local Government’ J. W. Meyer W. R. Scott (Eds) Organizational Environments Sage Newbury Park, CA 199–215
A. C. Michalos (1997) ArticleTitle‘Issues for Business Ethics in the Nineties and Beyond’ Journal of Business Ethics 16 IssueID3 219–230 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1017926723225
K. Nomura O. Abe (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Role of Networks in␣Promoting Environmental Education by NGOs in Asia: From a Viewpoint of International Cooperation’ International Review for Environmental Strategies 2 IssueID1 107–125
O. Ortez (2004) ArticleTitle‘Spreading Manufacturing Growth Gains Through Local Jobs: Lessons from the Guatemalan Highlands’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 163–170
D. O’Rourke (2003) ArticleTitle‘Outsourcing Regulation: Analyzing Nongovernmental Systems of Labor Standards and Monitoring’ The Policy Study Journal 31 IssueID1 1–29
J. Pfeffer G. R. Salancik (1978) The External Control of Organizations: A Resource Dependency Perspective Harper and Row New York
J. Piazza (2002) Going Global – Unions and Globalization in the US, Sweden and Germany Lexington Books Lanham, MD
M. Prieto C. Quinteros (2004) ArticleTitle‘Never the Twain Shall Meet? Women’s organisations and trade unions in the Maquila Industry in Central America’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 149–157
T. J. Radin (2004) ArticleTitle‘The Effectiveness of Global Codes of Conduct: Role Models That Make Sense’ Business and Society Review 109 IssueID4 415–447 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.0045-3609.2004.00204.x
S. Roberts (2003) ArticleTitle‘Supply Chain Specific? Understanding the Patchy Success of Ethical Sourcing Initiatives’ Journal of Business Ethics 44 IssueID2–3 159–170
J. Roman (2004) ArticleTitle‘The Trade Union Solution or the NGO Problem? The Fight for Global Labour Rights’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 100–109
D. A. Rondinelli T. London (2003) ArticleTitle‘How Corporations and Environmental Groups Cooperate: Assessing Cross-Sector Alliances and Collaborations’ Academy of Management Executive 17 IssueID1 61–76
J. N. Rosenau E.-O. Czempiel (Eds) (1992) Governance without Government: Order and Change in World Politics Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
S. P. Sethi (2002) ArticleTitle‘Standards for Corporate Conduct in the International Arena: Challenges and Opportunities for Multinational Corporations’ Business and Society Review 107 IssueID1 20–40 Occurrence Handle10.1111/0045-3609.00125
J. Simpkins (2004) ArticleTitle‘The Global Workplace: Challenging the Race to the Bottom’ Development in Practice 14 IssueID1–2 110–118
K. G. Smith S. J. Carroll S. J. Ashford (1995) ArticleTitle‘Intra- and Interorganizational Cooperation: Towards a Research Agenda’ Academy of Management Journal 38 IssueID1 7–22
S. Strange (1996) The Retreat of the State: The Diffusion of Power in the World Economy Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
R. Sullivan (2003) ArticleTitle‘NGO Expectations of Companies and Human Rights’ Non-State Actors and International Law 3 303–322 Occurrence Handle10.1163/157180703322765111
T. Taylor (2005) ArticleTitle‘In Defence of Outsourcing’ CATO Journal 25 IssueID2 367–377
H. Teegen J. P. Doh S. Vachani (2004) ArticleTitle‘The Importance of Nongovernmental Organizations (NGOs) in Global Governance and Value Creation: An International Business Research Agenda’ Journal of International Business Studies 35 IssueID6 463–483 Occurrence Handle10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8400112
M. Traub-Werner A. J. Cravey (2002) ArticleTitle‘Spatiality, Sweatshops and Solidarity in Guatemala’ Social and Cultural Geography 3 IssueID4 383–401 Occurrence Handle10.1080/1464936021000032469
P. Utting (2001) Regulating Business via Multistakeholder Initiatives: A Preliminary Assessment United Nation Research Institute for Social Development Geneva
R. Tulder Particlevan A. Kolk (2001) ArticleTitle‘Multinationality and Corporate Ethics: Codes of Conduct in the Sporting Goods Industry’ Journal of International Business Studies 32 IssueID2 267–283
F. B. Weinstein (1969) ArticleTitle‘The Concept of Commitment in International Relations’ Journal of Conflict Resolution 13 IssueID1 39–57
S. Weston M. M. Lucio (1998) ArticleTitle‘In and Beyond European Works Councils: Limits and Possibilities for Trade Union Influence’ Employee Relations 20 IssueID6 551–564 Occurrence Handle10.1108/01425459810247305
J. Wills (1998) ArticleTitle‘Taking on the CosmoCorps? Experiments in Transnational Labor Organizations’ Economic Geography 74 IssueID2 111–130
J. Wills (2002) ArticleTitle‘Bargaining for the Space to Organize in the Global Economy: A Review of the Accor–IUF Trade Union Rights Agreement’ Review of International Political Economy 9 IssueID4 675–700
M. Zeng X.-P. Chen (2003) ArticleTitle‘Achieving Cooperation in Multiparty Alliances: A Social Dilemma Approach to Partnership Management’ Academy of Management Review 28 IssueID4 587–605
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Egels-Zandén, N., Hyllman, P. Exploring the Effects of Union–NGO Relationships on Corporate Responsibility: The Case of the Swedish Clean Clothes Campaign. J Bus Ethics 64, 303–316 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-5497-y
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-5497-y