Abstract
This paper posits that differences in corporate governance structure partly result from differences in institutional arrangements linked to business systems. We developed a new international triad of business systems: the Anglo-American, the Communitarian and the Emerging system, building on the frameworks of Choi et al. (British Academy of Management (Kynoch Birmingham) 1996, Management International Review 39, 257–279, 1999). A common factor determining the success of a corporate governance structure is the extent to which it is transparent to market forces. Such transparency is more than pure financial transparency; as it can also be based on factors such as governmental, banking and other types of institutional transparency mechanism. There may also be a choice for firms to adopt voluntary corporate disclosure in situations where mandatory disclosure is not established. The Asian financial crisis of 1997–1999 and the more recent corporate governance scandals such as Enron, Andersen and Worldcom in the United States and Ahold and Parmalat in Europe show that corporate governance and business ethics issues exist throughout the world. As an illustration we focus on Asia’s emerging1 markets, as, both in view of the pressure of globalization and taking into account the institutional arrangements peculiar to the emerging business system, these issues are important there. Particularly for those who have to find an accommodation between the corporate governance structures and disclosure standards of the Emerging system and those of the Anglo-American and Communitarian systems.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
A.R. Admati P. Pfleiderer (2000) ArticleTitle‘Forcing Firms to Talk: Financial Disclosure and Externalities’ Review of Financial Studies 13 479–520 Occurrence Handle000088333900001 Occurrence Handle10.1093/rfs/13.3.479
M. Albert (1991) Capitalisme Contre Capitalisme Seuil Paris
American Law Institute: 1982, 1990, Principles of Corporate Governance and Structure: Analysis and Recommendations, Tentative Drafts, No. 1–10.
Aoki, M. and H. Kim: 1995, ‘Corporate Governance in Transition Economies’, Finance and Development (September) 20–22.
M. Aoki H. Kim (1995) ‘Corporate Governance in Transitional Economies: Insider control and the Role of Banks EDI Development Studies, The World Bank Washington DC
T. Baums (1992) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Governance in Germany: The Role of the Banks’ American Journal of Comparative Law 40 503–527 Occurrence HandleA1992KA17000006
S. Bhattacharya G. Chiesa (1995) ArticleTitle‘Proprietary Information, Financial Intermediaries, and Research Incentives’ Journal of Financial Intermediation 4 328–357 Occurrence HandleA1995TB92600002 Occurrence Handle10.1006/jfin.1995.1014
B. Black R. Kraakman (1996) ArticleTitle‘A Self–Dealing Model of Corporate Law’ Harvard Law Review 109 1911–1981 Occurrence HandleA1996UX04500002
B. Black (1998) ArticleTitle‘Information Asymmetry, the Internet, and Securities Offerings’ Journal of Small and Emerging Business Law 2 91–99
B. Black (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Legal and Institutional Preconditions for Strong Stock Market’ UCLA Law Review 48 781–858 Occurrence Handle000168115600001
A.W.A. Boot V. Thakor (2001) ArticleTitle‘The Many Faces of Information Disclosure’ Review of Financial Studies 14 1021–1058 Occurrence Handle000171686500004 Occurrence Handle10.1093/rfs/14.4.1021
E.H. Bowman M. Useem (1995) ‘The Anomalies of Corporate Governance’ B.M. BowmanE.H. Kogut (Eds) Redesigning the Firm. Oxford University Press NY
S.A. Cadbury (1993) ‘Highlights of the Proposals of the Committee on Financial Aspects of Corporate Governance’ D.D. Prentice J. HollandP. R. (Eds) Contemporary Issues in Corporate Governance. Clarendon Press Oxford
C.W. Calomiris C.D. Rammirez (1996) ArticleTitle‘The Role of Financial Relationships in the History of American Corporate Finance’ Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 9 52–73 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1745-6622.1996.tb00115.x
Carlin, W. and C. Mayer: 1999, ‘How do Financial Systems Affect Economic Performance?, OFRC Working Paper Series, Fe08. Oxford Financial Research Centre.
Charkham, J.: 1989, ‘Corporate governance and the market for control of companies’, Bank of England Panel Paper, No. 25.
J. Child T. Monir (1983) ArticleTitle‘Theoretical Perspectives in Cross-national Organizational Research’ International Studies of Management and Organization 12 23–70
C.J. Choi S.H. Lee J.B. Kim (1996) it Collaborating Across Business Systems it British Academy of Management Kynoch Birmingham
J.C. Choi M. Raman O. Usoltseva S.H. Lee (1999) ArticleTitle‘Political Embeddedness in the New Triad: Implications for Emerging Economies’ Management International Review 39 257–275
C.J. Choi C.C.J.M. HiltonB.J. Millar (2004) it Emergent Globalization Palgrave MacMillan London
Claessens, S., S. Djankov, J. P. H. Fan and L. H. P. Lang: 1999a, ‘Expropriation of Minority Shareholders in East Asia’, Working Paper (Social Science Research Network). (http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id= 202390).
Claessens, S., S. Djankov and L. H. P. Lang: 1999b, ‘Who control East Asian corporations-and the implications for legal reform. World Bank’, Working paper, No. 195.
J.C. Coffee (1984) ArticleTitle‘Market Failure and the Economic Case for a Mandatory Disclosure System’ Virginia Law Review 70 71–753
J.C. Coffee (1999) ArticleTitle‘The Future as History: The Prospects for Global Convergence in Corporate Governance and its Implications’ Northwester University Law Review 93 641–707
H. Demsetz K. Lehn (1985) ‘The Structure of Corporate Ownership: Causes and Consequences’. it Journal of Political Economy 93 1155–1177
D. Diamond (1984) ArticleTitle‘Financial Intermediation and Delegated Monitoring’ Review of Economic Studies 51 393–444 Occurrence HandleA1984TA03200003
C.K. DozY. Prahalad (1984) ArticleTitle‘Patterns of Strategic Control within Multinational Corporations’ Journal of International Business Studies 15 55–72
J. Dunning (1995) ArticleTitle‘Reappraising the Eclectic Paradigm in an Age of Alliance Capitalism’ Journal of International Business Studies 26 461–491 Occurrence HandleA1995TC74900001
R.A. Dye (1986) ArticleTitle‘Proprietary and Nonproprietary Disclosures’ Journal of Business 59 331–366 Occurrence HandleA1986C448900007 Occurrence Handle10.1086/296331
R.A. Dye (1990) ArticleTitle‘Mandatory Versus Voluntary Disclosures: The case of Financial and Real Externalities’ The Accounting Review 65 1–24
F. Easterbrook D. Fischel (1991) The Economic Structure of Corporate Law Harvard University Press Cambridge
T.I. Eldomiaty (2001) ‘The Role of Banks in Shareholders Versus Stakeholders Business Systems’, Paper presented at the “International Conference on Money, Investment and Risk” Nottingham Trent University UK
Franks, J. and C. Mayer: 1992, ‘Corporate Control: A Synthesis of the International Evidence. Working Paper, no. 165–92. London Business School.
M. Fruin (1992) The Japanese Enterprise System Oxford University Press Oxford
M. Gerlach J. Lincoln (1992) ‘The Organization of Business Networks in the U.S. and Japan’ R. Eccles N. Nohria (Eds) Networks and Organizations. Harvard Business School Press Boston
R.J. Gilson M.J. Roe (1993) ArticleTitle‘Understanding the Japanese Keiretsu: Overlaps Between Corporate Governance and Industrial Organization’ Yale Law Journal 102 871–906 Occurrence HandleA1993KG44200001
N. Gonedes (1980) ArticleTitle‘Public Disclosure Rules, Private Information Production, Decisions and Capital Market Equilibrium’ Journal of Accounting Research 18 441–475 Occurrence HandleA1980KZ18200008
C.W. Gray (1996) ArticleTitle‘In Search of Owners: Privatization and corporate Governance in Transition Economies’ World Bank Research Observer 11 179–197 Occurrence HandleA1996VG60100002
O. Hart (1995) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Governance: Some theory and implications’ The Economic Journal 105 678–689
Hedge, S. and J. McDermott: 2000, ‘Firm Characteristics as Cross Sectional Determinants of Adverse Selection’, Mimeo, (University of Connecticut. Connecticut).
H. Hirakawa (2001) ‘East Asia’s financial and economic crisis and its lessons’, Journal of Tokyo Keizai University 223 41–54
P.H. Ho (2001) ArticleTitle‘Corruption and Economic Growth’ Journal of Comparative Economics 29 66–80
J. Holland (1998) ArticleTitle‘Private Voluntary Disclosure, Financial Intermediation and Market Efficiency’ Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 25 29–68
B. Holmström J. Tirole (1993) ArticleTitle‘Market Liquidity and Performance Monitoring’ Journal of Political Economy 101 678–709
T. Hoshi A. Kashyap D. Scharfstein (1991) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Structure, Liquidity and Investment: Evidence from Japanese Industrial Groups’ Quarterly Journal of Economics 106 33–60 Occurrence HandleA1991EX48600002
S. Huntington (1996) ArticleTitle‘The West Unique, not Universal’ Foreign Affairs 75 28–46 Occurrence HandleA1996VW77000005
M.C. Jensen W.H. Meckling (1976) ArticleTitle‘Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure’ Journal of Financial Economics 3 305–360 Occurrence HandleA1976CJ65000001
J. Kay A. Silberston (1995) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Governance’ National Institute Economic Review 153 84–97
Khanna, T. and K. Palepu: 1999, ‘Emerging Markets Business Groups, Foreign Investors, and Corporate Governance’, NBER,Working Paper, no. w6955.
M.Z. Klipper (1998) ArticleTitle‘The Governance of Privatized Firms: Authority, Responsibility and Disclosure’ Economics of Transition 6 101–111 Occurrence Handle000074282700006
H. Kim (1995) ArticleTitle‘Markets, Financial Institutions, and Corporate Governance: Perspectives from Germany’ Law and Policy in International Business 26 371–405
B. Kogut (1991) ArticleTitleCountry Capabilities and the Permeability of Borders’ Strategic Management Journal 12 33–47 Occurrence HandleA1991FQ97500004
S. Kumar (1996) ArticleTitleCorruption Slows Growth Asian Business 32 10–12
Kunetsova, O. and A. Kuznetsov: 1998, ‘Corporate Governance under Transition and the Responsibility of the State: The Case of Russia’. Paper presented in the Academy of International Business Conference (City University Business School, London).
R. La Porta F. Lopez-de-Silanes A. Shleifer R.W. Vishny (1997) ArticleTitle‘Legal Determinants of External Finance’ Journal of Finance 52 1131–1150
R. La Porta F. Lopez-de-Silanes A. Shleifer R.W. Vishny (1998) ArticleTitle‘Law and Finance’ Journal of Political economy 06 1113–1155
La Porta, R., F. Lopez-de-Silanes, A. Shleifer and R. W. Vishny: 1998b, ‘Agency problems and dividend policies around the world. Harvard Institute of Economic Research’, Working Papers, no. 1839.
R. La Porta F. Lopez-de-Silanes A. Shleifer W. Vishny R (1999) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Ownership Around the World’ Journal of Finance 54 471–517 Occurrence Handle000079181400002
Lehmann, J.P.: 1996, ‘Corporate Governance in East Asia & Western Europe: Competition, Confrontation and Co-operation. The European Institute of Japanese Studies’, Working Paper, no. 24.
Leuz, C.: 1998, Voluntary disclosure of cash flow statements and segment data in Germany. Manuscript, Universität Frankfurt.
Levine, R. and S. Zervos: 1996, ‘Stock markets, banks and economic growth’, Working Paper (The World Bank).
R. Levine (1998) ArticleTitle‘The Legal Environment, Banks, and Long-run Economic Growth’ Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 30 596–613 Occurrence Handle000075296300013
Lodge, G. C.: 1990, Comparative Business-Government Relations (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs).
L. Lowenstein (1996) ArticleTitle‘Financial Transparency and Corporate Governance: You Manage What You Measure’ Columbia Law Review 96 1335–1362 Occurrence HandleA1996UX82100006
J.R. Macey G.P. Miller (1995) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Governance and Commercial Banking: A Comparative Examination of Germany, Japan, and the United States’ Stanford Law Review 48 73–112 Occurrence HandleA1995TU43500004
P.G. Mahoney (1995) ArticleTitle‘Mandatory Disclosure as a Solution to Agency Problems’ University of chicago law Review 62 1047–1112 Occurrence HandleA1995RU32100002
C. Mayer (1988) ArticleTitle‘New Issues in Corporate Finance’ European Economic Review 32 1167–1183 Occurrence HandleA1988N848800017 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0014-2921(88)90077-3
P. Mauro (1995) ArticleTitle‘Corruption and Growth’ Quarterly Journal of Economics 110 681–712 Occurrence HandleA1995RN97800005
Modigliani, M. and E. Perotti: 2000, ‘Security Versus Bank Finance: The Importance of a Proper Enforcement of Legal Rules. Fondazoine Eni Enrico Mattei, Working paper, no. 37.99.
F. Mueller (1994) ArticleTitle‘Societal Effect, Organizational Effect, and Globalization’ Organization Studies 15 407–428 Occurrence HandleA1994PP50900005
Nam, I. C., Y. Kang and J. Kim: 1999, Comparative corporate governance trends in Asia. OECD, Conference on ‘Corporate governance in Asia: A comparative perspectives,’ Seoul, 3–5 March.
D.C. North (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance Cambridge University Press Cambridge
K. Ohmae (1985) Triad Power: The Coming Shape of Global Competition Free Press New York
Pannier, D.: (ed.) 1996. ‘Corporate Governance of Public Enterprises in Transitional Economies. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development’, World Bank Technical Paper, No. 323.
J. Peek E.S. Rosengren (1997) ArticleTitle‘The International Transmission of Financial Shocks: The case of Japan’ American Economic Review 87 495–505 Occurrence HandleA1997XX92000002
Perotti, E. C. and E. L. von Thadden: 2001, ‘Outside Finance, Dominant Investors and Strategic Transparency. Centre for Economic Policy Research’, Discussion paper, no. 2733, (London).
P.H. Phan (2001) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Governance in the Newly Emerging Economies’ Asia Pacific Journal of Management 18 131–136 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1010630320396
K. Pistor S. RaiserM. Gelfer (2000) ArticleTitle‘Law and Finance in Transition Economies’ Economics of Transition 8 325–368 Occurrence Handle000088750600003 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1468-0351.00047
M.E. Porter (1990) The Competitive Advantage of Nations MacMillan London
S.D. Prowse (1992) ArticleTitle‘The Structure of Corporate Ownership in Japan’ Journal of Finance 47 1121–1140 Occurrence HandleA1992JK57500013
R.G. Rajan (1992) ArticleTitle‘Insiders and Outsiders: The Choice Between Informed and Arm’s Length Debt’ Journal of Finance 47 1367–1400 Occurrence HandleA1992JT34400006
Rajan, R. G. and L. Zingales: 1998, ‘Which Capitalism? Lessons from the East Asian Crisis’. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 11: 40–48.
R.B. Reich (1991) The Work of Nations: Preparing Ourselves for the 21st Century Capitalism Alfred Knopf New York
Schmidt, H., J. Drukarczyk, D. Honold, S. Prigge, A. Schüler and G. Tetens: 1997, Corporate Governance in Germany. Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft: Baden-Baden. Veröffentlichungen des. HWWA - Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung, Hamburg. Band 31
W. Shan W. Hamilton (1991) ArticleTitle‘Country-Specific Advantage and International Cooperation’ Strategic Management Journal 12 419–432 Occurrence HandleA1991GE73500002
A. Shleifer R.W. Vishny (1997) ArticleTitle‘A Survey of Corporate Governance’ Journal of Finance 52 737–783 Occurrence HandleA1997XA18900012
A. Sorge (1991) ArticleTitle‘Strategic Fit and the Societal Effect: Interpreting Cross-National Comparisons of Technology, Organization, and Human Resources’ Organization Studies 12 161–190 Occurrence HandleA1991FQ53100001
J.M. Stopford S. Strange (1991) Rival firms Cambridge University Press Rival States, Cambridge
L. Thurow (1992) Head to Head: The Coming Economic Battle Among Japan, Europe and America Edward Morrow New York
R. Verrecchia (1982) ArticleTitle‘The use of Mathematical Models in Financial Accounting’ Journal of Accounting Research 20 1–42 Occurrence HandleA1982RH32200001
E.L. Von Thadden (1995) ArticleTitle‘Long-term Contracts, Short-term Investment and Monitoring’ Review of Economic Studies 62 557–575
D.E. Weinstein Y. Yafeh (1998) ArticleTitle‘On the Costs of a Bank-Centered Financial System: Evidence from the Changing Main Bank Relations in Japan’ Journal of Finance 53 635–672 Occurrence Handle000072526100007 Occurrence Handle10.1111/0022-1082.254893
R. Whitley (1990) ArticleTitle‘Eastern Asian Enterprise Structures and the Comparative Analysis of Forms of Business Organizations’ Organization Studies 11 47–74 Occurrence HandleA1990CR62200003
O.E. Williamson (1985) The Economic Institutions of Capitalism Free Press New York
O.E. Williamson (1988) ArticleTitle‘Corporate Finance and Corporate Governance’ Journal of Finance 43 IssueID(3 567–591 Occurrence HandleA1988P220200002
D.B. Yoffie (1996) ArticleTitle‘Competing in the Age of Digital Convergence’ California Management Review 38 31–53 Occurrence HandleA1996VE88800002
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Millar, C.C., Eldomiaty, T.I., Choi, C.J. et al. Corporate Governance and Institutional Transparency in Emerging Markets. J Bus Ethics 59, 163–174 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-3412-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-3412-1