Abstract
The concept of dominance poses several dilemmas. First, while entrenched in genetics education, the metaphor of dominance promotes several misconceptions and misleading cultural perspectives. Second, the metaphors of power, prevalence and competition extend into science, shaping assumptions and default concepts. Third, because genetic causality is complex, the simplified concepts of dominance found in practice are highly contingent or inconsistent. The conceptual problems are illustrated in the history of studies on the evolution of dominance. Conceptual clarity may be fostered, I claim, by viewing diploid organisms as diphenic and by framing genetic causality modestly through individual alleles and their corresponding haplophenotypes.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
D. Allchin (2000) ArticleTitleMending mendelism Am. Biol. Teacher 62 632–639
D. Allchin (2002) Dissolving dominance L. Parker R. Ankeny (Eds) Mutating Concepts, Evolving Disciplines: Genetics, Medicineand Society Kluwer Dordrecht 43–62
D. Allchin (2003) ArticleTitleScientific Myth-conceptions Science Education 87 329–351 Occurrence Handle10.1002/sce.10055
W. Bateson ([1902] 1928) The problems of heredity and their solution R.C. Punnett (Eds) Scientific Papers of William Bateson Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK 4–28
R.J. Berry (1965) Teach Yourself Genetics English Universities Press London
M. Bix R.M. Locksley (1998) ArticleTitleIndependent and Epigenetic Regulation of the Interleukin-4 Alleles in CD4 + T cells Science 281 1352–1354 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.281.5381.1352 Occurrence Handle9721100
N. Campbell J.B. Reece L.G. Mitchell (1999) Biology EditionNumber5 Benjamin Cummings Menlo Park, CA
J.M. Caplan M. Pigliucci (2001) ArticleTitleGenes “For” phenotypes: a modern history view Biol. Philos. 16 189–213 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1006773112047
C.A. Clarke P.M. Sheppard (1960) ArticleTitleThe evolution of dominance under disruptive selection Heredity 14 73–87
C.A. Clarke P.M. Sheppard (1963) ArticleTitleInteractions between major genes and polygenes in the determination of the mimetic patterns of Papilio dardanus Evolution 17 404–413
C.G. Correns ([1900] 1950) ArticleTitleMendel's law concerning the behavior of progeny in varietal hybrids (Eng. trans.) Genetics 25 IssueID5,2 33–41
L. Darden (1991) Theory Change in Science: Strategies from Mendelian Genetics Oxford University Press Oxford
H. de Vries ([1900] 1950) ArticleTitleConcerning the law of segregation of hybrids Genetics 35 IssueID5,2 30–32
F. Di Trocchio (1991) ArticleTitleMendel's experiments: A reinterpretation J. Hist. Biol. 24 485–519 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00156322
M.P. Donovan (1997) ArticleTitleThe vocabulary of biology and the problem of semantics J. College Sci. Teach. 26 381–382
C.T. Druery (1902) ArticleTitleExperiments in plant hybridisation [translation of Mendel] J. Roy. Hort. Soc. 26 1–32
R. Falk (2001) ArticleTitleThe rise and fall of dominance Biol. Philos. 16 285–323 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1010611605295
R.A. Fisher (1928a) ArticleTitleThe possible modification of the response of the wild type to recurrent mutations Am. Nat. 62 115–126 Occurrence Handle10.1086/280193
R.A. Fisher (1928b) ArticleTitleTwo further notes on the origin of dominance Am. Nat. 62 571–574 Occurrence Handle10.1086/280234
E.B. Ford (1955) ArticleTitlePolymorphism and taxonomy Heredity 9 255–264
E.B. Ford (1964) Ecology Genetics Methuen London
M. Foucault (1972) The Archaeology of Knowledge Pantheon New York
G. Fritz (1999) ArticleTitleAllchin's mistake BioQUEST Notes 10 IssueID1 9–12
A.I. Goldman (1999) Knowledge in a Social World Oxford Clarendon Press
D. Haraway (1989) Primate Visions Routledge New York
D. Hull (1974) Philosophy of Biological Science Prentice Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ
N. Katsanis S.J. Ansley J.L. Badano E.R. Eichers R.L. Lewis B.E. Hoskins P.J. Scambler W.S. Davidson P.L. Beales J.R. Lupski (2001) ArticleTitleTriallelic inheritance in Bardet-Biedl syndromea Mendelian recessive discorder Science 293 2256–2259 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1063525 Occurrence Handle11567139
H.B.D. Kettlewell (1959) ArticleTitleDarwin's missing evidence Sci. Am. 200 IssueIDMarch 48–53 Occurrence Handle13635037
H.B.D. Kettlewell (1973) The Evolution of Melanism: The Study of Recurring Necessity; with Special Reference to Industrial Melanism in the Lepidoptera Clarendon Press Oxford
W. Klug M. Cummings (2000) Concepts of Genetics EditionNumber6 Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ
E. Kroeber W.H. Wolff R.L. Weaver (1969) Biology, 2d ed D.C. Heath Lexington, MA
G. Lakoff M. Johnson (1980) Metaphors We Live By The University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
E.S. Lander R.A. Weinberg (2000) ArticleTitleGenomics: journey to the center of biology Science 287 1777–1781 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.287.5459.1777 Occurrence Handle10755930
B. Lewin (2000) Genes VII Oxford University Press New York
R.C. Lewontin (1992) Genotype and Phenotype E. Keller E.A. Lloyd (Eds) Keywords in Evolutionary Biology Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA 137–144
M.E.N. Majerus (1998) Melanism: Evolution in Action Oxford University Press Oxford
O. Mayo R. Bürger (1997) ArticleTitleThe evolution of dominance: a theory whose time has passed? Biol. Rev. 72 97–110 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0006323196004987
V.A. McKusick (1998) Mendelian Inheritance in Man: A Catalog of Human Genes and Genetic Disorders EditionNumber12 Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore, MD
Mendel G. [1866] 1966. Versuche über Pflanzenhybriden [experiments on plant hybrids]. In: English translation in Stern C., Sherwood E. (eds). The Origin of Genetics: A Mendel Source Book. W.H. Freeman, San Francisco, pp. 1–48.
K. Mikkola (1984) ArticleTitleDominance relations among the melanic forms of biston betularia and Odontoptera bidentata (LepidopteraGeometridae) Heredity 52 9–16
T.H. Morgan (1926) The Theory of the Gene Yale University Press New Haven, CT
H.J. Muller (1932) Further studies on the nature and causes of gene mutations D.F. Jones (Eds) Proceedings of the Sixth International Congress of Genetics Brooklyn Botanical Garden MenashaWI 213–255
Olby R.C. 1997. Mendel, Mendelism and Genetics. MendelWebURL: www.netspace.org/MendelWeb/MWolby.intro.html (updated Feb 22, 1997; accessed Dec 15, 2000).
OMIMTM2000. Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man, McKusick-Nathans Institute for Genetic Medicine. Johns Hopkins University (BaltimoreMD) and National Center for Biotechnology Information, National Library of Medicine. Bethesda, MD. URL: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/omim/ (accessed Dec 15, 2000).
H.A. Orr (1991) ArticleTitleA test of Fisher's theory of dominance Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88 11413–11415 Occurrence Handle1763055
S.P. Otto D. Bourguet (1999) ArticleTitleBalanced polymorphism and the evolution of dominance Am. Nat. 153 561–574 Occurrence Handle10.1086/303204
S. Oyama (2000a) The Ontogeny of Information EditionNumber2 Duke University Press Durham, NC
S. Oyama (2000b) Evolution's Eye Duke University Press Durham, NC
W.B. Provine (1985) The R.A. Fisher-Sewall Wright controversy and its influence upon modern evolutionary biology R. Dawkins M. Ridley (Eds) Oxford Surveys in Evolutionary Biology Oxford University Press Oxford 197–219
W.B. Provine (1986) Sewall Wright and Evolutoinary Biology The University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
J. Rodgers (1991) ArticleTitleMechanisms Mendel never knew Mosaic 22 IssueID3 2–11
N.V. Rothwell (1993) Understanding Genetics: A Molecular Approach Wiley-Liss New York
K. Schaffner (1993) Discovery and Explanation in Biology and Medicine The University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
S. Schwartz (2002) ArticleTitleCharacters as units and the case of the presence and absence hypothesis Biol. Philos. 17 369–388 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1020131508987
R.A. Skipper SuffixJr. (2002) ArticleTitleThe persistence of the R.A. Fisher-Sewall Wright controversy Biol. Philos. 17 341–367 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1020178411042
E. Sober (1984) The Nature of Selection MIT Press Cambridge, MA
K. Sterelny P. Kitcher (1988) ArticleTitleThe return of the gene J. Philos. 85 339–361
A.J. Tobin J. Duscheck (1998) Asking About Life Saunders Fort Worth, TX
E. Tschermak ([1900] 1950) ArticleTitleConcerning Artificial crossing in Pisum sativum Genetics 35 IssueID5,2 42–47
D.A. West (1977) ArticleTitleMelanism in biston (Lepidoptera: Geometridae) in the rural central Appalachians Heredity 39 75–81
A.O.M. Wilkie (1994) ArticleTitleThe molecular basis of genetic dominance J. Med. Genet. 31 89–98 Occurrence Handle8182727
S. Wright (1968–69) Evolution and the Genetics of Populations The University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Allchin, D. The Dilemma of Dominance. Biol Philos 20, 427–451 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-2561-z
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-2561-z