Abstract
The problem of moral compliance is the problem of explaining how moral norms are sustained over extented stretches of time despite the existence of selfish evolutionary incentives that favor their violation. There are, broadly speaking, two kinds of solutions that have been offered to the problem of moral compliance, the reciprocity-based account and the punishment-based account. In this paper, I argue that though the reciprocity-based account has been widely endorsed by evolutionary theorists, the account is in fact deeply implausible. I provide three arguments that suggest that moral norms are sustained by punishment, not reciprocity. But in addition to solving the problem of moral compliance, the punishment-based account provides an additional important theoretical dividend. It points the way for how theorists might build an evolutionary account of a feature of human groups that has long fascinated and troubled social scientists and moral philosophers – the existence of moral diversity.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
R.D. Alexander (1987) The Biology of Moral Systems Aldine De Gruyter New York
R. Axelrod (1984) The Evolution of Cooperation Basic Books New York
R. Axelrod W.D. Hamilton (1981) ArticleTitleThe evolution of cooperation Science 211 1390–1396
P. Bingham (1999) ArticleTitleHuman uniqueness: a general theory Quart. Rev. Biol. 74 IssueID2 133–169 Occurrence Handle10.1086/393069
D. Black (1998) The Social Structure of Right and Wrong Academic Press London
C. Boehm (1999) Hierarchy in the Forest Harvard University Press CambridgeMA
E. Bourguignon L. Greenbaum (1973) Diversity and Homogeneity in World Societies HRAF Press New Haven, CT
R. Boyd (1989) ArticleTitleMistakes allow evolutionary stability in the repeated Prisoner's Dilemma J. Theor. Biol. 136 47–56
R. Boyd S. Bowles H. Gintis P. Richerson (2003) ArticleTitleThe evolution of altruistic punishment Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 100 IssueID6 3531–3535 Occurrence Handle10.1073/pnas.0630443100
R. Boyd P. Richerson (1989) ArticleTitleThe evolution of reciprocity in sizable groups J. Theor. Biol. 132 337–356
R. Boyd P. Richerson (1992) ArticleTitlePunishment allows the evolution of cooperation (or anything else) in sizable groups Ethol. Sociobiol. 13 171–195
D. Brown (1991) Human Universals McGraw-Hill New York
Carpenter J., Mathews P. and Okomboli O.Why punish? Social reciprocity and the enforcement of prosocial norms. J. Evol. Econ. 14(4): 407–429.
E. Cashdan (1980) ArticleTitleEgalitarianism among hunters and gatherers Am. Anthropol. 82 116–120 Occurrence Handle10.1525/aa.1980.82.1.02a00100
F. Waal ParticleDe (1996) Good Natured: The Origin of Right and Wrong in Humans and Other Animals Harvard University Press CambridgeMA
R. Dunbar (1997) Grooming, Gossip and the Evolution of Language Harvard University Press CambridgeMA
W. Durham (1991) Coevolution Stanford University Press StanfordCA
M. Edel A. Edel (2000) Anthropology and Ethics Transaction Publishers New Brunswick, NJ
R.B. Edgerton (1992) Sick Societies The Free Press New York
E. Fehr S. Gachter (2002) ArticleTitleAltruistic punishment in humans Nature 415 137–140
A.P. Fiske (1991) Structures of Social Life The Free Press New York
D. Fudenberg E. Maskin (1986) ArticleTitleThe folk theorem in repeated games with discounting and incomplete information Econometrica 54 533–554
A. Gibbard (1990) ArticleTitleNorms, discussion, and ritual: evolutionary puzzles Ethics 100 IssueID4 787–802 Occurrence Handle10.1086/293234
H. Gintis E.A. Smith S. Bowles (2001) ArticleTitleCostly signaling and cooperation J. Theor. Biol. 213 103–119 Occurrence Handle10.1006/jtbi.2001.2406
J. Haidt (2000) The moral emotions R.J. Davidson K. Scherer H.H. Goldsmith (Eds) Handbook of Affective Sciences Oxford University Press New York
J. Henrich R. Boyd (2001) ArticleTitleWhy people punish defectors J. Theor. Biology 208 79–89
J. Henrich R. Boyd S. Bowles C. Camerer E. Fehr H. Gintis (2001) Foundations of Human Sociality Oxford University Press New York
C. Horne (2001) ArticleTitleThe enforcement of norms: group cohesion and meta-norms Soc. Psychol. Quart. 64 IssueID3 253–266 Occurrence Handle10.2307/3090115
D. Hume (1992 [1739]) A Treatise of Human Nature Prometheus Books BuffaloNew York
I. Kant (1972 [1887]) Justice and punishment (from Critique of Practical Reason) G. Ezorsky (Eds) Philosophical Perspectives on Punishment State University of New York Press Albany, NY
L. Keeley (1996) War Before Civilization: The Myth of the Peaceful Savage Oxford University Press New York
S.J. Maynard G.R. Price (1973) ArticleTitleThe logic of animal conflict Nature 246 15–18
G.P. Murdock (1949) Social Structure Free Press New York
P. Oliver (1980) ArticleTitleRewards and punishment as selective incentives for collective action: theoretical investigations Am. J. Sociol. 85 IssueID6 1356–1375 Occurrence Handle10.1086/227168
M. Olson (1965) The Logic of Collective Action Harvard University Press CambridgeMA
E. Ostrom (1990) Governing the Commons Cambridge University Press New York
C.A. Robarcheck C.J. Robarchek (1992) Cultures of war and peace: a comparative study of Waorani and Semai J. Silverberg P. Gray (Eds) Aggression and Peacefulness in Humans and Other Primates Oxford University Press New York
S. Roberts (1979) Order and Dispute St. Martin's Press New York
L. Samuelson (1997) Evolutionary Games and Equilibrium Selection MIT Press CambridgeMA
B. Skyrms (1990) The Dynamics of Rational Deliberation Harvard University Press CambridgeMA
E. Sober D.S. Wilson (1998) Unto Others Harvard University Press CambridgeMA
Sripada C.S., Stich S. A framework for the psychology of norms. To appear In: Carruthers S., Laurence S. and Stich S. (eds), Innateness and the Structure of the Mind, Vol. 2. Oxford University Press, London.
R. Trivers (1971) ArticleTitleThe evolution of reciprocal altruism Quart. J. Biol. 46 IssueID1 35–57
M.R. Uyenoyama M.W. Feldman (1992) Altruism: some theoretical ambiguities E.F. Keller E.A. Lloyd (Eds) Keywords in Evolutionary Biology Harvard University Press CambridgeMA
N. Vidmar D.T. Miller (1980) ArticleTitleSociological processes underlying attitudes toward legal punishment Law Soc. Rev. 14 IssueID3 565–602
E. Westermark (1937) Ethical Relativity Brace and Company HarcourtNew York
D.S. Wilson C. Wilczynski A. Wells L. Weiser (2000) Gossip and other aspects of language as group-level adaptations C. Heyes L. Huber (Eds) The Evolution of Cognition MIT Press Cambridge, MA
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sripada, C.S. Punishment and the Strategic Structure of Moral Systems. Biol Philos 20, 767–789 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-004-5155-2
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-004-5155-2