Abstract
There is, at present, little precise understanding of the relative contributions of the various income streams used by impoverished rural households in southern Africa. The impact of household profiles on overall income also is not well understood. There is, therefore, little consideration of these factors in national economic accounting. This paper is an attempt to reduce this gap in knowledge by reflecting on the relative contribution of agro-pastoralism, secondary woodland resources, and formal and informal cash income streams to households in the semi-arid rural village of Thorndale, Limpopo Province, South Africa. In the absence of jobs and confronted with high migrant labor, households with open access to natural resources derived more benefits from land-based livelihoods than cash income streams (i.e., 57.5 % vs. 42.5 %). Total livelihood income was valued at US$2887 per household per annum. A significant correlation between monetary values derived from crops and formal wages was established, and it was found that households with high cash incomes tended to invest more in crop production. Over 80 of households were male-headed. Of these heads of household, more than 60 were long-term migrants to urban areas, leaving household decision-making to the women. The low literacy rates of women have deprived them of paid jobs outside the area and, therefore, have increased their dependence on crops (62%) and secondary woodlands resources (60%). This was further reflected in the proportion of households in which females were the main contributors of cash income (9.7%), or joint contributors with men (24.4%). Various positive correlations were established between the number of women per household and the three land-based livelihoods. This implied that women’s total control over such activities was mostly a result of the absence of men and not a typical phenomenon. In spite of this control, it was not positively reflected in the lives of majority of the women. Households differed in their participation in livelihood activities. Household size influenced the level of production and was positively correlated with the value of secondary woodland resources and crops. The study shows the interdependence of land-based livelihood sources and the impact of household features on production and consumption. Policies that focus on livelihood options need to recognize and accommodate associated household dynamics.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
M. Adams B. Cousins S. Manona (2000) “Land tenure and economic development in rural South Africa: Constraints and opportunities” B. Cousins (Eds) At the Crossroads: Land and Agrarian Reform in South Africa into the 21st Century School of Government, University of the Western Cape Cape Town, South Africa 111–128
E. Ardington F. Lund (1996) “Questioning rural livelihoods” M. Lipton F. Ellis M. Lipton (Eds) Land Labor and Livelihoods in Rural South Africa, Vol. 2: KwaZulu-Natal and Northern Province Indicator Press Durban, South Africa 31–58
Y. Aumeeruddy-Thomas S. Saigal S. Kapoor A. B. Cunningham (1999) Joint Management in the Making: Reflections and Experiences. UNESCO Paris, France
F. Barhoorn H. T. Riezebos (1990) North-East District CFDA. Ministry of Local Government and Lands Summary report. Gaborone, Botswana
J. C. Barrett (1992) The Economic Role of Cattle in Communal Farming Systems in Zimbabwe. Pastoral Development Network Paper 32b. ODI London, UK
W. Beinart (1992) ArticleTitle“Transkeian smallholders and agrarian reform” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 11 IssueID2 178–199
R. J. A. Berkvens (1997) Backing Two Horses: Interaction of Agricultural and Non-agricultural Household Activities in a Zimbabwean Communal Area.Working paper Vol. 24. Leiden African Studies Centre The Netherlands
H. R. Bernard (1994) Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, 2nd edition. SABA Publishers California, USA
P. Bradley P. Dewees (1993) “Indigenous woodlands, agricultural and household economy in the communal areas” P. N. Bradley K. McNamara (Eds) Living with Trees: Policies for Forest Management in Zimbabwe World Bank Washington DC
D. F. Bryceson (1996) ArticleTitle“Deagrarianization and rural employment in sub-Saharan Africa: A sectoral perspective” World Development 24 IssueID1 97–111
D. F. Bryceson (2002) ArticleTitle“Multiplex livelihoods in rural Africa: Recasting the terms and conditions of gainful employment” Journal of Modern African Studies 40 1–28
B. M. Campbell M. Luckert I. Scoones (1997) ArticleTitle“Local level valuation of savanna resources: A case study from Zimbabwe”. Economic Botany 51 IssueID1 59–77
B. M. Campbell R. Costanza M. van den belt (2000a) ArticleTitle“Land use options in dry tropical woodland ecosystems in Zimbabwe: Introduction, overview and synthesis”. Ecological Economics 33 341–351
B. M. Campbell D. Dore M. Luckert B. Mukamuri J. Gambiza (2000b) ArticleTitle“Land use options in dry tropical woodland ecosystems in Zimbabwe: Economic comparisons of livestock production in communal grazing lands in Zimbabwe”. Ecological Economics 33 413–438
B. M. Campbell S. Jeffrey W. Kozanayi M. Luckert M. Mutamba C. Zindi (2002) Household Livelihoods in Semi-Arid Regions: Options and Constraints. CIFOR Bogor, Indonesia
D. Carney M. Drinkwater T. Rusinow K. Neefjes S. Wanmali N. Singh (1999) Livelihoods Approaches Compared: A Brief Comparison of the Livelihoods Approaches of the UK Department for International Development (DFID). CARE, Oxfam and the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) DFID Report. Sussex, UK
W. Cavendish (2000) ArticleTitle“Empirical irregularities in the poverty-environment relationship of rural households: Evidence from Zimbabwe” World Development 28 1979–2003
C. Crehan (1992) “Rural households: Making a living” H. Bernstein B. Crow H. Johnson (Eds) Rural Livelihoods: Crises and Responses Oxford University Press Oxford, UK 87–112
B. Crow (1992) “Rural livelihoods: Action from above” H. Bernstein B. Crow H. Johnson (Eds) Rural Livelihoods: Crises and Responses Oxford University Press Oxford, UK 251–273
A. B. Cunningham (1997) ArticleTitle“Review of ethnobotanical literature from eastern and southern Africa” Bulletin of the African Ethnobotany Network 1 23–88
S. David (1998) ArticleTitle“Intra-household processes and the adoption of hedgerow intercropping” Agriculture and Human Values 15 IssueID1 31–42
J. Davison (1992) ArticleTitle“Changing relations of production in southern Malawi’s households: Implications for involving rural women in development” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 1 IssueID2 72–84
Forestry Department of Water Affairs (1997) National Forestry Action Plan. DWAF Pretoria, South Africa
S. Dercon (1998) ArticleTitle“Wealth, risk and activity choice: Cattle in western Tanzania” Journal of Development Economics 55 1–42
D. B. K. Dovie (2004) “Economic valuation of secondary resources in the context of total livelihoods” M. J. Lawes H. C. Eeley C. M. Shackleton B. S. Geach (Eds) Indigenous Forests and Woodlands in South Africa: Policy, People and Practice University of Natal Press Durban, South Africa 197–199
D. B. K. Dovie C. M. Shackleton E. T. F. Witkowski (2002) ArticleTitle“Direct-use values of woodland resources consumed and traded in a South African village”. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology 9 IssueID3 269–283 Occurrence Handle10.1080/13504500209470122
D. B. K. Dovie E. T. F. Witkowski C. M. Shackleton (2003) ArticleTitle“Direct-use value of smallholder crop production in a semi-arid rural South African village”. Agricultural Systems 76 337–357
D. B. K. Dovie E. T. F. Witkowski C. M. Shackleton (2004) ArticleTitle“The fuelwood crisis in Southern Africa–relating fuelwood use to livelihoods in a rural village”. GeoJournal 60 123–133
G. H. Duvel D. B. Afful (1996) ArticleTitle“Sociocultural constraints on sustainable cattle production in some communal areas of South Africa”. Development Southern Africa 13 IssueID3 429–440
F. Ellis (1998) ArticleTitle“Household strategies and rural livelihood diversification” Journal of Development Studies 35 IssueID1 1–38
L. J. Fenwick M. C. Lyne (1999) ArticleTitle“The relative importance of liquidity and other constraints inhibiting the growth of small-scale farming in Kwazulu-Natal”. Development Southern Africa 16 IssueID1 141–155
T. Forsyth M. Leach I. Scoones (1998) Poverty and Environment: Priorities for Research and Policy. IDS,UNDP Report. Brighton, UK
E. Francis (1998) ArticleTitle“Gender and rural livelihoods in Kenya” Journal of Development Studies 35 72–95
E. Francis (1999) ArticleTitle“Learning from the local: Rural livelihoods in Ditsobotla, North West Province, South Africa” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 17 IssueID1 49–73
InstitutionalAuthorNameGovernment Communications (1999) South Africa-Agriculture. GCIS, GCIS Report 1999. Pretoria, South Africa
I. Guijt F. Hinchcliffe M. Melnyk (1995) The Hidden Harvest: The Value of Wild Resources in Agricultural Systems. IIED London, UK
R. M. Hassan (Eds) (2002) Accounting for Stock and Flow Values of Woody Land Resources: Methods and Results from South Africa. CEEPA Pretoria, South Africa
G. Hatch (1996) “Livestock and rural livelihoods in KwaZulu-Natal” M. Lipton F. Ellis M. Lipton (Eds) Land Labor and Livelihoods in Rural South Africa, Vol. 2: KwaZulu-Natal and Northern Province Indicator Press Durban, South Africa 77–90
C. High C. M. Shackleton (2000) ArticleTitle“The comparative value of wild and domestic plants in home gardens of a South African rural village”. Agroforestry Systems 48 141–156
S. P. Johnson (1993) The Earth Summit: The United Nations Conference Environment and Development. Graham and Trotman London, UK
T. Kepe (1997) Environmental Entitlements in Mkambati: Livelihoods, Social Institutions and Environmental Change on the Wild Coast of the Eastern Coast. University of the Western Cape, School of Government Cape Town, South Africa
J. Kirsten R. Townsend C. Gibson (1998) ArticleTitle“Determining the contribution of agricultural production to household nutritional status in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa”. Development Southern Africa 15 IssueID4 573–587
S. W. Lawry (1986) Livestock and Range Management in Sehlabathebe: A Study of Communal Resource Management, Land Conservation and Range Development Project. Ministry of Agriculture, Cooperatives and Marketing Maseru, Lesotho
M. Leach M. Mearns I. Scoones (1997) Environmental Entitlements: A Framework for Understanding the Institutional Dynamics of Environmental Change. IDS Brighton, UK
T. Letsela E. T. F. Witkowski K. Balkwill (2002) ArticleTitle“Direct use values of communal resources in Bokong and Tsehlanyane in Lesotho* Whither the commons?” International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology 9 351–368 Occurrence Handle10.1080/13504500209470130
M. Lipton (1996) “Comment on research on poverty and development twenty years after redistribution with growth” M. Bruno B. Pleskovic (Eds) Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics 1995 World Bank Washington, DC 73–79
M. Lipton S. Maxwell (1992) The New Poverty Agenda: An Overview. ODI London, UK
M. Lipton F. Ellis M. Lipton (Eds) (1996) Land Labor and Livelihoods in Rural South Africa, Vol.2 KwaZulu-Natal and Northern Province. Indicator Press Durban, South Africa
E. J. Luoga E. T. F. Witkowski K. Balkwill (2000a) ArticleTitle“Subsistence use of wood products and shifting cultivation within a miombo woodland of eastern Tanzania, with notes on commercial uses”. South African Journal of Botany 66 IssueID1 72–85
E. J. Luoga E. T. F. Witkowski K. Balkwill (2000b) ArticleTitle“Differential utilization and ethnobotany of trees in Kitulanghalo forest reserve and surrounding communal lands, eastern Tanzania”. Economic Botany 54 328–343
M. T. Makhura F. M. Goode G. K. Coetzee (1998) ArticleTitle“A cluster analysis of commercialization of farmers in developing rural areas of South Africa”. Development Southern Africa 15 429–448
C. Manona (1999) Deagrarianisation and the Urbanization of a Rural Economy: Agrarian Patterns in Melani Village in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. African Studies Centre Institute of Social and Economic Research. Grahamstown, South Africa and Leiden, The Netherlands
C. M. Matanyaire (1996) ArticleTitle“Farmers production practices and perceptions of problems as a guide for research on rain-fed food crops in Northern Namibia” Development Southern Africa 3 IssueID5 681–691
J. May C. Rogerson A. Vaughan (2000) “Livelihoods and assets” J. May (Eds) Poverty and Inequality in South Africa: Meeting the Challenge David Philip Publishers Cape Town, South Africa 229–256
P. McAllister (1992) ArticleTitle“Production, land use and development planning in Transkei: A critique of the Transkei agricultural development study” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 11 IssueID2 201–222
P. McAllister (2000) Maize Yields in the Transkei: How Productive is Subsistence Cultivation? Land Reform and Agrarian Change in Southern Africa Occasional Paper Series No.14. University of the Western Cape Cape Town, South Africa
M. A. Melnyk J. Bell (1996) ArticleTitle“The direct-use values of tropical moist forests foods: the Huottuja (Piaora) Amerindians of Venezuala”. Ambio 25 468–472
M. Mohasi S. D. Turner (1999) Land and Livelihoods in Southern Lesotho. University of the Western Cape, School of Government Cape Town, South Africa
G. M. Moor W. L. Nieuwoudt (1998) ArticleTitle“Tenure security and productivity in small-scale agriculture in Zimbabwe: Implications for South Africa”. Development Southern Africa 15 IssueID4 609–620
R. F. Noss (1990) ArticleTitle“Indicators for monitoring biodiversity: A hierarchical approach” Conservation Biology 4 IssueID4 355–364
InstitutionalAuthorNameOffice of Technology Assessment (1987) Technologies to Sustain Tropical Forest Resources and Biological Diversity. OTA Washington, DC
T. Reardon C. Delgado P. Matlon (1992) ArticleTitle“Determinants and effects of income diversification amongst farm households in Burkina Faso”. The Journal of Development Studies 28 IssueID2 264–296
N. A. Robinson (Eds) (1993) Agenda 21: Earth’s Action Plan Annotated. Oceana New York
B. N. Sandangi R. P. Singh (1993) ArticleTitle“Understanding profiles of the self-employed rural youth for promoting occupational diversification”. Journal of Rural Development 12 IssueID1 57–75
I. C. Scoones M. Melnyk J. Pretty (Eds) (1992) The Hidden Harvest: Wild Foods and Agricultural Systems.Literature Review and Annotated Bibliography 111.1. IIED London, UK
C. M. Shackleton (1996) ArticleTitle“Potential stimulation of local rural economies by harvesting secondary products: A case study from the Transvaal lowveld, South Africa” Ambio 25 IssueID1 33–38
C. M. Shackleton S. E. Shackleton (2000) ArticleTitle“Direct use values of secondary resources harvested from communal savannas in the bushbuckridge lowveld, South Africa”. Journal of Tropical Forest Products 6 28–47
C. M. Shackleton S. E. Shackleton B. Cousins (2001) ArticleTitle“The role of land-based strategies in rural livelihoods: The contribution of arable production, animal husbandry and natural resource harvesting in communal areas in South Africa”. Development Southern Africa 18 581–604
C. M. Shackleton T. R. Netshiluvhi S. E. Shackleton B. S. Geach A. Balance D. F. K. Fairbanks (2002) ArticleTitle“Direct-use values of woodland resources from three rural villages”. Economic Botany 56 IssueID2 130–146
N. Tellegen (1997) Rural Enterprises in Malawi: Necessity or Opportunity? Aldershot Ashgate UK
C. J. F. ter Braak P. Šmilauer (2002) Program CANOCO Version 4.5. Centre for Biometry Wageningen, The Netherlands
J. Unni (1996) ArticleTitle“Diversification of economic activities and non-agricultural employment in rural Gujarat” Economic and Political Weekly 31 IssueID33 2243–2251
C. Valdivia J. Gilles (2001) ArticleTitle“Gender and resource management: Households and groups, strategies and transitions”. Agriculture and Human Values 18 IssueID1 5–9
P. Van Esterik (1999) ArticleTitle“Right to food; right to feed; right to be fed The intersection of women’s rights and the right to food”. Agriculture and Human Values 16 IssueID2 225–232
A. Vaughan (1992) “Options for rural restructuring” R. Schrire (Eds) Wealth or Poverty? Critical Choices for South Africa Oxford University Press Cape Town, South Africa
S. H. von Bach E. A. Nuppenau (1996) ArticleTitle“The stage of development and agricultural performance: A causality analysis of South African traditional agriculture”. Development Southern Africa 13 IssueID2 277–286
E. O. Wilson (1992) The Diversity of Life. Allen Lane: The Penguin Press London, UK
J. H. Zar (1999) Biostatistical Analysis EditionNumber4 Prentice-Hall Upper Saddle River, New Jersy
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Delali B. K. Dovie is a conservation biologist with interests in agricultural and natural resource economics and conservation, rural sociology, and global environmental change issues. He is currently a START/IGBP African Doctoral Fellow, and Honorary Research Fellow, School of Animal, Plant & Environmental Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa.
E. T. F. Witkowskiis an ecologist with expertise in eco-physiology, restoration and plant ecology, and ethnobotany. He is Professor and Director of the Restoration and Conservation Biology Research Group, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa.
Charlie M. Shackletonis an ecologist and Professor at the Department of Environmental Science, Rhodes University with many years of experience and good working knowledge of agro-ecological research, natural resources, plant population dynamics, and ethnobotany.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dovie, D.B.K., Witkowski, E.T.F. & Shackleton, C.M. Monetary valuation of livelihoods for understanding the composition and complexity of rural households. Agric Hum Values 22, 87–103 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-004-7233-0
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-004-7233-0