Abstract
Groundwater resources in the Sohag area, Egypt are currently threatened by contamination from municipal and industrial activities, and agricultural pesticides. To cope with the growing population, there has been development in the desert zone on both sides of the Nile Valley including agricultural investment areas, wastewater disposal sites, new urban areas, and industry. Use of agrochemicals in the old cultivated and newly reclaimed lands and wastewater disposal sites in the study area represent the most hazardous contamination sources. Prevention of contamination and management of the Quaternary aquifer is urgently needed. To address vulnerability assessment of the Quaternary aquifer, the Generic and Pesticide DRASTIC GIS-based models have been used. The Generic DRASTIC index ranged between 94 and 189, and the Pesticide DRASTIC index ranged between 94 and 226. The results showed that 83% of the Quaternary aquifer is characterized by the high and very high vulnerability classes to municipal, industrial and agricultural pesticides contamination. It was found that nearly all the development projects are located in the very high vulnerability class areas. Management alternatives for the Quaternary aquifer may be improved by application of these models, allowing sensitive groundwater sources to be protected for continuing use in the future.
Résumé
Les ressources en eau souterraine de la région de Sohag, Egypte, sont actuellement menacées de pollution par les activités urbaines, industrielles, et par les pesticides agricoles. Pour faire face à l’accroissement de la population, on a aménagé une zone désertique des deux côtés de la vallée du Nil, avec investissements agricoles, lagunages, nouvelles zones urbaines, industries. L’utilisation de composés chimiques sur les terres anciennement cultivées et sur celles récemment mises en valeur, ainsi que les lagunages, représentent les sources de contamination les plus dangereuses. La protection contre les pollutions et la gestion de l’aquifère quaternaire sont extrêmement urgentes. Pour s’attaquer à l’évaluation de la vulnérabilité de l’aquifère quaternaire, on a utilisé les modèles “Generic DRASTIC” et “Pesticide DRASTIC” basés sur GIS. L’index Generic DRASTIC s’échelonne entre 94 et 189, et l’index Pesticide DRASTIC s’échelonne entre 94 et 226. Les résultats ont montré que 84% de l’aquifère quaternaire présente une vulnérabilité Forte à Très Forte. On a découvert que presque tous les projets de développements sont localisés dans les zones classées Très Haute Vulnérabilité. La gestion de l’aquifère quaternaire peut être améliorée par l’utilisation de ces modèles, permettant aux ressources en eau souterraine vulnérables d’être protégées durablement pour leur utilisation future.
Resumen
Los recursos de agua subterránea en la zona Sohag, Egipto están actualmente amenazados por la contaminación de actividades industriales y municipales, y por plaguicidas agrícolas. Para hacer frente al crecimiento de la población, ha existido un desarrollo en la zona desértica a ambos lados del Valle del Nilo, incluyendo áreas de inversión agrícola, sitios de eliminación de aguas residuales, nuevos centros urbanos e industrias. El uso de agroquímicos en las antiguas tierras cultivadas y en tierras recientemente recuperadas y los sitios de eliminación de aguas residuales en la zona del estudio representan las fuentes más peligrosas de contaminación. Es necesario en forma urgente la prevención de la contaminación y gestión del acuífero Cuaternario. Se utilizaron los modelos génerico y de pesticidas basado en DRASTIC GIS para enfocar la evaluación de la vulnerabilidad del acuífero Cuaternario. El índice genérico del DRASTIC varió entre 94 y 189, mientras que el de pesticida de DRASTIC varió entre 94 y 226. Los resultados mostraron que el 83% del acuífero Cuaternario está caracterizado por una clase de vulnerabilidad alta y muy alta a la contaminación industrial y municipal y por pesticidas agrícolas. Se encontró que casi todos los proyectos de desarrollo están localizados en zonas con una clase de muy alta vulnerabilidad. Las alternativas de gestión del acuífero Cuaternario pueden ser mejoradas por la aplicación de estos modelos, permitiendo que las fuentes sensibles de aguas subterráneas sean protegidas para su uso continuado en el futuro.
摘要
来, 埃及索哈杰地区的地下水资源受到了城市、工业活动和农业杀虫剂污染的威胁. 为应对人口增长, 农业投资区、废水处理站、新的市区和工业已发展至尼罗河河谷两岸的荒漠地区. 在传统耕地和新开垦土地上使用的农用化学品及研究区中的废水处理站是最具危害的污染源. 故亟需进行污染防治和第四系含水层的管理. 为评价第四系含水层的脆弱性, 应用了基于GIS的背景的和杀虫剂的DRASTIC模型. 背景DRASTIC指数为94至189, 杀虫剂DRASTIC指数为94至226. 结果表明, 对于城市、工业和农业杀虫剂污染, 83%的第四系含水层的脆弱性等级为高和非常高. 且几乎所有的发展计划都位于脆弱性非常高的地区. 第四系含水层的管理措施或可通过这些模型的应用得到改进, 以保护这些敏感的地下水资源在未来的持续利用.
Resumo
Os recursos de água subterrânea na área de Sohag, Egipto, estão actualmente ameaçados pela contaminação por actividades municipais e industriais, e pelos pesticidas utilizados na agricultura. Devido ao aumento da população, tem havido um desenvolvimento económico crescente na zona do deserto, em ambas as margens do rio Nilo, e que inclui a construção de áreas de desenvolvimento agrícola, estações de tratamento de águas residuais, novas zonas urbanas e indústria. O uso de produtos agroquímicos, quer nos antigos, quer nos novos terrenos agrícolas, e as estações de tratamento de águas residuais, representam no entanto as mais perigosas fontes de contaminação. É urgente a prevenção da contaminação e a gestão do aquífero Quaternário. De forma a avaliar a vulnerabilidade deste sistema aquífero foram usados os modelos baseados no método DRASTIC genérico e no método DRASTIC para pesticidas acoplados a um SIG. O índice DRASTIC genérico variou entre 94 e 189, e o índice DRASTIC para pesticidas variou entre 94 e 226. Os resultados mostram que 83% do aquífero Quaternário é caracterizado por uma vulnerabilidade à contaminação por actividades municipais, industriais e por pesticidas agrícolas que varia de elevada a muito elevada. Conclui-se que a grande maioria dos projectos de desenvolvimento se encontram sobre áreas que apresentam a classe de vulnerabilidade mais elevada. As alternativas de gestão dos recursos do aquífero Quaternário podem ser melhoradas através da utilização deste tipo de modelos, permitindo que os recursos de água subterrânea mais sensíveis sejam protegidos para ser usados de forma continuada no futuro.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Study area
The Sohag Governorate covers part of the Nile Valley, Egypt on the reach extending from the northern edge of Qena Governorate at latitude 26°07′N to the southern edge of Assiut Governorate at latitude 26°57′N. It is bounded between longitudes 31°20′ and 32°14′E (Fig. 1a). The study area, incorporating the Sohag Governorate, covers an area of 11,022 km2. The length of the River Nile in the study area is 125 km, and the width of the valley ranges between 16 and 20 km.
Introduction
Groundwater contamination is one of the principal environmental and public health problems in the Sohag area. Groundwater contamination sources in the study area include extensive use of agro-chemical fertilizers and pesticides and wastewater disposal. The Quaternary aquifer in the study area (Fig. 1b) is currently under contamination stress due to agricultural activities in the old cultivated and reclaimed lands as well as the impact of the development projects located in the desert zone of the study area (Fig. 2). Agricultural pesticides and wastewater have a major impact on degradation of groundwater quality in the study area.
Agriculture and pesticides
The entire valley is mainly used for agricultural activities except for areas occupied by settlement. The edges of the valley on the east and west flanks are marked by new cultivated fringes. Widespread reclamation activities have been started throughout the last two decades aiming at cultivating the low land and barren desert zone extending between the Nile floodplain and the Eocene limestone plateau on both sides of the Nile Valley.
The economy of the area depends mainly on crop production. Crops are cultivated in a 2 or 3-year crop rotation including winter, summer, and autumn crops. Winter crops include wheat, horse beans, barley, lentil, clover, onion, garlic, flax, chickpea, lupine, fenugreek, and vegetables. Summer crops include cotton, maize, sorghum, soy bean, sesame, groundnut, and vegetables. Autumn crops include maize, sorghum, and vegetables. Permanent crops include sugar cane, and there is also permanent production in gardens. Irrigation water is applied by the traditional method of flooding (basin irrigation) which occurs at a frequency of two and three times a month (Abdel Moneim 1992; Shamrukh et al. 2001).
Pesticides are used in agriculture to inhibit growth of various organisms. Pesticides include herbicides, insecticides, nematicides and fungicides which are used to control weeds, insects, nematodes and diseases (Wischmeier and Smith 1978). The application of pesticides, when combined with sensitive groundwater areas, can have a large impact on the water quality. Agricultural contaminants such as pesticides will dissolve in the irrigation water and infiltrate through the soil profile.
Although the use of DDT and other organochlorine pesticides was banned in Egypt many years ago, recent studies showed that six organochlorine pesticides residues (DDT, dieldrin, endrin, heptachlor, heptachlor epoxide and lindane) are found in cow’s milk collected from different villages of the study area (Dawood et al. 2004). Presence of organochlorine residues in soils that were heavily treated years ago is suspected to be an important present-day source (Fiedler et al. 2000). These pesticide residues have a potential health hazardous effect on humans particularly infants and children. Organochlorine pesticides persist and tend to bioaccumulate in the environment (Dawood et al. 2004). The occurrence of persistent organochlorine compounds in the environment is changing relatively slowly over a span of years (Watterson 1991). The most common effects of the wide spread of organochlorine compounds in the environment are birth defects, neurological effects and behavioral effects, reproductive effects and cancer (Windham 2002).
Urbanization and wastewater
The establishment of urban and agricultural communities in the wide deserts in Egypt is an important development for the twenty-first century. With the very high population density in the Nile Valley and delta, major efforts have been made by the government of Egypt to construct new industrial communities in the desert to act as new poles of attraction, and to create new job opportunities (El-Gohary et al. 2002). According to the 2002 census estimation, the total population of Sohag Governorate is 3.7 × 106 (GASG 2004) representing 5% of the Egyptian population. The forms of development in the area include land reclamation projects, new urban communities, industrial areas, and wastewater disposal sites in the desert zone of the Nile Valley. In the last few years, four artificial cities have been constructed: El-Kawser, east of El-Ahaiwa, west of Tahta and west of Girga. There are big factories in the area including a sugar factory, and soft drinks and clothes factories. Other small private factories are represented in the study area such as onion drying, sweets, macaroni and oil dehydration factories.
One of the major problems facing these new communities is the potential health and environmental hazard posed by industrial wastewater. Untreated wastewater discharged by industrial activities is often contaminated by a variety of toxic or harmful substances (El-Gohary et al. 2002). The main pollution source from municipal activities includes leakage from sewage systems and septic tanks, and probable release of wastewater from wastewater disposal sites. The main pollutant products of these domestic activities are bacteria and nitrogen compounds. The degree of leakage from sewage systems depends on the age of the system and its design. The individual septic tank (soil absorption system) is the main method of sewage disposal in rural areas. Seepage of sewage water is also probable from industrial factories in the study area that could lead to contamination of surface water as well as groundwater (EEAA 1997).
In the study area, eight sites have already been chosen for projected wastewater disposal at Tima, Tahta, El-Maragha, El-Dair, El-Kola, El-Manshah, Girga and El-Balyana (Fig. 2). Currently, two sites (El-Dair and El-Kola) are operating and the others are planned to be used in the future. The improper wastewater disposal at Sohag City (El-Kola and El-Dair sites) has the potential to contaminate the surface water resources (River Nile and irrigation canals) and the underlying aquifer. The groundwater at these two sites is critically contaminated chemically and bacteriologically (Ali 2005).
Objectives
To avoid degradation of groundwater quality imposed by long-term impact of municipal, industrial and agricultural contaminants, management alternatives are urgently needed. Determining vulnerability zones in the Quaternary aquifer would help planners and decision makers in deciding which areas need sensitive and extra care and for setting priority levels of management. Determining vulnerability zones is a primary step towards making a decision support system (DSS) for planners and decision makers.
This study aims to address the vulnerability assessment of the Quaternary aquifer system with respect to contamination from municipal and industrial activities and agricultural pesticides using the Generic and Pesticide DRASTIC GIS-based models. Groundwater or aquifer vulnerability to contamination is a concept for which several definitions and assessment methods are available (USEPA 1993; NRC 1993; Vrba and Zaporozec 1994; Gogu and Dassargues 2000). The DRASTIC aquifer vulnerability model was developed in 1987 for the US Environmental Protection Agency (Aller et al. 1987). The model considers a contaminant introduced at the surface, which moves downwards due to recharge at a rate equal to water movement. The vulnerability of the aquifer is assessed by examining intrinsic properties of the aquifer and vadose zone, the water table depth, topography, and recharge. The DRASTIC approach for quantifying groundwater susceptibility has been widely used in North America (Navulur and Engel 1998; Fagnan et al. 1998; Ducci 1999; Stark et al. 1999; Fritch et al. 2000) and around the world, including China, Italy, Portugal, South Africa, and Algeria (Menani 2001; Napolitano and Fabbri 1996; Dai et al. 2001; Shahid 2000; Lobo-Ferreira and Oliveira 1997; Lynch et al. 1994).
Geologic framework
The study area is a part from the Nile Valley which has been geologically investigated by many authors (e.g. Said 1990; Issawi and McCauley 1992). The various rock units distributed in the Sohag area (Fig. 1a) are composed wholly of sedimentary succession ranging in age from Lower Eocene to Recent. The main lithostratigraphic units in the study area are summarized in Fig. 1b.
Hydrogeologic setting
The Sohag area belongs to the arid region of North Africa which is generally characterized by hot summer and cold winter with low rainfall. Surface water hydrology of the area is represented by the River Nile, irrigation canals, and drains. The area gets the irrigation water from the River Nile and the main irrigation canals which take water from the River Nile upstream of Nag-Hammadi Barrages located ∼15 km south of the study area.
The aquifer system in the study area is formed by the alluvial deposits of the Nile and consists of two layers having distinct hydraulic properties (Fig. 3). The upper layer is a semi-permeable clay-silt, which functions as a semi-confining layer to the underlying aquifer. The clay-silt layer is laterally extensive, having greater thickness near the river channel and vanishing near the valley fringes where it is overlain by desert sands. The lower layer is composed of gravels and sands and forms the main aquifer, having high horizontal and vertical permeability. The lower boundary of the aquifer is composed of an extensive and thick deposit of Pliocene clays of very low permeability. The lateral boundaries along the sides of the valley are considered no-flow where the horizontal permeabilities of the formations and hydraulic gradients are small enough to justify the assumption that no flow occurs across these boundaries (MPWWR 1988). The thickness of this aquifer as well as its width differs from one locality to another (Farrag 1982). The groundwater in this aquifer is found under semi-confined conditions at the middle of the valley and under unconfined conditions at the fringes where the Nile silt is absent.
The aquifer recharge is mainly due to applied irrigation water, seepage from the surface-water conveyance system and subsurface inflow across external boundaries. The main discharge components are discharge to the River Nile, outflow across external boundaries, capilliary upward flow from a shallow water table owing to evapotranspiration, and groundwater pumping from wells. The monthly average evaporation in the Sohag area ranges between 3.2 mm in December and 12 mm in June (Ibrahim 1996).
The groundwater balance for the study area was calculated from modeling results (Ahmed 2007). The inflow was calculated as 8.12E + 05 m3/day, storage was calculated as 3.03E + 05 m3/day, seepage from River Nile and irrigation canals was calculated as 2.69E + 06 m3/day, and recharge from excess irrigation was calculated as 3.56E + 06 m3/day. On the other hand, the outflow was calculated as 2.47E + 05 m3/day, storage was calculated as 1.20E + 05 m3/day, outflow into River Nile and irrigation canals was calculated as 5.73E + 06 m3/day, extraction from wells was calculated as 2.04E + 05 m3/day, and seepage into drains was calculated as 1.09E + 06 m3/day.
Methodology: DRASTIC vulnerability assessment
One of the most widely used groundwater vulnerability-assessment methods is DRASTIC, developed by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as a method for assessing groundwater pollution potential (Aller et al. 1987). The acronym DRASTIC corresponds to the initials of the seven hydrogeologic parameters: depth to water, net recharge, aquifer media, soil media, topography, impact of vadose zone media, and hydraulic conductivity of the aquifer. These parameters are the most important mapable factors which control the groundwater contamination potential. The DRASTIC technique produces a standardized methodology which gives results suitable for screening regions with respect to groundwater protection, monitoring, and clean-up efforts. DRASTIC models may help delineate areas where pesticides, municipal and industrial contaminants may pose a greater threat to groundwater. The DRASTIC system is divided into two portions: the designation of mapable units termed hydrogeologic settings, and the application of a scheme for relative ranking of hydrogeologic parameters, herein called the DRASTIC rating. In the DRASTIC rating, each factor is mapped and classified either into ranges or into significant media types which have an impact on contamination potential. Each factor or parameter is assigned a subjective rating between 1 and 10 based on functional curves (Table 1). This rating is then scaled by a weighting factor ranging between 1 and 5, and the weighted ratings are summed to obtain the DRASTIC index DI as follows:
where:
- Dr :
-
Ratings for the depth to water table
- Dw :
-
Weights assigned to the depth to water table
- Rr :
-
Ratings for ranges of aquifer recharge
- Rw :
-
Weights for the aquifer recharge
- Ar :
-
Ratings assigned to aquifer media
- Aw :
-
Weights assigned to aquifer media
- Sr :
-
Ratings for the soil media
- Sw :
-
Weights for soil media
- Tr :
-
Ratings for topography (slope)
- Tw :
-
Weights assigned to topography
- Ir :
-
Ratings assigned to vadose zone
- Iw :
-
Weights assigned to vadose zone
- Cr :
-
Ratings for hydraulic conductivity
- Cw :
-
Weights given to hydraulic conductivity
The DI score is relative, with no specific units. The total scores for two or more settings can only be compared if all of the parameters have been similarly evaluated, and the weighting of each parameter is the same for each calculation. The site with the highest DI is considered the most likely to become contaminated.
Pesticide DRASTIC is a special case of the DRASTIC Index, which is designed to be used when the activity of concern is the application of pesticides to an area. The difference between the two indexes is in the assignment of relative weights for the seven DRASTIC factors. For each parameter there are two weights. The first is for the application of DRASTIC to generic municipal and industrial contaminants, whereas the second is for agricultural pesticides. Due to the presence of municipal, industrial and agricultural activities in the study area, the Generic DRASTIC and Pesticide DRASTIC GIS-based models were used in the present work for vulnerability assessment of the Quaternary aquifer.
The DRASTIC factors and data preparation
Preparation of DRASTIC factors was achieved through gathering data from different sources including geologic data, using groundwater flow model results of Ahmed (2007), a digital elevation model (DEM) of the study area, and published research and maps.
A DEM covering the study area was downloaded from the NASA (US National Aeronautics and Space Administration) website to be used for extracting the topography parameter. The digital elevation model of the study area is subjected to projection into UTM, cleaning and filling the voids before using and processing in ArcGIS 9.2 for deriving the slope parameter for the DRASTIC models. The 3DEM software and STRMFILL utility are used for accomplishing these steps.
Building the DRASTIC database
The different hydrogeologic datasets were arranged in a geo-spatial database using ArcGIS 9.2 for handling the DRASTIC parameters in a GIS environment. The different data and maps are digitized and projected into UTM Zone 36 N. The seven DRASTIC layers are prepared as raster grids of cell size 100 m (x, y), forming 684 and 785 columns and rows, respectively. The DRASTIC parameters include the following factors.
Depth to water table (D)
The depth from the ground surface to the water table influences the contaminant load that reaches the groundwater (Thirumalaivasan et al. 2003). This is because pollutants do not have as far to travel through the soil profile before reaching the groundwater if the water table is shallow (Brady and Weil 2002). The risk of contamination increases with a more shallow depth, while groundwater with deeper water tables have a lesser chance of contamination. The groundwater elevation map (Fig. 4) is used for depth calculation. In the study area, the depth to the water table ranges from < 5 m to 44 m (Ahmed 2007). The individual cells will be rated on a 1–10 standard scale, with 10 being the shallowest depth, and thus the most at risk from contamination.
Net recharge (R)
Net recharge is the total quantity of water that infiltrates from the ground surface to the water table on an annual basis. Recharge is the principal factor for leaching and transporting contaminants to the water table. The more the recharge, the greater the chance for contaminants to reach the water table. The aquifer recharge is mainly due to applied irrigation water and seepage from the surface-water conveyance system. Warner et al. (1991) determined recharge through the clay (semi-confined) as 0.8–1.1 mm/day and through the unconfined part as 1.9–2.1 mm/day. This parameter will be rated on a 1–10 standard scale, with 10 being the highest recharge.
Aquifer media (A)
There have been many studies carried out in the study area and the Nile Valley in general to estimate the aquifer parameters such as the works of Attia (1974, 1985), RIGW (1980), Barber and Carr (1981), Attia et al. (1983, 1986), Abadi (1995), Abd El-Bassier (1997), Abdel Moneim (1988, 1992), MPWWR (1988), Warner et al. (1991), Abdel Moneim and Abu El Ella (1996), RIGW-IWACO (1989) and Ahmed (2007). According to Ahmed (2007), the calibrated hydraulic conductivity values ranges between 125 m/day at the middle of the valley and 82.5 m/day at the fringes (Fig. 5). This parameter will be rated on a 1–10 standard scale, with 10 being the highest hydraulic conductivity of aquifer media.
Soil media (S)
The properties of soils control the amount of water that may infiltrate the ground surface and reach the groundwater (Babiker et al. 2005). Permeable soils, such as sand or gravel, allow more water to infiltrate to the water table, making groundwater more vulnerable, while less permeable soils such as clays, allow less infiltration (Brady and Weil, 2002) and there is, therefore, less groundwater vulnerability. Infiltration is the key factor in transporting agricultural contaminants from the surface, through the soil profile, to the groundwater.
To obtain the soil map of the study area, results of the soil surveys, borehole data and the works of Ibrahim (1995), Ali (2005), Abdel Rahman (2006) and Ahmed (2007) were used. The gathered data were treated and interpolated using ArcGIS 9.2 to obtain the soil types for the cultivated lands. Due to lack of soil data for the desert and reclaimed lands, geologic data were used for deriving the soil types. The final soil map was obtained by merging the two data layers (Fig. 6). Soils in the study area can be distinguished as follows:
-
1.
Soils of the cultivated lands. The soils of the cultivated lands include sand, loamy sand, sandy loams, silt loam, loam, sandy clay loam, silt clay loam, clay loam, and clay.
-
2.
Soils of the reclaimed and desert lands: Soils of these lands are presented in DRASTIC models by the lithologic equivalent. The desert and reclaimed lands include the following categories: (1) fine sand and silt intercalations, (2) siltstone, sandstone, and claystone, (3) sand, (4) gravel, (5) gravel and sand.
In this work, the soils are ranked according to their permeabilities on a 1–10 standard scale, with 10 being the most permeable soil.
Topography (T)
Topography refers here to the slope variability of the land surface. The degree of slope will determine the extent of runoff of the pollutant and degree of settling (long enough to infiltrate). The slope of the land surface dictates whether water will run off the surface, or if it will infiltrate into the soil. Contaminants will similarly leave the area as runoff, or settle into the ground, eventually reaching the water table (Brady and Weil 2002). Topography also gives some indication of where pollutants will concentrate. Runoff from agricultural crops will be channeled from a higher elevation to a lower elevation, making lower slopes more vulnerable to contamination. The topography of study area was obtained from the DEM covering the study area (Fig. 7). Slope values are calculated from the topographic elevations using the Spatial Analyst Tools in ArcGIS 9.2. The slope values are rated based on the standardized 1–10 scale, with 10 being the lowest slope.
Impact of the vadose zone (I)
The vadose zone is the unsaturated extension of the saturated zone of the aquifer. Its materials, like the soils above, control the amount of water, and therefore contaminants, which penetrate to the saturated zone (Babiker et al. 2005). A high permeability such as sandstone, will allow more water to percolate through than a lower permeability such as clay-rich layer (Brady and Weil 2002), making the higher permeability aquifers more vulnerable to contamination.
The scheme is similar to that for the soil media (Aller et al. 1987), where clay-rich textures are impermeable and allow fewer contaminants to infiltrate, and thus receive a lower rating, while sands and gravels are very permeable and allow more contaminants to enter the groundwater system. The impact of the vadose zone is ranked on 1–10 standard scale, with 10 being the most permeable.
Hydraulic conductivity (C)
The hydraulic conductivity controls the rate of groundwater movement in the saturated zone, thereby controlling the degree and fate of the contaminants. This factor indicates the ability of the aquifer to transmit water which indicates the speed of transfer within the groundwater system. The vertical hydraulic conductivity was used in this context. The vertical hydraulic conductivities of the aquifer materials, as obtained from the calibrated groundwater flow model, are 57 m/day at the middle of the valley and 36 m/day at fringes (Ahmed 2007). High hydraulic conductivity values ranked as 10, and lower values as 1.
DRASTIC calculations and analysis
The hydrogeological parameter units were rated according to DRASTIC specified ranges. ArcGIS 9.2 was used for processing and visualization of the different data layers of DRASTIC models. Reclassify Tool was used to classify the different rates into 10 classes. Map algebra and model builder tools were used for calculating the DRASTIC and Pesticide DRASTIC models. The DRASTIC rating from each input layer was multiplied by the Generic DRASTIC and Pesticide DRASTIC weight for that layer and summed to determine the DRASTIC index. Further calculations were undertaken for deriving the classes of vulnerability and calculating the areas of each class.
Results
Aquifer vulnerability to municipal and industrial contamination
The Generic DRASTIC index map showed that the study area is characterized by different zones of vulnerability to municipal and industrial contamination. The Generic DRASTIC index ranges between 94 and 189. Four zones of vulnerability can be distinguished as low, moderate, high and very high (Fig. 8). The results showed that the Quaternary aquifer in the desert zone is characterized by the high and very high vulnerability to municipal and industrial contamination. At the middle of the valley, the aquifer is characterized by the high vulnerability class.
Aquifer vulnerability to agricultural pesticides
The Pesticide DRASTIC index map showed that the Quaternary aquifer in the study area is characterized by different zones of vulnerability to agricultural pesticides. The Pesticide DRASTIC index ranged between 94 and 226, which is higher than the Generic DRASTIC index. The Pesticide DRASTIC index can be further divided into four classes as low, moderate, high and very high (Fig. 9). The aquifer in the reclaimed lands and the desert zone is more vulnerable than in the middle of the valley. Similar to the Generic DRASTIC, the aquifer in the reclaimed lands and the desert zones is characterized by the high and very high vulnerability to agricultural pesticides.
The Pesticide DRASTIC index shows that the potential for contaminating groundwater with agricultural pesticides is greater than with contamination with municipal and industrial contaminants (Table 2). In addition, the DRASTIC results showed that 83% of the Quaternary aquifer is characterized by the very high vulnerability to municipal, industrial and pesticides contamination (Table 3).
Contamination risk in relation to development projects
As stated earlier, the development projects in the study area may pose a great threat to the Quaternary aquifer. Results of the DRASTIC models showed that nearly all the development projects are located in the very high class of vulnerability with respect to contamination with municipal, industrial and pesticide contaminants (Fig. 10).
The old cultivated lands and pesticides
Results of the DRASTIC models showed that the Quaternary aquifer underneath the old cultivated lands including the residential areas is characterized by the high class of vulnerability with respect to contamination with municipal, industrial and agricultural pesticides (Fig. 11).
Discussion
The Quaternary aquifer in the Sohag area is shallow and characterized by high hydraulic conductivity. The main recharge to the aquifer is from excess irrigation water and seepage from irrigation canals. Soils in the study area and the vadose zone present a significant impact in facilitating transport of contaminants through the soil profile. Septic tanks and cesspools in rural areas pose a real threat to the Quaternary aquifer. The development projects in the desert zone of the study area represent a new source of groundwater contamination for the Quaternary aquifer.
The present study revealed that 83% of the Quaternary aquifer is characterized by the high and very high vulnerability classes with respect to contamination with municipal, industrial and agricultural contaminants. Results of the present study indicate that more attention and care is needed concerning management of land and water resources. Monitoring of groundwater levels and concentrations of municipal, industrial and agricultural contaminants is urgently needed.
The DRASTIC models are valuable and comprehensive tools for monitoring groundwater vulnerability at specific sensitive sites across a large-scale area. Management of contamination of the Quaternary aquifer in the Sohag area would be improved by the application of these models, allowing sensitive groundwater resources to be protected for continuing use in the future.
Recommendations for mitigation of contamination risk
For mitigating the contamination risk in the high and very high vulnerability zones, the following recommendations should be taken into consideration:
-
1.
Prevent the use of agricultural pesticides in these areas and use other safe methods of controlling pests and weeds such as biological methods of remediation
-
2.
Use well controlled wastewater disposal systems with accurate management and monitoring of wastewater release to prevent contamination from the wastewater disposal sites
-
3.
Remove and/or stop the use of septic tanks and cesspools in the rural areas and use well managed sewage systems instead
-
4.
Implement continuous monitoring of the environmental impact of wastewater disposal systems associated with industrial and new urban sites
-
5.
Manage agricultural investment areas using modern methods of irrigation such as drip and sprinkler methods along with bio-remediation of pests and weeds
-
6.
Monitor the municipal, industrial and agricultural contaminants in these areas to acertain the status of contamination and make corrective measures
References
Abadi SA (1995) Geological and hydrogeological studies in the area between longitude 32°18′–32°20′E and Latitude 25°28′–26°00′N, Nag Hammadi, Egypt. MSc Thesis, Assiut University, Egypt
Abd El-Bassier MA (1997) Hydrogeological and hydrogeochemical studies of the Quaternary aquifer in Qena Governorate, Egypt. MSc Thesis, Assiut Univ., Egypt
Abdel Moneim AA (1988) Hydrogeology of the Nile Basin in Sohag Province. MSc Thesis, Geol. Dept., Fac. Sci., Assiut Univ., Egypt
Abdel Moneim AA (1992) Numerical simulation and groundwater management of the Sohag aquifer The Nile Valley, Upper Egypt. PhD Thesis, University of Strathclyde, Scotland
Abdel Moneim AA, Abu El Ella EM (1996) Numerical simulation of the water bearing formation in the Aluminum company area, Nag Hammadi, Upper Egypt. Presented in Geology of the Arab World, 3rd International Conferences, Cairo, 27 February–1 March 1996
Abdel Rahman AA (2006) Hydrogeological and geophysical assessment of the reclaimed areas in Sohag, Nile Valley, Egypt. PhD Thesis, Ain Shams University, Egypt
Ahmed AA (2007) Using lithologic modeling techniques for aquifer characterization and groundwater flow modeling of Sohag area, Egypt. Second International Conference on Geo-Resources in The Middle East and North Africa, Cairo, 24–28 February 2007
Ali MH (2005) Geochemical characteristics of the surfacial Nile basin sediments and their environmental relevance, Sohag area, Egypt. MSc Thesis, Fac. Sci., South Valley Univ., Sohag, Egypt
Aller LT, Bennet T, Lehr JH, Petty RJ, Hackett G (1987) DRASTIC: a standardized system for evaluating groundwater pollution potential using hydrogeologic settings. NWWA/EPA Series. EPA-600/2-87-035, USEPA, Washington, DC
Attia A (1974) Parameter and characteristics of the groundwater reservoir in Upper Egypt. MSc Thesis, Cairo Univ., Egypt
Attia FA (1985) Management of water systems in Upper Egypt. PhD Thesis, Cairo Univ., Egypt
Attia FA, Amer AM, Hefny K (1983) Groundwater conditions in Upper Egypt after the construction of the HAD. Proc. of the Intern. Conf. on water resources development in Egypt, Cairo, June 1983
Attia FA, Allam MN, Amer MA (1986) A hydrologic budget analysis for the Nile Valley in Egypt. Bull Fac Eng, Cairo Univ 24(4):453–459
Babiker IS, Mohamed MA, Hiyama T, Kato K (2005) A GIS-based DRASTIC model for assessing aquifer vulnerability in Kakamigahara Heights, Gifu Prefecture, Central Japan. Sci Tot Environ 345(1–3):127–140
Barber W, Carr DP (1981) Water management capabilities of the alluvial aquifer system of the Nile Valley, Upper Egypt. Technical report No. 11, Water Master Plan, Ministry of Irrigation, Cairo
Brady NC, Weil RR (2002) The nature and properties of soils. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Dai FC, Lee CF, Zhang XH (2001) GIS-based geo-environmental evaluation for urban land-use planning: a case study. Eng Geol 61(4):257–271
Dawood AA, Abd El-Maaboud RM, Helal MA, Mohamed SA, Ali WH (2004) Detection of organochlorine pesticide residues in samples of cow milk collected from Sohag and Qena Governorates. Assiut Univ Bull Environ Res 7(2), October 2004
Ducci D (1999) GIS techniques for mapping groundwater contamination risk. Nat Hazards 20(2–3):279–294
EEAA (Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency) (1997) Sohag Governorate Environmental Profile, SEAM Programme, GEAPs/Health Care Waste/Industry/Municipal Solid Waste, EEAA, Cairo
El-Gohary FA, Wahaab RA, Nasr FA, Ali HI (2002) Three Egyptian industrial wastewater management programmes. The Environ 22:59–65
Fagnan N, Lefebvre R, Boisvert E, Michaud Y (1998) Evaluation of groundwater vulnerability to contamination in the Laurentian Piedmont using the Drastic Method (in French). University of Quebec, INRS–Georesources, Quebec, 215 pp
Farrag AA (1982) Hydrogeological studies on the Quaternary water-bearing sediments in the area between Assiut and Aswan. MSc Thesis, Assiut Univ., Egypt
Fiedler H, Hutzinger O, Welsch-Pausch K, Schmiedinger A (2000) Evaluation of the occurrence of PCDD/PCDF and POPs in waste and their potential to enter the food chain. University of Bayreuth, Bayreuth, Germany, Environmental Institute, Marietta, GA, USA, pp 15–17
Fritch TG, McKnight CL, Yelderman JC (2000) An aquifer vulnerability assessment of the Paluxy aquifer, central Texas, USA, using GIS and a modified DRASTIC approach. Environ Manage 25(3):337–345
GASG (General Authority of Sohag Governorate) (2004) Periodical Reports of Information Center, July 2001, GASG, Sohag
GASG (General Authority of Sohag Governorate) (2005) Maps of governorate projects, GASG, Sohag
Gogu RC, Dassargues A (2000) Current trends and future challenges in groundwater vulnerability assessment using overlay and index methods. Environ Geol 39(6):549–559
Ibrahim AG (1995) Management of saline underground water for irrigation in Upper Egypt. PhD Thesis, Dept. of Soils & Water, Fac. Agri., Assiut University, Egypt
Ibrahim MT (1996) The dimensions of arid climate on the Nile Valley and its effects on human activity. MSc Thesis, Geography Dept., Fac. Arts, South Valley Univ., Sohag, Egypt
Issawi B, McCauley JF (1992) The Cenozoic rivers of Egypt: the Nile problem. In: Freidman R, Adams B (eds) The followers of hours. Oxbow Mong. 20, Oxbow, Oxford, pp 121–138
Lobo-Ferreira JP, Oliveira MM (1997) Drastic groundwater vulnerability mapping of Portugal. In: Groundwater: sn endangered resource. Proceedings of Theme C 27th Congress of the International Association for Hydraulic Research, San Francisco, 10–15 August 1997, pp 132–137
Lynch SD, Reynders AG, Schulz RR (1994) Preparing input data for a national-scale groundwater vulnerability map of southern Africa. In: 6th National Hydrological Symposium, SANCIAHS, Pietermaritzburg, South AFrica, September 1993
Menani MR (2001) Evaluating and mapping the groundwater pollution susceptibility of the El Madher alluvial aquifer, eastern Algeria, using the Drastic method. Science et changements planétaires/Sécheresse 12(2):95–101
MPWWR (1988) Rehabilitation and improvement of water delivery systems in old lands. Proj. No. EGY/85/012, Final Report, Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, Cairo
Napolitano P, Fabbri AG (1996) Single-parameter sensitivity analysis for aquifer vulnerability assessment using DRASTIC and SINTACS. In: HydroGIS 96: application of Geographic Information Systems in Hydrology and Water Resources Management, Vienna, April 1996, IAHS Publ. No. 235, IAHS, Wallingford, UK, pp 559–566
Navulur KC, Engel BA (1998) Groundwater vulnerability assessment to non-point source nitrate pollution on a regional scale using GIS, ASAE 41(6):1671–1678
NRC (National Research Council) (1993) Groundwater vulnerability assessment: contamination potential under conditions of uncertainty. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
RIGW (Research Institute of Groundwater) (1980) Safe yield studies for groundwater in Nile Delta and Upper Egypt (in Arabic). RIGW, Cairo
RIGW (Research Institute of Groundwater) (1990) Hydrogeological maps of Egypt, scale 1:100,000. Water Research Center, Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, RIGW, Cairo
RIGW-IWACO (1989) Groundwater development for irrigation and drainage in the Nile Valley. Groundwater development in the area of west Tahta. Technical note 70, 124-89-05, REGW, Cairo
Said R (1990) The geology of Egypt. Balkema, Rotterdam, 734 pp
Shahid S (2000) A study of groundwater pollution vulnerability using DRASTIC/GIS, West Bengal, India. J Environ Hydrol 8(1)
Shamrukh M, Corapcioglu MY, Hassona FA (2001) Modeling the effect of chemical fertilizers on groundwater quality in the Nile Valley aquifer, Egypt. Groundwater 39(1):59–67
Stark SL, Nuckols JR, Rada J (1999) Using GIS to investigate septic system sites and nitrate pollution potential. J Environ Health 61(8):15–22
TEGPC and CONOCO (1987) Geological map of Egypt (Scale 1:500000), sheet NG 36 NW Assiut, CONOCO, Houston, TX
Thirumalaivasan D, Karmegam M, Venugopal K (2003) AHP-DRASTIC: software for specific aquifer vulnerability assessment using DRASTIC model and GIS. Environ Model Softw 18:645–656
USEPA (US Environmental Protection Agency) (1993) A review of methods for assessing quifer sensitivity and groundwater vulnerability to pesticide contamination. EPA/813/R-93/002, USEPA, Washington, DC, 147 pp
Vrba J, Zaporozec A, EDS (1994) Guidebook on mapping groundwater vulnerability. Int Assoc Hydrogeol 16:131
Warner JW, Gates TK, Attia FA, Mankarious WF (1991) Vertical leakage in Egypt’s Nile Valley: estimation and implication. J Irrig Drain Eng 117(4):515–533
Watterson A (1991) Pesticides and your food (green print). Green Print, London, 148 pp
Windham B (2002) The health effects of pesticides. In: Dawood AA, Abd El-Maaboud RM, Helal MA, Mohamed SA, Ali WH (2004) Detection of organochlorine pesticide residues in samples of cow milk collected from Sohag and Qena Governorates. Assiut Univ Bull Environ Res 7(2), October 2004
Wischmeier WH, Smith DD (1978) Predicting rainfall-erosion losses: a guide to conservation planning, Agr. handbook no. 537, USDA, Washington, DC
Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank the General Authority of Sohag Governorate (GASG) for supporting this work and providing the information. The author also thanks the anonymous reviewers and editors of Hydrogeology Journal for their kind efforts and support.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ahmed, A.A. Using Generic and Pesticide DRASTIC GIS-based models for vulnerability assessment of the Quaternary aquifer at Sohag, Egypt. Hydrogeol J 17, 1203–1217 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-009-0433-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-009-0433-3