Abstract
We investigated whether regular training in cold weather has an effect on the development of exercise-induced bronchospasm. Nineteen sedentary males and 20 male long distance runners who were regularly training in Erzurum participated in this study. They had no history of asthma, atopy or allergic rhinitis. Pre- and post-exercise spirometry was performed in the participants in room temperature. EIB was defined as at least a ≥10% fall in FEV1 or a ≥15% fall in FEF25-75% or a ≥25% fall in PEFR. EIB was established in 7 of 20 athletes and in 1 of 19 sedentaries. Prevalence of EIB will be higher even if it is established in room temperature when training for the sports like long distance running which is not a cold weather sport. We conclude that it will be more convenient to establish EIB in room temperature and in the laboratory since the exercise test and spirometry can be performed more accurately under more standard conditions.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Exercise-induced bronchospasm (EIB) is a phenomenon of transient airflow obstruction associated with physical exertion [18]. Heat and water loss from the airway surface caused by hyperventilation are main factors in the pathophysiological mechanism of EIB [4, 5, 12, 31, 36]. Symptoms typically occur shortly after the cessation of exercise and may persist for several hours [24]. Dry and cold air is the strongest triggering mechanism of bronchospasm for the people predisposed to EIB [1, 14, 34]. The clinical symptoms are coughing, wheezing, dyspnea, and excessive mucus [10]. A mismatch between fitness level and performance, “heavy legs” [24], muscle cramps, headache, abdominal pain and fatigue [33] may also be observed.
EIB, which has negative effects on physical performance and health, is frequently observed in athletes [24]. Self-reported symptoms by elite athletes are not reliable in identifying EIB [6, 22, 23], so it is advisable to diagnose it with pulmonary function measurements before and after exercise [22]. EIB frequently goes undiagnosed [18] and had formerly not been established during routine screening methods [28]. The lack of high sensitivity or specificity demonstrates that self-reported symptoms are poor indices of pulmonary dysfunction [23]. Some of the athletes did report a history of treated asthma [13].
The aim of this study was to investigate whether regular training in cold weather has an effect on the development of exercise-induced bronchospasm.
Materials and Methods
Nineteen sedentary males and 20 male long distance runners aged 18 – 25 yrs volunteered to participate in this study. The long distance runners were the athletes who were training in Erzurum regularly and had taken part in both national and international races. Sedentary males had not performed regular exercise or any job requiring heavy physical activity. EIB had not been diagnosed either by physicians or had not been detected in the previous scanning tests of the participants. They had no history of asthma, atopy or allergic rhinitis. Mean age, height and weight of the sedentaries and athletes were 18.8 ± 1.9 and 18.6 ± 2.0 yrs, 174.1 ± 6.1 and 178.7 ± 7.9 cm, 72.3 ± 6.4 and 76.0 ± 6.3 kg, respectively.
The tests were performed at room temperature in March. The pulmonary function tests were applied to the participants pre-exercise using Biopac’s MP100 Data Acquisition System. The system calibrated before each use in the laboratory. The measured pulmonary parameters were FVC, FEV1, FEF25-75% and PEFR. The intensity of the exercise on the treadmill (Powerfit 1000, Sports Art) was increased until heart rate was increased 80–90% of the maximum heart rate (220–age ± 10) and continued an extra 5 minutes. Pulmonary function tests were repeated immediately after the exercise. The criteria for the assessment of EIB was ≥10% fall in FEV1 or ≥15% fall in FEF25-75% or ≥25% fall in PEFR. Statistical analysis was applied using SPSS 10.0.1 for Windows. The differences between the groups were evaluated with the X2 test after Yates’ correction. The significance level was considered as P < 0.05.
Results
EIB was established in 7 of 20 athletes and in 1 of 19 sedentaries (Table 1). The difference between the groups was significant (p = 0.044). Participants who had ≥10% fall in FEV1 (5 athletes) had an average fall of 27% in FEV1, participants who had ≥15% fall in FEF25-75% (4 athletes) had an average fall of 26% in FEF25-75%. The fall rate in the sedentaries who had ≥ 25% fall in PEFR was 33%.
Discussion
The most commonly used criteria for the assessment of EIB is 10% decrease in FEV1 [10, 16, 19, 22, 23, 25, 26, 28]. Post-exercise falls of 15–25% [24] or 12.5% [23] in FEF25-75% is a criteria for EIB. Authors also used 15% [13], 18% [16] or 25% [17] decrease in PEFR for the assessment of EIB.
The prevalence of EIB is 4–20% in the general population [24] and 3–35% [11] or 10–50% in athletes [32]. In the literature, EIB prevalence is greater in athletes [16, 19–21, 27–29, 37] than in the sedentaries [2, 3, 7]. The present study suggested that prevalence of EIB in the long distance runners is higher than in non-athletes. There was no study in the literature investigating both athletes and sedentaries, so we suggest that our study is the first in this field. Future studies about prevalence of EIB in the larger population of athletes and non-athletes together may give more accurate results.
EIB is more common in cold weather sports [33]. Provost-Craig et al. [21] found the prevalence of EIB to be 30% in 100 ice-skaters. Rundell and Spiering [25] established EIB in 30% of the athletes exposed to cold and dry weather exercise. Mannix et al. [16] found EIB prevalence to be 35% in elite ice-skaters. Rundell et al. [26] determined 10% and more fall of FEV1 in 9 of 18 [50%] cross-country skiers. Ogston and Butcher [19] established EIB with spirometry in 28 of 99 cross-country skiers after 15-minute cross-country skiing exercise. EIB was determined in 23% of the athletes taking part in the Winter Olympic Games 1998 [38]. The prevalence of EIB in our study (35%) is similar to that of cold weather sports. However, the fact that Helenius et al. [9] found that exercise in subzero temperature had almost no effect on pulmonary function of elite runners was not in agreement with our study.
In the studies on cold weather athletes, the exercise tests on which the diagnosis of EIB was based were performed in cold weather conditions [2, 16, 19, 21, 25, 26]. Helenius et al. [10] stated that exercise tests should be performed in cold weather in order to establish EIB in elite athletes. Leuppi et al. [15] found the prevalence of EIB to be 11.5% in ice hockey players and 4.2% in ground ball players and suggested that exercising in low temperatures was a risk factor for prevalence of EIB. In 18 of 23 athletes who were diagnosed as EIB in cold weather field exercise tests, Rundell et al. [22] found post-exercise spirometry results of the laboratory exercise tests performed in room temperature as normal, and reported that a laboratory exercise challenge at room temperature is not appropriate for assessment of EIB in elite cold weather athletes, and it will likely result in false-negative evaluations. The duration of field exercises varied between 80 seconds to 1 hour in Rundell et al.’s study [22] and the duration of laboratory exercises was limited to 8 minutes, so we suggest that the results of EIB can be affected by the duration difference along with cold weather. The exercise test should be performed under laboratory conditions in diagnosing EIB since the temperature and humidity can not be controlled in the field exercise and everyone cannot be perform field exercises [33]. In this study, the exercise tests were performed in a cold climate and during winter months but at room temperature. Contrary to the suggestion, we think that when the long distance runners exercising regularly in cold weather are exposed to an exercise test in room temperature, the prevalence of EIB is not different from that in cold weather.
The prevalence of EIB is lower in warm weather sports [33]. Hammerman et al. [8] have determined EIB in 49 of 755 athletes who had no previous history of asthma or EIB. Schoene et al. [29] have established EIB in 10% of the male elite track and field athletes, Thole et al. [35] found EIB prevalence to be 14% of the cross-country runners trained in Los Angeles, California which is not as cold as Erzurum. The studies mentioned above had not been applied to the cold weather athletes and the fact that the prevalence of EIB in our study was higher than that of these studies can be attributed to athletes trained in cold weather in Erzurum in our study.
The greatest fall in the post-exercise pulmonary volume is observed in the least conditioned athletes [30]. The prevalence of EIB is higher in the asthmatic patients [3] and patients who have atopy [3, 10] and allergic rhinitis [28]. In this study, although the risk factors mentioned above did not exist in the history of the participants and their physical conditions were good, the effect of cold weather was of great importance in the higher prevalence of EIB.
We suggest that prevalence of EIB will be higher even if it is established in room temperature when training for sports like long distance running, which is not a cold-weather sport, is performed in cold weather. We are of the opinion that it will be more convenient to establish EIB in room temperature and in the laboratory since the exercise test and spirometry can be performed more accurately under more standard conditions.
References
SD Anderson K Holzer (2000) ArticleTitleExercise-induced asthma: Is it the right diagnosis in elite athletes? J Allergy Clin Immunol 106 419–428
V Backer CS Ulrik (1992) ArticleTitleBronchial responsiveness to exercise in a random sample of 494 children and adolescents from Copenhagen Clin Exp Allergy 22 741–747
CW Bierman I Kawabori WE Pierson (1975) ArticleTitleIncidence of exercise-induced asthma in children Pediatrics 56 847–850
V Brusasco E Crimi (1994) ArticleTitleAllergy and sports: exercise-induced asthma Int J Sports Med 15 S184–S186
R Dosani GRV Loon NK Burki (1987) ArticleTitleThe relationship between exercise-induced asthma and plasma catecholamines Am Rev Respir Dis 136 973–978
RA Feinstein J LaRussa A Wang-Dohlman AA Bartolucci (1996) ArticleTitleScreening adolescent athletes for exercise-induced asthma Clin J Sport Med 6 119–123
H Gökbel Ş Ataş (1999) ArticleTitleExercise-induced bronchospasm in nonasthmatic obese and nonobese boys J Sports Med Fitness 39 361–364
SI Hammerman JM Becker J Rogers TC Quedenfeld GE D’Alonzo SuffixJr (2002) ArticleTitleAsthma screening of high school athletes: identifying the undiagnosed and poorly controlled Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol 88 380–384
IJ Helenius HO Tikkanen T Haahtela (1996) ArticleTitleExercise-induced bronchospasm at low temperature in elite runners Thorax 51 628–629
IJ Helenius HO Tikkanen T Haahtela (1998) ArticleTitleOccurrence of exercise-induced bronchospasm in elite runners: dependence on atopy and exposure to cold air and pollen Br J Sports Med 32 125–129
I Helenius T Haahtela (2000) ArticleTitleAllergy and asthma in elite summer sport athletes J Allergy Clin Immunol 106 444–452
CD Hendrickson JM Lynch K Gleeson (1994) ArticleTitleExercise-induced asthma: a clinical perspective Lung 172 1–14
DS Kukafka DM Lang S Porter J Rogers et al. (1998) ArticleTitleExercise-induced bronchospasm in high school athletes via a free running test Chest 114 1613–1622
JM Kyle (1994) ArticleTitleExercise-induced pulmonary syndromes Med Clin North Am 78 413–421
JD Leuppi M Kuhn C Comminot WH Reinhart (1998) ArticleTitleHigh prevalence of bronchial hyperresponsiveness and asthma in ice hockey players Eur Respir J 12 13–16
ET Mannix MO Farber P Palange P Galassetti F Manfredi (1996) ArticleTitleExercise-induced asthma in figure skaters Chest 109 312–315
ET Mannix F Manfredi MO Farber (1999) ArticleTitleA comparison of two challenge tests for identifying exercise-induced bronchospasm in figure skaters Chest 115 649–653
H Milgrom LM Taussig (1999) ArticleTitleKeeping children with exercise-induced asthma active Pediatrics 104 e38
J Ogston JD Butcher (2002) ArticleTitleA sport-specific protocol for diagnosing exercise-induced asthma in cross-country skiers Clin J Sport Med 12 291–295
WE Pierson RO Voy (1988) ArticleTitleExercise-induced bronchospasm in the XXIII summer Olympic games N Engl Reg Allergy Proc 9 209–213
MA Provost-Craig KS Arbour DC Sestili JJ Chabalko E Ekinci (1996) ArticleTitleThe incidence of exercise-induced bronchospasm in competitive figure skaters J Asthma 33 67–71
KW Rundell RL Wilber L Szmedra et al. (2000) ArticleTitleExercise-induced asthma screening of elite athletes: field versus laboratory exercise challenge Med Sci Sports Exerc 32 309–316
KW Rundell J Im LB Mayers et al. (2001) ArticleTitleSelf-reported symptoms and exercise-induced asthma in elite athlete Med Sci Sports Exerc 33 208–213
KW Rundell DM Jenkinson (2002) ArticleTitleExercise-induced bronchospasm in the elite athlete Sport Med 32 583–600
KW Rundell BA Spiering (2003) ArticleTitleInspiratory stridor in elite athletes Chest 123 468–474
KW Rundell BA Spiering DA Judelson MH Wilson (2003) ArticleTitleBronchoconstriction during cross-country skiing: Is there really a refractory period? Med Sci Sports Exerc 35 18–26
NT Rupp MF Guill DS Brudno (1992) ArticleTitleUnrecognized exercise-induced bronchospasm in adolescent athletes Am J Dis Child 146 941–944
NT Rupp DS Brudno MF Guill (1993) ArticleTitleThe value of screening for risk of exercise-induced asthma in high school athletes Ann Allergy 70 339–342
RB Schoene K Giboney C Schimmel et al. (1997) ArticleTitleSpirometry and airway reactivity in elite track and field athletes Clin J Sport Med 7 257–261
E Smith N Mahony B Donne M O’Brien (2002) ArticleTitlePrevalence of obstructive airflow limitation in Irish collegiate athletes Ir J Med Sci 171 202–205
SL Spector (1993) ArticleTitleUpdate on exercise-induced asthma Ann Allergy 71 571–577
WW Storms (1999) ArticleTitleExercise-induced asthma: diagnosis and treatment for the recreational or elite athlete Med Sci Sports Exerc 31 S33–S38
WW Storms (2003) ArticleTitleReview of exercise-induced asthma Med Sci Sports Exerc 35 1464–1470
RH Strauss ER McFadden SuffixJr RH Ingram SuffixJr JJ Jaeger (1977) ArticleTitleEnhancement of exercise-induced asthma by cold air N Engl J Med 297 743–747
RT Thole RE Sallis AL Rubin GN Smith (2001) ArticleTitleExercise-induced bronchospasm prevalence in collegiate cross-country runners Med Sci Sports Exerc 33 1641–1646
FS Virant (1992) ArticleTitleExercise-induced bronchospasm: epidemiology, pathophysiology and therapy Med Sci Sports Exerc 24 851–855
JM Weiler T Layton M Hunt (1998) ArticleTitleAsthma in United States Olympic athletes who participated in the 1996 Summer Games J Allergy Clin Immunol 102 722–726
RL Wilber KW Rundell L Szmedra et al. (2000) ArticleTitleIncidence of exercise-induced bronchospasm in Olympic winter sport athletes Med Sci Sports Exerc 32 732–737
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ûçok, K., Dane, Ş., Gökbel, H. et al. Prevalence of Exercise-Induced Bronchospasm in Long Distance Runners Trained in Cold Weather. Lung 182, 265–270 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00408-004-2503-6
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00408-004-2503-6