Abstract
The case of Fred Hoyle’s prediction of a resonance state in carbon-12, unknown in 1953 when it was predicted, is often mentioned as an example of anthropic prediction. However, an investigation of the historical circumstances of the prediction and its subsequent experimental confirmation shows that Hoyle and his contemporaries did not associate the level in the carbon nucleus with life. Only in the 1980s, after the emergence of the anthropic principle, did it become common to see Hoyle’s prediction as anthropically significant. At about the same time mythical accounts of the prediction and its history began to abound. Not only has the anthropic myth no basis in historical fact, it is also doubtful if the excited levels in carbon-12 and other atomic nuclei can be used as an argument for the predictive power of the anthropic principle.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Ajzenberg Fay, Thomas Lauritsen (1952) Energy levels of light nuclei. IV. Reviews of Modern Physics 24: 321–402
Ajzenberg Fay, Thomas Lauritsen. (1955) Energy levels of light nuclei. V. Reviews of Modern Physics 27: 77–166
Alpher Ralph, Robert Herman. (1950) Theory of the origin and relative abundance distribution of the elements. Reviews of Modern Physics 22: 153–212
Arnett, David. 2005. Sir Fred Hoyle and the theory of the synthesis of the elements. In The scientific legacy of Fred Hoyle, ed. Douglas Gough, 9–24. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Balashov Yuri. (1991) Resource letter AP-1: The anthropic principle. American Journal of Physics 59: 1069–1076
Barrow John D. (1981) The lore of large numbers: Some historical background to the anthropic principle. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society 22: 388–420
Barrow John D. (2002) The constants of nature: From alpha to omega. Jonathan Cape, London
Barrow John D., Tipler Frank J. (1986) The anthropic cosmological principle. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Bartusiak Marcia. (1993) Through a universe darkly: A cosmic tale of Ancient Ethers, dark matter, and the fate of the universe. HarperCollins, New York
Bethe Hans. (1939) Energy production in stars. Physical Review 55: 434–456
Bethe Hans, Critchfield Charles L. (1938) The formation of deuterons by proton combination. Physical Review 54: 248–254
Bondi, Hermann. 1966. Some philosophical problems in cosmology. In British philosophy in the mid- century, ed. C.A. Mace, 393–400. London: Allen and Unwin.
Bondi Hermann, Salpeter Edwin E. (1952) Thermonuclear reactions and astrophysics. Nature 169: 304–305
Britten Roy. (1952) The scattering of 31.5-MeV protons from several elements. Physical Review 88: 283–294
Burbidge Geoffrey R. (2003) Sir Fred Hoyle. Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society 49: 213–247
Burbidge, Geoffrey R. 2008. Hoyle’s role in B2 FH. Science 319: 1484.
Burbidge E. Margaret, Burbidge Geoffrey R., Fowler William A., Fred Hoyle. (1957) Synthesis of the elements in the stars. Reviews of Modern Physics 29: 547–650
Carr Bernard J. (1982) On the origin, evolution and purpose of the physical universe. Irish Astronomical Journal 15: 237–253
Carr Bernard J., Martin Rees. (1979) The anthropic principle and the structure of the physical world. Nature 278: 605–612
Carter, Brandon. 1974. Large number coincidences and the anthropic principle in cosmology. In Confrontation of cosmological theories with observational data, ed. Malcolm S. Longair, 291–298. Dordrecht: Reidel.
Carter Brandon. (1983) The anthropic principle and its implications for biological evolution. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A 310: 347–365
Carter, Brandon. 2006. Anthropic principle in cosmology. In Current issues in cosmology, ed. Jean C. Pecker and Jayant V. Narlikar, 173–180. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cenadelli Davide. (2010) Solving the giant star problem: Theories of stellar evolution from the 1930s to the 1950s. Archive for History of Exact Sciences 64: 203–267
Chown Marcus. (1999) The Magic Furnace. Jonathan Cape, London
Chown, Marcus. 2003. Open minds reap rewards. The Guardian, 13 March.
Clayton, Donald C. (1968). Principles of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company
Clayton Donald C. (2001) Fred Hoyle, 1915–2001. Bulletin of the American Astronomical Society 33: 1570–1572
Clayton, Donald C. 2007a. Hoyle, Fred. In Biographical encyclopedia of astronomers, ed. Thomas Hockey, 532–534. New York: Springer.
Clayton Donald C. (2007) Hoyle’s equation. Science 318: 1876–1877
Cook Charles W., Fowler William A., Lauritsen Charles C., Thomas Lauritsen. (1957) B12, C12, and the red giants. Physical Review 107: 508–515
Davies Paul C.W. (1978) Cosmic heresy?. Nature 273: 336–337
Dicke Robert H. (1961) Dirac’s cosmology and Mach’s principle. Nature 192: 440–441
Dunbar, D. Noel F., Ralph E. Pixley, William A. Wenzel, and Ward Whaling, 1953. The 7.68-MeV state in C12. Physical Review 92: 649–650.
Fermi, Enrico. 1949. Teorie sulle origine degli elemente. In Collected Papers, vol. 2, 707–720. Rome: University of Chicago Press.
Fowler William A. (1954) Experimental and theoretical results on nuclear reactions in stars. Mémoires de la Société Royale des Sciences de Liège 14: 88–112
Fowler William A. (1984) The quest for the origin of the elements. Science 226: 922–935
Fowler William A., Greenstein Jesse L. (1956) Element-building reactions in stars. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 42: 173–180
Fynbo Hans O.U. et al (2005) Revised rates for the stellar triple-α process from measurements of 12C nuclear resonances. Nature 433: 136–139
Gingerich, Owen. 1994. The summer of 1953: A watershed for astrophysics. Physics Today 41(December): 34–40.
Gingerich Owen. (2006) God’s universe. Belknap Press, Cambridge
Gold Thomas. (1954) Relation between modern cosmologies and nuclear astrophysical processes. Mémoires de la Société Royale des Sciences de Liège 14: 68–69
Greenberg John L. (2005) A conversation with William A. Fowler—Part II. Physics in Perspective 7: 165–203
Greenberg, John L., and Judith R. Goodstein. 1983. The origins of nuclear astrophysics at Caltech. http://resolver.caltech.edu/CaltechAUTHORS:20091021-103101222.
Greenstein Jesse L. (1954) Nuclear reactions affecting the abundance of the elements: General survey. Mémoires de la Société Royale des Sciences de Liège 14: 307–336
Gregory Jane. (2005) Fred Hoyle’s universe. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Gribbin John, Martin Rees. (1989) Cosmic coincidences: Dark matter, mankind, and anthropic cosmology. Bantam Books, New York
Hayakawa Satio, Chushiro Hayashi Mitsuo Imoto, Ken Kikuchi. (1956) Helium capturing reactions in stars. Progress of Theoretical Physics 16: 507–527
Hemmendinger Arthur. (1949) Erratum: Disintegration of Be8. Physical Review 75: 1267
Holbrow Charles H. (1987) The giant cancer tube and the Kellogg Radiation Laboratory. Physics Today 34(July): 42–49
Holloway M.G., Moore B.L. (1940) The disintegration of N14 and N15 by deuterons. Physical Review 58: 847–860
Hornyak, W.F., Thomas Lauritsen, Philip Morrison, and William A. Fowler. 1950. Energy levels of light nuclei. III. Reviews of Modern Physics 22: 291–372.
(1946) The synthesis of the elements from hydrogen. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 106: 343–383
Hoyle Fred (1954) On nuclear reactions occurring in very hot stars. I: The synthesis of elements from carbon to nickel. Astrophysical Journal, Supplement Series 1: 121–146
Hoyle, Fred. 1957. [No title]. In Religion and the scientists, ed. N.F. Mott et al., 55–66. London: SCM Press.
Hoyle, Fred. 1958. Origins of the elements in the stars. In La Structure et l’Évolution de l’Univers, ed. R. Stoops, 281–296. Brussels: Institut Internationale de Physique Solvay.
Hoyle Fred (1965) Galaxies, nuclei, and quasars. Harper & Row, New York
Hoyle Fred (1975) Astronomy and cosmology: A modern course. W. H. Freeman and Company, San Francisco
Hoyle Fred (1980) Steady-state cosmology re-visited. University College Cardiff Press, Cardiff
Hoyle, Fred. 1982a. Two decades of collaboration with Willy Fowler. In Essays in nuclear astrophysics, ed. C.A. Barnes, D.D. Clayton, and D.N. Schramm, 1–11. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hoyle Fred (1982) The universe: Past and present reflections. Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 20: 1–35
Hoyle Fred (1986) Personal comments on the history of nuclear astrophysics. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society 27: 445–453
Hoyle Fred (1991) Some remarks on cosmology and biology. Memorie della Societa Astronomica Italiana 62: 513–518
Hoyle, Fred. 1993. The anthropic and perfect cosmological principles: Similarities and differences. In The anthropic principle, ed. Francesco Bertola and Umberto Curi, 85–89. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hoyle Fred (1994) Home is where the wind blows: Chapters from a cosmologist’s life. University Science Books, Mill Valley
Hoyle Fred, Burbidge Geoffrey R., Narlikar Jayant V. (1993) A quasi-steady state cosmological model with creation of matter. Astrophysical Journal 410: 437–457
Hoyle Fred, Dunbar D. Noel F., Wenzel William A., Ward Whaling. (1953) A state in C12 predicted from astrophysical evidence. Physical Review 92: 1095
Hoyle Fred, Martin Schwarzschild. (1955) On the evolution of type II stars. Astrophysical Journal, Supplement 2: 1–40
Hoyle, Fred, and N. Chandra Wickramasinghe. 1997. Life on Mars? A case for a cosmic heritage. Bristol: Clinical Press, 1997.
Hoyle Fred, Wickramasinghe N. Chandra. (1999) The universe and life: Deductions from the weak anthropic principle. Astrophysics and Space Science 268: 89–102
Hufbauer Karl. (2006) Stellar structure and evolution. Journal for the History of Astronomy 37: 203–227
Kirchner F., Laaf O., Neuert H. (1937) Über das Berylliumatom mit der Masse 8. Die Naturwissenschaften 25: 794
Klee Robert. (2002) The revenge of Pythagoras: How a mathematical sharp practice undermines the contemporary design argument in astrophysical cosmology. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 53: 331–354
Kragh Helge. (1996) Cosmology and controversy. The historical development of two theories of the universe. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Kragh, Helge. 2010. The road to the anthropic principle. RePoss: Research Publications on Science Studies 7. http://www.ivs.au.dk/reposs.
Lang, Kenneth R., Owen, Gingerich (eds) (1979) A source book in astronomy and astrophysics, 1900–1975. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Leslie, John (eds) (1990) Physical cosmology and philosophy. Macmillan, New York
Leslie John. (1994) Anthropic prediction. Philosophia 23: 117–144
Linde, Andrei. 2007. The inflationary universe. In Universe or multiverse? ed. Bernard Carr, 127–150. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Livio Mario, Dave Hollowell Achim Weiss, Truran James W. (1989) The anthropic significance of the existence of an excited state of 12C. Nature 340: 281–284
Malm R., Buechner W.W. (1951) Alpha-particle groups from the N14(d, α)C12 and N15(d, α)C13 reactions. Physical Review 81: 519–522
Mitton Simon. (2005) Fred Hoyle: A life in science. Aurum Press, London
Mosterin, Jesús. 2004. Anthropic explanations in cosmology. Proceedings of the 12th international congress of logic, methodology and philosophy of science, ed. Petr Hájek, Luis Valdés-Villanueva, and Dag Westerståhl, 441–471. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Nakagawa Kimiko, Takashi Ohmura Hisao Takebe, Shinya Obi. (1956) Nuclear reactions in the later stage of the stellar evolution. Progress of Theoretical Physics 16: 389–415
Narlikar Jayant V. (1999) Wonders of the cosmos. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Oberhummer, Heinz, Attila Csótó, and Helmut Schlattl. 2000. Fine-tuning carbon-based life in the universe by the triple-alpha process in red giants. In The future of the universe and the future of our civilization, ed. V. Burdyuzha and G. Khozin, 197–206. Singapore: World Scientific.
Oberhummer, Heinz, Rudolf Pichler, and Attila Csótó. 1998. The triple-alpha process and its anthropic significance. In Nuclei in the cosmos, V, ed. Nikos Prantzos and Sotiris Harrissopulos, 119–123. Paris: Editions Frontières.
Öpik Ernst. (1951) Stellar models with variable composition. II: Sequences of models with energy generation proportional to the fifteenth power of temperature. Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy A 54: 49–77
Reeves, Hubert. 1993. The growth of complexity in an expanding universe. In The anthropic principle, ed. Francesco Bertola and Umberto Curi, 67–84. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rozental Iosif L. (1980) Physical laws and the numerical values of fundamental constants. Soviet Physics Uspekhi 23: 296–306
Salpeter Edwin E. (1952) Nuclear reactions in stars without hydrogen. Astrophysical Journal 115: 326–328
Salpeter Edwin E. (1955) The 7.68-MeV level in C12 and stellar energy production. Physical Review 98: 1183–1184
Salpeter Edwin E. (1955) Energy production in stars. Vistas in Astronomy 1: 283–290
Salpeter Edwin E. (1957) Nuclear reactions in stars. Buildup from helium. Physical Review 107: 516–525
Salpeter Edwin E. (2002) A generalist looks back. Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 40: 1–25
Salpeter Edwin E. (2008) Nuclear astrophysics before 1957. Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia 25: 1–6
Sandage, Allan R., and Martin Schwarzschild. 1952. Inhomogeneous stellar models. II. Models with exhausted cores in gravitational contraction. Astrophysical Journal 116: 463–476.
Scerri Eric R. (2007) The periodic table: Its story and significance. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Schlattl Helmut et al (2004) Sensitivity of the C and O production on the 3α rate. Astrophysics and Space Science 291: 27–33
Schwarzschild Martin. (1958) Structure and evolution of the stars. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Singh Simon. (2004) Big bang. Fourth Estate, London
Smolin, Lee. 2007. Scientific alternatives to the anthropic principle. In Universe or multiverse? ed. Bernard Carr, 323–366. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Spear Ray. (2002) The most important experiment ever performed by an Australian physicist. The Physicist 39: 35–41
Staub Hans, Stephens William E. (1939) Anomalous scattering of neutrons by helium. Physical Review 55: 131–139
Susskind Leonard. (2006) The cosmic landscape: String theory and the illusion of intelligent design. Little, Brown and Company, New York
Tassoul Jean-Louis, Monique Tassoul. (2004) A concise history of solar and stellar physics. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Tollestrup Alvin V., Fowler William A., Lauritzen Charles C. (1949) Energy release in beryllium and lithium reactions with protons. Physical Review 76: 428–430
Walker, Mark, and Milan Ćirković. 2003. Anthropic reasoning and the contemporary design argument in astrophysics: A reply to Robert Klee. http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/archive/00001443/.
Weinberg Steven. (2001) Facing up: Science and its cultural adversaries. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Weinberg, Steven. 2007. Living in the multiverse. In Universe or multiverse? ed. Bernard Carr, 29–42. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wheeler John A. (1940) The alpha-particle model and the properties of the nucleus Be8. Physical Review 59: 27–36
Wickramasinghe N. Chandra. (2005) A journey with Fred Hoyle: The search for cosmic life. World Scientific, Singapore
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by Roger Stuewer.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kragh, H. An anthropic myth: Fred Hoyle’s carbon-12 resonance level. Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 64, 721–751 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00407-010-0068-8
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00407-010-0068-8