Abstract
Comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA) offers health care professionals a technique for multidimensional diagnosis of frail elderly people to plan medical, psychosocial, and rehabilitative care. In the present paper, we provide a brief history of geriatric assessment, a description of the varied organization of geriatric assessment programs (GAPs), and a review of published effectiveness studies of programs worldwide performing comprehensive geriatric assessment. Program diversity has complicated drawing conclusions about the efficacy of CGA from a literature reporting generally positive, but not uniformly significant, results. We suggest that sample size limitations explain much of the variability in findings. Using the techniques of meta-analysis, we evaluate the effect of GAPs on mortality when all controlled trials are considered cumulatively. Meta-analysis of six-month mortality demonstrates a statistically significant 36% reduction of mortality for inpatient CGA programs (odds ratio = 0.64; 95% confidence interval = 0.50 to 0.83), and a 32% mortality reduction for all CGA programs (odds ratio = 0.68; 95% confidence interval = 0.57 to 0.80). Further use of meta-analytic techniques can be employed to clarify the effect of GAPs on other important outcomes (e.g., reduced hospital and nursing home use, improved functional status), and to identify program characteristics best promoting these benefits.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Rubenstein L.Z.: Geriatric assessment: an overview of its impacts. Clin. Geriatr. Med. 3: 1–15, 1987.
Kane R.A., Kane R.L., Rubenstein L.Z.: Comprehensive assessment of the elderly patient. In: Petersen M.D., White D.L. (Eds.), Health Care of the Elderly. Sage Publications, Beverly Hills, 1989.
Wieland D.: Geriatric assessment: a guide and review of the literature. In: Brocklehurst J.C., Williams T.F. (Eds.), Multidisciplinary health assessment of the elderly patient. Dan Med Bull, Special Gerontology Supplement, No. 7: 7-24, 1989.
Rubenstein L.Z., Wieland D.: Comprehensive geriatric assessment. In: Lawton M.P. (Ed.), Annual Review of Gerontology and Geriatrics, Springer Publ. Co., New York, 1989, vol. 9.
Brocklehurst J.C.: Geriatric Care in Advanced Societies. University Park Press, Baltimore, 1975.
Matthews D.A.: Dr. Marjory Warren and the origin of British geriatrics. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 32: 253–258, 1984.
Barker W.H.: Adding Life to Years. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1987.
Kane R.L., Kane R.A.: Long-Term Care in Six Countries: Implications for the United States. Fogarty International Center Proceedings No. 33. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, 1976.
Kane R.A., Kane R.L.: Assessing the Elderly: A Practical Guide to Measurement. D.C. Heath, Lexington, Massachusetts, 1981.
Epstein A.M., Hall J.A., Besdine R., Cumella E., Feldstein M., McNeil B.J., Rowe J.W.: The emergence of geriatric assessment units: the “new technology of geriatrics”. Ann. Intern. Med. 106: 299–303, 1987.
National Institutes of Health: National Institutes of Health Consensus Development Statement: Geriatric Assessment Methods for Clinical Decision-Making. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 36: 342–347, 1988.
American Collegeof Physicians, Health and Public Policy Committee: Comprehensive functional assessment for elderly patients. Ann. Intern. Med. 108: 70–72, 1988.
Society of General Internal Medicine Task Force on Health Assessment: Health status assessment for elderly patients. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 37: 562–569,1989.
American Geriatrics Society, Public Policy Committee: Comprehensive geriatric assessment. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 37: 473–474, 1989.
Brocklehurst J.C., Williams T.F.: Multidisciplinary health assessment of the elderly patient. Dan Med Bull, Special Gerontology Supplement, No. 7,1989.
Rubenstein L.Z., Campbell L.J., Kane R.L.: Geriatric Assessment. WB Saunders, Philadelphia, 1987.
Hendriksen C, Lund E., Stromgard E.: Consequences of assessment and intervention among elderly people: three-year randomized controlled trial. Br. Med. J. 289: 1522–1524, 1984.
Campion E.W., Jette A., Berkman B.: An interdisciplinary geriatric consultation service: a controlled trial. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 31: 792–796,1983.
Winograd C.H.: Inpatient geriatric consultation. Clin. Geriatr. Med. 3: 193–202,1987.
Rubenstein L.Z., Josephson K.R., Wieland G.D., English P.A., Sayre J.A., Kane R.L.: Effectiveness of a geriatric evaluation unit: a randomized clinical trial. N. Engl. J. Med. 311:1664–1670,1984.
Martin D.C., Morycz R.K., McDowell J., Snustad. D., Karpf M.: Community-based geriatric assessment. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 33: 602–606,1985.
Millman A., Forciea M.A., Fogel D., Johnson J.C.: A model of interdisciplinary ambulatory geriatric care in a Veterans Administration Medical Center. Gerontologist 26: 471–474,1986.
Williams T.F., Hill J.G., Fairbank M.E., Knox K.G.: Appropriate placement of the chronically ill and aged: a successfull approach by evaluation. JAMA 266: 1332–1335,1973.
Tulloch A.H., Moore V.: A randomized controlled trial of geriatric screening and surveillance in general practice. J. Roy. Col. General Pract. 29: 733–742,1979.
Vetter N.J., Jones D.A., Victor C.R.: Effects of health visitors working with elderly patients in general practice: a randomized controlled trial. Br. Med. J. 288: 369–372,1984.
Collard A.F., Bachman S.S., Beatrice D.F.: Acute care delivery for the geriatric patient: an innovative approach. QRB (June): 180-185, 1985.
Allen C.C., Becker P.M., McVey L.J., Saltz C.C., Feussner J.R., Cohen H.J.: A randomized controlled clinical trial of a geriatric consultation team: compliance with recommendations. JAMA 255: 2617–2621, 1986.
Hogan D.B., Fox R.A., Badley B.W.D., Mann O.E.: Effect of a geriatric consultation service on management of patients in an acute care hospital. Can. Med. Assoc.J. 136: 713–717,1987.
Williams M.E., Williams T.F., Zimmer J.G., Hall W.J., Podgorski C.A.: How does the team approach to outpatient geriatric evaluation compare with traditional care: a report of a randomized controlled trial. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 35: 1071–1078,1987.
Gilchrist W.J., Newman R.J., Hamblen D.L., Williams B.O.: Prospective randomized study of an orthopaedic geriatric inpatient service. Br. Med. J. 297: 1116–1118, 1988.
Kennie D.C., Reid J., Richardson I.R., Kiamari A.A., Kelt C: Effectiveness of geriatric rehabilitative care after fractures of the proximal femur in elderly women: a randomized clinical trial. Br. Med. J. 297: 1083–1085, 1988.
Schuman J.E., Beattie E.J., Steed D.A., Gibson J.E., Merry G.M., Campbell W.D., Kraus A.S.: The impact of a new geriatric program in a hospital for the chronically ill. Can. Med. Assoc. J. 118: 639–645,1978.
Barker W.H., Williams T.F., Zimmer J.G., Van Buren C, Vincent S.J., Pickrel S.G.: Geriatric consultation teams in acute hospitals: impact on back-up of elderly patients. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 33: 422–428,1985.
Balaban D.J.: Chronic care study: a randomized longitudinal study of patients with chronic diseases treated on a special care unit. Final Report. Leonard Davis School of Health Economics, Philadelphia, 1980.
Lefton E., Bonstelle S., Frengley J.D.: Success with an inpatient geriatric unit: a controlled study. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 31: 149–155,1983.
Popplewell P.Y., Henschke P.J.: What is the value of a geriatric assessment unit in a teaching hospital?: a comparative study. Aust. Health Rev. 6: 23–25,1983.
Teasdale T.A., Schuman L., Snow E., Luchi R.J.: A comparison of outcomes of geriatric cohorts receiving care in a geriatric assessment unit and on general medicine floors. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 31: 529–534,1983.
Gayton D., Wood-Dauphine S., de Lorimer M., Tousignant P., Hanley J.: Trial of a geriatric consultation team in an acute care hospital. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 35: 726–736,1987.
Reid J., Kennie D.C.: Geriatric rehabilitative care after fractures of the proximal femur: one-year follow-up of a randomized clinical trial. Br. Med. J. 299: 25–26,1989.
Applegate W.B., Akins D., Van der Zwaag R., Thoni K., Baker M.G.: A geriatric rehabilitation and assessment unit in a community hospital. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 31: 206–210,1983.
Rubenstein L.Z., Josephson K.R., Wieland G.D., Pietruszka F., Tretton C, Strome S., Cole K.D., Campbell L.J.: Geriatric assessment on a subacute hospital ward. Clin. Geriatr. Med. 3: 131–143, 1987.
Berkman B., Campion E., Swagerty E., Goldman M.: Geriatric consultation teams: alternate approach to social work discharge planning. J. Gerontol. Soc. Work 5: 77–88,1983.
Lichtenstein H., Winograd C.H.: Geriatric consultation: a functional approach. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 32: 356, 1984.
Burley L.E., Currie CT., Smith R.G., Williamson J.: Contribution, from geriatric medicine within acute medical wards. Br. Med. J. 263: 90–92,1979.
Miller D.K., Rubenstein L.Z., Josephson K.R.: Impact of a geriatric evaluation unit (GEU) on functionally-adjusted life expectancy (Abstract). Gerontologist 29 (Special Issue): 253A, 1989.
Rubenstein L.Z., Wieland D., Josephson K.R., Ros-brook B., Sayre J.A., Kane R.L.: Improved survival for frail elderly inpatients on a geriatric evaluation unit (GEU): who benefits? J. Clin. Epidemiol. 41: 441–449, 1988.
Saltz C.C., McVey L.J., Becker P.M., Feussner J.R., Cohen H.J.: Impact of a geriatric consultation team on discharge placement and repeat hospitalization. Gerontologist 28: 344–350,1988.
Yusuf S., Pateo R., Lewis J., Collins R., Sleight P.: Beta blockade during and after myocardial infarction: an overview of the randomized trials. Prog. Cardiovasc. Dis. 27: 335–367,1985.
Antiplatelet Trialists’ Collaboration: Secondary prevention of vascular disease by prolonged antiplatelet treatment. Br. Med. J. 296: 320–331,1988.
Pinholt E.M., Kroenke K., Hanley J.F., Kussman M.J., Twyman P.L., Carpenter J.L.: Functional assessment of the elderly: a comparison of standard instruments with clinical judgment. Arch. Intern. Med. 147: 484–488, 1987.
Winograd C.H., Gerety M.B., Brown E., Kolodny V.: Targeting the hospitalized elderly for geriatric consultation. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 36: 1113–1119,1988.
Katz P.R., Dube D.H., Calkins E.: Use of a structured functional assessment format in a geriatric consultative service. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 33: 681–686,1985.
Poliquin N., Straker M.: A clinical psychogeriatric unit: organization and function. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 25: 132–137,1977.
Cheah K.C., Beard O.W.: Psychiatric findings in the population of a geriatric evaluation unit: implications. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 28: 153–156,1980.
Williamson J., Stokoe I.H., Gray S., Fisher M., Smith A., McGhee A., Stephenson E.: Old people at home: their unreported needs. Lancet 1: 1117–1120,1964.
Lowther C.P., MacLeod R.D.M., Williamson J.: Evaluation of early diagnostic services for the elderly. Br. Med. J. 3: 275–277,1970.
Bayne J.R., Caygill J.: Identifying needs and services for the aged. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 25: 264–268,1977.
Brocklehurst J.C., Carty M.H., Leeming J.T., Robinson J.M.: Medical screening of old people accepted for residential care. Lancet II: 141–143, 1978.
Reifler B.V., Eisdorfer C: A clinic for impaired elderly and their families. Am. J. Psychiatry 137: 1399–1403, 1980.
Sloane P.: Nursing home candidates: hospital inpatient trial to identify those appropriately assignable to less intensive care. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 28: 511–514, 1980.
Liem P.H., Chernoff R., Carter W.J.: Geriatric rehabilitation unit: a three-year outcome evaluation. J. Gerontol. 41: 44–50,1986.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rubenstein, L.Z., Siu, A.L. & Wieland, D. Comprehensive geriatric assessment: Toward understanding its efficacy. Aging Clin Exp Res 1, 87–98 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03323881
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03323881