“A riot is at bottom the language of the unheard” (Revd. Martin Luther King, 1967)
Abstract
Despite the important role which the police play in the reproduction of social order, there is a lacuna in critical criminological literature on the policing of democratic societies. As a consequence, the mistaken impression is fostered that policing in Canada is not problematic. This paper challenges this view, documenting the extent of police malpractice and raising the question of the need for police accountability. Within this context the authors discuss three forms which police accountability has historically taken: judicial inquiry, community police monitoring groups, and consultative liaison panels. One problem which the authors note is the way in which all three models depend upon the police for information about the nature of crime and policing, making them susceptible to dominant discourses about policing. Thus they continue by discussing the left realist model as potentially a fourth model. This form of police accountability emerged in Britain during the 1980s and is characterized by the production of an alternative discourse on crime and police practices based on locally conducted and controlled victimization surveys. The extent to which this practice of police accountability might be relevant to the Canadian context remains yet to be explored. The authors note in closing, however, that this is an empirical and not a theoretical question, meaning that Canadian criminologists must become more practical and less academic in their discourses of social control.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Bottomley, K. “Review Article: Victims of Crime”International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 1988: 51–54.
Brogden, M. “Law and Criminal Labels: The Case of The French Métis in Western Canada”Journal of Human Justice, Vol. 1, No. 2, Spring, 1990:13–32.
Brown, L. and C. BrownAn Unauthorized History of the RCMP, Toronto: James Lewis and Samuel, 1973.
Brown, L. “The RCMP and Their Ancestors: Over 100 Years of Willing Service”, in Currie, D. and B.D. MacLean,Rethinking The Administration of Justice, Toronto: Garamond, 1991 (in press).
Canada, Ministry of The Solicitor General, Research and Statistics Group, Programs BranchThe Canadian Urban Victimization Survey, Bulletin 2: Reported and Unreported Crimes Ottawa: Ministry of Supply and Services 1984.
Canadian Press, “Native Justice Inquiry Ends”Calgary Hearld, November 23, 1989:A7.
Canadian Press, “Native Justice Inquiry Resumes”.Calgary Herald, November 6, 1989:A9.
Clark, L. and D. LewisRape: The Price of Coercive Sexuality, Toronto: The Women's Press, 1977.
Cowell, D., T. Jones and J. Young,Policing The Riots, London: Junction, 1982.
Critchley, T.A.A History of Police in England and Wales, London: Constable, 1978.
Currie, D., B.D. MacLean and D. Milovanovic, “Three Traditions of Critical Justice Inquiry: Class, Gender and Discourse” D. Currie and B.D. MacLean (eds.)Rethinking The Administration of Justice, Toronto: Garamond, 1991 (in press).
Dion, R.Crimes of The Secret Police, Montréal: Black Rose Books, 1982.
Ericson, R.V. and P. BaranekThe Ordering of Justice: A Study of Accused Persons as Dependants in the Criminal Process, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1982/3/6.
Ericson, R.V.Making Crime: A Study of Detective Work, Toronto: Butterworths, 1981.
Ericson, R.V. “Reforming The Police and Policing Reform” in R.S. Ratner and J. McMullan (eds.),State Control: Criminal Justice Politics in Canada, Vancouver: UBC Press, 1987.
Ericson, R.V.Reproducing Order: A Study of Police Patrol Work, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1982/84.
Fidler, R.RCMP: The Real Subversives, Toronto: Vanguard, 1973.
Fleming, T. “The Bawdy House Boys: Some Notes on Media, Sporadic Moral Crusades and Selective Law Enforcement” biCanadian Criminology Forum, Vol. 3, No. 2, 1981.
Fleming, T. “Criminalizing a Marginal Community: The Bawdy House Raids” T. Fleming and L. Visano,Deviant Designations: Crime, Law and Deviance in Canada, Toronto: Butterworths, 1983.
Goff, C. and C. Reasons “Organizational Crimes Against Employees, Consumers, and The Public.” in B.D. MacLean (ed)The Political Economy of Crime: Readings for a Critical Criminology, Toronto: Prentice-Hall Canada, 1986:204–231.
Gorman, L. and J. McMullan “In Defence of The Law of The Land: Social Control and The Unemployed Movement in The Dirty Thirties in British Columbia”,Canadian Criminology Forum, Vol. 8, 1987:84–102.
Gunn, R. and C. MinchSexual Assault: The Dilemma of Disclosure, The Question of Conviction, Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press, 1988.
Gutzmore, C. “Capital, ‘Black Youth’ and Crime”,Race and Class, Vol. 25, No. 2, 1983:13–30.
Jones, T., B.D. MacLean and J. YoungThe Islington Crime Survey: Crime Victimization and Policing in Inner-City London, Aldershot: Gower, 1986.
Lea, I. and J. Young,What is To Be Done About Law and Order? Harmmondsworth: Penguin, 1984.
Lewis, C., R. Agrad, K.J. Gopic, J. Harding, T.S. Singh and R. Williams,Executive Summary of the Report of the Race Relations and Policing Task Force, Toronto: Solicitor General of Ontario, 1989b.
Lewis, C., R. Agrad, K.J. Gopic, J. Harding, T.S. Singh and R. Williams,The Report of the Race Relations and Policing Task Force, Toronto: Solicitor General of Ontario, 1989a.
Lowman, J. “Notions of Formal Equality Before The Law: The Experience of Street Prostitutes and Their Customers”The Journal of Human Justice, Volume. 1, Number 2, Spring 1990:55–76.
MacLean, B.D.The Islington Crime Survey 1985: A Cross-Sectional Study of Crime and Policing in The London Borough of Islington, London: Ph.D. Dissertation, University of London, 1985.
MacLean, B.D. “Critical Criminology and Some Limitations of Traditional Inquiry” B.D. MacLean (ed.)The Political Economy of Crime: Readings for a Critical Criminology, Toronto: Prentice-Hall Canada, 1986:1–20.
MacLean, B.D. and W.S. DeKeseredy “Taking Working Class Victimization Seriously: The Contribution of Left Realist Surveys” unpublished manuscript, 1990.
MacLeod, L.Wife Battery in Canada: The Vicious Circle, Ottawa: Ministry of Supply and Services, 1980.
McMahon, M.W. and R.V. EricsonPolicing Reform: A Study of the Reform Process and Police Institution in Toronto, Toronto: Centre for Criminology, University of Toronto, 1984.
Morand, Justice D.R. (Chair)The Royal Commission Into Metropolitan Police Practices, Toronto: Government of Ontario, 1976.
Pease, K. “The Local Crime Survey: Pitfalls and Possibilities” paper presented atRealist Criminology: Crime Control and Policing in the 1990s, Vancouver, Harbour Centre, May 25, 1990.
Pelletier, G.The October Crisis, Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1971.
Reiner, R.The Politics of The Police, Brighton: Wheatsheaf Books, 1985.
Scarman, LordThe Brixton Disorders 10–12 April 1981: Report of an Inquiry By the Rt. Hon. The Lord Scarman, O.B.E., London: HMSO, 1981.
Seccombe, W. “Sheila Rowbotham on Labour and The Greater London Council”Canadian Dimension, Vol. 21, No. 2, 1987:32–37.
Shearing, C.D. (ed)Organizational Police Deviance, Toronto: Butterworths, 1981.
Stenning, P.C. “The Role of Police Boards and Commissions as Institutions of Municipal Police Governance” in C.D. Shearing (ed)Organizational Police Deviance. Toronto: Butterworths, 1981:161–208.
Taylor, I. “Martyrdom and Surveillance: Ideological and Social Practices of Police in Canada in the 1980s”Crime and Social Justice No. 26, 1986:60–78.
Young, J. “Left Idealism, Reformism and Beyond: From New Deviancy Theory to Marxism” B. Fineet al (eds.)Capitalism and The Rule of Law, London: Hutchinson, 1979:11–28.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Currie, D., DeKeseredy, W. & MacLean, B. Reconstituting social order and social control: Police accountability in Canada. The Journal of Human Justice 2, 29–53 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02637529
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02637529