Abstract
Land and water management is increasingly focused upon the drainage basin. Thirty-six terms recently used for schemes of “integrated basin management” include reference to the subject or area and to the aims of integrated river basin management, often without allusion to the multiobjective nature. Diversity in usage of terms has occurred because of the involvement of different disciplines, of the increasing coherence of the drainage basin approach, and the problems posed in particular parts of the world. The components included in 21 different approaches are analyzed, and, in addition to showing that components related broadly to water supply, river channel, land, and leisure aspects, it is concluded that there are essentially five interrelated facets of integrated basin management that involved water, channel, land, ecology, and human activity. Two aspects not fully included in many previous schemes concern river channel changes and the dynamic integrity of the fluvial system. To clarify the terminology used, it is suggested that the termcomprehensive river basin management should be used where a wide range of components is involved, whereasintegrated basin management can signify the interactions of components and the dominance of certain components in the particular area.Holistic river basin management is advocated as a term representing an approach that is both fully comprehensive and integrated but also embraces the energetics of the river system and consideration of changes of river channels and of human impacts throughout the river system. The paradigm of working with the river can be extended to one of working with the river in the holistic basin context.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Literature Cited
Adams, W. M. 1985. River basin planning in Nigeria.Applied Geography 5:297–308.
Allee, D. J., L. B. Dworsky, and R. M. North (eds.). 1982. Unified river basin management—stage II, American Water Resources Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Ambroggi, R. P. 1980. Water.Scientific American 243:91–104.
Annen, G. 1978. River basin management in FR Germany.Progress in Water Technology 10:1–7.
Brookes, A. 1990. Restoration and enhancement of engineered river channels: Some European experiences.Regulated Rivers 5:45–56.
Brookes, A., and H. J. Long. 1990. Morphological assessment of the River Stort catchment. National Rivers Authority, Thames Region, Reading, UK.
Burchi, S. 1985. Different types of river basin entities—a global outlook. Pages 293–298in J. Lundqvist, U. Lohm and M. Falkenmark (eds.), Strategies for river basin management. D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Cobourn, J. 1989. Is cumulative watershed effects analysis coming of age?Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 44:267–270.
Coy, L. B. 1981. Unified river basin management. Pages 284–292in R. M. North, L. B. Dworsky, and D. J. Allee (eds.), Unified river basin management. American Water Research Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Crabb, P. 1988. Managing the Murray-Darling basin.Australian Geographer 19:64–88.
Cunningham, G. M. 1986. Total catchment management—resource management for the future.Journal of Soil Conservation, New South Wales 42:4–6.
Dart, M. C. 1983. River basin management. Pages 73–78in World Water 3, Proceedings ICE Conference London 1983. Thomas Telford, London.
David, L. 1985. River basin development strategies in the Tisza Valley. Pages 19–29in J. Lundqvist, U. Lohm, and M. Falkenmark (eds.), Strategies for river basin management. D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Day, D. G. 1988. Challenges to riverine planning in Australia.Australian Geographical Studies 26:309–319.
Dovers, S. R., and D. G. Day. Australian rivers and statute law.Environmental Planning and Law Journal 5:90–108.
Falkenmark, M. 1981. Integrated view of land and water.Geografiska Annaler 63A:261–271.
Falkenmark, M. 1985. Integration in the river basin context.Ambio 114:118–120.
Gardiner, J. L. 1988a. Environmentally sound river engineering: examples from the Thames catchment.Regulated Rivers 2:445–469.
Gardiner, J. L. 1988b. River Thames flood defence, a strategic initiative. Paper presented to IWEM Central Southern Branch Meeting, Wallingford, Oxon, 29 June 1988.
Gardiner, J. L. 1990. River catchment planning for land drainage, flood defence and the environment.Journal of the Institution of Water and Environmental Management 4:442–450.
Gardiner, J. L. (ed.). 1991. River projects and conservation: A manual for holistic appraisal. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
Gardiner, J. L., A. F. Dearsley, and J. R. Woolnough. 1987. The appraisal of environmentally sensitive options for flood alleviation using mathematical modelling.Journal of the Institution of Water and Environmental Management 1:171–184.
Graf, W. L. 1985. The Colorado River—instability and basin management. Association American Geographers, Washington, DC. 86 pp.
Gregory, K. J. 1976. Changing Drainage Basins.Geographical Journal 142:237–247.
Gregory, K. J. 1979a. Drainage network power.Water Resources Research 15:775–777.
Gregory, K. J. 1979b. Hydrogeomorphology: How applied should we become?.Progress in Physical Geography 3:84–101.
Gregory, K. J. 1987a. Environmental effects of river channel changes.Regulated Rivers 1:358–363.
Gregory, K. J. 1987b. The power of nature—energetics in physical geography. Pages 1–31in K. J. Gregory (ed.), Energetics of physical environment. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
Gregory, K. J. 1987c. River channels. Pages 207–235in K. J. Gregory and D. E. Walling (eds.), Human activity and environmental processes. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
Gustafson, J. E. 1989. A new perspective in river basin management. Pages 427–434in H. Laikari (ed.), River basin management—V advances in water pollution control, 9. Pergamon, IAWPRC.
Haas, J. W. 1981. Managing natural resources in the 1980's. Pages 55–61in R. M. North, L. B. Dworsky, and D. J. Allee (eds.), Unified river basin management. American Water Resources Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Hatcher, K. J. 1982. A systems view of integrated water resources management. Pages 145–160in D. J. Allee et al. (eds.), Unified river basin management—stage II. American Water Resources Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Herricks, E. E., and M. I. Braga. 1987. Habitat elements in river basin management and planning.Water Science Technology 19:19–29.
Hey, R. D. 1982. Gravel-bed rivers: Form and processes.In R. D. Hey et al. (eds.), Gravel-bed rivers, fluvial processes engineering and management. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
Huggett, R. J. 1980. Systems Analysis in Geography. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Jenkins, S. H. 1978. River basin management—Proceedings, Conference at Essen, 1977.Progress in Water Technology 10, 345 pp.
Lord, W. B. 1982. Unified river basin management in retrospect and prospect. Pages 58–67in L. B. Dworsky and D. J. Allee (eds.), Unified river basin management—stage II. American Water Resources Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Lundqvist, J., U. Lohm, and M. Falkenmark. 1985. River basin strategy for coordinated land and water conservation. Pages 5–17in J. Lundqvist, U. Lohm, and M. Falkenmark (eds.), Strategies in river basin management. D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Mageed, Y. A. 1985. The integrated river basin development, the challenges to the Nile Basin countries. Pages 151–160in J. Lundqvist et al. (eds.), Strategies in river basin management. D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Mbumwae, L. L. 1988. Environmental management of the Zambezi River system.Regulated Rivers 2:553–557.
McDonald, A. T., and D. Kay. 1988. Water resources: Issues and strategies. Longman, Harlow.
McFadden, J. J. 1983. The Thames River implementation program. Pages 211–222in B. Mitchell, and J. S. Gardner (eds.), River basin management: Canadian experiences. University of Waterloo Department of Geography, Pub. No. 20, Waterloo, Ontario.
Meyers, C. D. 1977. Energetics: Systems analysis with applications to water resources planning and decision making. US Army Engineers Institute for Water Resources, IWR Contract Report 77-6 Fort Belvoir, Virginia.
Mitchell, B. 1987. A comprehensive-integrated approach for land and water management. Occasional paper 1, centre for water policy research. University of New England, Armidale, NSW, Australia.
Mitchell, B., and J. S. Gardner, 1983. Introduction. Pages 1–4in B. Mitchell, and J. S. Gardner (eds.), River basin management: Canadian experiences. University of Waterloo Department of Geography Pub No. 20, Waterloo, Ontario.
Mitchell, B., and J. J. Pigram. 1989. Integrated resource management and the Hunter Valley Conservation Trust, NSW, Australia.Applied Geography 9:196–211.
Mosely, P. 1985. Upstream-downstream interactions as natural constraints to basin wide planning for China's River Huang. Pages 131–140in J. Lundqvist, U. Lohm, and M. Falkenmark (eds.), Strategies for river basin management. D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
National Rivers Authority. 1989. Land drainage catchment plans: Implementations guidelines report. Catchment Planning, Technical Series, NRA Thames Region, Reading, UK.
Newson, M. D. 1986. River basin engineering—fluvial geomorphology.Journal of the Institution of Water Engineers 40:307–324.
Newson, M. D. 1987. Land and water: The “River Look” on the face of geography. University of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Department of Geography, Seminar Paper No. 51. 32 pp.
Newson, M. D. 1988. Applied physical geography: The opportunities and constraints of environmental issues revealed by river basin management.Scottish Geographical Magazine 104:67–71.
New Zealand Catchments Authorities Association 1988. Catchwords, No. 82. 11 April 1988.
North, R. M., L. B. Dworsky, and D. J. Allee (eds.). 1981. Unified river basin management. Proceedings, Symposium 4–7 May 1980. American Water Resources Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Odum, H. T., and E. C. Odum. 1976. Energy basis for man and nature. Wiley, New York.
Osmond, D. S., and D. F. McQuay, 1983. Watershed management in central Ontario: A case study. Pages 239–252in B. Mitchell and J. S. Gardner (eds.), River basin management: Canadian experiences, University of Waterloo Department of Geography Publ. No. 20, Waterloo, Ontario.
Pantulu, V. R. 1981. Role of environmental factors in internationally shared water resources. United Nations Interregional meeting of International River Organisation Daker, Senegal, 20. 29 January 1981.
Pantulu, V. R. 1983. River basin management.Ambio 12:109–111.
Pantulu, V. R. 1985. Ecosystem modelling of a river basin. Pages 31–40in J. Lundqvist, U. Lohm, and M. Falkenmark (eds.), Strategies for river basin management. D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Parker, D. J. and E. C. Penning-Rowsell, 1980. Water planning in Britain. George Allen & Unwin, London.
Pentland, R. L. 1983. A federal perspective on river basin management. Pages 71–84in B. Mitchell and J. S. Gardner (eds.), River basin management: Canadian experiences. University of Waterloo, Department of Geography Publ. No. 20. Waterloo, Ontario.
Primus, C. L. 1983. River basin planning in Alberta: Current status and future issues. Pages 43–48in B. Mitchell and J. S. Gardner (eds.), River basin management: Canadian experiences. University of Waterloo Department of Geography Publ. No. 20. Waterloo, Ontario.
Reynolds, P. J. 1985. Ecosystem approaches to river basin planning. Pages 41–48in J. Lundqvist, U. Lohm, and M. Falkenmark (eds.), Strategies for river basin management. D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Richter, D. D., S. R. Saplaco, and P. F. Nowak. 1985. Watershed management problems in humid tropical uplands.Nature and Resources 21:10–21.
Saha, S. K. 1981. River basin planning as a field of study: Design of a course structure for practitioners. Pages 9–40in S. K. Saha and C. J. Barrow (eds.), River basin planning: Theory and practice. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
Saha, S. K., and C. J. Barrow. 1981. Introduction. Pages 1–7in S. K. Saha and C. J. Barrow (eds.), River basin planning: Theory and practice. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
Schenk, C. F. 1983. The Stratford-Avon River environmental project. Pages 223–238in B. Mitchell and J. S. Gardner (eds.), River basin management: Canadian experiences. University of Waterloo Department of Geography Publ. No. 20. Waterloo, Ontario.
Siann, J. M. 1981. Conflicting interests in river basin planning. Pages 215–232in S. K. Saha and C. J. Barrow (eds.), River basin planning: Theory and practice. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK.
Sinclair Knight. 1981. Summary report—Hunter Valley, July 1981. Sinclair Knight & Partners, Paramatta, New South Wales.
Smith, C. T. 1969. The drainage basin as an historical basis for human activity. Pages 101–110in R. J. Chorley (ed.), Water, Earth and Man. Methuen & Co, London.
Stone, P. J. 1980. A systems approach to water resources allocation in international river basin development.Water Resources Research 16:1–13.
Ullah, W. 1983. River basin planning in urbanizing environments in Newfoundland: Problems and present data needs. Pages 175–186in B. Mitchell and J. S. Gardner (eds.), River basin management: Canadian experiences. University of Waterloo Department of Geography Publ. No. 20. Waterloo, Ontario.
United Nations. 1970. Integrated river basin development: Report of a panel of experts. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, New York.
Van Beek, J. L. 1981. Planning for integrated management of the Atchafalaya River basin: Natural system viability and policy constraints. Pages 328–337in R. M. North, L. B. Dworsky, and D. J. Allee (eds.), Unified river basin management. American Water Research Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Veen, M. A., and G. Baarse. 1982. Policy analysis of water management for the Netherlands (PAWN). Pages 113–122in M. J. Lowing (ed.), Optional allocation of water resources. International Association of Hydrological Sciences Publication No. 135.
Wall, J. R. D. 1981. A management plan for the Acelhuate River, El Salvador: Soil conservation, river stabilization and pollution control. Land Resources Development Centre, Land Resources Study 30. Overseas Development Administration, Surbiton, L.R.D.C.
Wengert, N. 1981. A critical review of the river basin as a focus for resources planning, development and management. Pages 9–27in R. M. North, L. B. Dworsky, and D. J. Allee (eds.), Unified river basin management. American Water Research Association, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
White, G. F. (ed.), 1977. Environmental effects of complex river developments. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.
Winkley, B. R. 1972. River regulation with the aid of nature. International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage, Eighth Congress, Varna, Transactions Vol. V, 29.1, 433–457.
Wolman, A. 1980. Some reflections on river basin management.Progress in Water Technology 13:1–6.
Young, D. D. 1978. River basin management in the U.K.Progress in Water Technology 10:9–18.
Ziyun, F. 1985. Some strategic principles for long term river basin development. Pages 141–150in J. Lundqvist et al. (eds.), Strategies in river basin management. D. Reidel. Dordrecht.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Downs, P.W., Gregory, K.J. & Brookes, A. How integrated is river basin management?. Environmental Management 15, 299–309 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02393876
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02393876