Abstract
The approach developed by Environment Canada to assess risk to aquatic and terrestrial plants in nontarget habitats potentially exposed to pesticides evaluated for registration is described. An anonymous sample of pesticide submissions is used to illustrate the approach and to examine its merits and limitations in relation to test species, response variability, testing protocols, ecological relevance, and comparability with other regulatory agencies. Future directions are identified, particularly in relation to impending nontarget-plant testing guidelines for pesticide registration in Canada. This approach incorporates some of the latest research and developments in the field of risk assessment for plants. The novelty of this approach also lies in the use of the plant screening data routinely generated by chemical pesticide companies, which is intended to provide a maximum amount of information to evaluators at minimal increment cost to registrants. The proposed approach can serve as a basis for guideline development and modernization for other jurisdictions.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Literature Cited
Agriculture Canada, Environment Canada, and Department of Fisheries and Oceans. 1987. Environmental chemistry and fate guidelines for registration of pesticides in Canada, T-1-255, 56 pp.
APHA/AWWA/WEF. 1992. Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater. Section 8220: Aquatic plants (proposed). Pages 8/42–8/45in American Public Health Association, American Water Works Association and Water Environment Federation, 18th edition, Washington, DC.
ASTM. 1991a. Standard guide for conducting static 96-h toxicity tests with microalgae. Pages 845–856in 1991 Annual book of ASTM standards, Vol. 11–04. Designation E 1218-90. American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia.
ASTM. 1991b. Standard guide for conducting static toxicity tests withLemna gibba G3. Pages 1137–1146in 1991 Annual book of ASTM standards, Vol. 11–04. Designation E 11415-91. American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia.
Bartell, S. M., R. H. Gardner, and R. V. O'Neill. 1992. Ecological risk estimation. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, Florida, 252 pp.
Blanck, H., G. Wallin, and S. Wangberg. 1984. Species-dependent variation in algal sensitivity to chemical compounds.Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 8:339–351.
Boutin, C., K. E. Freemark, and C. Keddy. 1993. Proposed guidelines for registration of chemical pesticides: nontarget plant testing and evaluation. Technical report series No. 145. Canadian Wildlife Service (Headquarters), Environment Canada, Ottawa, 91 pp.
Brown, R. A., and D. Farmer. 1991. Track-sprayer and glasshouse techniques for terrestrial plant bioassays with pesticides. Pages 197–208in J. W. Gorsuch, W. R. Lower, W. Wang, and M. Lewis (eds.), Plants for toxicity assessment, 2 vol. American Society for Testing and Materials STP 1115, Philadelphia.
Cairns, J., Jr. 1993a. Environmental science and resource management in the 21st century: Scientific perspective.Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 12:1321–1329.
Cairns, J., Jr. 1993b. Will there ever be a field of landscape toxicology?Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 12:609–610.
Cohen, S. Z., S. M. Creeger, R. F. Carsel, and C. B. Enfield. 1984. Potential pesticide contamination of groundwater from agricultural uses. Pages 297–325in R. F. Kruegar and J. D. Seiber (eds.), Treatment and disposal of pesticide wastes. American Chemical Society Symposium Series No. 259, Washington, DC.
Costanza, R., B. G. Norton, and B. D. Haskell. 1992. Ecosystem health: New goals for environmental management. Island Press, Washington, DC, 269 pp.
Elliott, J. G., and B. J. Wilson (eds.). 1983. The influence of weather on the efficiency and safety of pesticide application: The drift of herbicides. British Crop Protection Council Occasional Publication No. 3., London, 135 pp.
Fahrig, L., and K. E. Freemark. 1993. Landscape-scale effects of toxic events for ecological risk assessmentIn J. Cairns and B. Niederlehner (eds.), Toxicity testing at different levels of biological organization. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, Florida (in press).
Fletcher, J. S. 1990. Use of algae versus vascular plants to test for chemical toxicity. Pages 33–39in W. Wang, J. W. Gorsuch and W. R. Lower (eds.), Plants for toxicity assessment. American Society for Testing and Materials STP 1091, Philadelphia.
Fletcher, J. S., F. L. Johnson, and J.C. McFarlane. 1990. Influence of greenhouse versus field testing and taxonomic differences on plant sensitivity to chemical treatment.Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 9:769–776.
Forbes, T. L., and V. E. Forbes. 1993. A critique of the use of distribution-based extrapolation models in ecotoxicology.Functional Ecology 7:249–254.
Frans, R. E., and R. E. Talbert. 1977. Design of field experiment and the measurement and analysis of plant response. Pages 15–23in B. Truelove (ed.), Research methods in weed science. Southern Weed Science Society, Auburn, Alabama.
Freemark, K. E., and C. Boutin. 1994. Impacts of agricultural herbicide use on terrestrial wildlife: A review.Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment (in review).
Freemark, K. E., P. MacQuarrie, S. Swanson, and H. Peterson. 1990. Development of guidelines for testing pesticide toxicity to nontarget plants for Canada. Pages 14–29in W. Wang, J. W. Gorsuch and W. R. Lower (eds.), Plants for toxicity assessment. American Society for Testing and Materials STP 1091, Philadelphia.
Garrod, J. F. 1989. Comparative responses of laboratory and field grown test plants to herbicides.Aspects of Applied Biology 21:51–64.
Gohlich, H. 1983. Assessment of spray drift in sloping vineyards.Crop Protection 2:37–49.
Goring, C. A. I., D. A. Laskowski, J. H. Hamaker, and R. W. Meikle. 1975. Principles of pesticide degradation in soil. Pages 135–172in R. Haque and V. H. Freed (eds.), Environmental dynamics of pesticides. Plenum Press, New York.
Gorsuch, J. W., W. R. Lower, W. Wang, and M. Lewis (eds.). 1991. Plants for toxicity assessment, 2 vol. American Society for Testing and Materials STP 1115, Philadelphia.
Greig-Smith, P. 1992. A European perspective on ecological risk assessment, illustrated by pesticide registration procedures in the United Kingdom, Environmental Toxicology Chemistry 11:1673–1690.
Hald, A. B., and N. Elmegaard. 1988. Pesticide exclusion strips between agricultural and non-agricultural areas in Denmark: Introduction to a Danish 3-year project in cereals, 1985–87.Ecological Bulletins (Copenhagen) 39:189–190.
Hamill, A. S., P. B. Marriage, and G. Friesen. 1977. A method for assessing herbicide performance in small plot experiments.Weed Science 25:386–389.
Kennedy, J. M., and R. E. Talbert. 1977. Comparative persistence of dinitroaniline type herbicides on the soil surface.Weed Science 25:373–381.
Levin, S.A., M. A. Harwell, J. R. Kelly, and K. D. Kimball (eds.). 1989. Ecotoxicology: Problems and Approaches. Springer-Verlag, New York, 547 pp.
Lewis, C., and R. Petrie. 1991. Plant data analysis by Ecological Effects Branch in the Office of Pesticides Program. Pages 6–15in J. Fletcher and H. Ratsch, Plant tier testing: A workshop to evaluate nontarget plant testing in subdivision J pesticide guidelines. EPA/600/9-91/041, US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Corvallis, Oregon.
Lockhart, W. L., B. N. Billeck, and C. L. Baron. 1989. Bioassays with a floating aquatic plant (Lemna minor) for effects of sprayed and dissolved glyphosate.Hydrobiologia 188/189:353–359.
MacLeod, D. A. 1993. Recommended statistical methods for nontarget plant testing. Pages B1-B78in C. Boutin, K. E. Freemark, and C. J. Keddy (eds.), Proposed guidelines for registration of chemical pesticides: Nontarget plant testing and evaluation. Technical Report Series No. 145. Canadian Wildlife Service (Headquarters), Environment Canada, Ottawa.
Marrs, R. H., A. J. Frost, R. A. Plant, and P. Lunnis. 1992. The effects of herbicide drift on semi-natural vegetation: The use of buffer zones to minimize risks.Aspects of Applied Biology 29:57–64.
Marshall, E. J. P., and J. E. Birnie. 1985. Herbicide effects on field margin floras. Proceedings 1985, British Crop Protection Conference—Weeds, BCPC Publication, Croydon, England, pp. 1021–1028.
Martin, A. C., H. S. Zim, and A. L. Nelson. 1951. American wildlife and plants. McGraw-Hill, New York, 500 pp.
Maybank, J., K. Yoshida, and R. Grover. 1978. Spray drift from agricultural pesticide applications.Journal of the Air Pollution Control Association 28:1009–1014.
Norby, A., and R. Skuterud. 1975. The effects of boom height, working pressure and wind speed on spray drift.Weed Research 14:385–395.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 1981. OECD guidelines for testing of chemicals. Paris.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 1984a. Algal growth inhibition test. OECD guidelines for testing of chemicals no. 201. Paris, 13 pp.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 1984b. Terrestrial plants, growth test. OECD guidelines for testing of chemicals no. 208. Paris, 6 pp.
OECD. 1989. Report of the OECD workshop on ecological effects assessment. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Environment Monographs No. 26. Paris, 66 pp.
Peterson, H. G., and F. P. Healey. 1985. Comparative pH dependent metal inhibition of nutrient uptake byScenedesmus quadricauda (Chlorophyceae).Journal of Phycology 21:217–222.
Peterson, H. G., F. P. Healey, and R. Wagemann. 1984. Metal toxicity to algae: A highly pH dependent phenomenon.Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science 41:974–979.
Peterson, H. G., C. Boutin, P. A. Martin, K. E. Freemark, N. J. Ruecker, and M. J. Moody. 1993. Aquatic phytotoxicity of 23 pesticides applied at expected environmental concentrations.Aquatic Toxicology (in press).
Pimental, D., L. McLaughlin, A. Zepp, B. Lakitan, T. Kraus, P. Kleinman, F. Vancini, W. J. Roach, E. Graap, W. S. Keeton, and G. Selig. 1991. Environmental and economic effects of reducing pesticide use.BioScience 41:402–409.
Ramamoorthy, S., and E. Baddaloo. 1991. Evaluation of environmental data for regulatory and impact assessment. Studies in environmental science 41. Elsevier, New York, 466 pp.
Rao, P. S. C., and J. M. Davidson. 1980. Estimation of pesticide retention and transformation parameters required in nonpoint source pollution models. Pages 23–67in M. R. Overcash and J. M. Davidson (eds.), Environmental impact of nonpoint source pollution. Ann Arbor Scientific Publication, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan.
Schwinn, F. J. 1988. Importance, possibilities and limitations of chemical control now and in future—an industry view.Ecological Bulletins (Copenhagen) 39:82–88.
Sheehan, P. J., A. Baril, P. Mineau, D. K. Smith, A. Harfenist, and W. K. Marshall. 1987. The impact of pesticides on the ecology of prairie nesting ducks. Technical Report Series No. 19. Canadian Wildlife Service (Headquarters), Environment Canada, Ottawa, 641 pp.
Sotherton, N. W. 1991. Conservation headlands: A practical combination of intensive cereal farming and conservation. Pages 373–398in L. G. Firbank, N. Carter, J. F. Darbyshire, and G. R. Potts (eds.), The Ecology of temperate cereal fields. Blackwell Scientific, London, 469 pp.
Statistics Canada. 1992. Agricultural profile of Canada. Part 1. Catalogue 93-350.
Suter, G. W. II. 1993. Ecological risk assessment. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, Florida, 538 pp.
Swanson S. M., C. P. Rickard, K. E. Freemark, and P. MacQuarrie. 1991. Testing for pesticide toxicity to aquatic plants: Recommendations for test species. Pages 77–97in J. W. Gorsuch, W. R. Lower, W. Wang, and M. Lewis (eds.), Plants for toxicity assessment, 2 vol. American Society for Testing and Materials STP 1115, Philadelphia.
Tubea, B., K. Hawxby, and R. Mehta. 1981. The effects of nutrient, pH and herbicide levels on algal growth.Hydrobiologia 79:221–227.
USEPA. 1982. Pesticide assessment guidelines, subdivision J. Hazard evaluation: Nontarget plants. US Environmental Protection Agency, EPA-540/9-82-020, Office of Pesticides and Toxic Substances, Washington, DC, 55 pp.
van Leeuwen, K. 1990. Ecotoxicological effects assessment in the Netherlands: Recent developments.Environmental Management 14:779–792.
van Leeuwen, C. J., P. T. J. van der Zandt, T. Aldenberg, H. J. M. Verhaar, and J. L. M. Hermens. 1992. Application of QSARs, extrapolation and equilibrium partitioning in aquatic effects assessment. I. Narcotic industrial pollutants.Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 11:267–282.
Wang, W., J. W. Gorsuch and W. R. Lower (eds.). 1990. Plants for toxicity assessment. American Society for Testing and Materials STP 1091, Philadelphia, 363 pp.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Freemark, K., Boutin, C. Nontarget-plant risk assessment for pesticide registration. Environmental Management 18, 841–854 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02393614
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02393614