Summary
The sources of errors which may occur when cytophotometric analysis is performed with video microscopy using a charged-coupled device (CCD) camera and image analysis are reviewed. The importance of these errors in practice has been tested, and ways of minimizing or avoiding them are described. Many of these sources of error are known from scanning and integrating cytophotometry; they include the use of white instead of monochromatic light, the distribution error, glare, diffraction, shading distortion, and inadequate depth of field. Sources of errors specifically linked with video microscopy or image analysis are highlighted as well; these errors include blooming, limited dynamic range of grey levels, non-linear responses of the camera, contrast transfer, photon noise, dark current, read-out noise, fixed scene noise and spatial calibration. Glare, contrast transfer, fixed scene noise, depth of field and spatial calibration seem to be the most serious sources of errors when measurements are not carried out correctly. We include a table summarizing all the errors discussed in this review and procedures for avoiding them. It can be concluded that if accurate calibration steps are performed and proper guidelines followed, image cytometry can be applied safely for quantifying amounts of chromophore per cell or per unit volume of tissue in sections, even when relatively simple and inexpensive instrumentation is being used.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Aikens,R. S. (1990) CCD cameras for video microscopy. InOptical Microscopy for Biology (edited byHerman,B. &Jacobson,K.) pp. 207–18. New York: Wiley-Liss.
Aikens,R. S.,Agard,D. A. &Sedat,J. W. (1989) Solid-state imagers for microscopy.Meth. Cell. Biol. 29, 291–313.
Allison,D. C.,Ridolpho,P. F.,Rasch,E. M.,Rasch,R. W. &Johnson,T. S. (1981) Increased accuracy of absorption cytophotometric DNA values by control of stain intensity.J. Histochem. Cytochem. 29, 1219–28.
Allison,D. C.,Lawrence,G. N.,Ridolpho,P. F.,O'Grady,B. J.,Rasch,R. W. &Rasch,E. M. (1984) Increased accuracy and speed of absorption cytometric DNA measurements by automatic corrections for nuclear darkness.Cytometry 5, 217–27.
Araki,T.,Chikamori,K.,Sasaki,K.,Kawata,S.,Minami,S. &Yamada,M. (1987) Topographic estimations by component spectroanalysis of two formazans of nitrobluetetrazolium in tissue sections.Histochemistry 86, 567–72.
Baak,J. P. A.,Oort,J.,Fleege,J. C.,VanDiest,P. J. &Ploem,J. S. (1991) Techniques in quantitative pathology. InManual of Quantitative Pathology in Cancer Diagnosis and Prognosis (edited byBaak,J. F. A., pp. 45–56. Berlin: Springer Verlag.
Bacus,J. W. &Grace,L. J. (1987) Optical microscope system for standardized cell measurement and analysis.Appl. Opt. 26, 3280–93.
Barba,J.,Chan,K. S. &Gil,J. (1992) Quantitative perimeter and area measurement of digital images.Micr. Res. Techn. 21, 300–14.
Bartels,P. H. (1991) Videophotometry: sources of error. InManual of Quantitative Pathology in Cancer Diagnosis and Prognosis (edited byBaak,J. F. A.) pp. 182–8. Berlin: Springer Verlag.
Bitensky,L.,Butcher,R. G. &Chayen,J. (1973) Quantitative cytochemistry in the study of lysosomal function. InLysosomes in Biology and Pathology (edited byDingle,J. T.) pp. 465–510. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Boguth,W. &Piller,H. (1988) The influence of the aperture of illumination on the accuracy of microscope-photometric measurements of internal transmittance.J. Microsc. 149, 117–25.
Bookman,R. J. &Horrigan,F. T. (1993) Sampling characteristics of CCD video cameras. InOptical Microscopy: Emerging Methods and Applications (edited byHerman,B. &Lemasters,B. H.) pp. 115–131. San Diego: Academic Press.
Castleman,K. R. (1987) Spatial and photometric resolution and calibration requirements for cell image analysis instruments.Appl. Opt. 26, 3338–42.
Castleman,K. R. (1993) Resolution and sampling requirements for digital image processing, analysis and display. InElectronic Light Microscopy (edited byShotton,D.) pp. 71–93. New York: Wiley-Liss.
CCIR (1990)Recommendation 601-2Encoding parameters of digital television for studios.
Chieco,P. &Boor,P. (1984) Quantitative histochemistry in pathology and toxicology. An evaluation of the original two-wavelength method of Ornstein.Lab. Invest. 50, 355–62.
Chieco,P. &Robutti,F. (1992)Metodi in Citologia Analitica. 1. Citofotometria del DNA e Analisi in situ dell' Attività Proliferativa nei Tumori Solidi (edited by Italian league against tumour). Bologna: Eurocopy.
Chieco,P.,Melchiorri,C.,Lisignoli,G.,Marabini,A. &Orlandi,C. (1991) A multifaced DNA ploidy analysis to determine ovarian carcinoma aggressiveness.Cancer 67, 1878–85.
Cole,M. (1971) Instrument errors in quantitative image analysis.Microscope 19, 87–104.
Dawson,A. E.,Norton,J. A. &Weinberg,D. S. (1990) Comparative assessment of proliferation and DNA content in breast carcinoma by image analysis and flow cytometry.Am. J. Pathol. 136, 1115–24.
Donovan,R. M. &Goldstein,E. (1985) A charge coupled device-based image cytophotometry system for quantitative histochemistry and cytochemistry.J. Histochem. Cyto-chem. 33, 551–6.
Duijndam,W. A. L.,Smeulders,A. W. M.,VanDuijn,P. &Verweij,A. C. (1980a) Optical errors in scanning stage absorbance cytophotometry. I. Procedures for correcting apparent integrated absorbance values for distributional, glare, and diffraction errors.J. Histochem. Cytochem. 28, 395–400.
Duijndam,W. A. L.,VanDuijn,P. &Riddersma,S. H. (1980b) Optical errors in scanning stage absorbance cytophotometry. II. Application of correction factors for residual distributional error, glare and diffraction error in practical cytophotometry.J. Histochem. Cytochem. 28, 395–400.
Fand,S. B. &Spencer,R. P. (1964) Off-peak absorption measurements in Feulgen cytophotometry.J. Cell. Biol. 22, 515–20.
Goldstein,D. J. (1970) Aspects of scanning microdensitometry. I. Stray light (glare).J. Microsc. 92, 1–16.
Goldstein,D. J. (1971) Aspects of scanning microdensitometry. II. Spot size, focus and resolution.J. Microsc. 93, 15–42.
Goldstein,D. J. (1975) Aspects of scanning microdensitometry. III. The monochromator system.J. Microsc. 105, 33–56.
Goldstein,D. J. (1981) Errors in microdensitometry.Histochem. J. 13, 251–67.
Goldstein,D. J. (1982) Scanning microdensitometry of objects small relative to the wavelength of light.J. Histochem. Cytochem. 30, 1040–50.
Gonzalez,R. C. &Wintz,P. (1986)Digital Image Processing, 2nd edn. Reading: Addison Wesley Publishing Co.
Hiraoka,Y.,Sedat,J. W. &Agard,D. A. (1987) The use of a charged-coupled device for quantitative optical microscopy of biological structures.Science 238, 36–41.
Inoué,S. (1986)Video Microscopy. New York: Plenum Press.
James,J. &Tanke,H. J. (1991)Biomedical Light Microscopy. Dordrecht: Kluver Academic Publisher.
Jarvis,L. R. (1981) Microdensitometry with image analyser video scanners.J. Microsc. 121, 337–46.
Jenkins,T. (1992) Is that a camera on your tie clip? The new-generation mini CCDs.Adv. Imaging. 7/9, 22–4.
Jordan,S. W.,Brayer,J. M.,Bartells,P. H. &Anderson,R. E. (1988) Video-based image collection for quantitative histopathology.Anal. Quant. Cytol. Histol. 10, 37–46.
Kristian,J. &Blouke,M. (1982) Charge-coupled devices in astronomy.Scientific American 247, 48–55.
Middelhoek,S. &Audet,S. A. (1989)Silicon Sensors, pp. 35–103. London: Academic Press.
Ornstein,L. (1952) The distributional error in microspectrophotometry.Lab. Invest. 1, 250–62.
Philips (1991)Video Data Handbook. Sunnyvale: Signetics Company.
Piller,H. (1977)Microscope Photometry. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
Pluta,M. (1988)Advanced Light Microscopy, Vol. 1.Principles and Basic Properties. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Ramm,P.,Kulick,J. H.,Stryker,M. P. &Frost,B. J. (1984) Video and scanning microdensitometer-based imaging systems in autoradiographic densitometry.J. Neurosci. Meth. 11, 89–100.
Sanchez,L.,Regh,M.,Biesterfeld,S.,Chatelain,R. &Böcking,A. (1990) Performance of a TV image analysis system as a microdensitometer.Anal. Quant. Cytol. Histol. 12, 279–84.
Schultz,M. L.,Lipkin,L. E.,Wade,M. J.,Lemkin,P. F. &Carman,G. M. (1974) High resolution shading correction.J. Histochem. Cytochem. 22, 751–4.
Smeulders,A. W. M. &TenKate,T. K. (1987) Accuracy of optical density measurement of cells. 1: Low resolution.Appl. Opt. 26, 3249–56.
Tsay,T. T.,Inman,R.,Wray,B.,Herman,B. &Jacobson,K. (1990) Characterization of low-level cameras for digitized video microscopy.J. Microsc. 160, 141–59.
VanNoorden,C. J. F. (1989) Principles of cytophotometry in enzyme histochemistry and validity of the reactions.Acta Histochem. Suppl. 37, 21–35.
VanNoorden,C. J. F. &Butcher,R. G. (1986) The out-of-range error in microdensitometry.Histochem. J. 18, 397–8.
VanNoorden,C. J. F. &Butcher,R. G. (1991) Quantitative enzyme histochemistry. InHistochemistry. Theoretical and Applied (edited byStoward,P. J. &Pearse,A. G. E.) pp. 355–432. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Walter,R. J. &Berns,M. W. (1986) Digital image processing and analysis. InVideo Microscopy (edited by)InoueS.) pp. 327–92. New York: Plenum Press.
Young,I. T. (1988) Sampling density and quantitative microscopy.Anal. Quant. Cytol. Histol. 10, 269–75.
Zimmer,H. G. (1973) Microphotometry. InMicromethods in Molecular Biology (edited byNeuhoff,V.) pp. 297–328. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chieco, P., Jonker, A., Melchiorri, C. et al. A user's guide for avoiding errors in absorbance image cytometry: a review with original experimental observations. Histochem J 26, 1–19 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02388388
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02388388