Abstract
Descriptive decision science says how peopledo make up their minds (e.g. as psychological and organizational theory). Normative decision science says howideal peoplewould make up their minds (e.g. as statistical decision theory). Prescriptive decision science (PDS) says how peopleshould make up their minds (including a distinctive fusion of the descriptive and normative). PDS supports the development and validation of decision-aiding technology, to make it appropriate for specific circumstances, balancing considerations of feasible input, useful output, logical coherence, and cost of implementation. The author argues for a major redirection of effort toward PDS by the decision science community, and suggests promising directions for its development with illustrations from his company's work.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
R.C. Bromage, R.V. Brown, J.O. Chinnis, Jr., M.S. Cohen and J.W. Ulvila, Decision aids for submarine command and control, Phase III. Concept implementation, Technical Report 83-2, Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1983).
R.V. Brown, Presenting risk management information to policy makers, Executive summary, Technical Report 85-4, Report to National Science Foundation. Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1985).
R.V. Brown, Decision analytic tools in government, In:Government Infostructures, ed. K.B. Levitan (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT, 1987).
R.V. Brown, Handling second-order assessment uncertainty: A prescriptive approach to decision aiding, J. Risk and Uncertainty, in press.
R.V. Brown, C.R. Peterson, W.H. Shawcross and J.W. Ulvila, Decision analysis as an element in an operational decision aiding system (Phase II), Technical Report 75-13, Decisions and Designs, Inc., McLean, VA (1975). (NTIS No. AD A018109).
R.V. Brown and D.V. Lindley, Reconciling incoherent judgments (RIJ) — Toward principles of personal rationality, Technical Report TR 78-8-72, Decisions and Designs, Inc., McLean, VA (1978). (NTIS No. AD A059639).
R.V. Brown and J.W. Ulvila, Communicating information to risk managers: Techniques with examples from nuclear regulation, Vol. I: Main report; Vol. II: Supplementary material, Technical Report 85-4, Report to National Science Foundation. Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1985).
R.V. Brown, K.B. Laskey and G.L. Lilien, Institutional estimation: Measuring quantitative features of populations of institutions (Phase I), Technical Report 85-5, Decision Science Consortium, Falls Church, VA (1985). (NTIS No. PB87-216461/A06).
R.V. Brown and D.V. Lindley, Plural analysis: Multiple approaches to quantitative research, Theory and Decision 20(1986)133.
R.V. Brown, J.W. Ulvila and G.L. Lilien, Personalist appraisal of estimates: A methodology for evaluating industrial market research and other institutional estimation studies, Report No. 17, Institute for the Study of Business Markets (1988).
M.S. Cohen and R.V. Brown, Decision support for attack submarine commanders, Technical Report 80-11, Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1980).
M.S. Cohen, Decision support for attack submarine commanders: Target range pooling and attack planning (U), Technical Report 82-1, Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1982). Confidential.
M.S. Cohen, Validation of a target range decision aid (U), Proc. 49th MORS Symp., Alexandria, VA. Military Operations Research Society (1982). Secret.
M.S. Cohen, R.C. Bromage, J.O. Chinnis, Jr., J.W. Payne and J.W. Ulvila, A personalized and prescriptive attack planning decision aid, Technical Report 82-4, Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1982).
M.S. Cohen, M.A. Tolcott, A.W. Martin, J.M. Leddo and J.R. McIntyre, Cognitive strategies in submarine command decision making, Technical Report 87-13, Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Reston, VA (1988).
A.N.S. Freeling, Alternative frameworks for the reconciliation of probability assessments, Technical Report 80-4, Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1980).
C.J. Grayson, Management science and business practice, Harvard Business Review (July–August, 1973).
K.B. Laskey, Design of plural analysis: Allocation of resources between two or more studies, under revision for Operations Research (1989).
D.V. Lindley, Reconciliation of probability distributions, Oper. Res. 31(1983)866.
D.V. Lindley, Reconciliation of discrete probability distributions, in:Bayesian Statistics, Vol. 2, ed. J.M. Bernardo et al. (North-Holland, 1985) pp. 375–390.
D.V. Lindley, Using expert advice on a skew judgmental distribution, Oper. Res. 35(5) 1987.
D.V. Lindley, A. Tversky and R.V. Brown, On the reconciliation of probability assessments, J. Roy. Stat. Soc., Series A142(2)(1979)146.
J.F. Smith, T.R. Mitchell and L.R. Beach, A cost-benefit mechanism for selecting problem-solving strategies: Some extensions and empirical tests, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 29(1982)370.
J.W. Ulvila and R.V. Brown, Attack planning decision aid for submarine command and control, Technical Report 83-4, Decision Science Consortium, Inc., Falls Church, VA (1983).
J.W. Ulvila and R.V. Brown, Decision analysis comes of age, Harvard Business Review (September–October, 1982) 130.
D. von Winterfeldt, T. Eppel and C. Ford, An experimental investigation of plural analysis: Estimating the market share of compact disc players in 1990, Behavioral Science, in press.
R.L. Winkler and S. Makridakis, The combination of forecasts, J. Roy. Stat. Soc. 146(1983)150.
References
P.C. Fishburn, Independence in utility theory with whole product sets, Oper. Res. 13(1965)28.
A. Tversky, Additivity, utility, and subjective probability, J. Mathematical Psychology 4(1967)175.
D. von Winterfeldt and W. Edwards,Decision Analysis and Behavioral Research (Cambridge University Press, New York, 1986).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brown, R.V. Toward a prescriptive science and technology of decision aiding. Ann Oper Res 19, 465–483 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02283535
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02283535