Abstract
Agricultural research and education ended 100 years of funding under the Hatch Act with a decade of unprecedented criticism of goals and outcomes. This paper examines the way that planners can accommodate some of these criticisms within a framework for understanding the ethical and social goals of agriculture that is consistent with traditional practice. The paper goes on to state that some criticisms are so fundamental that they cannot be readily incorporated into this framework. They must be regarded as a challenge, both politically and intellectually, to longstanding practices within academic institutions devoted to agriculture.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Aiken, William, and Hugh LaFollette. (1977).World Hunger and Moral Obligation, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice-Hall.
Aiken, William. (1982). “The Goals of Agriculture,”Agriculture, Change and Human Values, R. Haynes and R. Lanier, eds., Gainesville, FL. Humanities and Agriculture Program, University of Florida, pp. 29–54.
Aiken, W. (1984). “Ethical Issues in Agriculture,”Earthbound, T. Reagan, ed. New York, Random House.
Aiken, William. (1986). “On Evaluating Agricultural Research,”New Directions for Agriculture and Agricultural Research. K. Dahlberg, ed., Totowa, NJ, Rowman and Allanheld, pp. 31–41.
Arrow, Kenneth. (1951, 2nd ed. 1963).Social Values and Individual Choice, New Haven, CT, Cowles Foundation for Research in Economics at Yale University.
Auxter, Thomas. (1985). “Poetry and Self-Knowledge in Rural Life,”Agriculture and Human Values 2(2):15–27.
Beitz, Charles R. (1979).Political Theory and International Relations, Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press.
Berry, Wendell. (1977).The Unsettling of America, San Francisco, Sierra Club Books.
Bishop, Katherine. (1987). “California U. Told to change Research to Aid Small Farms,”The New York Times, November 19, 1987, p. 13A.
Blatz, Charles V. (1984). “Ethical Issues in Private and Public Ranch Land Management,”Agriculture and Human Values 1(4):3–16.
Bonnen, James T. (1986). “A Century of Science in Agriculture: Lessons for Science Policy,”American Journal of Agricultural Economics 68:1065–1080.
Buchanon, James M. (1987). “The Economizing Element in Knight's Ethical Critique of Capitalism,”Ethics 98(1):61–75.
Busch, Lawrence and William B. Lacy. (1983).Science, Agriculture and the Politics of Research, Boulder, CO, Westview Press.
Buttel, Frederick. (1987). “Social Science Institutions, Knowledge, and Tools to Address Problems and Issues,”Proceedings of Phase I Workshop, Neill Schaller, compiler, Social Science Agricultural Agenda Project, Spring Hill Conference Center, Minneapolis, MN, June 9–11, 1987, pp. 79–115.
Callicott, J. Baird. (1980) “Animal Liberation: A Triangular Affair,”Environmental Ethics, 2:311–338.
Callicott, J. Baird. (1987). “Just the Facts, Ma'am,”The Environmental Professional, 9:277–288.
Callicott, J. Baird. (1988). “Agroecology in Context,”Journal of Agricultural Ethics 1(1):3–9.
Caplan, A. L. (1986). “The Ethics of Uncertainty: The Reglation of Food Safety in the United States,”Agriculture and Human Values 3(1 & 2):180–190.
Collins, Joseph and Frances Moore Lappe, (1977).Food First, New York: Ballentine Books.
Coye, Molly Joel. (1986). “Health Effects of Agricultural Research, K. Dahlberg, ed. Totowa, NJ, 165–198.
Dahlberg, Kenneth A. ed. (1986).New Directions for Agriculture and Agricultural Research: Neglected Dimensions and Emerging Alternatives, Totowa, NJ., Rowman and Allanheld.
Danbom, David B. (1986). “Publicly Sponsored Agricultural Research in the United States from Historical Perspective,”New Directions for Agriculture and Agricultural Research (Kenneth A. Dahlberg, ed.) Totowa, NJ, Rowman and Allanheld, pp. 147–162.
de Castro, Josue. (1977).The Geopolitics of Hunger, New York, The Monthly Review Press.
Diesing, Paul (1982).Science and Ideology in the Policy Sciences, New York, Aldine Publishing Co.
Doyle, Jack. (1985).Altered Harvest, New York, Viking Penguin.
Ebenreck, S. (1983). “A Partnership Farmland Ethic,”Environmental Ethics 5(1):33–45.
Emerson, Ralph Waldo. (1870, reprinted 1904). “Farming,”Society and Solitude, Boston, Houghton Mifflin, pp. 139–154.
Fox, Michael W. (1986).Agricide, New York, Schocken Book.
Gendron, Bernard. (1977).Technology and the Human Condition, New York, St. Martins Press.
Hager, Philip. (1987). “UC Ordered to Alter Focus of Farm Research,”The Los Angeles Times, November 18, 1987, pp. 1A, 22A.
Harris, C. E. Jr. (1986).Applying Moral Theories. Belmont, CA, Wadsworth.
Haynes, Richard, and Ray Lanier eds. (1982).Agriculture, Change and Human Values: Proceedings of a Multidisciplinary Conference, Gainesville, FL, Humanities and Agriculture Program, The University of Florida.
Heffernan, William D. (1986). “Review and Evaluation of Social Externaliies,”New Directions for Agriculture and Agricultural Research, K. Dahlberg, ed. Totowa, NJ, Roman and Allanheld, 199–220.
Hightower, Jim. (1975).Hard Tomatoes, Hard Times, Cambridge, MA, Schenkman.
Hightower, Jim. (1976).Eat Your Heart Out. New York, Crown Books.
Hoag, Robert. (1986). “Happiness and Freedom: Recent Work on John Stuart Mill,”Philosophy and Public Affairs, 15:188–199.
Hoffman, W. Michael. (1984). “The Ford Pinto,”Business Ethics: Readings and Cases in Corporate Morality, W. M. Hoffman and J. M. Moore, eds., New York, McGraw-Hill, 412–420.
Hollander, Rachelle D. (1986). “Values and Making Decisions about Agricultural Research,”Agriculture and Human Values 3(3):33–40.
Jackson, Wes. (1980).New Roots for Agriculture, San Francisco, Friends of the Earth.
Johnson, Glenn L. (1984). “Academia Needs a New Covenant for Serving Agriculture,” Special Publication, Mississippi Agriculture and Forestry Experiment Station.
Johnson, Glenn L. (1987).Research Methodology for Economists, New York, Macmillan.
Jordan, John Patrick, Paul F. O'Connell, and Roland R. Robinson, (1986). “Historical Evolution of the State Agricultural Experiment Station System,”New Directions for Agriculture and Agricultural Research (Kenneth A. Dahlberg, ed.) (Totowa, NJ, Rowman and Allanheld, pp. 147–162.
Kirkendall, Richard S. (1987). “Up to Now: A History of American Agriculture from Jefferson to Revolution to Crisis,”Proceedings of Phase I Workshop, (Niell Schaller, ed.) Social Science Agricultural Agenda Project, Spring Hill Conference Center, Minneapolis, MN, June 9–11, 1987.
Knight, Frank. (1935).The Ethics of Competition, London, George Allen & Unwin, Ltd.).
Kunkel, H. O. (1984). “Agricultural Ethics—The Setting,”Agriculture and Human Values 1(1):20–23.
Leopold, Aldo. (1949).A Sand County Almanac, and Sketches Here and There, London, Oxford University Press.
Levine, J. (1986). “Hearts and Minds: The Politics of Diet and Heart Disease,”Consuming Fears, H. M. Sapolsky, ed. New York, Basic Books.
Locke, John. (1690, reprinted 1980).The Second Treatise of Government, C. B. MacPherson, ed., Indianapolis, Hackett Publishing Co.
Lowrance, William W. (1986).Modern Science and Human Values, New York, Oxford University Press.
Madden, Patrick & Paul B. Thompson. (1987). “Ethical Perspectives on Changing Agricultural Technology in the United States,”Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy, 3:85–116.
Martin, Philip and Alan Olmstead. (1985). “The Agricultural Mechanization Controversy,” Science, 227:601–606.
Mason, Jim and Peter Singer. (1980).Animal Factories, New York, Crown Books.
McClennan, Edward F. (1983). “Rational Choice and Public Policy: A Critical Survey,”Social Theory and Practice, 9(2–3):335–379.
Montmarquet, James A. (1985). “Philosophical Foundations for Agrarianism,”Agriculture and Human Values 2(2):5–14.
Mortimer, R. C. (1950).Christian Ethics, London, Hutchinson.
Naess, Arne. (1984). “A Defense of the Deep Ecology Movement,”Environmental Ethics, 6(3):265–270.
Nagel, Thomas. (1977). “Poverty and Food: Why Charity Is Not Enough,”Food Policy,. (Peter Brown & Henry Shue, eds.) New York, The Free Press, pp. 54–62.
National Research Council, (1972).Report of the Committee on Research Advisory to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C., National Academy of Science.
National Research Council, (1975).Agricultural Production Research Efficiency, Washington, D.C., National Academy of Science.
O'Neill, Onora. (1980). “The Moral Perplexities of Famine Relief,”Matters of Life and Death: New Introductory Essays in Moral Philosophy, Tom Regan, ed., New York, Random House.
O'Neill, Onora. (1986).Faces of Hunger, London, Allen & Unwin.
Pimentel, David, and Susan Pimentel. (1986). “Energy and Other Natural Resources Used by Agriculture and Society,”New Directions for Agriculture and Agricultural Research, K. Dahlberg, ed. Totowa, NJ, Rowman and Allanheld, 259–287.
Regan, Tom (1983).The Case For Animal Rights, Berkeley, U. California Press.
Robbins, Lionel. (1935).An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science, London, Macmillan.
Ruttan, Vernon W. (1983).Agricultural Research Policy, Minneapolis, MN, U. Minnesota Press.
Ruttan, Vernon W. (1986). “Toward a Global Agricultural Research System: A Personal View,”Research Policy 15:307–327.
Sauer, Richard J. (1987). “From the Perspective of Users and Affected Persons,”Proceedings of Phase I Workshop, Niell Schaller, compiler, Social Science Agricultural Agenda Project, Spring Hill Conference Center, Minneapolis, MN, June 9–11, 1987, pp. 267–280.
Schaller, Niell, compiler. (1987).Proceedings of Phase I Workshop, Social Science Agricultural Agenda Project, Spring Hill Conference Center, Minneapolis, MN, June 9–11, 1987.
Schell, Orville. (1984).Modern Meat, New York, Random House.
Schooler, Dean Jr. (1972).Science, Scientists and Public Policy, New York, The Free Press.
Schuh, G. Edward. (1986). “Revitalizing Land Grant Universities,”Choices Second Quarter.
Schumacher, E. F. (1973).Small Is Beaultiful, New York: Harper & Row.
Shepard, Philip. (1984). “Moral Conflict in Agriculture: Conquest or Moral Coevolution?”Agriculture and Human Values, 1(4):17–25.
Shue, Henry. (1980).Basic Rights, Princeton, NJ, Princeton U. Press.
Sinclair, Ward. (1987). “Judge Rules Research Program Favors Large Farms,”The Washington Post, November 19, 1987, p. A24.
Singer, Peter. (1972). “Famine, Affluence, and Morality,”Philosophy and Public Affairs 1(3).
Singer, Peter. (1973). “Animal Liberation,”The New York Review of Books, (April, 1973) pp. 17–21.
Stansbury, Dale L. (1986). “The Context and Implications of the National Agricultural Research, Extension, and Teaching Act of 1977,”New Directions for Agriculture and Agricultural Research: Neglected Dimensions and Emerging Alternatives, K. Dahlberg, ed. (Totowa, NJ: 1986, Rowman and Allanheld) pp. 132–146.
Thompson, Paul B. (1986). “The Social Goals of Agriculture,”Agriculture and Human Values 3(4):32–42.
Thompson, Paul B. (1988a). “Ethics in Agricultural Research,”Journal of Agricultural Ethics, 1:11–20.
Thompson, Paul B. (1988b). “Of Cabbages and Kings,”Public Affairs Quarterly 2(1):69–88.
Tweeten, Luther. (1983). “Food for People and Profit: Ethics and Capitalism,” The Farm and Food System in Transition — Emerging Policy Issues, No. FS5, Cooperative Extension Service, Michigan State University.
Unger, Stephen H. (1982).Controlling Technology: Ethics and the Responsible Engineer, New York, Holt, Rhinehart and Winston.
Wunderlich, Gene, ed. (1987).Ideas, Facts and Choices: Three Lectures on Philosophy and Applied Economics, Natural Resource Economics Division, Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Staff Report AGES870512.
Ziman, John. (1968).Public Knowledge: The Social Dimension of Science, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Additional information
Paul Thompson is an Associate Professor of Philosophy and of Agricultural Economics at Texas A&M University. He is currently conducting research under a grant from the National Science Foundation, Ethics and Values Studies program on the role of ethics and values in the planning of agricultural research activities, and completing a textbook entitledEthics, Public Policy and Argiculture with Eileen Olsen VanRavenswaay and Robert Matthews, slated for publication by John Wiley & Sons in 1990.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Thompson, P.B. Ethical dilemmas in agriculture: The need for recognition and resolution. Agric Hum Values 5, 4–15 (1988). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02217643
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02217643