Abstract
A recent initiative in some Latin American countries, to define thebasic core of credited titles of domestic scientific journals in the different knowledge fields, is reviewed. The policy aim is to strengthen the best journals and to minimize the noise produced by the great number of journals that do a disservice to the authors who publish in them either because of their low quality or because even if they are reasonably good, have a very low impact. It is argued that if the exercise were carried out in a rigorous and systematic way in the countries of the region that publish scientific journals, one might eventually obtain a depurated list of Latin American periodical publications. Such list might be useful as a supplement to the catalogues of mainstream journals registered by ISI and other international databases, and could provide “valid” alternatives of publication of results for Latin American researchers and for authors of other regions active in subjects in which the countries of the region have significant scientific contributions. It might also help to provide a better indication of the total publishing activity of Latin American countries.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Notes and references
C. A. Macias-Chapula, Análisis de citas de cuatro revistas biomédicas latinoamericanas,Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 14, 4 (1991) 420–427.
L. Ferreiro, S. Ugena, Citation mechanics in journals covered by the Journal Citation Reports,Scientometrics, 24 (1992) 149–162.
Independently of the criticisms that can be raised against such bases, as an example of this invisibility it is enough to mention that upon a total of over 3000 registers, the SCI includes only 49 Latin American journals. See alsoE. Garfield, Journal citation Studies, 26. Latin American journals. In:E. Garfield (Ed.)Essays of an Information Scientist, Institute for Scientific Information, Philadelphia, PA, (1974–1976), 577–583.
The endogamic diffusion of results, i.e. the publication by the same person of all his works in the same institutional journal, often from his own Department, and the limited number of contributions published in journals of the international domain, is a typical feature of underdeveloped structures. For a Spanish case, seeA. Villagrá Rubio, Scientific production of Spanish universities in the fields of social sciences and language,Scientometrics, 24 (1992) 3–19.
A recent analysis of this situation in Spain is that ofC. Ortega, L. M. Plaza, M. J. Martin, M. C. Urdin, Spanish scientific and technical journals, state of the art,Scientometrics, 24 (1992) 21–42. The diversity of situations of scientific development in different countries is analysed, among others, byS. Arunachalam, S. Markanday, Science in the middle-level countries: a bibliometric analysis of scientific journals of Australia, Canada, India and Israel,Journal of Information Science, 3 (1981) 13–26. The analysis of these authors offers interesting elements with regard to the fields where a country has greater relative strength and the journals that have a possibility to become international.
Through case studies of Latin American journals I have studied some of these problems.H. Vessuri, Una estrategia de publicación científica para la fisiología latinoamericana: “Acta Physiologica Latinoamericana”,Interciencia, 14 1 (1989) 9–13;H. Vessuri, La revista científica periférica. El caso de “Acta Científica Venezolana”,Interciencia, 12, 3 (1987) 124–134;H. Vessuri, ┐Ciencia Hoje” o en América Latina también se puede,Interciencia, 16, 6 (1988) 317–318;H. Vessuri, M. Safar, Elementos para la historia social de la química en Venezuela: la Sociedad Venezolana de Química, In:E. Diaz, Y. Texera, H. Vessuri,La ciencia periférica, Caracas, Monte Avila Edtores, 1993, pp. 121–166.
C. Freeman, Recent developments in science and technology indicators: a review. Science Policy Research Unit, Brighton: Sussex University, 1982, mimeo.
UNESCO,Grupo de Trabajo, para la Selección de Revistas Científicas Latinoamericanas April 28 – May 1, 1964, University of Puerto Rico, Centro de Cooperación Científica de la UNESCO para América Latina, Montevideo, 1964.
A few years later, from a country by subject count of the serial periodical collection at the British Library Lending Division, a similar proportion of Latin American journals was established.M. P. Carpenter, F. Narin, The subject composition of the world's scientific journals,Scientometrics, 2 (1980) 53–63.
Although there is evidence that the traditional role of scientific societies as journal publishers is being reconsidered by them in response to economic, social and professional pressures, it would seem that it is nonetheless valid that they continue to be among the largest publishers of specialized journals, contributing significantly to scientific communication.K. B. Levitan, Scientific societies and their journals: Biomedical scientists assess the relationship,Social Studies of Science, 9 (1979) 393–400.
CONACYT, Call for the evaluation of Mexican scientific journals, published in the Mexican daily press, April 18th, 1993.
R. F. Krzyzanowski, E. M. Krieger, F. A. da Moura Duarte, Programa de apóio as revistas científicas pela FAPESP,Ciencia da Informacao, 20, 2 (1991) 137–150.
R. Lisker, A. Loría, Letter to the editor,Boletin de la AIC, 21, Nov.–Dec., 1994, p. 38.
J. Rios, Las revistas de excelencia que publican los Institutos y Centros de Coordinación de Humanidades de la UNAM, de acuerdo con el Indice de Revistas Mexicanas de Excelencia, publicado por el CONACYT el 18 de abril de 1994, UNAM, México, May 1994, mimeo.
M. A. Pérez Angón Indice de revistas científicas mexicanas (editorial note),Boletín de la AIC, 20, Sept.–Oct. 1994, p. 4.
Some recent examples of studies of Latin American sciences using international databases are published inScientometrics, 23, 1 (1992), among themJ. Gaillard, Use of publication lists to study scientific production and strategies of scientists in developing countries, pp. 57–73;H. Delgado, J. M. Russell, Impact of studies published in the international literature by scientists at the National University of Mexico, pp. 75–90;J. E. Rabinovich, Publications of scientists of developing countries in international journals: are they channels to the international circuit for colleagues that only publish in national journals?, pp. 91–104. These and other papers were included in the Proceedings of the International Conference onScience Indicators for Developing Countries, edited byR. Arvanitis, J. Gaillard, ORSTOM/CNRS, Paris, 1992. See alsoM. Krauskopf, R. Pessot, R. Vicuña, Science in Latin America. How much and along what lines?Scientometrics, 10 (1986) 199–206.
Op. cit. (1964).
Krzyanowski, et al.,op cit..
CONACYT,op. cit. Call for the evaluation of Mexican scientific journals, published in the Mexican daily press, April 18th, (1994).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vessuri, H. Recent strategies for adding value to scientific journals in Latin America. Scientometrics 34, 139–161 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02019178
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02019178