Summary
Comparing populations that differ in access to mutualists can suggest how traits associated with these interactions have evolved. I discuss geographical and seasonal variation in the success of a primarily tropical mutualism (the fig/pollinator interaction), and evaluate some possible adaptations allowing it to persist at the edge of its range. Pollinators probably have difficulty in seasonal sites because 1) fig trees flower rarely in winter and 2) trees that do flower are less detectable and more difficult to reach. Fig biologists believe that seasonality must have selected for adaptations allowing pollinators to survive winter. However, geographical comparisons do not support two current ideas, the synchrony-breakdown hypothesis and the specificity-breakdown hypothesis. I pose two alternatives: plasticity of fruit and wasp developmental time, and adaptations of free-living fig wasps. I also distinguish between the impact of seasonality on monoecious versus dioecious figs; the latter group appear better adapted to reproduce in cool climates. A combination of comparative, observational, and experimental approaches has great potential for advancing our understanding of mutualisms.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Baijnath, H., and Ramcharun, S., Microscopic observations of the ostiolar bracts in some South African examples of the genusFicus L. (Moraceae). Proc. Electron micr. Soc. S. Afr.11 (1981) 135–136.
Baijnath, H., and Ramcharun, S., Aspects of pollination and floral development inFicus capensis Thunb. (Moraceae). Bothalia14 (1983) 883–888.
Baijnath, H., and Ramcharun, S., Reproductive biology and chalcid symbiosis inFicus burtt-davyi (Moraceae). Monogr. Syst. bot. Mo. Bot. Gdn25 (1988) 227–235.
Baijnath, H., Naicker, S., and Ramcharun, S., The interaction of figs and fig wasps, in: Insects and the Plant Surface, pp. 348–349 Eds B. E. S. Juniper and T. R. E. Southwood. Edward Arnold Ltd, London 1986.
Balakrishnan Nair, P., and Abdurahiman, U. C., Population dynamics of the fig waspKradibia gestroi (Grandi) (Hymenoptera Chalcidoidea, Agaonidae) fromFicus exasperata Vahl. Proc. K. ned. Akad. Wet., Ser. C87 (1984) 365–375.
Barker, N. P., Evidence of a volatile attractant inFicus ingens (Moraceae). Bothalia15 (1985) 607–611.
Bentley, B. L., Plants bearing extrafloral nectaries and the associated ant community: interhabitat differences in the reduction of herbivore damage. Ecology57 (1976) 815–820.
Berg, C. C., Floral differentiation and dioecism inFicus (Moraceae), in: Minisymposium, Figs and Fig Insects, pp. 15–25. CNRS, Montpellier, France 1984.
Berg, C. C., Classification and distribution ofFicus. Experientia45 (1989) 605–611.
Bond, W., and Slingsby, P., Collapse of an ant-plant mutualism: the Argentine ant (Iridomyrmex hunilis) and myrmecochorous Proteaceae. Ecology65 (1984) 1031–1037.
Borchert, R., Phenology and control of flowering in tropical trees. Biotropica15 (1982) 81–89.
Boucek, Z., Watsham, A., and Wiebes, J. T., The fig wasp fauna of the receptacles ofFicus thonningii (Hymenoptera, Chalcidoidea). Tijdschr. Ent.124 (1981) 149–233.
Brantjes, N. B. M., Wind as a factor influencing flower-visiting byHadena bicruris (Noctuidae) andDeilephila elpenor (Sphingidae). Ecol. Ent.6 (1981) 361–363.
Briand, F., and Yodzis, P., The phylogenetic distribution of obligate mutualism: evidence of limiting similarity and global instability. Oikos39 (1982) 273–275.
Bronstein, J.L., Coevolution and Contraints in a Neotropical Fig-Pollinator Wasp Mutualism. Ph. D. Dissertation. University of Michigan, Ann Arbor 1986.
Bronstein, J. L., Maintenance of species-specificity in a Neotropical fig-pollinator wasp mutualism. Oikos48 (1987) 39–46.
Bronstein, J. L., Fruit production in a monoecious fig: consequences of an obligate mutualism. Ecology69 (1988) 207–214.
Bronstein, J. L., Mutualism, antagonism, and the fig-pollinator interaction. Ecology69 (1988) 1298–1302.
Bronstein, J. L., Predators of fig wasps. Biotropica20 (1988) 215–219.
Bronstein, J. L., and Hoffmann, K. L., Spatial and temporal variation in frugivory at a neotropical figFicus pertusa Oikos49 (1987) 261–268.
Bronstein, J. L., Gouyon, P.-H., Gliddon, C., Kjellberg, F., and Michaloud, G., Ecological consequences of flowering asynchrony in monoecious figs: a simulation study. unpublished manuscript.
Brown, T. W., and Walsingham, F. G., The sycamore fig in Egypt. J. Hered.8 (1917) 3–12.
Butcher, F. G., The Florida fig wasp,Secundeisenia mexicana (Ashm.), and some of its hymenopterous symbionts. Fla. Ent.47 (1964) 235–238.
Carde, R. T., Chemo-orientation in flying insects, in: Chemical Ecology of Insects, pp. 111–124. Eds W. J. Bell and R. T. Carde. Chapman and Hall, New York 1984.
Chapman, R. F., Bernays, E. A., and Simpson, S. J., Attraction and repulsion of the aphid,Cavariella aegopodii by plant odors. J. chem. Ecol.7 (1981) 881–888.
Chopra, R. N., and Kaur, H., Pollination and fertilization in someFicus species. Beitr. Biol. Pfl.45 (1969) 441–446.
Compton, S. G., and Robertson, H. G., Complex interactions between mutualisms: ants tending homopterans protect fig seeds and pollinators. Ecology69 (1988) 1302–1305.
Condit, I. J., Caprifigs and caprification. Calif. Agric. exp. Sta. Bull.319 (1920) 341–377.
Condit, I. J., The Fig. Chronica Botanica, Waltham 1947.
Corlett, R. T., The phenology ofFicus benjamina andF. microcarpa in Singapore. J. Singapore natl Acad. Sci.13 (1984) 30–31.
Corlett, R. T., The phenology ofFicus fistulosa in Singapore. Biotropica19 (1987) 122–124.
Corner, E. J. H.,Ficus glabberima Bl. and the pedunculate species ofFicus subgen.Urostigma in Asia and Australasia. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London, Ser. B281 (1978) 347–371.
Corner, E. J. H.,Ficus (Moraceae) and Hymenoptera (Chalcidoidea): figs and their pollinators. Biol. J. Linn. Soc.25 (1985) 187–195.
Cox, P. A., Extinction of the Hawaiian avifauna resulted in a change of pollinators for the leie,Freycinetia arborea. Oikos41 (1983) 195–199.
Cruden, R. W., Kinsman, S., Stockhouse II, R. E., and Linhart, Y. B., Pollination, fecundity, and the distribution of moth-flowered plants. Biotropica8 (1976) 204–210.
Cunningham, D. D., On the phenomena of fertilization inFicus roxburghii, Wall. A. Rev. bot. Gdn. Calcutta1 (Appendix) (1889) 13–47.
Damstra, K. S. J., Notes on Zimbabwean tree families. The fig family (Moraceae). Zimbabwe Sci. News19 (1985) 151–154.
Eisikowitch, D., and Galil, J., effect of wind on the pollination ofPancratium maritimum L. (Amaryllidaceae) by hawkmoths (Lepidoptera: Sphingidae). J. Anim. Ecol.40 (1971) 673–678.
Feinsinger, P., Wolfe, J. A., and Swarm, L. A., Island ecology: reduced hummingbird diversity and the pollination of plants, Trinidad and Tobago, West Indies. Ecology63 (1982) 494–506.
Foster, R. B., The seasonal rhythm of fruitfall on Barro Colorado Island, in: Ecology of a Tropical Forest, pp. 151–172. Eds E. G. Leigh, A. S. Rand and D. M. Windsor. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington 1982.
Frank, S. A., Theoretical and Empirical Studies of Sex Ratios, Mainly in Fig Wasps. Master's Thesis, University of Florida, Gainesville 1983.
Frank, S. A., The behavior and morphology of the fig waspsPegoscapus assuetus andP. jimenezi: descriptions and suggested behavioral characters for phylogenetic studies Psyche91 (1984) 289–308.
Frank, S. A., Hierarchical selection theory and sex ratios. II. On applying the theory, and a test with fig wasps. Evolution39 (1985) 949–964.
Galil, J., Sycamore wasps from ancient Egyptian tombs. Isr. J. Ent.2 (1967) 1–10.
Galil, J., Pollination in dioecious figs: pollination ofF. fistulosa byCeratosolen hewitti. Gdn Bull. Singapore26 (1973) 303–311.
Galil, J., Fig biology. Endeavour1 (1977) 52–56.
Galil, J., and Eisikowitch, D., On the pollination ecology ofFicus sycomorus in East Africa. Ecology49 (1968) 259–269.
Galil, J., and Eisikowitch, D., Flowering cycles and fruit types inFicus sycomorus in Israel. New Phytol.67 (1968) 745–758.
Galil, J., and Eisikowitch, D., On the pollination ecology ofFicus religiosa in Israel. Phytomorphology18 (1968) 356–363.
Galil, J., and Eisikowitch, D., Further studies on the pollination ecology ofFicus sycomorus L. (Hymenoptera, Chalcidoidea, Agaonidae). Tijdschr. Ent.112 (1969) 1–13.
Galil, J., and Eisikowitch, D., Studies on mutualistic symbiosis between syconia and sycophilous wasps in monoecious figs. New Phytol.70 (1971) 773–787.
Galil, J., and Eisikowitch, D., Further studies on pollination ecology inFicus sycomorus. II. Pollen filling and emptying byCeratosolen arabicus Mayr. New Phytol.73 (1974) 515–528.
Galil, J., and Meiri, L., Number and structure of anthers in fig syconia in relation to behaviour of the pollen vectors. New Phytol.88, (1981) 83–87.
Galil, J., and Neeman, G., Pollen transfer and pollination in the common fig (Ficus carica L.). New Phytol.79 (1977) 163–171.
Galil, J., Dulberger, R., and Rosen, D., The effects ofSycophaga sycomori L. on the structure and development of the syconia inFicus sycomorus L. New Phytol.69 (1970) 103–111.
Galil, J., Ramirez B. W., and Eisikowitch, D., Pollination ofFicus costaricana andF. hemsleyana byBlastophaga estherae andB. tonduzi in Costa Rica (Hymenoptera: Chalcidoidea, Agaonidae). Tijdschr. Ent.116 (1973) 175–183.
Galil, J., Stein, M., and Horovitz, A., On the origin of the sycomore fig (Ficus sycomorus L.) in the Middle East. Gdn Bull. Singapore29 (1976) 191–205.
Galil, J., Zeroni, M., and Bar-Shalom, D., Carbon dioxide and ethylene effects in the co-ordination between the pollinatorBlastophaga quadraticeps and the syconium inFicus religiosa. New Phytol.72 (1973) 1113–1127.
Godfray, H. C. J., Virginity in haplodiploid populations: a study on fig wasps. Ecol. Ent.13 (1988) 283–291.
Grandi, G., Studio morfologico e biologico dellaBlastophaga psenes (L.) Boll. Lab. Zool. Portici14 (1920) 63–204.
Hamilton, W. D., Wingless and fighting males in fig wasps and other insects, in: Sexual Selection and Reproductive Competition in Insects, pp. 167–220. Eds M. S. Blum and N. A. Blum. Academic Press, London 1979.
Heinrich, B., Energetics of pollination. A. Rev. ecol. Syst.6 (1975) 139–170.
Henderson, L. J., Fig wasps of Heron Island, Great Barrier Reef. Proc. Roy. Soc. Qd.93 (1982) 21–29.
Herre, E. A., Sex ratio adjustment in fig wasps. Science228 (1985) 896–898.
Herre, E. A., Coevolution of reproductive characteristics in twelve species of New World figs and their pollinator wasps. Experientia45 (1989) 637–647.
Herrera, C. M., Vertebrate-dispersed plants of the Iberian Peninsula: a study of fruit characteristics. Ecol. Monogr.57 (1987) 305–331.
Hespenheide, H. A., Selective predation by two swifts and a swallow in Central America. Ibis117 (1975) 82–99.
Hill, D. S., Figs of Hong Kong. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong 1967.
Hill, D. S., Figs (Ficus spp.) and fig wasps (Chalcidoidea). J. nat. Hist.1 (1967) 413–434.
Hoffmann, K. H., Metabolic and enzyme adaptation to temperature, in Environmental Physiology and Biochemistry of Insects, pp. 1–32. Ed. K. H. Hoffmann. Springer Verlag. Berlin 1984.
Janos, D. P., Mycorrhizae influence tropical succession. Biotropica12 (suppl) (1980) 56–64.
Janzen, D. H., Synchronization of sexual reproduction of trees within the dry season in Central America. Evolution21 (1967) 620–637.
Janzen, D. H., Dissolution of mutualism betweenCecropia and itsAzteca ants. Biotropica5 (1973) 15–28.
Janzen, D. H., How to be a fig. A. Rev. Ecol. Syst.10 (1979) 13–51.
Janzen, D. H., How many babies do figs pay for babies? Biotropica11 (1979) 48–50.
Janzen, D. H., How many parents do the wasps from a fig have? Biotropica11 (1979) 127–129.
Johri, B. M., and Konar, R. N., The floral morphology and embryology ofFicus religiosa Linn. Phytomorphology6 (1956) 97–111.
Joseph, K. J., Recherches sur les chalcidiens,Blastophaga psenes L. etPhilotrypesis L. du figuier (Ficus carica L.). Annls Sci. nat. Zool. 2e ser. XX13 (1958) 187–260.
Kjellberg, F., Doumesche, B., and Bronstein, J. L., Longevity of a fig wasp (Blastophaga psenes). Proc. K. ned. Akad. Wet. Ser.C 91 (1988) 117–122.
Kjellberg, F., and Maurice, S., Seasonality in the reproductive phenology ofFicus: Its evolution and consequences. Experientia45 (1989) 653–660.
Kjellberg, F., Gouyon, P.-H., Ibrahim, M., Raymond, M., and Valdeyron, G., 1987. The stability of the symbiosis between dioecious figs and their pollinators: a study ofFicus carica L. andBlastophaga psenes L. Evolution41 (1987) 693–704.
Lack, D., Darwin's Finches. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1947.
Levins, R., Thermal acclimation and heat resistance inDrosophila species. Am. Nat.103 (1969) 483–499.
Losey, G. S., Cleaning symbiosis in Puerto Rico with comparison to the tropical Pacific. Copeia1974 (1974) 960–970.
Michaloud, G., Aspects de la Reproduction des Figuiers Monoiques en Fôret Equatoriale Africaine. Ph. D. Dissertation, Université des Sciences et Techniques du Languedoc. Montpellier, France 1988.
Michaloud, G., and Michaloud-Pelletier, S.,Ficus hemi-epiphytes (Moraceae) et arbres supports. Biotropica19 (1987) 125–136.
Michaloud, G., Michaloud-Pelletier, S., Wiebes, J. T., and Berg, C. C., The co-occurrence of two pollinating species of fig wasp and one species of fig. Proc. K. ned. Akad. Wet. Ser. C88 (1985) 93–119.
Milton, K., Windsor, D. M., Morrison, D. W., and Estribi, M. A., Fruiting phenologies of two neotropicalFicus species. Ecology63 (1982) 752–762.
Newton, L. E., and Lomo, A., The pollination ofFicus vogelii in Ghana. Bot. J. Linn. Soc.78 (1979) 21–30.
Parsons, P. A., Resistance to cold temperature stress in populations ofD. melanogaster andD. simulans. Aust. J. Zool.25 (1977) 693–698.
Parsons, P. A., Parallel climatic races for tolerances to high temperature-desiccation stress in twoDrosophila species. J. Biogeog.7 (1980) 97–101.
Pemberton, C. E., The fig wasp in its relation to the development of fertile seed in the Moreton Bay fig. Hawaiian Planters' Rec.24 (1921) 297–319.
Pemberton, C. E., Fig wasps established on Kauai. Proc. Hawaiian ent. Soc.8 (1934) 399.
Ramirez B. W., Host specificity of fig wasps (Agaonidae). Evolution24 (1970) 681–691.
Ramirez B. W., Taxonomic and biological studies of neotropical fig wasps. U. Kans. Sci. Bull.49 (1970) 1–44.
Ramirez B. W., Germination of seeds of New World Urostigma (Ficus) and ofMorus rubra L. (Moraceae). Revta Biol. trop.24 (1976) 1–6.
Rawlins, J. E., Thermoregulation by the black swallowtail butterfly,Papilio polyxenes (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae). Ecology61 (1980) 345–357.
Ricklefs, R. E., Geographical variation in clutch size among passerine birds: Ashmole's hypothesis. Auk97 (1980) 38–49.
Rickson, R. F., Progressive loss of ant-related traits ofCecropia peltata on selected Caribbean islands. Am. J. Bot.64 (1977) 585–592.
Ridley, H. N., The Dispersal of Plants Throughout the World. L. Reeve and Co, Kent 1930.
Risch, S. J., and Rickson, F. R., Mutualism in which ants must be present before plants produce food bodies. Nature291 (1981) 149–150.
Rosenzweig, M. L., Net primary productivity of terrestrial communities: prediction from climatological data. Am. Nat.102 (1968) 67–74.
Stanley, S. M., and Parsons, P. A., The response of the cosmopolitan species,Drosophila melanogaster to ecological gradients. Proc. ecol. Soc. Aust.11 (1981) 121–130.
Thornthwaite, C. W., and Associates, Average climatic water balance data of the continents. Part I. Africa. Publ. Climat.15 (1962).
Thornthwaite, C. W., and Associates, Average climatic water balance data of the continents. Part II. Asia (excluding USSR). Publ. Climat.16 (1963).
Todzia, C., Growth habits, host tree species, and density of hemiepiphytes on Barro Colorado Island, Panama. Biotropica18 (1986) 22–27.
Tukey, L. D., Effect of night temperature on growth of the fruit of the Sour Cherry. Bot. Gaz.114 (1952) 155–165.
Valdeyron, G., Sur le système génétique du figuierFicus carica L. Essai d'interprétation évolutive. Annls Inst. natl. agron. (Paris)5 (1967) 1–167.
Valdeyron, G., and Lloyd, D. G., Sex differences and flowering phenology in the common fig,Ficus carica L. Evolution33 (1979) 673–685.
Valdeyron, G., Kjellberg, F., Ibrahim, M., Raymond, M., and Valizadeh, M., A one species-one population plant: how does the common fig escape genetic diversification? in: Genetic Differentiation and Dispersal in Plants, pp. 383–393. Eds P. Jacquard, G. Heim and J. Antonovics. Springer Verlag. Berlin 1985.
Valizadeh, M., Valdeyron, G., Kjellberg, F., and Ibrahim, M., Le flux génique chez le figuier,Ficus carica: la dispersion par le pollen dans un peuplement dense. Acta oecol., Oecol. Plant.8 (1987) 143–154.
Vallese, F., La caprificazione in terra d'Otrando. Lecce. Tipografio Sociale Cooperation, Italy 1904.
Verkerke, W., Anatomy ofFicus ottoniifolia (Moraceae) syconia and its role in the fig-fig wasp symbiosis. Proc. K. ned. Akad. Wet. Ser C89 (1986) 443–469.
Verkerke, W., Syconial anatomy ofFicus asperifolia (Moraceae), a gynodioecious tropical fig. Proc. K. ned. Akad. Wet. Ser.C 90 (1987) 461–492.
Verkerke, W., Sycone morphology and its influence on the flower structure ofFicus sur (Moraceae). Proc. K. ned. Akad. Wet. Ser. C91 (1988) 319–344.
Verkerke, W., Structure and function of the fig. Experientia45 (1989) 612–622.
Watt, W. B., Adaptive significance of pigment polymorphisms inColias butterflies. I. Variation of melanin pigment in relation to thermoregulation. Evolution22 (1968) 437–458.
Wharton, R. A., Tilson, J. W., and Tilson, R. L., Asynchrony in a wild population ofFicus sycomorus. S. Afr. J. Sci.76 (1980) 478–480.
Wiebes, J. T., Taxonomy and host preferences of Indo-Australian fig wasps of the genusCeratosolen (Agaonidae). Tijdschr. Ent.106 (1963) 1–112.
Wiebes, J. T., Indo-Malayan and Papuan fig wasps (Hymenoptera, Chalcidoidea) 2. The genusPleistodontes Saunders (Agaonidae). Zool. Meded. Leiden38 (1963) 303–321.
Wiebes, J. T., The genusKradibia Saunders and an addition toCeratosolen Mayr (Hymenoptera Chalcidoidea, Agaonidae). Zool. Meded. Leiden53 (1978) 165–184.
Wiebes, J. T., Co-evolution of figs and their insect pollinators. A. Rev. Ecol. Syst.10 (1979) 1–12.
Wiebes, J. T., Records and descriptions ofPegoscapus Cameron (Hymenoptera Chalcidoidea, Agaonidae). Proc. K. ned. Acad. Wet. Ser. C86 (1983) 243–253.
Williams, N. H., Floral fragrances as cues in animal behavior, in: Handbook of Experimental Pollination Biology, pp. 50–72. Eds C. E. Jones and R. J. Little. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York 1983.
Windsor, D. M., Morrison, D. W., Estribi, M. A., and de Leon, B., Phenology of fruit and leaf production by ‘strangler’ figs on Barro Colorado Island, Panama. Experientia45 (1989) 647–653.
Wolda, H., Insect seasonality: why? A. Rev. ecol. Syst.19 (1988) 1–18.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bronstein, J.L. A mutualism at the edge of its range. Experientia 45, 622–637 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01975679
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01975679