Abstract
A prospective controlled study of the diagnostic accuracy of blind percutaneous liver biopsy in comparison to laparoscopy plus guided biopsy for the recognition or exclusion of cirrhosis has been performed. One hundred twenty-six patients with a clinical diagnosis of chronic, diffuse, well-compensated liver disease were randomized into two groups and submitted either to percutaneous blind liver biopsy (PB: 64 patients) or to laparoscopy with guided biopsy (LB: 62 patients), in order to assess the accuracy of either procedure in diagnosing cirrhosis. PB correctly recognized or ruled out cirrhosis in 52 patients (82%). Inconclusive results were mostly false negative, as demonstrated by the presence on endoscopy of esophageal varices or by subsequent LB. LB demonstrated presence or absence of cirrhosis in all patients. The difference between the rate of accurate results of the two procedures is statistically significant. It is concluded that in patients without esophageal varices, LB should be the investigation of choice for the assessment of liver structure since the presence of cirrhosis can be missed in up to 20% of cases by PB.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Bruguera M, Borda JM, Mass P, Rodes J: A comparison of accuracy of peritoneoscopy and liver biopsy in the diagnosis of cirrhosis. Gut 15:799–800, 1974
Vido I, Wildhirt E: Korrelation des laparoskopischen und histologischen Befundes bei chronischer Hepatitis und Zirrhose. Dtsch Med Wochenschr 94:1633–1637, 1969
Hølund B, Poulsen H, Schlichting P: Reproducibility of liver biopsy diagnosis in relation to the size of the specimen. Scand J Gastroenterol 15:329–335, 1980
Soloway RD, Baggenstoss AH, Schoenfield LJ, Summerskill WHJ: Observer error and sampling variability, tested in evaluation of hepatitis and cirrhosis by liver biopsy. Am J Dig Dis 16:1082–1086, 1971
Abdi W, Millan JC, Mezey E: Sampling variability of percutaneous liver biopsy. Arch Intern Med 139:667–669, 1979
Fritsch WP, Herms W, Huth F, Wetzels E, Hauseman TU: Die Wertigkeit von Laparoskopie und Leberpunktion fur die Diagnostik chronischer Hepatopathien. Dtsch Med Wochenschr 97:1635–1637, 1972
Dagnini G: La laparoscopia nella diagnostica clinica. Padova, Piccin, 1978
Zotti S, Papaleo E, Marin G, Patella M, Bergamo S, Caldironi MW, Cecchetto A, Dagnini G: Laparoscopy and liver biopsy in the morphological diagnosis of cirrhosis: Concordance and diagnostic validity. Ital J Gastroenterol 13:14–17, 1981
Orlandi F, and the Study Group on Randomized Clinical Trials: Observer error in morphological diagnosis of chronic active hepatitis and cirrhosis. Ital J Gastroenterol 11:5–8 1979
Pagliaro L, Rinaldi F, Craxì A, Di Franco C, Di Piazza S, Filippazzo G, Magrin S, Maringhini A, Palazzo U, Vinci M: Predictive value (PV) of clinical, laparoscopic and histologic indicators of cirrhosis. Ital J Gastroenterol 1982 (in press)
Scheuer PJ: Cirrhosis.In Pathology of the Liver. RNM MacSween, PP Anthony, PJ Scheuer (eds). London, Churchill Livingstone, 1974, pp 258–271
Anthony PP, Ishak KG, Nayak NC, Poulsen HE, Scheuer PJ, Sobin LH: The morphology of cirrhosis: Definition, nomenclature and classification. Bull WHO 55:521–540, 1977
Beck K: Atlante di laparoscopia. Roma, Leonardo Edizioni Scientifiche, 1970
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pagliaro, L., Rinaldi, F., Craxì, A. et al. Percutaneous blind biopsy versus laparoscopy with guided biopsy in diagnosis of cirrhosis. Digest Dis Sci 28, 39–43 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01393359
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01393359