Abstract
Low global self-esteem among minority youth living in Western countries has been considered a truism for a long time. Empirical research, however, tells another story. A review of recent studies using well-established scales is presented, showing no systematic indications of lower global self-esteem. Four possible methodological/technical explanations for this finding are discussed: superficial measuring, defensiveness, measure equivalence, and respons patterns. It is concluded that there are no systematic and decisive methodological/technical explanations for the empirical find. In the present study attention is focusses on socio-psychological explanations. Three different assumptions underlying the argument for presumed lower self-esteem among minority youth were empirically studied among Turkish youth living in the Netherlands. The results show that these assumptions are not invariably true which explains why, in general, minority youth do not have lower global self-esteem. It is argued that these assumptions can also be used to predict under what conditions minority status will be associated with lower self-esteem.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Adam, B. D.: 1978, ‘Inferiorization and ‘self-esteem’, Social Psychology 41, pp. 47–53.
Bachman, J. G. and P. M. O'Malley: 1984a, ‘Yea-saying, nay-saying and going to extremes: Black and White differences in survey results due to response style?’, Public Opinion Quarterly 48, pp. 409–427.
Bachman, J. G. and P. M. O'Malley: 1984b, ‘Black-White differences in self-esteem: are they affected by response styles?’, American Journal of Sociology 90, pp. 624–639.
Bagley, C., K. Mallick and G. H. Verma: 1979, ‘Pupil self-esteem: a study of Black and White teenagers in British schools’, in G. K. Verma and C. Bagley (eds.), Race and Education across Cultures (Heinemann, London).
Bagley, C., G. H. Verma and K. Mallick: 1983, ‘The comparative structure of self-esteem in British and Indian adolescents’, in G. K. Verma and C. Bagley (eds.), Selfconcept, Achievement and Multicultural Education (McMillan, London).
Berry, J. W. and P. R. Dasen: 1974, ‘Introduction: history and method in the cross-cultural study of cognition’, in J. W. Berry and P. R. Dasen (eds.), Culture and Cognition: Readings in Cross-Cultural Psychology (Methuen, London).
Bijnen, E. J., T. Z. J. van der Net and Y. P. Poortinga: 1986, ‘On cross-cultural comparative studies with the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire’, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 17, pp. 3–16.
Brislin, R.: 1970, ‘Back-translation for cross-cultural research’, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 1, pp. 185–216.
Burns, R.: 1982, Self-Concept, Development and Education (Holt, Rinehart and Winston, London).
Combs, A. W., D. W. Soper and C. C. Courson: 1963, ‘The measurement of self-concept and self-report’, Educational and Psychological Measurement 23, pp. 493–500.
Coopersmith, S.: 1967, The Antecedents of Self-Esteem (Freeman, San Francisco).
Crandall, R.: 1973, ‘The measurement of self-esteem and related constructs’, in J. P. Robinson and P. R. Shaver (eds.), Measures of Social Psychological Attitudes (Survey Research Center for Social Research, Michigan).
Cress, J. N. and J. P. O'Donnell: 1975, ‘The self-esteem inventory and the Oglala Sioux: a validation study’, Journal of Social Psychology 97, pp. 135–136.
Crocker, J. and B. Major: 1989, ‘Social stigma and self-esteem: the self-protective properties of stigma’, Psychological Review 96, pp. 608–630.
Epps, E. G.: 1975, ‘The impact of school desegregation on aspirations, self-concepts and other aspects of personality’, Law and Contemporary Problems 39, pp. 300–313.
Franks, D. D. and J. Marolla: 1976, ‘Efficacious action and social approval as interacting dimensions of self-esteem: a tentative formulation through construct validation’, Sociometry 39, pp. 324–341.
Goldman, R. K. and B. Mercer: 1976, ‘Self-esteem and self-differentiation: a comparison between Black and White children in follow through and non-follow through classes’, Educational Research Quarterly 1, pp. 43–49.
Gordon, C.: 1969, Looking Ahead: Self-Conceptions of Race and Family as Determinants of Adolescents Orientation to Achievement (Rose Monograph Series, American Sociological Association, Washington).
Greenberg, E. S.: 1972, ‘Black children, self-esteem and the liberation movement’, Politics and Society 3, pp. 293–307.
Harter, S.: 1982, ‘The perceived competence scale for children’, Child Development 53, pp. 87–97.
Harter, S.: 1985, ‘Competence as a dimension of self-evaluation: towards a comprehensive model of self-worth’, in R. L. Leahy (ed.), The Development of the Self (Academic Press, New York).
Hauser, S.: 1971, Black and White Identity Formation (Wiley, New York).
Hines, P. and L. Berg-Cross: 1981, ‘Racial differences in global self-esteem’, Journal of Social Psychology 113, pp. 271–281.
Hoelter, J. W.: 1983, ‘Factorial invariance and self-esteem: reassessing race and sex differences’, Social Forces 61, pp. 834–846.
Hofman, J. E., B. Beit-Hallahmi and R. Hert-Lazarowitz: 1982, ‘Self-concept of Jewish and Arab adolescents in Israel’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 43, pp. 786–792.
Hogg, M. A., D. Abrams and Y. Pate: 1987, ‘Ethnic identity, self-esteem, and occupational aspirations of Indian and Anglo-Saxon British adolescents’, Genetic, Social, and General Psychology Monograph 113, pp. 487–508.
Hughes, M. and D. H. Demo: 1989, ‘Self-perceptions of Black Americans: self-esteem and personal efficacy’, American Journal of Sociology 95, pp. 132–159.
Jacques, J. M. and K. J. Chason: 1977, ‘Self-esteem and low status groups: a changing scene?’ Sociological Quarterly 18, pp. 399–412.
Jahoda, M.: 1958, Current Concepts of Positive Mental Health (Basic Books, New York).
Junger, M.: 1990, Delinquency and Ethnicity: an Investigation on Social Factors relating to Delinquency among Moroccan, Turkish, Surinamese and Dutch Boys (Kluwer, Deventer).
Kaplan, H. B.: 1982, ‘Prevalence of the self-esteem motive’, in M. Rosenberg and H. B. Kaplan (eds.), Social Psychology of the Self-Concept (Harlon Davidson, Arlington Heights).
Kline, P.: 1988, ‘The cross-cultural measurement of personality’, in G. K. Verma and C. Bagley (eds.), Cross-Cultural Studies of Personality, Attitudes and Cognition (McMillan, London).
Long, B. H.: 1969, ‘Critique of ‘Self-perceptions of culturally disadvantaged children’ by Soares and Soares’, American Educational Research Journal 6, 710–711.
Louden, D. M.: 1978, ‘Self-esteem and locus of control: some findings on immigrant adolescents in Britain’, New Community 6, pp. 218–234.
Louden, D. M.: 1981, ‘A comparative study of self-concepts among minority and majority group adolescents in English multi-racial schools’, Ethnic and Racial Studies 4, pp. 153–174.
Malpass, R. S. and Y. P. Poortinga: 1986, ‘Designs for equivalence’, in W. J. Lonner and J. W. Berry (eds.), Fields Methods in Cross-Cultural Comparison (Sage, Beverly Hills).
MacCarthy, J. D. and W. C. Yancey: 1971, ‘Uncle Tom and Mr. Charlie: metaphysical pathos in the study of racism and personal disorganization’, American Journal of Sociology 76, pp. 648–672.
McCreary-Juhasz, A.: 1985, ‘Measuring self-esteem in early adolescence’, Adolescence 20, pp. 877–887.
Nederhof, A. J.: 1981, Beter Onderzoek: Bestrijding van Foutenbronnen in Sociaal-Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (Vuga, 's-Gravenhage).
Nederhof, A. J.: 1985, ‘Methods of coping with social desirability bias: a review’, European Journal of Social Psychology 15, pp. 263–280.
O'Malley, P. M. and J. G. Bachman: 1983, ‘Self-esteem: change and stability between ages 13 and 23’, Development Psychology 19, pp. 257–268.
Pallas, A. M., D. R. Entwisle, K. L. Alexander and P. Weinstein: 1990, ‘Social structure and the development of self-esteem in young children’, Social Psychology Quarterly 53, pp. 302–315.
Phinney, J. S.: 1992, ‘Ethnic identity and national identity among ethnic minority youth’, paper presented at the XIth International Congress of the International Association for Cross-Cultural psychology, Liège, Belgium.
Poortinga, Y. P.: 1989, ‘Equivalence of cross-cultural data: an overview of basic issues’, International Journal of Psychology 24, pp. 737–756.
Porter, J. R. and R. E. Washington: 1979, ‘Black identity and self-esteem: a review of studies of Black self-concept 1968–1978’, Annual Review of Sociology 5, pp. 53–74.
Richman, C. L., M. L. Clark and K. Brown: 1985, ‘General and specific self-esteem in late adolescent students’, Adolescence 20, pp. 555–566.
Rosenberg, M.: 1965, Society and Adolescent Self-Image (Princeton Univ. Press, New Jersey).
Rosenberg, M.: 1979, Conceiving the Self (Basic Books, New York).
Rosenberg, M.: 1981, ‘The self-concept: social product and social force’, in M. Rosenberg and R. H. Turner (eds.), Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives (Basic Books, New York).
Rosenberg, M.: 1985, ‘Self-concept and psychological well-being in adolescence’, in R. L. Leary (ed.), The Development of the Self (Academic Press, New York).
Rosenberg, M. and R. G. Simmons: 1972, Black and White self-esteem: the urban school child (Rose Monographs Series, American Sociological Association, Washington).
Simons, R. G., L. Brown, M. D. Bush and D. A. Blyth: 1978, ‘Self-esteem and achievement of black and white adolescents’, Social Problems 26, pp. 86–96.
Smith, W. D., A. K. Burlew, M. H. Mosley and W. M. Whitney: 1978, Minority Issues in Mental Health (Addison Wesley, Reading, Mass).
Stager, S. T., L. Chasin and R. D. Young: 1983, ‘Determinants of self-esteem among labeled adolescents’, Social Psychological Quarterly 46, pp. 3–10.
Stone, M.: 1981, The Education of the Black Child in Britain: the Myth of Multiracial Education (Fontana, Glasgow).
Swann, W. B. and S. J. Read: 1981, ‘Acquiring self-knowledge: the search for feedback that fits’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 41, pp. 1119–1128.
Taylor, M. C. and E. J. Walsh: 1979, ‘Explanations of Black self-esteem: some empirical tests’, Social Psychology Quarterly 42, pp. 242–253.
TenBerge, F. M. F.: 1977, Optimizing Factorial Invariance (VRB Drukkerijen, Gronigen).
Veenhoven, R.: 1984, Conditions of Happiness (Reidel Publ., Dordrecht).
Verkuyten, M.: 1986, ‘Zelfwaardering van allochtone jongeren’, Pedagogisch Tijdschrift 5, pp. 296–304.
Verkuyten, M.: 1986b, ‘The impact of ethnic and sex differences on happiness among adolescents in the Netherlands’, Journal of Social Psychology 126, pp. 259–260.
Verkuyten, M.: 1988a, Zelfbeleving en Identiteit van Jongeren uit Etnische Minderheden (Gouda Quint, Arnhem).
Verkuyten, M.: 1988b, ‘General self-esteem of adolescents from ethnic minorities in the Netherlands and the reflected appraisal process’, Adolescence 23, pp. 863–871.
Verkuyten, M.: 1989, ‘Self-esteem among Dutch and Turkish children in the Netherlands’, Journal of Social Psychology 129, pp. 296–271.
Verkuyten, M.: 1989b, ‘Happiness among adolescents in the Netherlands: ethnic and sex differences’, Psychological Review 65, pp. 577–578.
Verkuyten, M.: 1990, ‘Self-esteem and the evaluation of ethnic identity among Turkish and Dutch adolescents in the Netherlands’, Journal of Social Psychology 130, pp. 285–297.
Verkuyten, M.: 1992, Zelfbeleving van Jeugdige Allochtonen: een Socio-Psychologische Benadering (Swets and Zeitlinger, Lisse).
Verkuyten, M.: 1992b, ‘Ethnic self-identification among Turkish youth in the Netherlands: self-evaluation and psychological acculturation’, paper presented at the XIth International Congress of the International Association of Cross-cultural Psychology, Liège, Belgium.
Verkuyten, M.: 1993, ‘Self-esteem among Ethnic Minorities and three Principles of Self-esteem Formation: Turkish Children in the Netherlands’, International Journal of Psychology 28, pp. 307–321.
Watkins, D.: 1989, ‘The role of confirmatory factor analysis in cross-cultural research’, International Journal of Psychology 24, pp. 685–701.
Watkins, D., M. K. Lam and M. Regmi: 1991, ‘Cross-cultural assessment of self-esteem: a Nepalese investigation’, Psychologica 34, pp. 98–108.
Weber, C.: 1989, Selbstkonzept, identität und integration (VWB-Verlag, Berlin).
Wells, L. E. and G. Marwell: 1976, Self-Esteem: its Conceptualization and Measurement (Sage, London).
Wylie, R.: 1979, The Self-Concept (vol, 2) (Nebraska Press, Lincoln).
Wylie, R.: 1989, Measures of Self-Concept (Nebraska Press, Lincoln).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Verkuyten, M. Self-esteem among ethnic minority youth in Western countries. Soc Indic Res 32, 21–47 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01078464
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01078464