Abstract
Because various phosphate (P) fertilizers differ widely in their solubility, it is commonly observed that crop response to P fertilizers varies under the same soil and crop conditions. Furthermore, a major problem encountered in the methods for determining the relative effectiveness (RE) of water-insoluble P fertilizer (e.g., phosphate rock) with respect to water-soluble P fertilizers, e.g., single superphosphate (SSP) and triple superphosphate (TSP), is that their growth response curves are usually nonlinear and often do not share a common maximum yield. In this paper, we review and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the three most commonly used methods for calculating the RE of phosphate rock with respect to TSP (or SSP). The three methods are vertical comparison, horizontal (substitution rate) comparison, and linear-response comparison.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Barrow NJ (1985) Comparing the effectiveness of fertilizers. Fert Res 8: 85–90
Bationo A, Chien SH, Henao J, Christianson CB and Mokwunye AU (1990) Agronomic evaluation of two unacidulated and partially acidulated phosphate rocks indigenous to Niger. Soil Sci Soc Am J (in press)
Bolland MDA, Weatherley AJ, Gilkes RJ and Bowden JW (1986) Granular reactive apatite rock phosphate is not an effective phosphorus fertilizer in the short term on lateritic soils in south-western Australia. Aust J Exp Agric 26: 217–225
Bolland MDA and Barrow NJ (1988) Effect of level of application on the relative effectiveness of rock phosphate. Fert Res 15: 181–192
Bolland MDA, Gilkes RJ and Allen DG (1988) The residual value of superphosphate and rock phosphates for lateritic soils and its evaluation using three soil phosphate tests. Fert Res 15: 253–280
Chien SH (1979) Dissolution of phosphate rocks in solution and soils. In: Seminar on Phosphate Rock for Direct Application pp 448–463. International Fertilizer Development Center, Muscle Shoals, Alabama, USA
Chein SH and Black CA (1976) Free energy of formation of carbonate apatites in some phosphate rocks. Soil Sci Soc Am J 40: 234–239
Chien SH and Hammond LL (1978) A comparison of various laboratory methods for predicting the agronomic potential of phosphate rocks for direct application. Soil Sci Soc Am J 42: 935–939
Chien SH and Hammond LL (1989) Agronomic effectiveness of partially acidulated phosphate rock as influenced by phosphorus-fixing capacity. Plant and Soil 120: 159–164
Chien SH, Sale PWG and Hammond LL (1990) Comparison of effectiveness of various phosphate fertilizer products. In: Proceedings of the Symposium on Phosphorus Requirements for Sustainable Agriculture in Asia and Oceania. International Rice Research Insitutte, Los Baños, The Philippines (in press)
Colwell JD and Godert WJ (1988) Substitution rates as measures of the relative effectiveness of alternative phosphorus fertilizers. Fert Res 15: 163–172
Engelstad OP, Jugsujinda A and De Datta SK (1974) Response by flooded rice to phosphate rocks varying in citrate solubility. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc 38: 524–529
Hellums DT, Chien SH and Touchton JT (1989) Potential agronomic value of calcium in some phosphate rocks from South America and West Africa. Soil Sci Soc Am J 53: 459–462
Khasawneh FE and Doll EC (1978) The use of phosphate rock for direct application to soils. Adv Agron 30: 159–206
Kpomblekou K (1989) Evaluation of phosphate availability from phosphate fertilizers derived from Togo phosphate rock. MS Thesis, Tuskegee University, Tuskegee, Alabama, USA
Leon LA, Fenster WE and Hammond LL (1986) Agronomic potential of eleven phosphate rocks from Brazil, Colombia, Peru, and Venezuela. Soil Sci Soc Am J 50: 798–802
Palmer B, Bolland MDA and Gilkes RJ (1979) A re-evaluation of the effectiveness of calcined Christmas Island C-grade rock phosphate. Aust J Exp Agric Anim Husb 19: 605–610
Terman GL and Engelstad OP (1976) Agronomic evaluation of fertilizers. Bull. Y-21, National Fertilizer Development Center, Muscle Shoals, Alabama, USA
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chien, S.H., Sale, P.W.G. & Friesen, D.K. A discussion of the methods for comparing the relative effectiveness of phosphate fertilizers varying in solubility. Fertilizer Research 24, 149–157 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01073583
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01073583