Abstract
This paper assesses the direct and indirect effects of regulatory reform in the trucking industry on the employment of owner-operators. We utilize a probit estimation form derived from driver utility functions to estimate the change in the probability that a truck driver is an owner-operator following deregulation.
We find that a representative driver with mean characteristics is 155.6 percent more likely to choose employment as an owner-operator in the deregulated environment. Thirty-six percentage points of this increase is due to the indirect effects of deregulation, which operate primarily through changes in wage differentials and unionization. The direct effect of deregulation accounts for a 120% increase in the probability of a driver choosing employment as an owner-operator.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Agar, Michael H. 1986. “Independents Declared: The Dilemmas of Independent Trucking”.Smith-sonian Series in Ethnographic Inquiry. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press.
Ashenfelter, Orley, Janet Currie, Henry S. Farber, and Matthew Spiegel. 1992. “An Experimental Comparison of Dispute Rates in Alternative Arbitration Systems”.Econometrica 60 (November): 1407–33.
Boyer, Kenneth D. 1993. “Deregulation of the Trucking Sector: Specialization, Concentration, Entry, and Financial Distress”.Southern Economic Journal 59 (January): 481–495.
Corsi, Thomas M. 1979. “The Impact of Multiple-Unit Fleet Owners in the Owner-Operator Segment on Regulatory Reform”.Transportation Journal 19 (Winter): 44–59.
Corsi, Thomas M. 1981. “Consequences of Regulatory Reform on the Owner-Operator Segment”.Transportation Research Record 758: 56–62.
Corsi, Thomas M., Michael H. Agar, and Merrill J. Roberts. 1985. “Dynamics of Owner-Operator Behavior and Profitability: 1978 versus 1984”. Proceedings, 26th Annual Meeting.Transportation Research Forum 26: 123–26.
Corsi, Thomas M., and Curtis M. Grimm. 1989. “ATLFs: Driving Owner-operators into the Sunset”. Journal of theTransportation Research Forum 29 (1989): 285–90.
Corsi, Thomas M., and Curtis M. Grimm. 1987. “Changes in Owner-Operator Use, 1977–1985: Implications for Management Strategy”.Transportation Journal 26 (Spring): 4–16.
Corsi, Thomas M., and Joseph R. Stowers. 1991. “Effects of a Deregulated Environment on Motor Carriers: A Systematic, Multi-Segment Analysis”.Transportation Journal 30 (Spring): 4–28.
Corsi, Thomas M., Michael J. Tuck, and Leland L. Gardner. “Owner-Operators and the Motor-Carrier Act of 1980”.The Logistics and Transportation Review 18 (1981): 255–277.
Hirsch, Barry T. 1992. Trucking Regulation, Unionization, and Labor Earnings: Is the Union Premium a Compensating Differential? Working Paper #91-02-4, Florida State University.
Interstate Commerce Commission, Bureau of Economics. 1978.The Independent Trucker: Nationwide Survey of Owner-Operators. Washington, D.C.: Interstate Commerce Commission (May).
Interstate Commerce Commission, Bureau of Economics. 1977.The Independent Trucker: A Preliminary Report on the Owner-Operator. Washington, D.C.: Interstate Commerce Commission (November).
Interstate Commerce Commission, Office Of Policy and Analysis. 1981.Preliminary Report. The Effect of Regulatory Reform on the Trucking Industry: Structure, Conduct and Performance. Interstate Commerce Commission (June).
Hearing, Committee on Small Business. 1987.Impact of Deregulation of the Trucking Industry on Small Businesses and Small Truck Owner/Operators. Hearing Before the Subcommittee on Antitrust, Impact of Deregulation, and Privatization of the Committee on Small Businesses, House of Representatives, One Hundredth Congress, First Session (October 6). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Keeler, Theodore E. 1989. “Deregulation and Scale Economies in the U.S. Trucking Industry: An Econometric Extension of the Survivor Principle”.Journal of Law and Economics 32 (October): 229–253.
Leibenstein, Harvey. 1966. “Allocative Efficiency vs. ‘X-Efficiency.’”American Economic Review 56 (June): 392–415.
Levinson, Harold M. 1982. “Trucking”. InCollective Bargaining: Contemporary Experience, edited by Gerald G. Somers. Industrial Relations Research Series. Madison, Wisc.: Industrial Relations Research Association.
Maister, David H. 1980.Management of Owner-Operator Fleet. Lexington, Mass.: D.C. Heath and Company.
McMullen, B. Starr, and Linda R. Stanley. 1988. “The Impact of Deregulation on the Production Structure of the Motor Carrier Industry”.Economic Inquiry 26 (April): 299–316.
Moore, Thomas Gale. 1978. “The Beneficiaries of Trucking Regulation”.Journal of Law and Economics 21 (April 1978): 327–343.
Moore, Thomas Gale. 1986. “Rail and Trucking Regulation”. InRegulatory Reform: What Actually Happened, edited by Leonard, W. Weiss and Michael, W. Klass. Boston: Little, Brown and Company.
Perry, Charles R. 1986.Deregulation and the Decline of the Unionized Trucking Industry. Labor Relations and Public Policy Series no. 28. Philadelphia: Univ. Pennsylvania, Wharton School.
Rose, Nancy L. 1987. “Labor Rent Sharing and Regulation: Evidence from the Trucking Industry”.Journal of Political Economy 95 (December): 1146–1178.
Rose, Nancy L. 1985. “The Incidence of Regulatory Rents in the Motor Carrier Industry”Rand Journal of Economics 16 (Autumn): 299–318.
U.S. Department of Justice. 1978.The Effects of I.C.C. Regulation on Independent Owner-Operators in the Trucking Industry. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Justice.
U.S. Department of Transportation. 1979.Problems of Truck Owner Operators. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Transportation (October 23).
Wyckoff, D. Daryl, and David H. Maister. 1975.The Owner-Operator: Independent Trucker. Lexington, Mass.: D.C. Heath and Company.
Wyckoff, D. Daryl, and David H. Maister. 1977. “The U.S. Owner-Operator Trucker: A Transportation Policy Based on Personal Bankruptcy.” Proceedings, 18th Annual Transportation Research Forum: 291–297.
Wyckoff, D. Daryl. 1979.Truck Drivers in America. Lexington, Mass.: D.C. Heath and Company.
Ying, John S. and Theodore, E. Keeler. 1991. “Pricing in a Deregulated Environment: The Motor Carrier Experience”.Rand Journal of Economics 22 (Summer): 264–273.
Ying, John S. 1990. “Regulatory Reform and Technical Change: New Evidence of Scale Economies in Trucking”.Southern Economic Journal 56 (April): 996–1009.
Ying, John S. 1990. “The Inefficiency of Regulating a Competitive Industry: Productivity Gains in Trucking Following Reform”.Review of Economics and Statistics 72 (May): 191–201.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
We are especially grateful to David Besanko, Ronald Braeutigam, Robert Drago, and John Heywood for insightful comments. For helpful discussions, we thank Marcus Alexis, Aaron Gellman, Leon Moses, Robert Porter, Ian Savage, Mark Shanley, Carol Simon, Paul Wolfson, and Christopher Udry. For their comments on an earlier draft, we thank Thomas Corsi, Curtis Grimm, and Theodore Keeler. We are grateful for information sent to us by Leon Witconis ofOwner Operator Magazine and William A. Coop ofRoad King Magazine. We acknowledge financial support from the National Science Foundation, Grant # SES-9111131 and from the Transportation Center of Northwestern University. We also thank two anonymous referees for their efforts in helping us to improve this paper.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Peoples, J., Peteraf, M. Deregulation and the competitive fringe: Owner-operators in the trucking industry. J Regul Econ 7, 27–42 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01062778
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01062778