Abstract
Temporal lobe epilepsy and certain personality disorders often result in experiences described as “religious.” TLE research suggests a possible neurological basis for such experiences. Immediately the question arises about the authenticity of these experiences as religious. An experience is authentic if it furthers the authentic growth of the subject, regardless of what triggered it. So pathology may occasion authentic religious experiences, even as history exemplifies. For practical purposes, the further question about God in religious experience is secondary. The exception, miraculous occurrences, should not be granted without sufficient reason. This approach dissolves all conflict between science and faith.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
James, W.,The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature. New York, Collier, 1961. Originally published in 1902.
Cf. Pruyser, P.W., “Some Trends in the Psychology of Religion.” In Strunk, O., ed.,The Psychology of Religion: Historical and Interpretative Readings. New York, Abingdon Press, 1971, pp. 91–116; Saffady, W., “New Developments in the Psychoanalytic Study of Religion: A Bibliographical Review of the Literature since 1960,”Psychoanalytic Review, 1976,63, 291–299; Scobie, G., “The Psychology of Religion: A Religious Revival?”Bulletin, British Psychological Society, 1977,30, 142–144; Spilka, B., “The Current State of the Psychology of Religion,”Bulletin, Council on the Study of Religion, 1978,9, 96–99; Strunk, O., Jr., “The Present Status of the Psychology of Religion,”J. Bible and Religion, 1957,25, 287–292.
Cf.op. cit., p. 42.
Cf. Blumer, D., “Treatment of Patients with Seizure Disorder Referred Because of Psychiatric Complications,”McLean Hospital J., Special Issue, June, 1977, 53–73; Boven, W., “Réligiosité et Epilepsie,”Schweizer Archiv für Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 1919,4, 153–169; Glaser, G. H., “The Problem of Psychosis in Psychomotor Temporal Lobe Epileptics,”Epilepsia, 1964,5, 271–278; Mabille, H., “Hallucinations Réligieuses et Délire Religieux Transitorie dans l'Epilepsie,”Annales Médico-Psychologiques, 1899,9–10, 76–81; Slater, E., and Beard, A. W., “Schizophrenia-like Psychoses of Epilepsy,”British J. Psychiatry, 1963,109, 95–150; Taylor, D. C., “Epileptic Experience, Schizophrenia and the Temporal Lobe.”McLean Hospital J., Special Issue. June, 1977, 22–39; Walker, E. A., and Blumer, D., “Longterm Behavioral Effects of Temporal Lobectomy for Temporal Lobe Epilepsy,”McLean Hospital J., Special Issue, June, 1977, 85–103.
Sherwin, I., “Clinical and EEG Aspects of Temporal Lobe Epilepsy with Behavior Disorder, the Role of Cerebral Dominance,”McLean Hospital J., Special Issue, June, 1977, 41–42.
op. cit., p. 147.
Serafetinides, E. A., “The Significance of the Temporal Lobe and Hemispheric Dominance in the Production of LSD Symptomatology in Man: A Study of Epileptic Patients Before and After Temporal Lobectomy,”Neuropsychologia. 1965,3, 69–79.
Cf. Panke, W. N., “Drugs and Mysticism,”International J. Parapsychology, 1966,8, 2. Also in White, J., ed.,The Highest State of Consciousness. Garden City, New York, Doubleday, 1972, pp. 257–277.
Flor-Henry, P., “Laterality Effects in Organic, Epileptic and Functional Psychoses,” Fifth World Congress of Psychiatry, 1971; “Psychosis and TLE: A Controlled investigation,”Epilepsia, 1969,10, 363–395.
Bear, D., ‘The Significance of Behavioral Change in Temporal Lobe Epilepsy,”McLean Hospital J., Special Issues, June, 1977, 9–21.
Stone, M.H., “Dreams, Free Association, and the Non-dominant Hemisphere: An Integration of Psychoanalytical, Neurophysiological, and Historical Data,”J. American Academy of Psychoanalysis, 1977,5, 255–284.
Taylor, D. C., “Epileptic Experience, Schizophrenia and the Temporal Lobe,”McLean Hospital J., Special Issue, June, 1977, 22–39.
Dewhurst, K., and Beard, A. W., “Sudden Religious Conversion in Temporal Lobe Epilepsy.”British J. Psychiatry, 1970,117, 497–507; Mabille,op. cit.; Ademan, G., and Hopkinson, G., “The Psychopathology of Mystical and Religious Conversion in Psychiatric Patients,”Confinia Neurologica, 1966,9, 1–19, 65–77; Slater and Beard,op. cit.
Sedman and Hopkinson,op. cit., p. 5.
op. cit., p. 106.
Gannon, T. M., and Traub, G. W.,The Desert and the City: An Interpretation of the History of Christianity. London, Macmillan, 1969, p. 122.
op. cit.Cf..
Christensen, C.W., “Religious Conversion,”Archives of General Psychiatry, 1963,9, 207–216.
Ibid., p. 208.
Carlson, H. B., “The Relationship of the Acute Confusional State to Ego Development,”International J. Psychoanalysis, 1961,42, 517–536.
Goleman, D., “Meditation as Meta-therapy: Hypotheses Toward a Proposed Fifth State of Consciousness,”J. Transpersonal Psychology, 1971,3, 1–26.
op. cit..
Glueck, B. C., and Stroebel, C. F., “Biofeedback and Meditation in the Treatment of Psychiatric Illness,”Comprehensive Psychiatry, 1975,16, 303–321.
Cf. Progoff, I.,Depth Psychology and Modern Man. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1959, pp. 223–240.
Helminiak, D. A., “Four Viewpoints on the Human: A Conceptual Schema for Interdisciplinary Studies,” unpublished paper. This approach was originally presented in Helminiak, D.A., “One in Christ: An Exercise in Systematic Theology,” Diss., Boston College and Andover Newton Theological School, 1979, pp. 368–388, 393–405. For a popular statement of the same, see Helminiak, D. A., “Where Do We Stand as Christians? The Challenge of Western Science and Oriental Religions,”Spiritual Life. 1982,28, 195–209.
Lonergan, B. J. F.,Method in Theology. New York, Herder and Herder, 1972: Doran, R. M.,Subject and Psyche: Ricoeur, Jung, and the Search for Foundations. Washington, University Press of America, 1977.
Cf. Lonergan, B. J. F.,Insight: A Study of Human Understanding. New York, Philosophical Library, Inc., 1957; Helminiak, D. A., “How is Meditation Prayer?”Review for Religious. 1982,41, 774–782: Helminiak, D. A., “Consciousness as a Subject Matter.” J. for Theory of Social Behavior in press.
Lonergan,Method in Theology, op. cit., pp. 20, 302.
Ibid., p. 292.
op. cit., especially p. 216; Helminiak, D. A., “Spiritual Development: A Particular View of Human Development,” unpublished paper.
Guillet. J. et al.,Discernment of Spirits. Collegeville, Minnesota, The Liturgical Press, 1970: Rahner, K.,The Dynamic Element in the Church, New York, Herder and Herder, 1964: Smith, H.F., “Discernment of Spirits,”Review for Religious, 1976,35, 432–454.
op. cit..
Heimann, H., “Grundsätzliche Erwägungen über eine Psyehopathologie der Bekehrung,”Monatsschrift für Psychiatrie und Neurologie, 1956,13, 16–36.
Ibid., 23.
Ibid., 22.
op. cit..
Cf. Nelson, J. B.,Embodiment: An Approach to Sexuality and Christian Theology. Minneapolis, Augsburg Publishing House. 1978, 1979, pp. 53–54.
Weitbrecht, H.J.,Beitrage zur Religionspsychopathologie insbesondere zur Psychopathologie der Bekehrung. Heidelberg, Scherrer, 1948, as cited in Heimann, H., “Religion und Psychiatrie,”Psychiatrie der Gegenwart, vol. 3. Berlin, Springer, 1961, pp. 471–492.
Tayior,op. cit.
Wapnick, K., “Mysticism and Schizophrenia.”J. Transpersonal Psychology, 1969,1, Also in White, J., ed.,The Highest State of Consciousness. Garden City, New York, Anchor Books, 1972, pp. 153–174.
Helminiak, D. A., “Meditation-Psychologically and Theologically Considered.”Pastoral Psychology, 1981,30, 6–20; Goleman, D., “Meditation and Consciouness: An Asian Approach to Mental Health,”American J. Psychotherapy, 1976,30, 41–54.
Freeman, F.R., “A Differential Diagnosis of the Inspirational Spells of Muhammad the Prophet of Islam.”Epilepsia, 1976,17, 423–427, 423.
op. cit..
Woods, M.,Was the Apostle Paul an Epileptic? New York, Cosmopolitan Press, 1913.
op. cit., p. 502.
Ibid., p. 503
Ibid., p. 504.
Heimann, “Grundsätzliche Erwagungen,”op. cit..
Eliade, M., “Shaman.” In Cavendish, R., ed.,Man, Myth and Magic: An Illustrated Encyclopedia of the Supernatural, vol. 19. New York, Marshall Cavendish Corp., 1970, p. 2547.
Ahern, B.M., “Pauline Mysticism,”The Way, 1978,18, 3–12.
Trungpa, C., “Dathun Letter,” unpublished paper edited from talks given at the second Vajradhatu Seminary at Snowmass, Colorado, Sept–Nov., 1974.
Cutting Through Spiritual Materialism. Berkeley, Shambhala, 1973, p. 176.
Cf. Johnston, W.,Silent Music: The Science of Meditation. New York. Harper and Row, 1974; Tart, C. T.,Transpersonal Psychologies. New York, Harper and Row, 1975, pp. 150–151.
Assagioli, R.,Psychosynthesis: A Manual of Principles and Techniques. New York, Penguin Books, 1965; Progoff,op. cit.
Cf. Lonergan,Insight, op. cit., 634–686: Lonergan, B. F., J.,Philosophy of God and Theology. Philadelphia, Westminster Press, 1973.
Lonergan,Method in Theology, op cit., p. 105.
Cf. Helminiak, “Meditation,”op. cit..
Helminiak, “One in Christ,”op. cit.; “How is Meditation Prayer?”op. cit.; “Meditation.”op. cit.
Daniel A. Helminiak, Ph.D., is Assistant Professor of Systematic Theology and Spirituality at Oblate School of Theology, 285 Oblate Drive, San Antonio, Texas. 78216. Reprints may be requested at the same address.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Helminiak, D.A. Neurology, psychology, and extraordinary religious experiences. J Relig Health 23, 33–46 (1984). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00999898
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00999898