Abstract
To apply the isotope dilution (ID) technique, it is necessary to grow the “N2-fixing” crop in a soil where the mineral N is labelled with15N. Normally the “N2-fixing” crop and a suitable non-N2-fixing control crop are grown in the same labelled soil and the15N enrichment of the control crop is assumed to be equal to the15N enrichment of the nitrogen (N) derived from the soil in the “N2-fixing” crop. In this case the proportion of unlabelled N being derived from the air via biological N2 fixation (BNF) in the “N2-fixing” crop will be proportional to the dilution of the enrichment of the N derived from the labelled soil.
To label the soil, the technique most often used is to add a single addition of15N-labelled N fertilizer shortly before, at, or shortly after, the planting of the crops. Data in the literature clearly show that this technique results in a rapid fall in the15N enrichment of soil mineral N with time. Under these conditions, if the control and the “N2-fixing” crops have different patterns of N uptake from the soil they will inevitably obtain different15N enrichments in the soil-derived N. In this case the isotope dilution technique cannot be applied, or if it is, there will be an error introduced into, the estimate of the contribution of N derived from BNF.
Several experiments are described which explore different strategies of application of the ID technique to attempt to attenuate the errors involved. The results suggest that it is wise to use slow-release forms of labelled N, or in some cases, multiple additions, to diminish temporal changes in the15N enrichment of soil mineral N. The use of several control crops produces a range of different estimates of the BNF contributions to the “N2-fixing” crops, and the extent of this range gives a measure of the accuracy of the estimates. Likewise the use of more than one15N enrichment technique in the same experiment will also give a range of estimates which can be treated similarly. The potential of other techniques, such as sequential harvesting of both control and test crops, are also discussed.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Barrie A (1991) New methodologies in stable isotope analysis. In: Stable Isotopes in Plant Nutrition Soil Fertility and Environmental Studies, pp 3–25. Int. Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna
Bergersen FJ and Turner GL (1983) An evaluation of15N methods for estimating nitrogen fixation in a subterranean cloverperennial ryegrass sward. Aust J Agric Res 34: 391–401
Boddey RM (1987) Methods for the quantification of nitrogen fixation associated with gramineae. CRC Crit Rev Plant Sci 6: 209–266
Boddey RM and Urquiaga S (1990) Quantification of the contribution of BFN to field grown plants: The use of the N isotope dilution technique - problems and some solutions. In: Gueye M, Mulonguy K and Dommergues Y (eds) Maximiser la Fixation Biologique de L'azote pour la Production Agricole et Forestière en Afrique, Vol 2(2), pp 298–316, Collection Actes de l'Inst Sénégalais Recherches Agricoles, Dakar, Senegal
Boddey RM, Chalk PM, Victoria RL, Matsui E and Döbereiner J (1983) The use of the15N dilution technique to estimate the contribution of associated biological nitrogen fixation to the nitrogen nutrition ofPaspalum notatum cv. batatais. Can J Microbiol 29: 1036–1045
Boddey RM, Chalk PM, Victoria RL and Matsui E (1984) Nitrogen fixation by nodulated soybean under tropical field conditions estimated by the15N isotope dilution technique. Soil Biol Biochem 16: 583–588
Boddey RM, Urquiaga S, Neves MCP, Suhet AR and Peres JR (1990) Quantification of the contribution of N2 fixation to fieldgrown grain legumes - A strategy for the practical application of the15N isotope dilution technique. Soil Biol Biochem 22: 649–655
Boller BC and Nosberger J (1988) Influence of dissimilarities in temporal and spatial N-uptake patterns on15N-based estimates of fixation and transfer of N in ryegrass-clover mixtures. Plant and Soil 112: 167–175
Broadbent FE, Nakashima T and Chang CY (1982) Estimation of nitrogen fixation by isotope dilution in field and greenhouse experiments. Agron J 74: 625–628
Cadisch G, Sylvester-Bradley R and Nosberger J (1989)15N-based estimates of N2 fixation of eight tropical forage legumes at two levels of P:K supply. Field Crops Res 22: 181–194
Chalk PM (1985) Estimation of N2 fixation by isotope dilution: An appraisal of techniques involving15N enrichment and their application. Soil Biol Biochem 17: 389–410
Chalk PM, Douglas LA and Buchanan SA (1983) Use of15N enrichment of soil mineralizable N as a reference for isotope measurements of biologically fixed nitrogen. Can J Microbiol 29: 1046–1052
Chen D, Chalk PM and Freney JR (1991) External-source contamination during extraction-distillation in isotope-ratio analysis of soil inorganic nitrogen. Anal Chim Acta 245: 49–55
Danso SKA (1988) The use of15N enriched fertilizers for estimating nitrogen fixation in grain and pasture legumes. In: Beck DP and Materon LA(eds) Nitrogen Fixation by Legumes in Mediterranean Agriculture, pp 345–348. Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht, The Netherlands
Duque FF, Neves MCP, Franco AA, Victoria RL and Boddey RM (1985) The response of field grownPhaseolus vulgaris to Rhizobium inoculation and the quantification of N2 fixation using15N. Plant and Soil 83: 333–343
Edmeades DC and Goh KM (1978) Symbiotic nitrogen fixation in a sequence of pastures of increasing age measured by a15N dilution technique. N Z J Agric Res 21: 623–628
Fried M, Danso SK and Zapata F (1983) The methodology of measurement of N2 fixation by non-legumes as inferred from field experiments with legumes. Can J Microbiol 29: 1053–1062
Giller KE and Witty JF (1987) Immobilized15N fertilizer sources improve accuracy of field estimates of N2-fixation by isotope dilution. Soil Biol Biochem 19: 459–463
Hamilton SD, Smith CJ, Chalk PM and Hopmans P (1992) A model based on measurement of soil and plant15N enrichment to estimate N2 fixation by soybean (Glycine max L. Merril) grown in pots. Soil Biol Biochem 24: 71–78
Hamilton SD, Chalk PM, Smith CJ and Hopmans P (1992) Evaluation of reference plants by labelling with35S in the estimation of N2 fixation by15N isotope dilution. Plant and Soil 145: 177–185
Hamilton SD, Hopmans P, Chalk PM and Smith CJ (1993) Field estimation of N2 fixation byAcacia spp. using15N isotope dilution and labelling with35S. For Ecol Manage 56: 297–313
Hardarson G, Danso SKA and Zapata F (1988) Dinitrogen fixation measurements in alfalfa-ryegrass swards using nitrogen-15 and the influence of the reference crop. Crop Sci 28: 101–105
Hardarson G, Danso SKA, Zapata F and Reichardt K (1991) Measurements of nitrogen fixation in fababean at different N fertilizer rates using the15N isotope dilution and ‘A value’ methods. Plant and Soil 131: 161–168
Henzell EF, Martin AE, Ross PJ and Haydock KP (1968) Isotopic studies on the uptake of nitrogen by pasture plants. IV. Uptake of nitrogen from labelled plant material by Rhodes grass and siratro. Aust J Agric Res 19: 65–77
Jensen ES, Andersen AJ and Thomsen JD (1985) The influence of seed-borne N in15N dilution studies with legumes. Acta Agric Scand 35: 438–443
Kohl DH and Shearer G (1981) The use of soils lightly enriched in15N to screen for N2-fixing activity. Plant and Soil 60: 487–489
Kucey RMN (1989) Contribution of N2 fixation to field bean and pea uptake over the growing season under field conditions in southern Alberta. Can J Soil Sci 69: 695–699
Ledgard SF, Morton R, Freney JR, Bergersen FJ and Simpson JR (1985) Assessment of the relative uptake of added and indigenous soil nitrogen by nodulated legumes and reference plants in the15N dilution measurement of N2 fixation. I. derivation of method. Soil Biol Biochem 17: 317–321
Ledgard SF, Simpson JR, Freney JR and Bergersen FJ (1985) Field evaluation of15N techniques for estimating nitrogen fixation in legume-grass associations. Aust J Agric Res 36: 247–258
Legg JO and Sloger C (1975) A tracer method for determining symbiotic nitrogen fixation in field studies. In: Klein ER and Klein PD (eds) Proc. 2nd Int. Conf. Stable Isotopes, pp 661–666. Oak Brook, USA
Miranda CHB and Boddey RM (1987) Estimation of biological nitrogen fixation associated with 11 ecotypes ofPanicum maximum grown in nitrogen-15-labeled soil. Agron J 79: 558–563
Pareek RP, Ladha JK and Watanabe I (1990) Estimating N2 fixation bySesbania rostrata andS. cannabina (syn.S. aculeta) in lowland rice soil by the15N dilution method. Biol Fertil Soils 10: 77–88
Patterson TG and LaRue TA (1983) Nitrogen fixation by soybeans: seasonal and cultivar effects, and comparison of estimates. Crop Sci 23: 488–492
Rennie RJ (1985) Theoretical errors in sequential N-15 labelling of soil to estimate N2 fixation by isotope dilution. Crop Sci 25: 891
Rennie RJ (1986) Advantages and disadvantages of nitrogen-15 isotope dilution to quantify dinitrogen fixation in fieldgrown legumes - a critique. In: Field Measurement of Dinitrogen Fixation and Denitrification, Soil Sci Soc Am Spec Publ 18, pp 43–58. Am Soc Agron, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Rennie RJ and Thomas JB (1987)15N-determined effect of inoculation with N2-fixing bacteria on nitrogen assimilation in Western Canadian wheats. Plant and Soil 112: 183–193
Sanginga N, Danso SKA, Zapata F and Bowmen GD (1990) Influence of reference trees on N2-fixation estimates inLeucaena leucocephala andAcacia albina using15N-labelling techniques. Biol Fertil Soils 9: 341–346
Smith CJ, Chalk PM, Hamilton SD and Hopmans P (1992) Estimating N2 fixation by field-grown lupins (Lupinus angustifolius L.) using soil and plant15N enrichment. Biol Fertil Soils 13: 235–241
Talbott HJ, Kenworthy WJ and Legg JC (1982) Field comparison of the nitrogen-15 and difference methods of measuring nitrogen fixation. Agron J 74: 799–804
Talbott HJ, Kenworthy WJ, Legg JO and Douglass LW (1985) Soil nitrogen accumulation in nodulated and non-nodulated soybeans: a verification of the difference method by a15N technique. Field Crops Res 11: 55–67
Urquiaga S, Cruz KHS and Boddey RM (1992) Contribution of nitrogen fixation to sugar cane: nitrogen-15 and nitrogen balance estimates. Soil Sci Soc Am J 22: 105–114
Vallis I, Haydock KP, Ross PJ and Henzell EF (1967) Isotopic studies on the uptake of nitrogen by pastures. III. The uptake of small additions of15N-labelled fertilizer by Rhodes grass and Townsville lucerne. Aust J Agric Res 18: 865–877
Vallis I, Henzell EF and Evans TR (1977) Uptake of soil nitrogen by legumes in mixed swards. Aust J Agric Res 28: 413–426
Viera-Vargas MS, Oliveira OC de, Souto CM, Cadisch G, Urquiaga S and Boddey RM (1994) Use of different15N techniques quantify the contribution of biological nitrogen fixation to legumes. Soil Biol Biochem (In press)
Vose P and Victoria RL (1986) Re-examination of the limitations of nitrogen-15 isotope dilution technique for the field measurement of dinitrogen fixation. In: Field Measurement of Dinitrogen Fixation and Denitrification, Soil Sci Soc Am Spec Publ 18, pp 23–41. Am Soc Agron, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Wagner GH and Zapata F (1982) Field evaluation of reference crops in the study of nitrogen fixation by legumes using isotope tecniques. Agron J 74: 607–612
Watanabe I (1991) Errors related to the15N dilution method for estimating nitrogen fixation. In: Stable Isotopes in Plant Nutrition Soil Fertility and Environmental Studies, pp 83–88. Int Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna
Watanabe I, Chui GY and Yoshida T (1990) Estimation of N2 fixation in soybean and cowpea by using residual15N. Soil Sci Plant Nutr 36: 375–381
Witty JF (1983) Estimating N2 fixation in the field using15N-labelled fertilizer: some problems and solutions. Soil Biol Biochem 15: 631–639
Witty JF and Giller KE (1991) Evaluation of errors in the measurement of biological nitrogen fixation using15N fertilizer. In: Stable Isotopes in Plant Nutrition, Soil Fertility and Environmental Studies, pp 59–72. Int Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna
Witty JF and Ritz K (1984) Slow release15N fertilizer formulations to measure N2-fixation by isotope dilution. Soil Biol Biochem 16: 657–661
Witty JF, Rennie RJ and Atkins CA (1988)15N addition methods for assessing N2 fixation under field conditions. In: Summerfield RJ (ed) World Crops: Cool Season Food Legumes, pp 715–730. Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Boddey, R.M., de Oliveira, O.C., Alves, B.J.R. et al. Field application of the15N isotope dilution technique for the reliable quantification of plant-associated biological nitrogen fixation. Fertilizer Research 42, 77–87 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00750501
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00750501