Summary
In an attempt to explain the discrepancy between the results obtained by American and Italian investigators with reference to the role of olfaction in pigeon navigation, 5 series of homing experiments, most of which had already been performed on Italian pigeons, were conducted with Ithaca birds.
-
1.
Application of an odorant (α-pinene) to the birds' beaks and nostrils did not produce consistent differences in initial orientation. The experimental birds were somewhat slower in homing. 2. Elimination of olfactory information during the outward journey did not result in different initial orientation. However, the experimental birds had poorer homing performances. 3. The initial orientation was significantly influenced by one out of 3 sorts of outward journey detours; the positive results from the effective detour could be repeated. 4. Pigeons made anosmatic by inserting plastic tubes in their nostrils were tested from familiar and unfamiliar release sites. At the familiar sites, the control bearings were randomly distributed and not homeward oriented; the experimentals, which were non-random in one site but random in the other, always were homeward oriented. At the unfamiliar site, all the groups were non-randomly oriented. The control birds were homeward directed; the clustering of the experimental bearings around the home direction was not significant or at the boundaries of the significance. Homing performances were very different, the controls performing normally, the experimentals being mostly lost. 5. Pigeons subjected to unilateral sectioning of the olfactory nerve and to plugging of one nostril — the ipsilateral in the control and the contralateral in the experimental birds — were tested from two unfamiliar sites. The orientation of the two treatments was nearly identical at both sites. At one site there was a major difference in homing performance, the controls returning well and the experimentals very poorly; at the other site there was no significant difference in homing performance.
These results are discussed separately by the Italian and the American investigators.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Batschelet, E.: Statistical methods for the analysis of problems in animal orientation and certain biological rhythms. Washigton: American Institute of Biological Sciences 1965
Batschelet, E.: Recent statistical methods for orientation data. In: Animal orientation and navigation. Galler, S.R., Schmidt-Koenig, K., Jacobs, G.J., Belleville, R.E. (eds.), NASA SP-262, pp. 61–91. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office 1972
Baldaccini, N.E., Benvenuti, S., Fiaschi, V., Papi, F.: New data on the influence of olfactory deprivation on the homing behavior of pigeons. In: Olfaction and taste V. Denton, D., Coghlan, J.P. (eds.). New York, London: Academic Press 1975
Baldaccini, N.E., Benvenuti, S., Fiaschi, V., Ioale', P., Papi, F.: Investigation of pigeon homing by means of “deflector cages”. Proceedings of Life Sciences, pp. 78–91. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1978
Benvenuti, S., Fiaschi, V., Fiore, L., Papi, F.: Disturbances of homing behaviour in pigeons experimentally induced by olfactory stimuli. Monitore zool. ital. (N.S.)7, 117–128 (1973)
Benvenuti, S., Fiaschi, V., Foa', A.: Homing behaviour of pigeons disturbed by application of an olfactory stimulus. J. comp. Physiol.120, 173–179 (1977)
Fiaschi, V., Wagner, G.: Pigeons' homing: some experiments for testing the olfactory hypothesis. Experientia32, 991 (1976)
Hartwick, R.F., Foa', A., Papi, F.: The effect of olfactory deprivation by nasal tubes upon homing behavior in pigeons. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.2, 81–89 (1977)
Hartwick, R.F., Kiepenheuer, J., Schmidt-Koenig, K.: Further experiments on the olfactory hypothesis of pigeon navigation. Proceedings of Life Sciences. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1978
Keeton, W.T.: Pigeon homing: no influence of outward-journey detours on initial orientation. Monitore zool. ital. (N.S.)8, 227–234 (1974)
Keeton, W.T., Brown, A.I.: Homing behavior of pigeons not disturbed by application of an olfactory stimulus. J. comp. Physiol.105, 252–266 (1976)
Keeton, W.T., Kreithen, M.L., Hermayer, K.L.: Orientation of pigeons deprived of olfaction by nasal tubes. J. comp. Physiol.114, 289–299 (1977)
Kiepenheuer, J.: The effect of magnetic field inversed during displacement on the homing behavior of pigeons. Proceedings of Life Sciences. Berlin. Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1978
Papi, F.: The olfactory navigation system of the homing pigeon. Verh. Dtsch. Zool. Ges.1976, 184–205 (1976)
Papi, F., Fiore, L., Fiaschi, V., Benvenuti, S.: Olfaction and homing in pigeons. Monitore zool. ital. (N.S.)6, 85–95 (1972)
Papi, F., Fiaschi, V., Benvenuti, S., Baldaccini, N.E.: Pigeon homing: outward journey detours influence the initial orientation. Monitore zool. ital. (N.S.)7, 129–133 (1973)
Papi, F., Ioale', P., Fiaschi, V., Benvenuti, S., Baldaccini, N.E.: Pigeon homing: cues detected during the outward journey influence initial orientation. Proceedings of Life Sciences, pp. 65–77. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1978
Schmidt-Koenig, K., Phillips, J.B.: Local anesthesia of the olfactory membrane and homing pigeons. Proceedings of Life Sciences. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1978
Siegel, S.: Nonparametric statistics for the behavioral sciences, p. 312. New York: McGraw-Hill 1956
Snyder, R.L., Cheney, C.D.: Homing performance of anosmic pigeons. Bull. Psychonom. Soc.6, 592–594 (1975
Waldvogel, J.A., Benvenuti, S., Keeton, W.T., Papi, F.: Homing pigeon orientation influenced by deflected winds at home loft. J. comp. Physiol.128, 297–301 (1978)
Wiltschko, R., Wiltschko, W., Keeton, W.T.: The effect of outward journey in an altered magnetic field in young homing pigeons. Proceedings of Life Sciences. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer 1978
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
The authors wish to thank Charles Walcott for aid in airplane tracking and Kathie Hermayer for performing the necessary surgery. We also wish to acknowledge the help of Andre Gobert, Douglas McCorkle, Michael Weiler, Jerry Waldvogel, and Douglas Quine in conducting test releases. Further thanks are extended to Angela Lui, Daniel Polikoff, Scott Smith, and Sean Tunis for their help in preparing for and participating in test releases. The Italian authors express their gratitude to the Cassa di Risparmio di Pisa for the financial support received. Additional support for this study came from the National Science Foundation Grants No. BMS 75-18905 A02 to William T. Keeton.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Papi, F., Keeton, W.T., Brown, A.I. et al. Do American and Italian pigeons rely on different homing mechanisms?. J. Comp. Physiol. 128, 303–317 (1978). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00657605
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00657605