Summary
Information relating to the etiology of human XX males is reviewed. The lesser body height and smaller tooth size in comparison with control males and first-degree male relatives could imply that the patients never had any Y chromosome. Neither reports of occasional mitoses with a Y chromosome, nor of the occurrence of Y chromatin in Sertoli cells are convincing enough to support the idea that low-grade or circumscribed mosaicism is a common etiologic factor. Reports of an increase in length of one of the X chromosomes in XX males are few and some are conflicting. Nor is there any evidence to support the idea of loss of material. However, absence of visible cytogenetic alteration does not rule out the possibility of translocations, exchanges or deletions.
A few familial cases are known. Mendelian gene mutations may account for a number of instances of XX males, similar genes being well known in several animal species. The existing geographical differences in the prevalence of human XX males could be explained by differences in gene frequency. But if gene mutation were a common cause of XX maleness there would be more familial cases.
Any hypothesis explaining the etiology of XX males should take into account the following facts. There are at least 4 examples of XX males who have inherited the Xg allele carried by their fathers, and at least 9 of such males who have not. The frequency of the Xg phenotype among XX males is far closer to that of males than to that of females, while the absence of any color-blind XX males (among 40 tested) resembles the distribution in females. Furthermore, H-Y antigen is present in XX males, often at a strength intermediate between that in normal males and females. Finally, in a pedigree comprising three independently ascertained XX males, the mothers of all three are H-Y antigen-positive, and the pattern of inheritance of the antigen in two of them precludes X-chromosomal transmission.
Many of the data are consistent with the hypothesis that XX males arise through interchange of the testic-determining gene on the Y chromosome and a portion of the X chromosome containing the Xg gene. However, actual evidence in favor of this hypothesis is still lacking, and the H-Y antigen data are not easy to explain. In contrast, if recent hypotheses on the mechanisms controlling the expression of H-Y antigen are confirmed, a gene exerting negative control on testis determination would be located near the end of of the short arm of the X chromosome. This putative gene is believed not to be inactivated in normal females, for at least two other genes located in the same region, i.e. Xg and steroid sulfatase, are not. Deletion or inactivation of these loci would explain how XX males arise and would be consistent with most, but not all, the facts.
There is yet no single hypothesis that by itself can explain all the facts accumulated about XX males. While mosaicism appears very unlikely in most cases, Mendelian gene mutation, translocation, X-Y interchange, a minute deletion or preferential inactivation of an X chromosome, or part thereof, remain possible. The etiology of XX maleness may well be heterogeneous.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Alvesalo L, Kari M (1977) Sizes of deciduous teeth in 47,XYY males. Am J Hum Genet 29:486–489
Alvesalo L, de la Chapelle A (1979) Permanent tooth sizes in 46,XX males. Ann Hum Genet Lond 43:97–102
Alvesalo L, de la Chapelle A (1981) Tooth sizes in two males with deletions of the long arm of the Y chromosome. Ann Hum Genet Lond 45:49–54
Alvesalo L, Osborne RH, Kari M (1975) The 47,XYY male, Y chromosome, and tooth size. Am J Hum Genet 27:53–61
Bartsch-Sandhoff M (1974) Erweiterte Mosaikhypothese als Erklärung für XX-Männer. Humangenetik 23:161–162
Bartsch-Sandhoff M, Schade H, Wiegelmann W, Solbach HG, Scholz W (1974) Eir Beitrag zur Genese von XX-Männern. Humangenetik 21:245–253
Berg K, Bearn AG (1966) An inherited X-linked serum system in man: the Xm system. J Exp Med 123:379–397
Berg K, Bearn AG (1968) Human serum protein polymorphisms: a selected review. Ann Rev Genet 2:341–362
Bernstein R, Wagner J, Isdale J, Nurse GT, Lane AB, Jenkins T (1978) X-Y translocation in a retarded phenotypic male. Clinical, cytogenetic, biochemical and serogenetic studies. J Med Genet 15: 466–474
Bernstein R, Jenkins T, Dawson B, Wagner J, Dewald G, Koo GC, Wachtel SS (1980) Female phenotype and multiple abnormalities in sibs with a Y chromosome and partial X chromosome duplication: H-Y antigen and Xg blood group findings. J Med Genet 17: 291–300
Bühler EM (1980) A synopsis of the human Y chromosome. Hum Genet 55:145–175
Caspersson T, Zech L, Johansson C, Modest EJ (1970) Identification of human chromosomes by DNA-binding fluorescing agents. Chromosoma 30:215–227
Cattanach BM, Pollard CE, Hawkes SG (1971) Sex-reversed mice: XX and X0 males. Cytogenetics 10:318–337
de la Chapelle A, Hortling H, Niemi M, Wennström J (1964) XX sex chromosomes in a human male. First case. Acta Med Scand [Suppl] 412:25–38
de la Chapelle A (1972) Analytic review nature and origin of males with XX sex chromosomes. Am J Hum Genet 24:71–105
de la Chapelle A, Miller OJ (1979) Report of the Committee on the Genetic Constitution of Chromosomes 10, 11, 12, X, and Y. Cytogenet Cell Genet 25:47–58
de la Chapelle A, Schröder J, Murros J, Tallqvist G (1977) Two XX males in one family and additional observations bearing on the etiology of XX males. Clin Genet 11:91–106
de la Chapelle A, Koo GC, Wachtel SS (1978) Recessive sex-determining genes in human XX male syndrome. Cell 15:837–842
de la Chapelle A, Simola K, Simola P, Knuutila S, Gahmberg N, Pajunen L, Lundqvist C, Sarna S, Murros J (1979) Heteromorphic X chromosomes in 46,XX males? Hum Genet 52:157–167
Cullen M, Greally M, Greally J (1976) The XX male syndrome — a case report. Clin Genet 10:73–76
Dosik H, Wachtel SS, Khan F, Spergel G, Koo GC (1976) Y-chromosomal genes in a phenotypic male with a 46,XX karyotype. J Am Med Assoc 236:2505–2508
Evans HJ, Buckton KE, Spowart G, Carothers AD (1979) Heteromorphic X chromosomes in 46,XX males: evidence for the involvement of X-Y interchange. Hum Genet 49:11–31
Forabosco A, Carratu A, Assuma M, de Pol A, Dutrillaux B, Cheli E (1977) Male with 45,X karyotype. Clin Genet 12:97–100
Ford CE (1961) Die Zytogenese der Intersexualität des Menschen. In: Overzier C (Hrsg) Die Intersexualität. Georg Theime Verlag, Stuttgart, pp 90–121
Fraccaro M, Tiepolo L, Zuffardi O, Chiumello G, Di Natale E, Gargantini G, Wolf U (1979) Familial XX true hermaphroditism and the H-Y antigen. Hum Genet 48:45–52
Fromantin M, Gautier D, Dienot B, Boisselier P, Thabaut A (1973) Le sujet masculin au caryotype XX — variété chromosomique du syndrome de Klinefelter? (A propos de 2 nouvelles observations). Lyon Médical 230:781–784
Ghosh SN, Shah PN, Gharupe HM (1978) Absence of H-Y antigen in XY females with dysgenetic gonads. Nature 276:180
Giammarini A, Rocchi M, Zennaro W, Filippi G (1980) XX male with breast cancer. Clin Genet 18:103–108
Iinuma K, Ohzeki T, Ohtaguro K, Higashihara E, Tanae A, Nakagome Y (1975) Y-chromatin positive cells in the smear preparations of the gonad from an XX male. Humangenetik 30:193–196
Kaiser P, Gerhard-Ratschow K, Zabel B, Gey W (1977) A new case of XX-male (XX/XXY mosaic). Hum Genet 39:131–137
Kasdan R, Nankin HR, Troen P, Wald N, Pan S, Yanaihara T (1973) Paternal transmission of maleness in XX human beings. N Engl J Med 288:539–545
Lo Curto F, Pucci E, Scappaticci S, Scotta S, Severi F, Burgio GB, Fraccaro M (1974) X0 and male phenotype. Am J Dis Child 128: 90–91
Lubetzki J, de Grouchy J, Duprey J, Lenormand M-E (1972) Caryotype 46,XX chez un sujet à phénotype mâle. Ann Méd Interne Paris 123: 635–639
Madan K (1976) Chromosome measurements on an XXp+ male. Hum Genet 32:141–142
Madan K, Walker S (1974) Possible evidence for Xp+ in an XX male. Lancet I:1223
Malka J, Dieterlen M, Hadjian A-J, Jonnard A, Bost M, Jalbert P (1975) Pédiatrie 30:73–76
Minowada S, Kobayashi K, Isurugi K, Fukutani K, Ikeuchi H, Hasegawa T, Yamada K (1979) Two XX male brothers. Clin Genet 15:399–405
Miro R, Caballin MR, Marina S, Egozcue J (1978) Mosaicism in XX males. Hum Genet 45:103–106
Mohandas T, Shapiro LJ, Sparkes RS, Sparkes MC (1979) Regional assignment of the steroid sulfatase-X-linked ichthyosis locus: implications for a noninactivated region on the short arm of human X-chromosome. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 76:5779–5783
Moorrees CFA, Fanning EA, Hunt EE Jr (1963) Age variation of formation stages for ten permanent teeth. J Dent Res 42:1450–1502
Mori Y, Mizutani S, Sonoda T, Furuyama J (1969) XX male: a case report. Jpn J Urol 60:279–285
Müller CR, Migl B, Traupe H, Ropers HH (1980a) X-linked steroid sulfatase: evidence for different gene-dosage in males and females. Hum Genet 54:197–199
Müller CR, Westerveld A, Migl B, Franke W, Ropers HH (1980b) Regional assignment of the gene locus for steroid sulfatase. Hum Genet 54:201–224
Nicolis GL, Hsu LY, Sabetghadam R, Kardon NB, Chernay PR, Mathur DP, Rose HG, Hirschhorn K, Gabrilove JL (1972) Klinefelter's syndrome in identical twins with the 46,XX chromosome constitution. Am J Med 52:482–491
Nielsen J, Sillesen I (1975) Incidence of chromosome aberrations among 11,148 newborn children. Humangenetik 30:1–12
Noel B, Tous J (1978) Sexual determination of XX men. J Génét Hum 26:287–288
Paluke WA, Chen Y, Chen H (1973) Presence of brightly fluorescent material in testes of XX males. J Med Genet 10:170–174
Pawlowitzki IH, Holzgreve W, Kövary M, Niermann H, Scholz W (1978) Testing mosaicism hypothesis in an XX male. Ann Génét Paris 21:152–156
Pietriga J-J (1977) Les hommes XX. Thèse, Faculté de Médecine de Dijon, pp 1–86
Polani PE, Angell R, Giannelli F, de la Chapelle A, Race RR, Sanger R (1970) Evidence that the Xg locus is inactivated in structurally abnormal X chromosomes. Nature 227:613–616
Powers HO, Neu RL, Smulyan H, Gardner LI (1970) An adult phenotypic male with a 46,XX chromosome complement. J Clin Endocrinol 31:576–579
Race RR, Sanger R (1975) Blood groups in man, 6th edn. Blackwell Scientific Publ, Oxford London Edinburgh Melbourne
Rehder H, Brühl P, Seth PK (1975) Das XX-Mann-Syndrom. Pathogenese und Beitrag zu den Fehlermöglichkeiten der Diagnose. Urologie A 14:182–186
Rios ME, Kaufman RL, Sekhorn GS, Bucy JG, Bauman JE, Jacobs LS (1975) An XX male: Cytogenetic and endocrine studies. Clin Genet 7:155–162
Roe TF, Alfi OS (1977) Ambiguous genitalia in XX male children: report of two infants. Pediatrics 60:55–59
Rubio GR, Weiss L, Nunez JF, Saeed uz Zafar M (1974) Phenotypic males with 46,XX karyotype. Henry Ford Hosp Med J 22:120
Selden JR, Wachtel SS, Koo GC, Haskins ME, Patterson DF (1978) Genetic basis of XX male syndrome and XX true hermaphroditsim: evidence in the dog. Science 201:644–646
Sellyei M, Wass L, Krausz T (1975) Non-random appearance of Y-chromatin-like fluorescence in the nuclei of thyroid and brain and its chromosomal background. Humangenetik 27:339–342
Soller M, Padeh B, Wysoki M, Ayalon N (1969) Cytogenetics of Saanen goats showing abnormal development of the reproductive tract associated with the dominat gene for polledness. Cytogenetics 8: 51–62
Steffensen DM, Gosden JR (1979) Report of the Committee on Molecular Cytogenetics. Cytogenet Cell Genet 25:77–81
Sutherland GR, Wiener S, Bartholomew AA (1972) A male with karyotype 46,XX. Ann Génét Paris 15:187–189
Takayasu H, Kinoshita K, Isurugi K, Matsumoto Y, Komine Y, Tonomura A (1973) Male hermaphrodite with 46,XX chromosome constitution. Acta Endocrinol 73:396–406
Tiepolo L, Zuffardi O, Fraccaro M, di Natale D, Gargantini L, Müller CR, Ropers HH (1980) Assignment by deletion mapping of the steroid suflatase X-linked ichthyosis locus to Xp223. Hum Genet 54:205–206
Wachtel SS (1979) Immunogenetic aspects of abnormal sexual differentiation. Cell 16:691–695
Wachtel SS, Ohno S, Koo GC, Boyse EA (1975) Possible role for H-Y antigen in the primary determination of sex. Nature 257:235–236
Wachtel SS, Koo GC, Breg WR, Thaler HT, Dilard GM, Rosenthal IM, Dosik G, Gerald PS, Saenger P, New M, Lieber E, Miller OJ (1976) Serologic detection of a Y-linked gene in XX males and XX true hermaphrodites. N Engl J Med 295:750–754
Wachtel SS, Basrur P, Koo GC (1978) Recessive male-determining genes. Cell 15:279–281
Wolf U (1979) XY gonadal dysgenesis and the H-Y antigen. Report on 12 cases. Hum Genet 47:269–277
Wolf U, Fraccaro M, Mayerová A, Hecht T, Maraschio P, Hameister H (1980a) A gene controlling H-Y antigen on the X chromosome. Tentative assignment by deletion mapping to Xp223. Hum Genet 54:149–154
Wolf U, Fraccaro M, Mayerová A, Hecht T, Zuffardi O, Hameister H (1980b) Turner syndrome patients are H-Y positive. Hum Genet 54:315–318
Yunis E, de la Cruz E, Nossa MA, Gutierrez G (1975) XX males: two new cases. Clin Genet 7:394–399
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
de la Chapelle, A. The etiology of maleness in XX men. Hum Genet 58, 105–116 (1981). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00284157
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00284157