Abstract
The dominating sources of phosphorus in municipal wastewaters are excreta, 1.4 g P/(cap.d) and detergents, 0.6 – 2 g P/(cap.d). Detergent phosphorus can be substituted by nitrilotriacetic acid or zeolites, but if a substantial reduction of phosphorus in municipal waters is to be achieved, modifying the treatment process is necessary. Primary, treatment by sedimentation removes only 10–15% and secondary biological treatment 20–30% of the phosphorus in waste water. If chemicals are added to the primary or secondary treatment stage or to a separate chemical stage, phosphorus can be efficiently removed. An effluent level of 0.8–1.5 g P m-3 is easily achieved and with a filtration step it is possible to maintain 0.2 g P m-3 in the effluent. Different process configurations are discussed. As precipitants, ferrous and ferric salts, alum and lime are widely used. By introducing anaerobic zones in the activated sludge process, it is possible to promote the growth of bacteria which enhance biological phosphorus uptake. This makes it possible to achieve high phosphorus removal without or, al least, with very small chemical additions. Several emerging physical, chemical and biological phosphorus removal processes are discussed. The removal of phosphorus to a level of 0.8–1.5 g P m-3 increases cost 10–20% compared with conventional primary secondary treatment. Higher removal efficiencies will rapidly increase the marginal cost per marginal kg P removed.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Albertson, O. E. & R. J. Sherwood, 1969. Phosphate extraction process. J. W at. Pollut. Contr. Fed. 41: 1467–1490.
Alexander, G. J. & R. J. Stevens, 1976. Per capita phosphorus loading from domestic sewage. Wat. Res. 10: 757–764.
Andersson, C. & C. Bornö , 1979. Kostnader för avloppsvattenrening. Statens Naturvårdverk, Stockholm, PM-series 1237, 127 pp. (in Swedish).
Andersson, L. G. & P. E. Sörensen, 1981. Simultandaelding og filtrering. Delrapport 2. Water Quality Institute, Hörsholm, Denmark, 34 pp. (in Danish).
Annaka, T., 1980. Research and practice on phosphorus control in Japan. Paper presented at the EPA international seminar on control of nutrients in municipal wastewater effluents, San Diego, California, USA, Sept. 9–11 1980, 47 pp.
Arvin, E., 1985. Biological removal of phosphorus from wastewater. CRC Crit. Rev. Envir. Cont. 15: 25–64.
Arvin, E. & G. H. Kristensen, 1985. Exchange of organics, phosphate and cations between sludge and water in biological phosphorus and nitrogen removal processes. Wat. Sci. Tech. 17: 147–162.
Arvin, E. & G. Petersen, 1980. A general equilibrium model for the precipitation of phosphate with iron and aluminium. Prog. Wat. Tech. 12: 283–298.
Baccini, P., 1985. Einschränkung des Phosphatverbrauches — Ein Beitrag zum Gewässerschutz. Gas-Wasser-Abwasser 65: 1–6.
Balmér, P., 1982. Water Quality Control in Sweden. Wat. Qual. Bull. 7: 127–130, 151–152.
Balmér, P., 1984. Erfarenheter med fällning av kommunalt avloppsvatten med kalk. Chalmers University of Technol. Dep. of San. Eng. Göteborg, Publ 3: 84, 24 pp. (in Swedish).
Balmér, P. & O. F. Fredriksen, 1975. A pilot plant scale evaluation of potential precipitants in the secondary precipitation process. Wat. Res. 9: 721–727.
Balmér, P. & B. Vik, 1978. Domestic wastewater treatment with oxidation ponds in combination with chemical precipitation. Prog. Wat. Tech. 10: 867–880.
Barnard, J. L., G. M. Stevens & P. J. Leslie, 1985. Design strategies for nutrient removal plant. Wat. Sci. Tech. 17: 233–242.
Barth, E. F. & H. D. Stensel, 1981. International nutrient control technology for municipal effluents. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 53: 1691–1701.
Boller, M., 1984. Chemical optimization of tertiary contact filters. Am. Soc. Civ. Eng. J. Env. Eng. Div. 110: 263–276.
Booman, K. A. & R. I. Sedlak, 1986. Phosphate detergents — a closer look. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 58: 1092–1100.
Brattebø, H. & H. Ødegaard, 1986. Phosphorus removal by granular activated alumina. Wat. Res. 20: 977–986.
Brix, H., 1986. Treatment of wastewater in the rhizosphere of wetland plants — the root-zone method. Wat. Sci. Tech. 19: 107–118.
Chapra, S. C., H. D. Wicke & T. M. Heide, 1983. Effectiveness of treatment to meet phosphorus objectives in the Great Lakes. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 55: 81–91.
Christensen, M. H., 1976. Possibilities in sewage treatment to reduce the quality of nutrients. Seminar on the recent development in the technological field in respect to prevention of pollution of the Baltic Sea Area (under the Convention of the Protection of Marine Environment of the Baltic Sea Area), Seminar Proceedings, Hanasaari Cultural Centre, Espoo, Finland, 18 to 22 Oct.: 215–246.
Comeau, Y., K. J. Hall, R. E. W. Hancock & W. K. Oldham, 1986. Biochemical model for enhanced biological phosphorus removal. Wat. Res. 20: 1511–1521.
Eggers, E. & J. C. van Dijk, 1986. Phosphorus removal by crystallization in a fluidized bed reactor. In H. H. Hahn, R. Klute & P. Balmér (eds). Recycling in chemical water and wastewater treatment. Schriftenreihe des ISWW, Karlsruhe No. 50 (ISSN 0722–7698): 349–361.
EPA, 1976. Process design manual for phosphorus removal. US Environmental Protection Agency, Technology Transfer. EPA 625/1–76–001a, Washington, 260 pp.
Fergusson, J. F. & L. Våle, 1984. Chemical aspects of the lime seawater process. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 56: 355–363.
Flögl, H. & W. Flögl, 1987. O-ring collectors. Forthcoming in Proc. Eur. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Ass. Lakes pollution and recovery. Rome, April 15–18, 1985.
Graham, H. J. and R. B. Hunsinger, 1974. Phosphorus removal in seasonal retention lagoons by batch chemical precipitation. Environment Canada. Canada — Ontario Agreement on Great Lakes Water Quality. Research Report No. 13, Ottawa, 40 pp.
Grohmann, A., 1985. Flocculation in pipes: Design and operation. In A. Grohmann, H. H. Hahn & R. Klute (eds), Chemical water and wastewater treatment. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart: 113–131.
Grönquist, S. H. Holmström, B. Hultman & L. G. Reinius, 1978. Experiences and process development in biological-chemical treatment of municipal wastewaters in Sweden. Prog. Wat. Tech. 10: 701–713.
Hartig, J. H. & F. J. Horvath, 1982. A preliminary assessment of Michigan's phosphorus detergent ban. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 54: 193–197.
Hedberg, T., 1985. Flocculation in tanks: Design and operation. In A. Grohmann, H. H. Hahn & R. Klute (eds), Chemical water and wastewater treatment. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart: 103–112.
Henriksen, A., 1963. Laboratory studies on the removal of phosphates from sewage by the coagulation process. Schweiz. Z. Hydrol. 25: 380–396.
Hultman, B., J. E. Lind, L. G. Reinius, L. Eklund, H. Engberg, S. Lilja & B. Nordström, 1984. Modified operational modes at Swedish municipal wastewater treatment plants. Wat. Sci. Tech. 16: 621–633.
Hultman, B. & B. Nordström, 1987. Utvärdering av olika driftsätt vid biologisk-kemisk rening av kommunalt avloppsvatten. Statens Naturvårdsverk, Stockholm, PM-series 1963, 50 pp (in Swedish).
Hökervall, E., 1971. Pre-precipitation — trials at the sewage treatment plants in Stockholm. Effl. Wat. Treat. J. 1: 551–553.
Joko, I., 1985. Phosphorus removal from wastewater by the crystallization method. Wat. Sci. Tech. 17: 121–132.
Jost, B. A., 1987. Practical experiences and cost of phosphorus removal. Forthcoming in Proc. Eur. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Ass. Lakes pollution and recovery. Rome, April 15–18, 1985.
Jost, B. A., 1986. Filtrationsverfahren in der weitergehenden Abwassereeinigung. Gas — Wasser — Abwasser 66: 790–797.
Kiiskinen, S., 1985. Pre-precipitation in the Helsinki sewage works. In A. Grohmann, H. H. Hahn & R. Klute (eds), Chemical water and wastewater treatment. Gustav Fisher Verlag, Stuttgart: 277–281.
Klute, R., 1985. Rapid mixing in coagulation/flocculation process-design criteria. In A. Grohmann, H. H. Hahn & R. Klute (eds), Chemical water and wastewater treatment. Gustav Fisher Verlag, Stuttgart: 53–65.
Krook, R., 1986. Hushållstvättmedel och vattenskydd. Statens Naturvårdsverk, Stockholm, PM-series 3189, 40 pp (in Swedish).
Leckie J. & W. Stumm, 1970. Phosphate precipitation. In E. F. GLoyna & W. W. Eckenfelder (eds), Water quality improvement by physical and chemical processes. University of Texas press, Austin, Texas, 449 pp.
Lee, G. F. & R. A. Jones, 1986. Detergent phosphate bans and eutrophication. Envir. Sci. Technol. 20: 330–331.
Lenhart, B. & C. Steinberg, 1986. Auswirkung der Phosphathöchstmengenverordnung am Ammersee. Vom Wasser 67: 237–247.
Levin, G. J. & J. Shapiro, 1965. Metabolic uptake of phosphorus by wastewater organisms. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 37: 800–821.
Lindholm, O., 1984. Dry weather deposition in combined sewers. In P. Balmer, P-A. Malmqvist & R. Sjöberg(eds). Planning and control of urban storm drainage. Proc. 3rd. int. conf. on urban storm drainage. Chalmers Univ. of Technol., Göteborg (ISBN 91–7032–128–0): 861–868.
Maki, A. W., D. B. Porcella & R. H. Wendt, 1984. The impact of detergent bans on receiving water quality. Wat. Res. 18: 893–903.
Malmqvist, P-A., 1983. Urban Stormwater Pollutant Sources. Ph. D. Thesis, Chalmers Univ. of Techn., Göteborg, 371 pp. (ISBN 91–7032–106-X).
Marais, G. v. R., R. E. Loewenthal & I. P. Siebritz, 1983. Observations supporting phosphate removal by biological excess uptake — a review. Wat. Sci. Tech. 15: 15–41.
Menar, A. B. & D. Jenkins, 1970. Fate of phosphorus in waste treatment process: Enhanced removal of phosphate by activated sludge. Envir. Sci. Technol. 4: 1115–1121.
National Swedish Environment Protection Board, 1979. Avloppsrening — tätorterna avloppsförhållande den 1 januari 1979. Statens Naturv»rdsverk, Stockholm, Meddelande 4/1979: 59 pp. (in Swedish).
Nesbitt, J. B., 1969. Phosphorus removal — the state of art. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 41: 701–724.
Pallesen, L., P. M. Berthouex & K. Booman, 1985. Environmental intervention analysis: Wisconsin's ban on phosphate detergents. Wat. Res., 19: 353–362.
Pearse, L. et al., 1935. Chemical treatment of sewage. Sewage Works J. 7: 997–1108.
Peterson, G., 1985. Upflow contact filtration. In A. Grohmann, H. H. Hahn & R. Klute (eds). Chemical water and wastewater treatment. Gustav Fisher Verlag, Stuttgart: 167–173.
Pöpel, J., 1967. Die Elimination von Phosphaten aus Abwasser durch chemiche Fellung. Gas- und Wasserfach. 108: 613–615.
Rudolfs, W., 1947. Phosphates in sewage treatment. I. Qualities of phosphates. Sewage Works J. 19: 43–47.
Spatzierer, G., C. Ludwig & N. Matsché, 1985. Biological phosphorus removal in combination with simultaneous precipitation. Wat. Sci. Tech. 17: 163–176.
Stendahl, K., 1986. Chemical treatment versus biological treatment. In H. H. Hahn, R. Klute & P. Balmér (eds). Recycling in chemical water and wastewater treatment. Schriftenreihe des ISWW, Karlsruhe No. 50 (ISSN 0722–7698): 59–70.
Stewart, E. A., 1986. Recovering energy from water hyacints. In H. H. Hahn, R. Klute & P. Balmér (eds). Recycling in chemical water and wastewater treatment. Schriftenreihe des ISSW, Karlsruhe No. 50 (ISSN 0722–7698): 391–411.
Stumm, w., 1985. Clean shirts and clean water. Environ. Sci. Tech. 19: 1013.
Stumm, W. & J. J. Morgan, 1981. Aquatic Chemistry. J. Wiley & Sons, N. Y., 780 pp.
Thomas, E. A., 1969. Die Elimination der Phosphorverbindungen aus dem Abwasser. Berichte der ATV 23: 253–275.
Thomas, E. A., 1972. Phosphate removal by recirculating iron sludge. J. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed. 44: 176–182.
Ulmgren, L., 1975. Swedish experiences in chemical treatment of wastewater. J. Wat. Pollut. Fed. 47: 696–703.
Veldkamp, R. G., 1985. Modeling phosphate sludge production, Wat. Sci. Tech. 17: 107–119.
WPCF. 1983. Nutrient control. Manual of practice FD-7. Facilities design. Wat. Pollut. Cont. Fed., Washington D. C., USA, 205 pp.
Vråle, L., 1978. Chemical precipitation of wastewater with lime and seawater. Prog. Wat. Tech. 10: 645–656.
Vråle, L., 1983. Spillvannstap fra oppsamlingsnett. Norwegian institute for water research, Oslo. Report VA 11/83, 106 pp. (ISBN 82–577–0608–6) (in Norwegian).
Wuhrmann, K., 1964. Stickstoff und Phosphorelimination: Ergebnisse von Versuchen in Technischen Masstab. Schweiz. Z. Hydrol. 26: 520–558.
Ødegaard, H., 1975. Flocculation of phosphate precipitates in wastewater treatment. Dr. ing. thesis. Div. Hydro and San. Eng. Univ. Trondheim, 247 pp.
Ødegaard, H., 1985a. Engineering aspects on flocculation. In A. Grohmann, H. H. Hahn & R. Klute (eds). Chemical water and wastewater treatment. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart: 81–102.
Ødegaard, H., 1985b. Kostnadsminimering ved rensing av avløpsvann. Norges Teknsik-Naturvitenskapelige Forskningsråd, Program for VAR-teknikk, Prosjektrapport 27/85, 117 p. (ISBN 82–7337–029–1.) (in Norwegian).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Balmér, P., Hultman, B. Control of phosphorus discharges: present situation and trends. Hydrobiologia 170, 305–319 (1988). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00024911
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00024911