Abstract
Resilience is commonly portrayed as a positive capability that allows individuals and organizations to thrive in dynamic contexts. This paper questions this oversimplified view based on a dialectical analysis of a telehealth innovation. We analyze the major contradictions that characterize the adoption of the innovation. First, we analyze contradictions between individuals and groups within each adopting hospital. Second, we analyze contradictions between the adopting hospitals. This two-level analysis leads to a deeper understanding of resilience as a dialectical process. The analysis of the case shows that, although the participating individuals and organizations demonstrated apparent resilience in adopting the telehealth innovation, the innovation remained in a fragile state where it was unclear whether it would continue to diffuse, stabilize as-is, or slowly deteriorate. Hence, while organizational resilience facilitated swift and successful adoption, it also created tensions that endangered further diffusion and the long term sustainability of the telehealth innovation. We suggest that understanding the future success of the innovation would be facilitated to a large extent by a dialectical analysis of the involved contradictions.
Chapter PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aarts, J., and Peel, V. “Using a Descriptive Model of Change When Implementing Large Scale Clinical Information Systems to Identify Priorities for Further Research,” International Journal of Medical Informatics (56), 1999, pp. 43–50.
Anderson, J. G. “Clearing the Way for Physicians’ Use of Clinical Information Systems,” Communications of the ACM (40:8), 1997, pp. 83–90.
Bangert, D., and Doktor, R. “The Role of Organizational Culture in the Management of Clinical e-Health Systems,” in Proceedings of the 36 th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 2003, pp. 163–171
Bacharach, S. B., Bamberger, P., and Sonnenstuhl, W. J. “The Organizational Transformation Process: The Micropolitics of Dissonance Reduction and the Alignment of Logics of Action,” Administrative Science Quarterly (41:3), 1996, pp. 477–506.
Benbasat, I., Goldenstein, D. K., and Mead, M. “The Case Research Strategy in Studies of Information Systems,” MIS Quarterly (11:3), 1987, pp. 369–386.
Berg, M. “Implementing Information Systems in Health Care Organizations: Myths and Challenges,” International Journal of Medical Informatics (64:2–3), 2001, pp. 143–156.
Bjerknes, G. “Dialectical Reflection in Information Systems Development,” Scandinavian Journal of Information Systems (3), 1991, pp. 55–77.
Casper, M. L., Barnett, E., Williams, G. I. J., Halverson, J. A., Braham, V. E., and Greenlund, K. J. “Atlas of Stroke Mortality: Racial, Ethnic, and Geographic Disparities in the United States,” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, January 2003 (available online through www.cdc.gov).
Chae, B., and Bloodgood, J. M. “The Paradoxes of Knowledge Management: An Eastern Philosophical Perspective,” Information and Organization (16:1), 2006, pp. 1–26.
Chiasson, M. W., and Davidson, E. “Pushing the Contextual Envelope: Developing and Diffusing Is Theory for Health Information Systems Research,” Information and Organization (14:3), 2004, pp. 155–188.
Constantinides, P., and Barrett, M. “Negotiating ICT Development and Use: The Case of a Telemedicine System in the Healthcare Region of Crete,” Information and Organization (16:1), 2006, pp. 27–55.
Coutu, D. L. “How Resilience Works,” Harvard Business Review (80:5), 2002, pp. 46–55.
Darke, P., Shanks, G., and Broadbent, M. “Successfully Completing Case Study Research: Combining Rigor, Relevance and Pragmatism,” Information Systems Journal (8:4), 1998, pp. 273–289.
Das, T. K., and Teng, B.-S. “Instabilities of Strategic Alliances: An Internal Tensions Perspective,” Organization Science (11:1), 2000, pp. 77–101.
Davidson, E. J. “Analyzing Genre of Organizational Communication in Clinical Information Systems,” Information, Technology, and People (13:3), 2000, pp. 196–209.
Dwivedi, A., Bali, R. K., James, A. E., and Naguib, R. N. G. “Telehealth Systems: Considering Knowledge Management and ICT Issues,” in Proceedings of the 23 rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE, Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, 2001, pp. 25–28.
Ford, J. D., and Ford, L. W. “Logics of Identity, Contradiction, and Attraction in Change,” The Academy of Management Review (19:4), 1994, pp. 756–785.
Hamel, G., and Valikangas, L. “The Quest for Resilience,” Harvard Business Review (81:9), 2003, pp.52–63.
Hornby, A. S. Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary of Current English, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 1988.
Horne III, J. F. “The Coming Age of Organizational Resilience,” Business Forum (22:2/3/4), 1997, pp. 24–28.
Horne III, J. F., and Orr, J. E. “Assessing Behaviors That Create Resilient Organizations,” Employment Relations Today (24:4), 1998, pp. 29–39.
Israel, J. The Language of Dialectics and the Dialectics of Language, Copenhagen: Munksgaard, 1979.
Klein, K. J., Dansereau, F., and Hall, R. J. “Levels Issues in Theory Development, Data Collection, and Analysis,” Academy of Management Review (19:2), 1994, pp. 195–229.
Lorenzi, N. M., and Riley, R. T. “Organizational ISSUES=change,” International Journal of Medical Informatics (69:2–3), 2003, pp. 197–203.
Maheu, M. M., Whitten, P., and Allen, A. E-Health, Telehealth, and Telemedicine: A Guide to Start-up and Success, San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2001.
Mallak, L. “Putting Organizational Resilience to Work,” Industrial Management (40:6), 1998, pp. 8–13.
Mathiassen, L. “Reflective Systems Development,” Scandinavian Journal of Information Systems (10:1&2), 1998, pp. 67–118.
Mathiassen, L., and Nielsen, P. A. “Soft Systems and Hard Contradictions: Approaching the Reality of Information Systems in Organizations,” Journal of Applied Systems Analysis, (16), 1989.
Moore, G. A. “Darwin and the Demon: Innovating Within Established Enterprises,” Harvard Business Review (82:7&8), 2004, pp. 86–92
Moore, G. A. Inside the Tornado: Marketing Strategies from Silicon Valley’s Cutting Edge, New York: HarperBusiness, 1999.
Raghupathi, W. “Health Care Information Systems,” Communications of the ACM (40:8), 1997, pp. 80–82.
Reinmoeller, P., and van Baardwijk, N. “The Link Between Diversity and Resilience,” MIT Sloan Management Review (46:4), Summer 2005, pp. 61–65.
Riolli, L., and Savicki, V. “Information System Organizational Resilience,” Omega: The International Journal of Management Science (31:3), 2003, pp. 227–233.
Robey, D., and Boudreau, M.-C. “Accounting for the Contradictory Organizational Consequences of Information Technology: Theoretical Directions and Methodological Implications,” Information Systems Research (10:2), 1999, pp. 167–185.
Robey, D., and Holmstrom, J. “Transforming Municipal Governance in Global Context: A Case Study of the Dialectics of Social Change,” Journal of Global Information Technology Management (4:4), 2001, pp. 19–31.
Robey, D., Ross, J. W., and Boudreau, M.-C. “Learning to Implement Enterprise Systems: An Exploratory Study of the Dialectics of Change,” Journal of Management Information Systems (19:1), 2002, pp. 17–46.
Robey, D., and Sahay, S. “Transforming Work Through Information Technology: A Comparative Case Study of Georgraphic Information Systems in County Government,” Information Systems Research (7:1), 1996, pp. 93–110.
Rond, M. D., and Bouchikhi, H. “On the Dialectics of Strategic Alliances,” Organization Science (15:1), 2004, pp. 56–69.
Sabherwal, R., and Newman, M. “Persistence and Change in System Development: A Dialectical View,” Journal of Information Technology (18:2), 2003, pp. 69–92.
Starr, R., Newfrock, J., and Delurey, M. “Enterprise Resilience: Managing Risk in the Networked Economy,” strategy+ business, Spring 2003, pp. 1–10.
Tanriverdi, H., and Iacono, C. S. “Knowledge Barriers to Diffusion of Telemedicine,” in Proceedings of the 19 th International Conference on Information Systems, R. Hirschheim, M. Newman, and J. I. DeGross (eds.), Helsinki, Finland, 1998, pp. 39–50.
Van de Ven, A. H., and Poole, M. S. “Explaining Development and Change in Organizations,” Academy of Management Review (20:3), 1995, pp. 510–540.
Walsham, G. “Interpretive Case Study in IS Research. Nature and Method,” European Journal of Information Systems (4), 1995, pp. 74–81.
Weick, K. E. “The Collapse of Sensemaking in Organizations: The Mann Gulch Disaster,” Administrative Science Quarterly (38:4), 1993, pp. 628–652.
Yin, R. K. Case Study Research Design and Methods (3rd ed.), Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc., 2003.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2006 International Federation for Information Processing
About this paper
Cite this paper
Cho, S., Mathiassen, L., Robey, D. (2006). The Dialectics of Resilience: A Multilevel Analysis of a Telehealth Innovation. In: Donnellan, B., Larsen, T.J., Levine, L., DeGross, J.I. (eds) The Transfer and Diffusion of Information Technology for Organizational Resilience. TDIT 2006. IFIP International Federation for Information Processing, vol 206. Springer, Boston, MA. https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-34410-1_22
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-34410-1_22
Publisher Name: Springer, Boston, MA
Print ISBN: 978-0-387-34409-6
Online ISBN: 978-0-387-34410-2
eBook Packages: Computer ScienceComputer Science (R0)