Abstract
The myth of the First Great Debate dominates the historiography of International Relations (IR). It maintains that realism evolved immediately before, during, and after the Second World War a s the critique of idealism, which it blamed for underestimating the analytical relevance of power in international relations as well as the importance of the international system’s anarchic structure. According to this myth, in other words, there is no continuity between idealism—sometimes called liberalism—and realism. The evolution of realism is cut off from ideological and cultural contexts and located in an apolitical, scientific, analytically focused realm. Since the 1990s and the “historiographical turn” in IR, a revisionist literature has questioned this disciplinary myth and the corresponding characterization of the origins of realism in the field (Bell 2001). But this revisionism has arguably only gone so far. There remains broad agreement that IR realism, as a self-conscious tradition, is of Anglophone origin, but gained wide support after the Second World War as a “discourse of disillusionment,” informed by German political theory and motivated by the attempt to understand the horror of German totalitarianism (Ashworth 2011; Bell 2010; Hobson 2012; Sylvest 2008).1
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
Bibliography
Akehurst, T. L. (2008) “The Nazi Tradition: The Analytic Critique of Continental Philosophy in Mid-Century Britain,” History of European Ideas 34: 548–555.
Angell, Norman (1903) Patriotism under Three Flags: A Plea for Rationalisation in Politics, London: T. F. Unwin.
Angell, Norman (1914) Prussianism and Its Destruction, London: William Heinemann.
Angell, Norman (1915) Wird der Krieg deutschen Militarismus ein Ende machen? Zürich: Verlag von Rascher & Cie.
Angell, Norman (1933) “The International Anarchy,” in Leonard Woolf, ed., The Intelligent Man’s Way to Prevent War, London: Victor Gollancz, 19–66.
Anonymous (1916) “The European Anarchy,” The North American Review 204: 149–150
Ashworth, Lucian M. (2011) “Realism and the Spirit of 1919: Halford Mackinder, Geopolitics and the Reality of the League of Nations.” European Journal of International Relations 17: 279–301.
Bell, Duncan (2001) “International Relations: the Dawn of a Historiographical Turn?” The British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 3(1), 115–126.
Bell, Duncan (2010) “Introduction: Under an Empty Sky — Realism and Political Theory,” Duncan Bell (ed) Political Thought and International Relations: Variations on a Realist Theme. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1–25.
Carr, Edward. H. (1939.) Propaganda in International Politics, Oxford: Oxford Clarendon Press.
Carr, Edward H. (2001 [1939]). The Twenty Years’ Crisis, 1919–1939. An Introduction to the Study of International Relations, Houndmills: Palgrave.
Carr, Edward H. (1942) Conditions of Peace, London: Macmillan.
Carr, Edward H. (1945) Nationalism and After, London: Macmillan.
Carr, Edward H. (1946) The Soviet Impact on the Western World, London: Macmillan.
Ceadel, Martin (2009), Living the Great Illusion: Sir Norman Angell, 1872–1967, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Clarke, Peter (1981) Liberals and Social Democrats, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dickinson, Goldsworthy Lowes (1916) The European Anarchy, London: George Allen & Unwin.
Frei, Christoph (2001) Hans J. Morgenthau: An Intellectual Biography, Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press.
Guilhot, Nicolas, ed. (2011) The Invention of International Relations Theory: Realism, the Rockefeller Foundation, and the 1954 Conference on Theory, New York: Columbia University Press.
Hall, Ian (2006a) “Power Politics and Appeasement: Political Realism in British International Thought, 1935–1955,” British Journal of Politics and International Relations 8: 174–192.
Hall, Ian (2006b) The International Thought of Martin Wight, New York: Palgrave.
Hall, Ian (2007) “‘A Shallow Piece of Naughtiness’: George Orwell on Political Realism,” Millennium: Journal of International Studies 36(2): 191–215.
Hall, Ian (2012) Dilemmas of Decline: British Intellectuals and World Politics, 1945–1975, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Hall, Ian (2014) “Martin Wight, the Western Tradition and the Whig Tradition of International Thought,” International History Review 36(5): 961–981.
Hayek, Friedrich (1944) The Road to Serfdom, Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Hayek, Friedrich (1945) Der Weg zur Knechtschaft, Eisenbach-Zürich: Eugen Rentsch Verlag.
Hintze, Otto (1928) “The International Anarchy, 1904–1914,” Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv 27: 143–145.
Hobhouse, Leonard T. (1901) Mind in Evolution, London: Macmillan.
Hobhouse, Leonard T. (1915) The World in Conflict, London: T. Fisher Unwin.
Hobhouse, Leonard T. (1916) Questions of War and Peace, London: T. Fisher Unwin.
Hobhouse, Leonard T. (1972) [1904] Democracy and Reaction, Brighton: The Harvester Press.
Hobhouse, Leonard T. (1996) “The Past and the Future. The Influence of Nationalism,” in John A. Hobson and M. Ginsberg (eds.), L. T. Hobhouse: His Life and Work, London: Routledge/Thoemmes Press, 325–330.
Hobson, John A. (1917) Democracy after the War, London: George Allen & Unwin.
Hobson, John M. (2012) The Eurocentric Conception of World Politics: Western International Theory, 1760–2010, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hoeres, Peter (2003) “Die Ursachen der deutschen Gewaltpolitik in britischer Sicht. Eine frühe Sonderwegsdebatte,” in Frank Becker TGb, Armin Owzar and Rudolf Schlögl, ed., Politische Gewalt in der Moderne: Festschrift für Hans-Ulrich Thamer. Muenster: Aschendorff Verlag, 193–211.
Holthaus, Leonie (2014) “L. T. Hobhouse and the Transformation of Liberal Internationalism,” Review of International Studies 40(4): 705–727.
Jones, Charles (1994) “E. H. Carr Through Cold War Lenses: Nationalism, Large States and the Shaping of Opinion,” in Andrea Bosco and Cornelia Navari, eds., Chatham House and British Foreign Policy 1919–1945. The Royal Institute of International Affairs During the Inter-War Period, London: Lothian Foundation Press, 163–186.
Jones, Charles (1998) E.H. Carr and International Relations: A Duty to Lie, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kennedy, Paul M. (1980) The Rise of Anglo-German Antagonism 1860–1914, London: George Allen & Unwin.
Koskenniemi, Martti (2002) The Gentle Civilizer of Nations: The Rise and Fall of International Law 1870–1960, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lebow, Richard Ned (2003) The Tragic Vision of Politics: Ethics, Interests, and Orders, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lebow, Richard Ned (2008) A Cultural Theory of International Relations, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Lebow, Richard Ned (2011) “German Jews and American Realism,” Constellations 18: 545–566.
Long, David and Brian C. Schmidt (2005) Imperialism and Internationalism in the Discipline of International Relations, Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
Morefield, Jeanne (2009) Covenants without Swords: Idealist Liberalism and the Spirit of Empire, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Morefield, Jeanne (2013) “A Democratic Critique of the State: G. Lowes Dickinson’s The European Anarchy,” in Henrik Bliddal CS and Peter Wilson (ed) Classics in International Relations: Essays in Criticism and Appreciation, London Routledge, 24–35.
Mirowski, Phillip, 2011. “Realism and Neoliberalism: From Reactionary Modernism to Postwar Conservatism,” in Nicolas Guilhot, ed., The Invention of International Relations Theory. Realism, the Rockefeller Foundation, and the 1954 Conference on Theory, New York: Columbia University Press, 210–238.
Morgenthau, Hans J. (1948) “The Political Science of E. H. Carr,” World Politics 1: 127–134.
Morgenthau, Hans J. (1965 [1946]) Scientific Man Versus Power Politics, Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Navari, Cornelia (1989) “The Great Illusion Revisited: The International Theory of Norman Angell,” Review of International Studies 15(4), 341–358.
Osiander, Andreas (1998) “Rereading Early Twentieth-Century IR Theory: Idealism Revisited,” International Studies Quarterly, 42(3), 409–432.
Parry, John (2006) The Politics of Patriotism. English Liberalism, National Identity and Europe, 1830–1886, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Royal Institute of International Affairs (1937a) “Summary Report of the Seventh Meeting of the Group, Held at Chatham House on Monday, April 12th, 1937.” RIIA Archives, London.
Royal Institute of International Affairs (1937b) “Summary Report of the Sixth Meeting of the Group, held at Chatham House on Monday, March 15th, 1937,” RIIA Archives, London.
Rusk, W. S. (1917) Review of Goldsworthy Lowes Dickinson, The European Anarchy, The Sewanee Review 25(1).
Sylvest, Casper (2008) “John H. Herz and the Resurrection of Classical Realism,” International Relations 22: 441–455.
Sylvest, Casper (2010) “British Liberal Historians and the Primacy of Internationalism,” in W. Mulligan and Brendan Simms (eds.) The Primacy of Foreign Policy in British History, 1660–2000: How Strategic Concerns Shaped Modern Britain, London: Palgrave Macmillan, 214–231.
Webster’s (1990) Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary, Springfield: Merriam-Webster.
Wight, Martin (1946) Power Politics, Looking Forward pamphlet 8, London: Royal Institute of International Affairs.
Wight, Martin (1952) “Germany,” in Arnold J. Toynbee and F. T. Ashton-Gwatkin, eds, Survey of International Affairs: The World in March1939, London: Oxford University Press, 293–365.
Wilson, Peter (1998) “The myth of the ‘First Great Debate’,” Review of International Studies 24: 1–15.
Woolf, Leonard (1933) “Introduction,” in Leonard Woolf, ed, The Intelligent Men’s Way to Prevent War, London: Victor Gollancz, 7–18.
Woolf, Leonard (1940) “Utopia and Reality,” Political Quarterly 11: 167–182,
Zimmern, Alfred E. (1918) Nationality and Government With Other War-Time Essays, London: Chatto & Windus.
Zimmern, Alfred E. (1939) “A Realist in Search of a Utopia,” The Spectator. November 24, 1939, 750.
Editor information
Copyright information
© 2015 Ian Hall
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Holthaus, L. (2015). Prussianism, Hitlerism, Realism: The German Legacy in British International Thought. In: Hall, I. (eds) Radicals and Reactionaries in Twentieth-Century International Thought. Palgrave Macmillan History of International Thought. Palgrave Macmillan, New York. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137520623_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137520623_6
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, New York
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-68597-4
Online ISBN: 978-1-137-52062-3
eBook Packages: Palgrave Political Science CollectionPolitical Science and International Studies (R0)