Abstract
Games of chance provide the paradigmatic cases of ‘soft’1 uncertainty to which traditional decision theories naturally apply; environmental economics provides many paradigmatic cases of ‘hard’ uncertainty which cannot be properly analyzed under the present state of the art. This restricts the application of traditional decision theory to `soft’ risks which may be covered by traditional market instruments, such as commercial insurance and financial securities. These limits are fully admitted by frequentist (or objectivist) decision theories. On the contrary, Bayesian theory claims to be applicable to any kind of uncertainty. Unfortunately, as is argued in this paper, this is not the case. Even classic Bayesian theory is not really applicable to ‘hard’ risks such as those involved in many important environmental problems. This does not imply that hard uncertainty cannot be analyzed in scientific terms. Recent advances in decision theory have suggested various promising approaches to the analysis of hard uncertainty, which — to the best of my knowledge — have not yet been applied in environmental economics. This paper aims to survey the relevant literature on the subject and to draw some implications for environmental risk control.
A preliminary and shorter draft of this paper has been published in (Vercelli, 1995).
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allais, M. (1953). “Le comportement de l’homme rationnel devant le risque: Critique des postulats et axiomes de l’école americaine”, Econometrica 21, 503–546.
Anscombe, F. J. and R. Aumann (1963). “A Definition of Subjective Probability”, Annals of Mathematical Statistics 34, 199–205.
Arrow, K. (1970). Essays in the Theory of Risk Bearing,Amsterdam, North-Holland.
Arrow, K. J. and L. Hurwicz (1972). “Optimality Criterion for Decision-Making under Ignorance”, in Uncertainty and Expectations in Economics,C. F. Carter and J. L. Ford (eds.), Oxford, Basil Blackwell, pp. 1–11.
Barret, C. R. and P. K. Pattanaik (1986). “Decision Making under Complete Uncertainty: The Ordinal Framework”, in Uncertainty in Economic Life, S. Sen (ed.), Elgar, Aldershot, U.K.
Basili, M. and A. Vercelli (1994). “Option Value and Environment: A Survey”, Working Paper F.E.E.M., Milano.
Basili, M. and A. Vercelli (1997). “Environmental Option Values: Uncertainty Aversion and Learning”, this volume.
Baumol, W. J. and W. E. Oates (1988). The Theory of Environmental Policy, Second Edition, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Bell, D. E., H. Raiffa and A. Tversky (eds.) (1988). Decision Making: Descriptive, Normative and Prescriptive Interactions, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Beltratti, A., G. Chichilnisky and G. Heal (1992). “Option and Non-Use Values of Environmental Assets”, manuscript.
Bewley, T. F. (1986). “Knightian Decision Theory: Part I”, Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper No. 807, New Haven, CT.
Billot, A. (1992). “From Fuzzy Set Theory to Non-Additive Probabilities: How Have Economists Reacted?”, Fuzzy Sets and Systems 49, 75–90.
Binmore, K. G. (1986). “Remodeled Rational Players”, Discussion Paper, London School of Economics, London.
Bohm, P. (1981). Deposit-Refund Systems: Theory and Applications to Environmental, Conservation, and Consumer Policy“, Washington, DC, Johns Hopkins University Press for Resources for the Future.
Camerer, C. and M. Weber (1992). “Recent Developments in Modeling Preferences: Uncertainty and Ambiguity”, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 5, 325–370.
Chateauneuf, A. and J. Y. Jaffray (1989). “Some Characterizations of Lower Probabilities and Other Monotone Capacities through the Use of Möbius Inversion”, Math. Social Sciences 17, 263–283.
Chateauneuf, A., R. Kast and A. Lapied (1992a). “Choquet Pricing for Financial Markets with Frictions”, mimeo.
Chateauneuf, A., R. Kast and A. Lapied (1992b). “Pricing in Slack Markets”, Document de Travail GREQE, No. 92A05.
Chichilnisky, G. (1992). “Layers of Uncertainty and Price Risks”, Discussion Paper, Columbia University, forthcoming in Market Risks, Springer-Verlag.
Chichilnisky, G. and G. Heal (1992). “Financial Markets for Unknown Risks”, Chapter 3.5 of this book.
Chichilnisky, G., J. Dutta and G. M. Heal (1992). “Price Uncertainty and Derivative Securities in a General Equilibrium Model”, manuscript, forthcoming in Market Risks,Springer-Verlag.
Chichilnisky, G. (1996). “Markets with Endogenous Uncertainty; Theory and Policy”. Theory and Decision 41, 99–131.
Chichilnisky, G. and G. M. Heal (1997). “Managing Unknown Risks: The Future of Global Reinsurance”. Journal of Portfolio Management Spring 1998.
Choquet, G. (1955). “Theory of Capacities”, Annales Institut Fourier 5, 131–295.
Costanza, R. (1991). “Assuring Sustainability of Ecological Economic Systems”, in Ecological Economics, R. Costanza (ed.), New York, Columbia University Press.
Costanza, R. and C. Perrings (1990). “A Flexible Assurance Bonding System for Improved Environmental Management”, Ecological Economics 3, 231–245.
Cropper, M. L. and W. E. Oates (1992). `Environmental Economics: A Survey“, Journal of Economic Literature 30(2), 675–740.
De Finetti, B. (1937). “La Prévision: Ses Lois Logiques, Ses Sources Subjectives”, Annales de l’Institute Henry Poincaré 7, 1–68. English translation: “Foresight: Its Logical Laws, Its Subjective Sources”, in Studies in Subjective Probability H. E. Kyburg and H. E. Smokier (eds.), New York, Wiley and Sons, 1964, pp. 93–158.
De Finetti, B. and F. Emanuelli (1967). Economia delle Assicurazioni, Torino, Utet.
Dempster, A. P. (1967). “Upper and Lower Probabilities Induced by a Multivalued Mapping”, Ann. Math. Statist. 38, 325–339.
Diaconis, P. and D. Freedman (1986). “On the Consistency of Bayes Estimates”, The Annals of Statistics 14(1), 1–26.
Dow, J. and S. R. C. Werlang (1992a). “Excess Volatility of Stock Prices and Knightian Uncertainty”, European Economic Review 36, 631–638.
Dow, J. and S. R. C. Werlang (1992b). “Uncertainty Aversion, Risk Aversion, and the Optimal Choice of Portfolio”, Econometrica 60, 197–204.
Dow, J. and S. R. C. Werlang (1992c). “The Ex-Ante Non-Optimality of the Dempster-Shafer Rule for Ambiguous Beliefs”, EPGE-Fundacao Getulio Vagas, Working Paper No. 185.
Dubois, D. (1980). “Un économiste précurseur de la théorie des possibilités: G. L. S. Shackle”, BUSEFAL 2, 70–73.
Ellsberg, D. (1961). “Risk, Ambiguity, and the Savage Axioms”, Quarterly Journal of Economics 75, 643–669.
Epstein, L. and M. Le Breton (1993). “Dynamically Consistent Beliefs Must Be Bayesian”, Journal of Economic Theory 61, 1–22.
Farber, S. (1991). “Regulatory Schemes and Self-Protective Environmental Risk Control: A Comparison of Insurance Liability and Deposit-Refund Systems”, Ecological Economics 3, 231–245.
Feynman, R. P. (ed.) (1963). The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. 1, pp. 643–669.
Fishburn, P. C. (1984). “Comment on the Kannai-Peleg Impossibility Theorem for Extending Orders”, Journal of Economic Theory 32, 176–179.
Fishburn, P. C. (1988). Nonlinar Preferences and Utility Theory, Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press.
Freedman, D. A. and R. A. Purves (1969). “Bayes’ Method for Bookies”, Annals of Mathematical Statistics 40, 1177–1186.
Gärdenfors, P. and N.-E. Sahlin (1982). “Unreliable Probabilities, Risk Taking, and Decision Making”, Synthèse 53, 361–386.
Ghirardato, P. (1994). “Coping with Ignorance: Unforeseen Contingencies and Non-Additive Uncertainty”, Discussion Paper, Department of Economics, Berkeley.
Gilboa, I. (1987). “Expected Utility with Purely Subjective Non-Additive Probabilities”, Journal of Mathematical Economics 16(1), 65–88.
Gilboa, I. (1989). “Additivizations of Nonadditive Measures”, Mathematics of Operation Research 4, 1–17.
Gilboa, I. and D. Schmeidler (1989). “Maximin Expected Utility with a Non-Unique Prior”, Journal of Mathematical Economics 18, 141–153.
Gilboa, I. and D. Schmeidler (1993). “Updating Ambiguous Beliefs”, Journal of Economic Theory 59, 33–49.
Gilboa, I. and D. Schmeidler (1994). “Case-Based Decision Theory”, mimeo.
Hahn, F. (1992). “A Remark on Incomplete Market Equilibrium’, Working Paper.
Hart, A. G. (1942). “Risk, Uncertainty, and the Unprofitability of Compounding Probabilities”, in Studies in Mathematical Economics and Econometrics, O. Lange, F. McIntyre and T. O. Yntema (eds.), Chicago, Chicago University Press.
Heal, G. (1991). “Risk Management and Global Change”, Paper presented at the First Nordic Conference on the Greenhouse Effect in Copenhagen, September, 1991.
Jones, R. and J. Ostroy (1984). “Flexibility and Uncertainty”, Review of Economic Studies 51, 13–32.
Kelsey, D. and J. Quiggin (1992). “Theories of Choice under Ignorance and Uncertainty”, Journal of Economic Surveys 6(2), 133–153.
Keynes, J.M. (1921). A Treatise on Probability,London, Macmillan.
Knight, F. (1921). Risk,Uncertainty and Profit, New York, Houghton Mifflin.
Kreps, D. M. (1988). Notes on the Theory of Choice, Boulder, CO, Westview Press.
Kreps, D. M. (1992). “Static Choice in the Presence of Unforeseen Contingencies”, in Economic Analysis of Markets and Games, P. Dasgupta, D. Gale, O. Hart and E. Maskin (eds.), Cambridge, MA, MIT Press, pp. 258–281.
Kurz, M. (1974). “The Kesten-Stigum Model and the Treatment of Uncertainty in Equilibrium Theory”, in Essays in Economic Behaviour Under Uncertainty, M. C. Balch, D. M. McFadden and S. Wu (eds.), Amsterdam, North-Holland.
Kurz, M. (1991a). “On Rational Belief Equilibria”, Discussion Paper, Stanford University, CA.
Kurz, M. (199lb). “On the Structure and Diversity of Rational Beliefs”, Discussion Paper, Stanford University, CA.
Kurz, M. (1993). “Rational Preferences and Rational Beliefs”, manuscript.
Kyburg, H. E., Jr. and H. E. Smokier (eds.) (1964). Studies in Subjective Probability, New York, Wiley and Sons.
Lucas, R. E. (1986). `Adaptive Behavior and Economic Theory“, Journal of Business 59 (Supplement), 5401–5426.
Luce, R. D. and H. Raiffa (1957). Games and Decisions. Introduction and Critical Survey, London, Wiley.
Machina, M. J. (1982). “`Expected Utility’ Analysis without the Independence Axiom”, Econometrica 50(2), 277–323.
Machina, M. J. (1987). “Choice under Uncertainty: Problems Solved and Unsolved, Economic Perspectives 1, 121–154.
Machina, M. J. and D. Schmeidler (1992). “A More Robust Definition of Subjective Probability”, Econometrica 60(4), 745–780.
Modica, A. and A. Rustichini (1994). `Awareness and Partitional Information Structures“, Theory and Decision 37, 107–124.
Montesano, A. (1991). “Measures of Risk Aversion with Expected and Nonexpected Utility”, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 4, 271–283.
Montesano, A. (1993). “Non-Additive Probabilities and the Measure of Uncertainty and Risk Aversion”, mimeo.
Morgenstern, O. and J. von Neumann (1944). Theory of Games and Economic Behaviour, Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press.
Perrings, C. (1987). Economy and Environment,Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Perrings, C. (1989). “Environmental Bonds and Environmental Research in Innovative Activity”, Ecological Economics 1, 95–110.
Quiggin, J. (1982). “A Theory of Anticipated Utility”, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 3(4), 323–343.
Ramsey, F. P. (1988). “Truth and Probability”, in Decision, Probability and Utility: Selected Readings, P. Gärdenfors and N.-E. Sahlin (eds.), Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 19–47.
Runde, J. (1994). “Keynes after Ramsay: In Defense of A Treatise on Probability”, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 25(1), 97–121.
Runde, J. (1996). “Chances and Choices. Notes on Probability and Belief in Economic Theory”, in The Metaphysics of Economics, U. Maki (ed.), Cambridge, Cambridge University Press (forthcoming).
Sarin, R. and P. Wakker (1992). `A Simple Axiomatization of Nonadditive Expected Utility“, Econometrica 60, 1255–1272.
Savage, L. J. (1954). The Foundations of Statistics, New York, John Wiley and Sons. Revised and enlarged edition, Dover, New York, 1972.
Schmeidler, D. (1982). “Subjective Probability without Additivity”, Working Paper, Foerder Institute for Economic Research, Tel Aviv University.
Schmeidler, D. (1986). “Integral Representation without Additivity”, Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society 97(2), 255–261.
Schmeidler, D. (1989). “Subjective Probability and Expected Utility without Additivity”, Econometrica 57,571–587.
Segal, U. (1987). “The Ellsberg Paradox and Risk Aversion: An Anticipated Utility Approach”, International Economic Review 28(1), 175–202.
Segerson, K. (1990). “`Institutional Markets’: The Role of Liability in Allocating Environmental Resources”, in Proceedings of the AERE Workshop on Natural Resource Market Mechanisms, Association of Environmental and Resource Economists.
Shackle, G. L. S. (1952). Expectations in Economics, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Shafer, G. (1976). A Mathematical Theory of Evidence, Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press.
Shafer, G. (1978). “Non-Additive Probabilities in the Works of Bernoulli and Lambert”, Arch. Hist. Exact. Sci. 19, 309–370.
Shafer, G. (1988). “Savage Revisited”, in Decision Making: Descriptive, Normative and Prescriptive Interactions, D. F. Bell, H. Raiffa and A. Tversky (eds.), Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 193–234.
Smets, P. (1990). “The Combination of Evidence in the Transferable Belief Model”, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 12,447–458.
Tietenberg, T. H. (1985). Emissions Trading: An Exercise in Reforming Pollution Policy, Washington DC, Resources for the Future.
Torsello, L. and A. Vercelli (1993). “The Environmental Bonds: A Critical Assessment”, Working Paper F.E.E.M., Milano.
Vercelli, A. (1991). Methodological Foundations of Macroeconomics. Keynes and Lucas, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Vercelli, A. (1995). “From Soft Uncertainty to Hard Environmental Uncertainty”, Economie Appliquée 48, 251–269.
Vercelli, A. (1996). “Uncertainty, Rationality and Learning: A Keynesian Perspective”, mimeo.
Wakker, P. (1990). `A Behavioural Foundation for Fuzzy Measures“, Fuzzy Sets and Systems 37, 327–350.
Weitzman, M. (1974). “Prices vs Quantities”, Review of Economic Studies 41(4), 477491.s
Yaari, M. (1987). “The Dual Theory of Choice under Risk”, Econometrica 55(1), 95115.
Zadeh, L. A. (1965). “Fuzzy Sets”, Information and Control 8, 338–353.
Zadeh, L.A. (1978). “Fuzzy Sets as a Basis for a Theory of Possibility”, Fuzzy Sets and Systems 1, 3–28.
Editor information
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1998 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Vercelli, A. (1998). Hard Uncertainty and Environmental Policy. In: Chichilnisky, G., Heal, G., Vercelli, A. (eds) Sustainability: Dynamics and Uncertainty. Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei (FEEM) Series on Economics, Energy and Environment, vol 9. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-4892-4_10
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-4892-4_10
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-010-6051-6
Online ISBN: 978-94-011-4892-4
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive