Abstract
A question-answering program providing access to a large amount of data will be most useful if it can tailor its answers to each individual user. In particular, a user’s level of knowledge about the domain of discourse is an important factor in this tailoring if the answer provided is to be both informative and understandable to the user. In this research, we address the issue of how the user’s domain knowledge can affect an answer. By studying texts, we found that the user’s level of domain knowledge affected the kind of information provided and not just the amount of information, as was previously assumed. Depending on the user’s assumed domain knowledge, a description can be either parts-oriented or process-oriented. Thus the user’s level of expertise in a domain can guide a system in choosing the appropriate facts from the knowledge base to include in an answer. We propose two distinct descriptive strategies that can be used in a question-answering program, and show how they can be mixed to include the appropriate information from the knowledge base, given the user’s domain knowledge. We have implemented these strategies in TAILOR, a computer system that generates descriptions of devices. TAILOR uses one of the two discourse strategies identified in texts to construct a description for either a novice or an expert. It can merge the strategies automatically to produce a wide range of different descriptions to users who fall between the extremes of novice or expert, without requiring an a priori set of user stereotypes.
This research was supported in part by the Defence Advanced Research Projects Agency under contract N00039-84-C-0165, and the National Science Foundation grant ISI-84-51438.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, R. C., R. J. Spiro and M. C. Anderson (1977): Schemata as Scaffolding for the Representation of Information in Connected Discourse. Technical Report 24, Center for the Study of Reading, Urbana, IL. [PARI*: 212]
Appelt, D. E. (1982): Planning Natural-Language Utterances. In: Proc. AAAI82, 59–62. [PARI*: 201]
Appelt, D. E. (1985): Planning English Sentences. Cambridge etc.: Cambridge Univ. Press. [WAHL*: 5, 16, 19; KOBS*: 53, 58ff., 62f.; PARI*: 201, 203]
Baker, D. L., R. B. Brownlee and R. W. Fuller (1957): Elements of Physics. Newton, MA: Allyn and Bacon. [PARI*: 205]
Britannica Junior Encyclopedia. Chicago: Encyclopedia Britannica Inc., 1963. [PARI*: 201, 205, 209]
The New Encyclopedia Britannica. Chicago: Encyclopedia Britannica Inc., 1984. [PARI*: 201, 205]
Carberry, S. (1983): Tracking User Goals in an Information-Seeking Environment. In: Proc. AAAI-83, 59–63. [WAHL*: 12; KOBS*: 59f.; CHIN*: 78; GARB*: 155; PARI*: 201, 203; FINI*: 413f.]
Carberry, S. (1988): Modeling the User’s Plans and Goals. In: Computational Linguistics 14(3), Special Issue on User Modeling (A. Kobsa and W. Wahlster, eds.), 23–37. [PARI*: 201; CARB*: 133; FINI*: 414]
Carberry, S.: Plan Recognition and its Use in Understanding Dialog. In this volume. [WAHL*: 12; RICH*: 39; KOBS*: 59; CHIN*: 78; QUIL*: 129; PARI*: 201; MCCO*: 251; JAME*: 256, 260, 278f.; SPAR*: 361f.; MORI*: 375f.; FINI*: 414]
Chevrolet Service Manual. Detroit, MI: General Motors Corporation, 1987. [PARI*: 201, 205]
Chi, M. T. H., R. Glaser and E. Rees (1981): Expertise in Problem Solving. In: R. J. Sternberg, ed.: Advances in the Psychology of Human Intelligence. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. [PARI*: 211]
Chin, D. N. (1986): User Modelling in UC, the UNIX Consultant. In: Proc. of the CHI’86, Boston, MA, 24–28. [KOBS*: 57, 65; CHIN*: 74; PARI*: 202, 229; COHE*: 325, 330; FINI*: 414]
Cohen, R. and M. Jones: Incorporating User Models into Expert Systems for Educational Diagnosis. In this volume. [WAHL*: 19; CARB*: 161; PARI*: 231; MCCO*: 250; SPAR*: 362]
Collier’s Encyclopedia. New York: Crowell-Collier, 1962. [PARI*: 201, 205, 207]
Davison, A. (1984): Readibility Formulas and Comprehension. Comprehension Instruction, Perspectives and Suggestions. New York etc.: Longman. [PARI*: 201]
The New Encyclopedia of Science. Milwaukee, WI: Raintree Publishers, 1982. [PARI*: 201, 205]
Grice, H. P. (1975): Logic and Conversation. In: P. Cole and J. L. Morgan, eds.: Syntax and Semantics 3: Speech Acts. New York: Academic Press. [CARB*: 146, 156; PARI*: 201, 212; JAME*: 261, 272, 301; COHE*: 321]
Grimes, J. E. (1975): The Thread of Discourse. The Hague, The Netherlands: Mouton. [PARI*: 206]
Hobbs, J. (1978): Coherence and Coreference. Technical Note 168, SRI International, Menlo Park, CA. [PARI*: 206]
Hobbs, J. (1978): Why is a Discourse Coherent? Technical Report 176, SRI International, Menlo Park, CA. [PARI*: 206]
Hobbs, J. and D. Evans (1980): Conversation as Planned Behavior. Cognitive Science 4, 349–377. [PARI*: 206]
Hoeppner, W., K. Morik and H. Marburger (1984): Talking it Over: The Natural Language Dialog System HAM-ANS. Technical Report ANS-26, Research Unit for Information Science and Artificial Intelligence, Univ. of Hamburg, Fed. Rep. of Germany. [CHIN*: 78; PARI*: 202]
Kaplan, S. J. (1982): Cooperative Responses from a Portable Natural Language Query System. Artificial Intelligence 19, 165–188. [WAHL*: 19, 26; PARI*: 201; FINI*: 416]
Kay, M. (1979): Functional Grammar. In: Proc. of the 5th Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, Berkeley, CA, 142–158. [PARI*: 223]
Lancaster, J. S. and J. L. Kolodner (1987): Problem Solving in a Natural Task as a Function of Experience. Technical Report, School of Information and Computer Science, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA. [PARI*: 211]
Lebowitz, M. (1983): RESEARCHER: An Overview. In: Proc. AAAI-83, 232–235. [PARI*:202]
Lebowitz, M. (1985): RESEARCHER: An Experimental Intelligent Information System. In: Proc. IJCAI-85, 858–862. [PARI*: 202]
Lebowitz, M. (1986): An Experiment in Intelligent Information Systems: RESEARCHER. In: R. Davies, ed.: Intelligent Library and Information Systems. London: Ellis Horwood. [PARI*: 202]
Lehnert, W. (1977): A Conceptual Theory of Question Answering. In: Proc. IJCAI-77, 158–164. [PARI*: 202]
Mann, W. C. (1984): Discourse Structure for Text Generation. Technical Report ISURR-84–127, Information Sciences Institute, Marina del Rey, CA. [PARI*: 206]
Mark, H. F., D. F. Othmer, C. G. Overberger and G. T. Seaborg, eds.; Executive Editor: M. Grayson; Associate Editor: D. Eckroth (1987): Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology. New York: John Wiley and Sons. [PARI*: 213]
McCoy, K. F. (1983): Correcting Misconceptions: What to Say When the User is Mistaken. In: Proc. of the CHI’83 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, Boston, MA, 197–201. [PARI*: 201]
McCoy, K. F. (1986): The ROMPER System: Responding to Object-Related Misconceptions Using Perspective. In: Proc. of the 24th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics, New York, NY, 97–105. [PARI*: 201f.; COHE*: 325, 330]
McCoy, K. F. (1988): Reasoning on a Dynamically Highlighted User Model to Respond to Misconceptions. In: Computational Linguistics 14(3), Special Issue on User Modeling (A. Kobsa and W. Wahlster, eds.), 52–63. [PARI*: 201f.; MCCO*: 233; SPAR*: 362]
McCoy, K. F.: Highlighting a User Model to Respond to Misconceptions. In this volume. [WAHL*: 7, 27; CHIN*: 101; QUIL*: 126; CARB*: 152, 161; PARI*: 201; JAME*: 260; MORI*: 375; FINI*: 416]
McKeown, K. R. (1985): Text Generation: Using Discourse Strategies and Focus Constraints to Generate Natural Language Text. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press. [PARI*: 202f., 206, 211, 223; JAME*: 279; COHE*: 325]
McKeown, K. R., M. Wish and K. Matthews (1985): Tailoring Explanations for the User. In: Proc. IJCAI-85, 794–798. [WAHL*: 12; PARI*: 201, 203; MCCO*: 251; FINI*: 415]
McKeown, K. R. and C. L. Paris (1987): Functional Unification Grammar Revisited. In: Proc. of the 25th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics, Stanford Univ., Stanford, CA, 97–103. [PARI*: 223]
The New Book of Knowledge: The Children’s Encyclopedia. New York: Grolier Inc., 1967. [PARI*: 201, 205]
Paris, C. L. (1984): Determining the Level of Expertise. In: Proc. of the 1st Annual Workshop on Theoretical Issues in Conceptual Information Processing, Atlanta, GA, 128–135. [PARI*: 212, 229]
Paris, C. L. (1985): Description Strategies for Naive and Expert Users. In: Proc. of the 23rd Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics, Chicago, IL, 238–246. [PARI*: 225; COHE*: 330]
Paris, C. L. and T. Kwee (1985): Guide to the Unification Process and its Implementation: Progress Report on Extending the Grammar Technical Report, Computer Science Dept., Columbia Univ., NY. [PARI*: 223]
Paris, C. L. (1987): The Use of Explicit User Models in Text Generation: Tailoring to a User’s Level of Expertise. Ph.D. Thesis, Dept. of Computer Science, Columbia Univ., NY. [PARI*: 211, 223f.]
Paris, C. L. and K. R. McKeown (1987): Discourse Strategies for Describing Complex Physical Objects. In: G. Kempen, ed.: Natural Language Generation: Recent Advances in Artificial Intelligence, Psychology and Linguistics. Dordrecht/Boston: Kluwer. [PARI*: 224]
Quilici, A., M. Dyer and M. Flowers (1988): Recognizing and Responding to Plan-Oriented Misconceptions. In: Computational Linguistics 14(3), Special Issue on User Modeling (A. Kobsa and W. Wahlster, eds.), 38–51. [QUEL*: 108; PARI*: 201]
Rich, E. (1979): User Modelling Via Stereotypes. Cognitive Science 3, 329–354. [WAHL*: 5, 11, 13f.; RICH*: 36; KOBS*: 53, 67; CHIN*: 78f., 83; PARI*: 201, 229; SPAR*: 342, 362; FINI*: 414ff.]
Rich, E.: Stereotypes and User Modeling. In this volume. [WAHL*: 13; CHIN*: 78f.; PARI*: 201; MCCO*: 235; JAME*: 256, 294; COHE*: 329; MORI*: 376; FINI*: 416, 422]
Sheperd, H. R. (1926): The Fine Art of Writing. New York: Macmillan. [PARI*: 206]
Sleeman, D. H. (1982): Inferring (Mal) Rules From Pupil’s Protocols. In: Proc. of the 6th European Conference on Artificial Intelligence, Orsay, France, 160–164. [PARI*: 211; MCCO*: 237]
Sleeman, D. H. (1985): UMFE: A User Modeling Front End Subsystem. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies 23, 71–88. [WAHL*: 15; RICH*: 36; KOBS*: 53, 56f.; PARI*: 229; SPAR*: 361; KASS*: 408; FINI*: 416]
Tennant, H. (1978): The Evaluation of Natural Language Question Answerers. Technical Report, Univ. of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, IL. [PARI*: 203]
Verwiebe, F. L., G. R. van Hooft and R. R. Suchy (1962): Physics: A Basic Science. Princeton, NJ: van Nostrand. [PARI*: 205]
Wallis, J. W. and E. H. Shortliffe (1982): Explanatory Power for Medical Expert Systems: Studies in the Representation of Causal Relationships for Clinical Consultation. Technical Report STAN-CS-82–923, Heuristic Programming Project, Dept. of Medicine and Computer Science, Stanford Univ., Stanford, CA. [PARI*: 201f., 211; COHE*: 329; FINI*: 415]
Wasserman, K. and M. Lebowitz (1983): Representing Complex Physical Ob- jects. Cognition and Brain Theory 6, 333–352. [PARI*: 222]
Wasserman, K. (1985): Unifying Representation and Generalization: Understanding Hierarchically Structured Objects. Ph.D. Thesis, Dept. of Computer Science, Columbia Univ., NY. [PARI*: 222]
Weissler, A. and P. Weissler (1973): A Woman’s Guide to Fixing the Car. New York: Walker and Company. [PARI*: 201, 205]
Wilson, P. T. and R. C. Anderson (1986): What They Don’t Know Will Hurt Them: The Role of Prior Knowledge in Comprehension. In: J. Orasanu, ed.: Reading Comprehension: From Research to Practice. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. [PARI*: 201, 212]
Woods, W. (1973): An Experimental Parsing System for Transition Network Grammars. In: R. Rustin, ed.: Natural Language Processing. New York: Algorithmics Press. [PARI*: 223]
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1989 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Paris, C.L. (1989). The Use of Explicit User Models in a Generation System for Tailoring Answers to the User’s Level of Expertise. In: Kobsa, A., Wahlster, W. (eds) User Models in Dialog Systems. Symbolic Computation. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-83230-7_8
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-83230-7_8
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-642-83232-1
Online ISBN: 978-3-642-83230-7
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive