Abstract
In this article we present an overview of legal ontological modeling over a period of more than a decade. Most of the research reported concerns results from mid-size (European) projects aimed at the development of legal reasoning and information management tools and systems. In these projects we developed ontologies for several legal or regulation domains. However, the main thread of this article is provided by fundamental research performed by us or under our supervision (e.g. PhD theses by [1], [2], [3]), leading to more abstract legal ‘core’ ontologies and legal reasoning architectures. The major insights we have obtained from these experiences can be summarized as follows:
-
Legal sources contain and assume non-legal, common-sense based domain knowledge. Therefore, a legal core ontology should be rooted in highly abstract common sense concepts as a foundational ontology. This notion is worked out in the LRI-Core ontology, presented in this article.
-
What remains as typical legal knowledge to be modelled is normative and legal responsability knowledge. However, in this article we only summarize our work in this area, refering to [4] and to [5] on these issues.
-
As law and legal theory is focussed on questions of justification, legal (core) ontologies, e.g. FOLaw, are epistemological frameworks, describing legal reasoning, rather than legal ontologies, explaining knowledge resources.
Access provided by Autonomous University of Puebla. Download to read the full chapter text
Chapter PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Keywords
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
References
Valente, A.: Legal knowledge engineering: A modelling approach. IOS Press, Amsterdam (1995)
den Haan, N.: Automated Legal Reasoning. PhD thesis, University of Amsterdam (1996)
Lehmann, J.: Causation in Artificial Intelligence and Law: a modelling approach. PhD thesis, University of Amsterdam (2003)
Valente, A., Breuker, J.A., Brouwer, P.W.: Legal modelling and automated reasoning with ON-LINE. International Journal of Human Computer Studies 51, 1079–1126 (1999)
Lehmann, J., Breuker, J.A., Brouwer, P.W.: CAUSATIONT: causation in AI & Law. In This volume (2004)
Breuker, J.A., Den Haan, N.: Separating world and regulation knowledge: where is the logic? In: Proceedings of the third international conference on AI and Law. ACM, Oxford (1991)
Clancey, W.J.: Heuristic classification. Artificial Intelligence 27, 289–350 (1985)
Patil, R.S.: Artificial intelligence techniques for diagnostic reasoning in medicine. In: Shobe, H.E. (ed.) Exploring Artificial Intelligence: Survey Talks from the National Conferences on Artificial Intelligence, pp. 347–379. Morgan Kaufmann, San Mateo (1988)
Rector, A.: Medical informatics. In: Baader, F., Calvanese, D.L., McGuinness, D., Nardi, D., Patel-Schneider, P. (eds.) Description Logic Handbook, pp. 415–435. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2002), http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/franconi/dl/course/dlhb/dlhb-10.pdf
Raz, J.: Legal principles and the limits of law. The Yale Law Journal 81, 823–854 (1972)
Kelsen, H.: General Theory of Norms. Clarendon Press, Oxford (1991)
Boer, A., van Engers, T.: A knowledge engineering approach to comparing legislation. In: Wimmer, M. (ed.) Proceedings of the Conference on Knowledge Management in E-Government. Springer, Heidelberg (2003)
Van Der Velden, W.: Coherence in law: a semantic and deductive explanation. In: Brouwer, B., Hol, T., Soeteman, A., Van Der Velden, W., De Wild, A. (eds.) Coherence and Conflict in Law, Deventer, Boston / Zwolle, pp. 257–287. Kluwer Law and Taxation Publishers (1992); Tjeenk Willink, W.E.J.:
Winkels, R.G.F., Den Haan, N.: Automated legislative drafting: Generating paraphrases of legislation. In: Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on AI and Law, College Park, Maryland, pp. 112–118. ACM, New York (1995)
Den Haan, N., Winkels, R.G.F.: The Deep Structure of Law. In: Prakken, H., Muntjewerff, A., Soeteman, A. (eds.) Legal Knowledge Based Systems: The Relation with Legal Theory – Seventh International Conference on Legal Knowledge-based Systems Legal Knowledge-Based Systems, JURIX–1994, pp. 43–54. Koninklijke Vermande (1994)
Breuker, J.A., Petkov, E., Winkels, R.: Drafting and validating regulations: the inevitable use of intelligent tools. In: Cerri, S., Dochev, D. (eds.) Artificial Intelligence: methodology, systems and applications, pp. 21–34. Springer, Heidelberg (2000)
Lindahl, L.: Conflicts in Systems of Legal Norms: A Logical Point of View. In: Brouwer, B., Hol, T., Soeteman, A., Van Den Velden, W., Wild, A.D. (eds.) Coherence and Conflict in Law, Boston / Zwolle, pp. 39–64. Kluwer Law and Taxation Publishers / W.E.J. Tjeenk Willink (1992); Proceedings of the Third Benelux-Scandinavian Symposium in Legal Theory, Amsterdam, January 3-5 (1991)
Hart, H.: The Concept of Law. Clarendon Press, Oxford (1961)
Bentham, J.: An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. In: Burns, J., Hart, H. (eds.), Athlone Press, London (1970)
Austin, J.: The Province of Jurisprudence Determined. In: Hart, H.L.A. (ed.), Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London (1954)
Hofstadter, A., McKinsey, J.: On the logic of imperatives. Philosophy of Science 6, 446–457 (1939)
Hohfeld, W.: Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Legal Reasoning. Yale University Press (1919); Edited by W.W. Cook, fourth printing (1966)
Allen, L., Saxon, C.: More IA needed in AI: Interpretation assistance for coping with the problem of multiple structural interpretations. In: Proc. of the Third International Conference on AI and Law, Oxford, pp. 53–61 (1991)
Allen, L.: The language of legal relations, RLL: useful in a legal ontology toolkit? In: Visser, P., Winkels, R. (eds.) Legal Ontologies: proceedings of the ICAIL 1997 workshop, pp. 47–60. ACM, New York (1997)
Hamfelt, A., Barklund, J.: Metaprogramming for representation of legal principles. In: Proceedings of Meta 1990, pp. 105–122 (1990)
McCarty, T.: A language for legal discourse I. basic structures. In: Proc. of the Second International Conference on AI and Law, Vancouver, pp. 180–189. ACM, New York (1989)
Alchourrón, C., Bulygin, E.: Normative Systems. Springer, Wien (1971)
Alchourrón, C., Bulygin, E.: The expressive conception of norms. In: Hilpinen, R. (ed.) New Studies in Deontic Logic, pp. 95–124. D. Reidel (1981)
Van Kralingen, R.W.: Frame-based Conceptual Models of Statute Law. PhD thesis, University of Leiden, The Hague, The Netherlands (1995)
Brouwer, P.W.: Samenhang in Recht: een analytische studie (coherence in law). Wolters-Noordhoff (1990)
Hart, H., Honoré, T.: Causation in the Law, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, New York (1985)
McNamara, P., Prakken, H. (eds.): Norms, logics and information systems; new studies in deontic logic and computer science. IOS-Press, Amsterdam (1999)
Mommers, L.: Applied legal epistemology: building a knowledge-based ontology of the legal domain. PhD thesis, University of Leiden (2002)
Winkels, R.G.F., Bosscher, D., Boer, A., Breuker, J.: Generating exception structures for legal information serving. In: Gordon, T.F. (ed.) Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Law (ICAIL 1999), pp. 182–189. ACM, New York (1999)
Lehmann, J., Breuker, J.A.: On defining ontologies and typologies of objects and processes for causal reasoning. In: Pease, A., Menzel, C., Uschold, M., Obrst, L. (eds.) Proceedings of IEEE Standard Upper Ontology, pp. 31–36. AAAI-Press, Menlo Park (2001)
Winkels, R., Boer, A., Hoekstra, R.: CLIME: lessons learned in legal information serving. In: Van Harmelen, F. (ed.) Proceedings of the European Conference on Artificial Intelligence 2002, Lyon (F). IOS-Press, Amsterdam (2002)
Muntjewerff, A., Breuker, J.A.: Evaluating PROSA, a system to train legal cases. In: Moore, J., Redfield, C., Johnson, L. (eds.) Artificial Intelligence in Education. FAIA-Series, pp. 278–290. IOS-Press, Amsterdam (2001) ISSN:0922-6389, ISBN:1 58603 173 2
Jansweijer, W., Van Der Stadt, E., Van Lieshout, J., Breuker, J.A.: Knowledgeable information brokering. In: Stanford, B., Kidd, P. (eds.) E-bussiness;: key issues, applications and technologies, IOS-Press, Amsterdam (2000)
van Heijst, G., Schreiber, A.T., Wielinga, B.J.: Using explicit ontologies for kbs development. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 46(2/3), 183–292 (1997)
Borst, P., Akkermans, J.M., Top, J.L.: Engineering ontologies. International Journal of Human Computer Studies 46(2/3), 365–406 (1997)
Van Kralingen, R., Visser, P., Bench-Capon, T., Van Den Herik, H.: A principled approach to developing legal knowledge systems. International Journal of Human Computer Studies 51, 1127–1154 (1999)
Hage, J., Verheij, B.: The law as a dynamic interconnected system of states of affairs: a legal top ontology. International Journal of Human Computer Studies 51, 1034–1077 (1999)
Breuker, J., Hoekstra, R.: Epistemology and ontology in core ontologies: FOLaw and LRI-Core, two core ontologies for law. In: Proceedings of EKAW Workshop on Core ontologies (2004), CEUR, http://sunsite.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/Publications/CEUR-WS/
Breuker, J., Van De Velde, W. (eds.): CommonKADS Library for Expertise Modeling: reusable problem solving components. IOS-Press/Ohmsha, Amsterdam/Tokyo (1994)
Lame, G.: Construction dÕontologie à partir de textes. Une ontologie de droit dédié à la recherche dõinformation sur le Web. PhD thesis, Ecole des Mines, Paris (2002), http://www.cri.ensmp.fr/
Lame, G.: Using NLP techniques to identify legal ontology components: Concepts and relations. In: Benjamins, V.R., Casanovas, P., Breuker, J., Gangemi, A. (eds.) Law and the Semantic Web. LNCS (LNAI), vol. 3369, pp. 169–184. Springer, Heidelberg (2005)
Sowa, J.F.: Knowledge Representation: Logical Philosophical, and Computational Foundations. Brooks Cole Publishing Co., Pacific Grove (2000)
Pease, A., Niles, I.: IEEE Standard Upper Ontology: A progress report. Knowledge Engineering Review 17, 65–70 (2002) (Special Issue on Ontologies and Agents)
Gangemi, A., Guarino, N., Masolo, C., Oltramari, A.: Sweetening WORDNET with DOLCE. AI Magazine 24, 13–24 (2003)
Massolo, C., Borgo, S., Gangemi, A., Guarino, N., Oltramari, A., Schneider, L.: The WonderWeb foundational ontologies: preliminary report. Technical Report Deliverable D17, version 2, ISTC-CNR, Italy (2002)
Pinker, S.: How the mind works. Penguin Books (1997)
Wegner, D.: The Illusion of Conscious Will. Bradford Books, MIT Press, Cambridge/London (2002)
Gangemi, A., Guarino, N., Masolo, C., Oltramari, A., Schneider, L.: Sweetening ontologies with DOLCE. In: Gomez-Perez, A., Benjamins, V.R. (eds.) Proceedings of the EKAW 2002, pp. 166–181. Springer, Heidelberg (2002)
Tulving, E.: Concepts of human memory. In: Squire, L., Lynx, G., Weinberger, N.M., McGaugh, J.L. (eds.) Memory: organization and locus of change, pp. 3–32. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1991)
Hayes, P.J.: The second naive physics manifesto. In: Hobbs, J.R., Moore, R.C. (eds.) Formal Theories of the Common Sense World, pp. 1–36. Ablex Publishing Corporation, Norwood (1985)
Kim, J.: Mind in a physical world: An essay on the mind-body problem and mental causation. In: Representation and Mind. MIT Press, Cambridge (1998)
Dennett, D.: The Intentional Stance. MIT-Press, Cambridge (1987)
Breuker, J.: Components of problem solving. In: Steels, L., Van de Velde, W., Schreiber, G. (eds.) EKAW 1994, vol. 867, pp. 118–136. Springer, Heidelberg (1994)
Pacheco, O., Carmo, J.: A role based model for the normative specification of organized collective agency and agents interaction. Journal of Autonomous Agents and Multi-Agent Systems 6, 145–184 (2003)
Steimann, F.: On the representation of roles in object-oriented and conceptual modelling. Data and Knowledge Engineering 35, 83–106 (2000)
Masolo, C., Vieu, L., Bottazzi, E., Catenacci, C., Ferrario, R., Gangemi, A., Guarino, N.: Social roles and their descriptions. In: Proceedings of Knowledge Representation Workshop (2004)
Lakoff, G., Núñez, R.: Where Mathematics Comes From. Basic Books (2000)
Strawson, P.F.: Individuals: an essay in descriptive metaphysics. Routledge (1959)
Damasio, A.R.: Looking for Spinoza. Putnam (2003)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2005 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Breuker, J., Valente, A., Winkels, R. (2005). Use and Reuse of Legal Ontologies in Knowledge Engineering and Information Management. In: Benjamins, V.R., Casanovas, P., Breuker, J., Gangemi, A. (eds) Law and the Semantic Web. Lecture Notes in Computer Science(), vol 3369. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-32253-5_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-32253-5_4
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-540-25063-0
Online ISBN: 978-3-540-32253-5
eBook Packages: Computer ScienceComputer Science (R0)