Abstract
In 2010, the European Court of Human Rights’ decision prompted a new debate on the abortion issue in Ireland. After explaining how Catholic teaching has shaped Irishness and influenced the Irish Republic’s pro-life policy, this chapter focuses on the legislative changes the European Court decision brought about and exposes how these have dramatically loosened the Church–state relationship. Changes are also taking place at the sociocultural level and this chapter assesses the extent to which the Catholic ethos is losing its influence on Irish minds and behaviours, more specifically in terms of abortion. It concludes by showing that these mutations have been followed by a different perception of crisis pregnancies and abortion both in Irish society and at the state level.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
- 1.
The only EU countries which have similarly restrictive abortion laws are Malta, Poland and Hungary. See Center for Reproductive Rights (2017).
- 2.
More precisely, the court ruled that Ireland’s failure to implement the existing constitutional right to a lawful abortion when a woman’s life is at risk violated one of the applicant’s rights under Article 8 (‘Right to Respect for Family and Private Life’) of the European Convention on Human Rights. Applicant C was in remission from cancer when she became pregnant. Unaware of her pregnancy, C underwent a series of medical check-ups. She claimed that she could not obtain clear advice about the risks to her health and life and to the foetus if she continued to term. She also feared that if her cancer recurred her life would be at risk, as she could not benefit from a suitable treatment because it could harm the foetus, which is protected by the Eighth Amendment. C decided to have an abortion but could not have access to it in Ireland.
- 3.
The European Court of Justice is different from the European Court of Human Rights. The former is a body of the European Union with 28 member states, whereas the latter is an international court established by the Council of Europe comprising 47 member states.
- 4.
- 5.
In the context of the political instability of the 1980s, FitzGerald accepted the Fianna Fáil’s wording for electoral reasons. Indeed, as the head of the opposition, he did not wish this issue to be on the political agenda during the 1982 general elections. However, he was criticised for supporting the amendment, which was qualified as sectarian by the Protestants from the perspective of his constitutional crusade policy. FitzGerald thus tried to propose another wording, but—due to a lack of consensus on it in the coalition government—he had no other solution than to go back to the original wording he had agreed upon during Fianna Fáil’s time in government.
- 6.
The story was revealed by Kitty Holland, an Irish Times journalist. A great deal of literature has been published on this case. Holland detailed Halappanavar’s story in Savita: The Tragedy That Shook a Nation (2013).
- 7.
See the main website of the Coalition to Repeal the Eighth Amendment or its Facebook page. For more details about Ailbhe Smyth’s commitment to women’s reproductive rights, read Crawford (2016).
- 8.
See the main website of the Artists’ Campaign to Repeal the Eighth Amendment or their Facebook page. In September 2016, the campaign released a short film, directed by Dave Tynan and written by Sarah Maria Griffin, entitled We Face This Land (Tynan and Griffin 2016).
- 9.
The Citizens’ Assembly , a group of 99 unelected representatives, was formed to consider several political questions, including that of abortion. More specifically, the Citizens’ Assembly recommended that terminations should be allowed without restriction up to the 12th week of pregnancy, or, when due to ‘socio-economic reasons’ up to the 22nd week of pregnancy. Also, in cases of fatal foetal abnormality, where the child is likely to die shortly before or after birth, it recommended that abortion be allowed at any stage of the pregnancy (Duffy 2017).
- 10.
Specifically Article 41.1.1 and Article 41.1.2 in Bunreacht Na hÉireann (the Irish Constitution).
- 11.
Specifically Article 41.2.1 and Article 42.1 in Bunreacht Na hÉireann (the Irish Constitution).
- 12.
It is also worth mentioning that the draft Constitution was read by John Charles McQuaid, archbishop of Dublin and Primate of Ireland, who previously declared that ‘[a constitution ] is an enactment guided and delimitated by the teachings of Catholic philosophy and theology. It enshrines and sets forth the aim of what ought to be our Christian endeavour in social policy’ (Cullen and Ó hÓgartaigh 2013, p. 10). McQuaid also wrote Éamon de Valera that ‘the aim of the State is to secure a social order, according to natural law and Christian teaching’ (p. 26).
- 13.
Benedict XVI declared that ‘direct abortion, that is to say willed as an end or as a means, is gravely contrary to the moral law’ (Benedict XVI 2013). As for Francis I, he sent a message of support for human life to Catholics in Ireland during the Dáil debates on the Protection of Life During Pregnancy 2013 (Francis I 2013). In 2015, he adopted a more compassionate approach than his predecessors by relaxing forgiveness rules for abortion, but he still sticks to Catholic teaching on abortion itself (Francis I 2015).
- 14.
The Mother and Child Scheme was a healthcare programme introduced as part of the 1947 Health Act that Noël Browne intended to implement in the early 1950s. It provided free medical care for mothers and their children up to the age of 16. The Catholic hierarchy opposed it, as they feared that it would pave the way for the introduction of birth-control methods or even abortion. This programme was thus never implemented as a result of Church pressure that led the coalition government to back away from the scheme; the episode caused Browne’s resignation as Minister for Health.
- 15.
The EVS survey started in 1981 and it takes place every 9 years. At the time of writing the fieldwork for the fifth wave of the EVS is due to take place in autumn 2017.
- 16.
Industrial schools were orphanages which also looked after neglected or abandoned children. The Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, established in 2003 after a large number of people gave evidence that they had been abused, found that children had undergone sustained physical, sexual and emotional abuse as well as neglect in these institutions. David Yallop wrote a critical account of child abuse in industrial schools and also covered the Murphy report in Beyond Belief: The Catholic Church and the Child Abuse Scandal (2010). The Magdalene Laundries were institutions, run by Roman Catholic orders, which confined women whose sexual behaviour did not conform with the Church’s teaching. Women who became pregnant were confined to a Magdalene Laundry and their newborn child was taken away from them shortly after birth. The film Magdalene Sisters raised awareness of this issue (Mullan 2002). Testimonies can also be found online (Dunphy 2013). The survivor advocacy group Justice for Magdalene Laundries, founded in 2009, obtained a formal apology from the Irish state and a compensation scheme for former residents of these institutions.
- 17.
Sheila Hodgers was a 26-year-old woman who died of cancer. She was denied treatment while pregnant because the Catholic ethos of the hospital did not allow treatment that might harm the foetus (Holland 2012). Ann Lovett was a 15-year-old girl from Granard who concealed her pregnancy and died after giving birth, in a grotto dedicated to the Virgin Mary, in 1984 (Hill 2003, p. 198). The Kerry Babies relates to the death of two newborn babies born after concealed pregnancies in 1984 (McCafferty 2010).
- 18.
See www.thinkcontraception.ie, accessed 23 April 2017. ‘Johnny’s Got You Covered’ has a Facebook page which mentions that Johnny is ‘a friend to everyone who wants protection from STIs & unplanned pregnancy’ (https://www.facebook.com/pg/thinkjohnny/about/?ref=page_internal). It also has a Twitter account (@thinkjohnny) and a Snapchat account (think_johnny).
- 19.
B4uDecide (www.b4udecide.ie, accessed 23 April 2017) is a website that gives young people the information they need to make informed decisions for themselves before having sex for the first time. It features quizzes, polls and video interviews with young people talking about relationships, sex and dealing with peers. Positive Options (www.positiveoptions.ie, accessed 23 April 2017) promotes state-funded crisis pregnancy counselling services all over the country.
- 20.
The decisions made by these international bodies (ECtHR , UN) have the effect of a spark which reignites the abortion controversy on both political and social levels.
Works Cited
Abortion Aftercare. Health Service Executive, 2017. http://abortionaftercare.ie, accessed 23 March 2017.
Amnesty International. Public Attitudes Towards Abortion in Ireland, 2016. http://www.redcresearch.ie/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/157316-%E2%80%93-Amnesty-International-Feb-2016-040316-Press-Release.pdf, accessed 16 April 2016.
Artists’ Campaign to Repeal the Eighth Amendment. https://www.artistsrepealthe8th.com, accessed 23 April 2017.
———. Facebook Page. www.facebook.com/artistsrepeal8, accessed 23 April 2017.
Benedict XVI. Address of His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI to the Members of the Diplomatic Corps Accredited to the Holy See. Rome, 7 January 2013. http://w2.vatican.va/content/benedict-xvi/en/speeches/2013/january/documents/hf_ben-xvi_spe_20130107_corpo-diplomatico.html, accessed 10 January 2013.
Center for Reproductive Rights. The World’s Abortion Laws 2017, 2017. http://worldabortionlaws.com/map/, accessed 6 May 2017.
Central Statistics Office. Marriages and Civil Partnerships 2015, 2016a. http://cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/er/mcp/marriagesandcivilpartnerships2015/, accessed 20 April 2016.
———. Vital Statistics Annual Report 2014, 2016b. http://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/ep/p-vsar/vsar2014/, accessed 30 October 2016.
Coalition to Repeal the Eighth Amendment. http://www.repealeight.ie/, accessed 23 April 2017.
———. Facebook Page. https://www.facebook.com/repeal8/?ref=page_internal, accessed 23 April 2017.
Collins, Stephen. “De Valera Sought Papal Approval for Constitution.” Irish Times, 27 November 2006. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/de-valera-sought-papal-approval-for-constitution-1.1264336, accessed 27 November 2006.
———. “Irish Times Poll: Majority Want Repeal of Eighth Amendment.” Irish Times, 7 October 2016. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/irish-times-poll-majority-want-repeal-of-eighth-amendment-1.2819814, accessed 29 April 2017.
Commissioner for Human Rights. Report by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe Following His Visit to Ireland from 22 to 25 November 2016. Council of Europe: Strasbourg, 2017.
Committee on the Rights of the Child. Concluding Observations on the Combined Third and Fourth Periodic Reports of Ireland. United Nations, 2016.
Crawford, Hillary E. “This Irish Abortion Activist Has Been Fighting For Women’s Rights For Decades.” Bustle, 24 August 2016. https://www.bustle.com/articles/169674-this-irish-abortion-activist-has-been-fighting-for-womens-rights-for-decades, accessed 23 April 2017.
Crisis Pregnancy Agency. 2017. http://www.crisispregnancy.ie/about-us/overview/, accessed 23 April 2017.
Cullen, Paul, and Kitty Holland. “Midwife Manager ‘Regrets’ Using ‘Catholic Country’ Remark to Savita.” Irish Times, 10 April 2013. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/midwife-manager-regrets-using-catholic-country-remark-to-savita-halappanavar-1.1355895, accessed 13 April 2013.
Cullen, Clara, and Margaret ÓhÓgartaigh, eds. His Grace Is Displeased—Selected Correspondence of John Charles McQuaid. Dublin: Merrion, 2013.
Dáil Éireann Debates. Leaders’ Questions. 12 June 2013. http://oireachtasdebates.oireachtas.ie/debates%20authoring/debateswebpack.nsf/takes/dail2013061200006?opendocument, accessed 12 June 2013.
———. Leaders’ Questions 949, no. 2 (2017). http://oireachtasdebates.oireachtas.ie/debates%20authoring/debateswebpack.nsf/takes/dail2017050400015?opendocument, accessed 4 May 2017.
Dáil na nÓg. Life Skills Matter – Not Just Points: A Survey of Implementation of Social, Personal and Health Education (SPHE) and Relationships and Sexuality Education (RSE) in Second-Level Schools. Dublin: Office of the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, 2010.
Department of Education and Science and National Council for Curriculum and Assessment. Junior Cycle: Social, Personal and Health Education. Guidelines for Teachers. Dublin: Government of Ireland, 2000.
Dooley, Maurice. “Abortion: Referendum or Legislation?” The Furrow 49, no. 2 (1998): 87–90.
Downing, John. “A Line Has Been Drawn: Church Can no Longer Influence Laws.” The Irish Independent, 13 June 2013. http://www.independent.ie/opinion/analysis/a-line-has-been-drawn-church-can-no-longer-influence-laws-29341309.html, accessed 23 March 2017.
Duffy, Ronan. “Citizens’ Assembly Recommends Abortion to be Allowed Without Restrictions up to 12 Weeks.” The Journal, 23 April 2017. http://www.thejournal.ie/citizens-assembly-vote-3354416-Apr2017/, accessed 23 April 2017.
Dunphy, Liz. No More Shame, 2013. www.youtube.com/user/NoMoreShameIreland, accessed 6 May 2017.
European Court of Human Rights. Case of A, B and C v. Ireland (GC) (Application, no 25579/05), 16 December 2010. http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2010/2032.html, accessed 9 May 2017.
European Values Study (EVS). Longitudinal Data File 1981–2008. Cologne: GESIS Data Archive, 2011. ZA4804 Data file Version 2.0.0.
Ferriter, Diarmaid. Occasions of Sin: Sex and Society in Modern Ireland. London: Profile, 2009.
Fletcher, Ruth. “Post-Colonial Fragments: Representations of Abortion in Irish Law and Politics.” Journal of Law and Society 28, no. 4 (2001): 568–89.
Forster, Katie. “Irish Women Go on Strike over the Abortion Ban.” The Irish Independent, 8 March 2017. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/irish-women-abortion-ban-strike-international-day-2017-republic-ireland-consitutional-amendment-a7617461.html, accessed 8 March 2017.
Francis I. All Life Has Inestimable Value. Vatican: Vatican Radio, 2013. http://en.radiovaticana.va/news/2013/07/17/pope_francis:_all_life_has_inestimable_value/en1-711052, accessed 18 July 2013.
———. Lettera del Santo Padre Francesco al Presidente del Pontificio Consiglio per la Promozione della Nuova Evangelizzazione all’approssimarsi del Giubileo Straordinario della Misericordia, Rome, 1 September 2015. http://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/it/bollettino/pubblico/2015/09/01/0637/01386.html#ing, accessed 20 April 2017.
Ganiel, Gladys. Transforming Post-Catholic Ireland: Religious Practice in Late Modernity. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.
Girvin, Brian. “Church, State and the Irish Constitution: The Secularisation of Irish Politics.” Parliamentary Affairs 49, no. 4 (1996): 599–615.
Hesketh, Tom. The Second Partitioning of Ireland? The Abortion Referendum of 1983. Dublin: Brandsma, 1990.
Hill, Myrtle. Women in Ireland: A Century of Change. Belfast: Blackstaff, 2003.
Holland, Kitty. “Reason for Women Not to Be Cheerful.” Irish Times, 29 December 2012. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/reasons-for-women-not-to-be-cheerful-1.5496, accessed 9 May 2017.
———. Savita: The Tragedy that Shook a Nation. Dublin: Transworld Ireland, 2013.
Hug, Chrystel, and Jo Campling, eds. The Politics of Sexual Morality in Ireland. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 1999.
Inglis, Tom. Moral Monopoly: The Rise and Fall of the Catholic Church in Modern Ireland. Dublin: University College Dublin, 1998.
Irish Catholic Bishops’ Conference. Pastoral Letter in Defence of Unborn Human Life by Bishop John Buckley, Bishop of Cork and Ross, 2013. http://www.catholicbishops.ie/2013/06/14/pastoral-letter-defence-unborn-human-life-bishop-john-buckley-bishop-cork-ross/, accessed 14 June 2013.
Jackson, Pauline C. “Outside the Jurisdiction: Irish Women Seeking Abortion,” 1987. In The Abortion Papers: Ireland, ed. Ailbhe Smyth. Dublin: Attic, 1992, 119–37.
Kenny, Enda. “Taoiseach Says Catholic Church Told of His ‘Duty to Legislate on Abortion.’” RTÉ, 5 May 2013. http://www.rte.ie/news/2013/0505/390515-abortion-legislation/, accessed 6 May 2013.
Leahy, Pat. “Poll Shows Public Support for Abortion is Cautious and Conditional.” Irish Times, 3 March 2017. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/poll-shows-public-support-for-abortion-is-cautious-and-conditional-1.2995696, accessed 3 March 2017.
Mayock, Paula, Karl Kitching, and Mark Morgan. Relationships and Sexuality Education (RSE) in the Context of Social, Personal and Health Education (SPHE), an Assessment of the Challenges to Full Implementation of the Programme in Post-Primary Schools. Dublin: Department of Education and Science, 2007.
McBride, Orla, Karen Morgan, and Hannah McGee. Crisis Pregnancy Programme Report n°24: Irish Contraception and Crisis Pregnancy Study 2010 (ICCP-2010): A Survey of the General Population. Dublin: Crisis Pregnancy Programme, 2012.
McCafferty, Nell. A Woman to Blame: The Kerry Babies Case. Cork: Attic, 2010.
Mullan, Peter. Dir. Magdalene Sisters. Scottish Screen, Film Council, Bórd Scannán na hÉireann, 2002.
Ó Cearúil, Micheál. Bunreacht na hÉireann: A Study of the Irish Text. Dublin: Stationery Office, 1999.
Ó Tuama, Seamus. “Revisiting the Irish Constitution and De Valera’s Grand Vision.” Irish Journal of Legal Studies 2, no. 2 (2011): 55–87.
O’Higgins, Siobhan, Marie Galvin, and Catriona Kennedy. The Implementation of SPHE at Post-Primary School Level: A Case Study Approach. Galway: National University of Ireland, 2007.
O’Regan, Michael. “Papal Nuncio Says Faith Must Influence Political Choices in Abortion Debate.” Irish Times, 2 June 2013. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/oireachtas/papal-nuncio-says-faith-must-influence-political-choices-in-abortion-debate-1.1414928, accessed 23 March 2017.
Smyth, Ailbhe, ed. “A Sadistic Farce: Women and Abortion in the Republic of Ireland.” In The Abortion Papers: Ireland, 7–24. Dublin: Attic, 1992.
Spreng, Jennifer E. Abortion and Divorce Law in Ireland. Jefferson, North Carolina and London: MacFarland, 2004.
Tynan, Dave (Dir.), and Sarah Maria Griffin (Writ.). We Face This Land, 2016. www.youtube.com/watch?v=571vnkdrWC0, accessed 23 April 2017.
Wilson, Bryan R. Religion and Secular Society: A Sociological Comment. London: C.A. Watts, 1966.
Yallop, David. Beyond Belief: The Catholic Church and the Child Abuse Scandal. London: Constable, 2010.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2018 The Author(s)
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Nault, E. (2018). Abortion in Ireland: From Religious Marginalisation to State Recognition. In: Villar-Argáiz, P. (eds) Irishness on the Margins. New Directions in Irish and Irish American Literature. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-74567-1_7
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-74567-1_7
Published:
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-74566-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-74567-1
eBook Packages: Literature, Cultural and Media StudiesLiterature, Cultural and Media Studies (R0)