Abstract
Arguably the most urgently incendiary flashpoints threatening Indo-Pacific peace lay in SCS waters. China, Taiwan, the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei variously claimed and occupied islets, reefs and cays here. Conflicting claims led to Sino-Vietnamese maritime violence in 1974, 1988 and 2014; coercion against Manila occurred in 1995 and 2012. Neutrality notwithstanding, America’s strong support for China’s rivals reinforced regional fissures along systemic-subsystemic cleavages with Sino-US pressures threatening ASEAN’s cohesion. Manila’s 2013 submission to a UNCLOS-based Arbitral Tribunal (AT) against Chinese actions precipitated fresh tensions. The AT’s July 2016 award for Manila, rejected by Beijing, provided a pivotal moment, which was transformed by President Rodrigo Duterte’s diplomatic dramatics. The other vocal claimant, Vietnam, adopted an ambiguous course as Donald Trump took office. The chapter examines recent developments through the prism of the past, offering glimpses of an uncertain future.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
References
Abe S, Duterte R (2016) Japan-Philippines joint statement. PMO, Tokyo, 26 Oct 2016
ADST (2016) Politics, Pinatubo and the Pentagon: the closure of Subic Bay. http://adst.org/20a16/05/politics-pinatubo-pentagon-closure-subic-bay-philippines/. Accessed 6 Nov 2016
Ali S (2005) US-China Cold War collaboration, 1971-1989. Routledge, London, pp 6–8
AmCham (2011) High-ranking Vietnamese officers visit US aircraft carrier in Eastern Sea. Ho Chi Minh City, 14 Aug 2011
AMTI (2016a) China’s new Spratly Island defenses. CSIS, Washington, 14 Dec 2016
AMTI (2016b) Build it and they will come. CSIS, Washington, 1 Aug 2016
AMTI (2016c) Vietnam responds with spratly air upgrades. CSIS, Washington, 15 Nov 2016
AMTI (2016d) Vietnam’s Island building: double-standard or drop in the bucket? CSIS, Washington, 11 May 2016
An B (2016) Xi, Duterte hail ‘springtime’ of ties. PD, 21 Oct 2016
Anderson J (2015) Sino-Vietnam relations before and after 1975. China Policy Institute, Nottingham, 15 Apr 2015
Aquino N, Calonzo A (2016) Duterte seeks arms from China, ends joint patrols with US. Bloomberg, 13 Sept 2016
ASEAN Secretariat (2016) Chairman’s statement of the 4th ASEAN-US Summit. Vientiane, 8 Sept 2016
AT (2016) PCA case no. 2013-19: Award. The Hague, 12 July 2016, p 116
Auslin M (2017) China won’t run from a fight with Trump. FP, 24 Jan 2017
Bedi R (2017) India in talks with Vietnam over Akash SAM system. JDW, 10 Jan 2017
Bigornia D (2016) Duterte: 2016 PH-US military exercises will be the last. ABS-CBN, Manila, 29 Sept 2016
Blanchard B, Rose A (2016) China says oil rig is not drilling in disputed waters after Vietnam complains. Reuters, Beijing, 20 Jan 2016
Boudreau J (2015) Vietnam goes shopping for US military hardware. Bloomberg (14 May 2015)
Brzezinski Z (1983) Power and principle. Farrar Strauss, New York, pp 409–410
Cabacungan G (2016) Duterte seeks alliances with China and Russia. Inquirer, 28 Sept 2016
Carter A (2016a) Remarks on ‘Asia-Pacific’s Principled Security Network’. DoD/IISS, Singapore, 4 June 2016
Carter A (2016b) Remarks in a press conference. Ko Olina, 30 Dec 2016
Carter A, Gazmin V (2016) Joint press conference. DoD, Manila, 14 Apr 2016
Chen K (1983) China’s war against Vietnam, 1979: a military analysis. University of Maryland, Baltimore, pp 11–13
Chen J (1995) China’s involvement in the Vietnam War, 1964-69. China Quart 142(June 1995)
CIA (1963a) DCI Briefing, Washington, 9 July 1963
CIA (1963b) Current Intelligence Memorandum: cast of characters in South Vietnam. Washington, 28 Aug 1963
CIA (1963c) McCone to Kennedy. Washington, 8 Oct 1963
CNOOC, PetroVietnam, PNOC (2005) Joint statement on the signing ceremony of a tripartite agreement for joint marine seismic undertaking in the agreement area in the SCS. PRC Embassy, Manila, 14 Mar 2005
Compton A, Litke M (2000) Clinton makes historic visit to Vietnam. ABC, Hanoi, 16 Nov 2000
CPCCC (1979) Zhonggong Zhongyang Guanyu Shengli Jieshu dui Yue Ziwei Fanji Baowei Bianjiang Zhanzheng di Tongzhi (A notice of the CPCCC on the Victorious conclusion of self-defensive counterattack against Vietnam and Border-Protection War). Beijing, 5 Mar 1979, p 2
Cui T (2016) Remarks at CSIS. Chinese Embassy, Washington, 13 July 2016
Dagooc E (2016) Duterte’s tirades vs US: an economic strategy. Philstar, 24 Oct 2016
Dai B (2016) Speech at China-US dialogue on SCS. MoFA, Washington, 5 July 2016
Dominguez G (2017) Philippine president asks China for help with sea patrols to combat piracy. Jane’s, 3 Feb 2017
DoS (1963a) MemCon: Vietnam. Washington, 28 Aug 1963
DoS (1963b) Rusk to Lodge: Cable 272. Washington, 29 Aug 1963
DoS (Undated) US involvement in the Vietnam War: The Gulf of Tonking and escalation, 1964. https://history.state.gov/milestones/1961-1968/gulf-of-tonkin. Accessed 27 Dec 2016
DoS Historian (Undated) Dien Bien Phu & the fall of French Indochina, 1954. https://history.state.gov/milestones/1953-1960/dien-bien-phu. Accessed 27 Dec 2016
Dossani R, Harold S (2016) Maritime issues in the East and South China Seas. RAND, Santa Monica, p 7
Drogin B (1991) After 89 years, US lowers flag at Clark Air Base. LAT, 27 Nov 1991
Drogin B (1992) Americans bid farewell to last Philippine base. LAT, 25 Nov 1992
Du M (2016) Air force to conduct regular patrols over islands. PD, 23 Sept 2016
Dumlao A (2016) Duterte urged: end US intervention. Philstar, 24 Sept 2016
Dunn J (1963) Memorandum for the record. DoS, Washington, 1 Nov 1963
Editorial (1979) Love and defend our motherland. Liberation Army Daily, 26 Mar 1979
Editorial (2016) Duterte’s pivot. Economist, 22 Oct 2016
Editorial (2017a) Tillerson’s animosity toward China bodes ill if acted upon. CD, 13 Jan 2017
Editorial (2017b) Pentagon to set tone for Trump’s SCS policy with USS Carl Vinson. GT, 8 Jan 2017
Farrer M (2016) Beijing warns US to stay out of SCS dispute. Guardian, 8 Sept 2016
Feast L, Torode G (2016) Risking Beijing’s ire, Vietnam begins dredging on SCS reef. Reuters, Sydney/Hong Kong, 9 Dec 2016
Ferdinando L (2016a) Carter hosts Indian counterpart, praises strong bilateral ties. DoD News, Washington, 29 Aug 2016
Ferdinando L (2016b) Carter, ASEAN ministers reaffirm commitment to regional security. DoD News, Washington, 1 Oct 2016
Ferdinando L (2016c) On USS Carl Vinson, Carter highlights Asia-Pacific rebalance. DoD News, 29 Sept 2016
Fineman M (1986) US-Philippine relations turning warmer in Post-Marcos Era. LAT, 12 July 1986
Garamone J (2016) Carter visits USS John Stennis operating in SCS. DoD News, Washington, 16 Apr 2016
Garver J (1981) Sino-Vietnamese conflict and the Sino-American rapprochement. Polit Sci Q 96(3):445–464
Gates J (1990) The US Army and irregular warfare, Chap. 3. College of Wooster, Wooster
Gazmin V, Goldberg P (2014) Agreement between the Government of the Republic of the Philippines and the Government of the USA on EDCA. MoD, Quezon City, 28 Apr 2014
Gopalakrishnan R (2014) Up to 21 dead, doctor says, as anti-China riots spread in Vietnam. Reuters, Hanoi, 15 May 2014
Griffiths J, Rivers M, Boykoff P (2016) Duterte: Philippines not severing ties with US. CNN, 22 Oct 2016
Guo M (ed) (1992) Zhong-Yue guanxi yanbian sishinian (Forty-year evolution of Sino-Vietnamese relations). Guangxi People's Press, Nanning
Hackett J (ed) (2016) Military balance. IISS/Routledge, London, pp 297-298, 306
Han H (ed) (1989a) Dangdai Zhongguo jundui de junshi gongzuo (The military affairs of the contemporary Chinese Army), vol 1. Chinese Social Sciences Press, Beijing, pp 540–541, 549-551
Han H (ed) (1989b) Dangdai Zhongguo jundui de junshi gongzuo, vol 1. Chinese Social Sciences Press, Beijing, pp 550-553
Harris H (2016) Address to the Lowy Institute for International Policy. PACOM, Sydney, 14 Dec 2016
Hilsman R (1963) DoS to AmEmbassy: cable 243, Washington, 24 Aug 1963
Hoover D (2010) The migration of Chinese-Vietnamese from Vietnam: the Truong family. Masters dissertation. Baylor University, Waco, p 4
Hsu S (2016) The ugly truth about Donald Trump’s China policies. Forbes, 1 Sept 2016
Hua X (2016) China asks for halt of illegal construction in Nansha islands. Xinhua, Beijing, 9 Dec 2016
Hubbard T (2001) Senate testimony: US-Philippine relations-opportunities to enhance our enduring partnership. DoS, Washington, 6 Mar 2001
Hui W (2001) US-China: bonds and tensions. In Shuxun C, Wolf C (eds) China, the United States, and the global economy. RAND, Santa Monica, p 273
Hung P (2013) Hanoi and Moscow in anti-Chinese bilateral cooperation. Asia News, 14 Nov 2013
Hung N (2016) Shared concerns about China bring Vietnam and Japan closer. EAF, 2 June 2016
Hunt K, Rivers M, Shoichet C (2016) In China, Duterte announces split with US: ‘America has lost’. CNN, 20 Oct 2016
Ide W (2017) SCS, not trade first point of friction for Trump, China. VoA, 24 Jan 2017
Institute of Diplomatic History (1993) Zhou Enlai waijiao huodong dashiji, 1949-1975 (A chronicle of Zhou Enlai’s diplomatic activities, 1949-1975). MoFA, Beijing, p 524
Kamm H (1978) Teng says China is cutting aid to Vietnam. NYT, 9 June 1978
Karnow S (1989) Reagan and the Philippines: setting Marcos Adrift. NYT, 19 Mar 1989
Kremlin (2010) Joint news conference following Russian-Vietnamese talks. Hanoi, 31 Oct 2010
Kyodo (2016) Maritime security ties to grow, Hanoi and Tokyo say. JT, 6 May 2016
LaGrone S (2014) Japan and Vietnam expand defense partnership. USNI News, 19 Mar 2014
Langdon A (2016) Frank Cable arrives in Vietnam for 7th annual Naval Engagement Activity. PACOM, Cam Ranh Bay, 3 Oct 2016
Larter D (2016) US deepens military ties with former foe Vietnam. Navy Times (23 May 2016)
Li K, Hao S (1989) Wenhua dageming zhong de renmin jiefangjun (The PLA during the Cultural Revolution). CPC Historical Materials Press, Beijing
Liang J (2016) Beijing ‘will never’ halt island work. PD, 19 July 2016
Library of Congress (1992) Country studies: Philippines. http://countrystudies.us/philippines/92.htm. Accessed 6 Nov 2016
Lichauco M, Storey M (1926) The conquest of the Philippines by the US, 1898-1925. Putnam, New York, pp 36–38
Liu X (2016a) Stop playing with fire in the SCS. Telegraph, 10 June 2016
Liu X (2016b) SCS arbitration is a political farce. Telegraph, 23 July 2016
Liu X (2016c) China celebrates 70th years of islands’ recovery. GT, 8 Dec 2016
Macapagal-Arroyo G (2004) The Philippine foreign policy. Malacanan Palace, Makati, 6 Aug 2004
Macas T (2016) Did Aquino ignore Gloria Arroyo at Palace meeting with Duterte, NSC? GMA, 27 July 2016
McGarry B (2016) USAF flies all three bombers in Pacific Op. Defense Tech, 17 Aug 2016
McNutt P, Roxas M (1947) Agreement between the USA and the Republic of the Philippines concerning military bases. Manila, 14 Mar 1947
MEA (2012) India-Vietnam relations. New Delhi, Jan 2012
Mendenhall J (1963a) Successor Heads of Government. DoS, Washington, 25 Oct 1963
Mendenhall J (1963b) Check-list of possible US actions in case of Coup, 25 Oct 1963
Miglani S (2016) US plans naval exercises with India and Japan in Philippine Sea. Reuters, 3 Mar 2016
Mishra S (2016) India and Vietnam can rescue Asia’s balance of power. NI (25 Apr 2016)
MoFA (1978) Statement on the expulsion of Chinese residents by Vietnam. Foreign Language Press, Peking, 9 June 1978
MoFA (1993) Zhou Enlai waijiao huodong dashiji, 1949-1975 (A Chronicle of Zhou Enlai's Important Diplomatic Activities, 1949-1975). World Affairs Press, Beijing
MoFA (2016a) Position paper of the Government of the PRC on the matter of Jurisdiction in the SCS Arbitration initiated by the Republic of the Philippines. Beijing, 4 Dec 2014
MoFA (2016b) Joint statement of China and the Philippines. Beijing, 21 Oct 2016
MoFA (2016c) Signing and exchange of notes concerning Japanese ODA loans to the Philippines. Tokyo, 26 Oct 2016
Mogato M (2017) Philippine says US military to upgrade bases, defense deal intact. Reuters, Manila, 26 Jan 2017
Morris L (2016) The importance of Sunnylands for US-ASEAN relations. RAND, Santa Monica, 24 Feb 2016
NNS (2016a) Chiefs of US and Chinese Navies agree on need for cooperation. Beijing, 18 July 2016
NNS (2016b) CNO visits Chinese North Sea Fleet. Underscores importance of International Law. Qingdao, 20 July 2016
Nong H (2016) The US-China battle in the post-Arbitration SCS. ICAS, 8 June 2016
NSC (1963a) MemCon: Vietnam. Washington, 26 Aug 1963
NSC (1963b) Forrestal to Kennedy: Memorandum for the President. Washington, 27 Aug 1963
NSC (1963c) MemCon with the President. Washington, 27 Aug 1963
NSC (1963d) MemCon with the President, Washington, 29 Aug 1963
NSC (1963e) Check-list for 4PM meeting. Washington, 29 Oct 196e
NSC (1963f) MemCon with the President. Washington, 29 Oct 1963)
NSC (1963g) Bundy to lodge: CIA cable 79407, 30 Oct 1963
NSC (1963h) MemCon with the President. Washington, 1 Nov 1963
NSC/DoS(1963) Forrestal and Hilsman to Kennedy: suggested draft of Presidential Letter adapted to Phase I of the plan. Washington, 12 Sept 1963
Obama B (2016a) Remarks before US-ASEAN Meeting. White House, Vientiane, 8 Sept 2016
Obama B (2016b) Remarks at opening session of the US-ASEAN Summit. White House, Rancho Mirage, 15 Feb 2016
Obama B (2016c) Remarks before US-ASEAN Meeting. White House, Vientiane, 8 Sept 2016
Obama B (2016d) Remarks to the people of Laos. White House, Vientiane, 6 Sept 2016
Obama B (2016e) Address to the people of Vietnam. White House, Hanoi, 24 May 2016
Paddock R (2016) Rodrigo Duterte, pushing split with US, counters Philippines’ deep ties. NYT, 26 Oct 2016
Panda A (2015) China’s HD-981 Oil rig returns, near disputed SCS waters. Diplomat, 27 June 2015
Pennekamp M (2016) When China and Vietnam went to war: four lessons for history. NI, 21 June 2016
Perlez J (2016) Rodrigo Duterte and Xi Jinping agree to reopen SCS Talks. NYT, 20 Oct 2016
Petty M (2014) Vietnam stops anti-China protests after riots, China evacuates workers. Reuters, Hanoi, 18 May 2014
Petty M, Gopalakrishnan R (2014) Vietnamese riot in industrial zones in anti-China protest. Reuters, Hanoi, 14 May 2014
Psaki J (2014) Press statement: Chinese oil rig operations near the Paracel Islands. DoS, Washington, 7 May 2014
Pubby M (2016) India firming up military ties with Vietnam. Economic Times (2 July 2016)
Qu A (1989) Chinese supporters in the operations to assist Vietnam and resist America. Junshi shilin (Circle of Military History), No. 6, p 40
Report (1992) Ramos is declared new president 6 weeks after Philippine election. NYT, 23 June 1992
Report (2016) Carter, New Japanese Defense Minister discuss changing security environment. DoD News, Washington, 16 Sept 2016
Rich M (2016) Rodrigo Duterte, in Japan, calls for US troops to exit Philippines in 2 years. NYT, 26 Oct 2016
Rodis R (2014) What did Estrada and Arroyo promise China? Inquirer, 21 Mar 2014
Romulo C, Acheson D (1951) Mutual defense treaty between the Republic of the Philippines and the USA. DoS, Washington, 30 Aug 1951
Rood S (2010) Examining the Arroyo legacy in the Philippines. Asia Foundation, New York, 7 Apr 2010
Roxas M, McNutt P (1946) Treaty of general relations between the Republic of the Philippines and the USA. Malacanan Palace, Manila, 4 July 1946
Ruwitch J, Linh N (2014) Chinese oil rig moved away from disputed waters off Vietnam. Reuters, Shanghai/Hanoi, 16 July 2014
Sa H (2016) Has Duterte killed the US-Philippine alliance? NI, 21 Sept 2016
Shi Y (1990) Mimi chubing yare conglin (Sending troops secretly to the sub-tropical jungles). PLA Literature Press, Beijing, pp 14–16
Shi Z (1993) Zhou Enlai de zhuoyue fengxian (Zhou Enlai’s outstanding contributions). CPC Central Academy, Beijing, p 286
Spetalnick M (2016) US lifts arms ban on old foe Vietnam as China tensions simmer. Reuters, Hanoi, 23 May 2016
State Council (1990) Zhou Enlai waijiao wenxuan (Selected diplomatic papers of Zhou Enlai). Central Press of Historical Documents, Beijing, pp 436–443
Stout D (2014) The last time China got into a fight with Vietnam, it was a disaster. Time, 15 May 2014
Sullivan M (2015) Ask the Vietnamese about war, and they think China, not the US. NPR, Morning Edition, 1 May 2015
Swaine M (2016) Chinese views on the SCS arbitration case between the PRC and the Philippines. CLM, No. 51, 30 Aug 2016, pp 3-5
Tanner G (2017) Cambodia wants China as its neighborhood bully. FP, 5 Jan 2017
Taruk P (2016) ASEAN Summit: Philippines signals less antagonistic approach with China over maritime dispute. CNN, 8 Sept 2016
Thayer C (2017a) Maritime disputes in the SCS: 2016 in review. Thayer Consultancy, Canberra, 24 Jan 2017
Thayer C (2017b) Vietnam and the SCS’s roiled waters. Thayer Consultancy, Canberra, 30 Jan 2017
Tillerson R (2017) Confirmation hearing. DoS, Washington, 11 Jan 2017
Tonnesson S (2015) 14 March 1988: East Asia’s last interstate battle. PRIO, Oslo, 24 July 2015
Torode G (2013) Spratly Islands dispute defines China-Vietnam relations 25 years after naval clash. SCMP, 17 Mar 2013
Tran Q, Obama B (2016) Joint statement. Hanoi, 24 May 2016
Tretiak D (1979) China’s Vietnam war and its consequences. China Quart 80 (December 1979): 753
Trung N, Vu T (2015) The real significance of the Japan-Vietnam strategic partnership. Diplomat, 16 Sept 2016
Tsvetov A (2015) Does Russia fit into the US-Vietnam equation? Diplomat, 14 July 2015
Van H (2014) Commemoration for 64 martyrs slaughtered by Chinese Navy in 1988 at Gac Ma Naval Battle. Wordpress, 11 Mar 2014
VNA (2016) Vietnam, Russia, step up defence ties. VoV, 23 Apr 2016
VNA (2017) Vietnam-China issue Joint Communique. VoV, 14 Jan 2017
Walcott S, Johnson C (eds) (2014) Eurasian corridors of interconnection: from the South China to the Caspian Sea. Routledge, New York, p 28
Wang D (Editor) (1989a) Dangdai Zhongguo kongjun (Contemporary Chinese Air Force). Chinese Social Science Press, Beijing, p 384
Wang D (1989b) Dangdai Zhongguo Kongjun (Chap. 17). Social Science Press, Beijing
Wang D (ed) (1989c) Dangdai Zhongguo Kongjun. Social Science Press, Beijing, p 392
Wang R (ed) (1992) Kongjun: huiyi shiliao (The Air Force: memoirs and reminiscences). PLA Press, Beijing, pp 559–560
White House (2016a) Joint statement of the US-ASEAN Special Leaders’ Summit: Sunnylands declaration. Sunnylands, 16 Feb 2016
White House (2016b) Remarks by President Obama and President Quang of Vietnam in joint press conference. Hanoi, 23 May 2016
White House (2016c) Joint statement: between the USA and the SRV. Hanoi, 23 May 2016
Wu S (2016) The SCS: China won’t accept cursory judgement of its inherent rights. ICAS, 25 June 2016
Xinhua (2016) Xi urges US to be ‘constructive’ in SCS. Hangzhou, 3 Sept 2016
Xinhua (2016a) Chinese leaders reject SCS arbitration award. Beijing, 12 July 2016
Xinhua (2016c) President Xi says China rejects any proposition, action based on SCS arbitration award. CRI, Beijing, 12 July 2016
Xinhua (2016d) Chinese premier stresses China’s stance on SCS issue. Vientiane, 9 Sept 2016
Xinhua (2016b) China refuses SCS arbitration award. Beijing, 12 July 2016
Xinhua (2016e) PLA Navy Chief urges China-US co-op in handling SCS. PD, 19 July 2016
Xinhua (2016f) Duterte says visit to China ‘signals a turning point in our shared history.’ PD, 22 Oct 2016
Xinhua (2017) President Xi extends good wishes in New Year speech. Beijing, 1 Jan 2017
Xiong X (1992) The prelude to the opening of Sino-American relations. Zhonggong dangshi ziliao 42(June 1992):56–96
Yang Y (2016) Press conference. MND, Beijing, 28 July 2016
Zhang S (1992) Deterrence and strategic culture: Chinese-American confrontations, 1949-1958, Chap. 8. Cornell University, Ithaca
Zhang X (1996) The Vietnam War, 1964-1969: a Chinese perspective. J Military Hist 60(4):736–737
Zhang T (2016) Rear admiral: US B-1 strategic bomber in SCS no worry. China Mil, 12 Aug 2016
Zhang J (2017) President Xi extends good wishes in New Year speech. Xinhua, Beijing, 1 Jan 2017
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2017 Springer International Publishing AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Ali, S.M. (2017). Strategic Triangles: US-China-ASEAN Insecurity Histronics. In: US-Chinese Strategic Triangles. Global Power Shift. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-57747-0_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-57747-0_6
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-57746-3
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-57747-0
eBook Packages: Political Science and International StudiesPolitical Science and International Studies (R0)