Abstract
Insanity is a distinctive element of criminal law because it brings together two very different disciplines, psychiatry and psychology on the one hand and the law on the other. It might strongly benefit from the introduction of structural neuroimaging, that, however, had so far a limited translational impact. Brain imaging purports to demonstrate functional status and thereby it can be useful to provide a scientific explanation for the clinical symptoms strenghtening the medico-legal reasoning. Despite international cases using brain imaging to support diminished responsibility, in Italy there are still a lot of controversies.
Is the neuroscientific logic deterministic? How may the classic psychiatric/neurologic examination and neuroscientific evidence work side by side? Are the symptoms not legally relevant really not relevant? Could the study of the brain inform the clinical diagnosis? Could the study of the brain inform the expert opinion on responsibility and insanity?
In this chapter, we describe the cognitive and behavioral profile of a defendant charged with murder, as well as his brain imaging correlates. Through the analysis of this real forensic case, we address the above questions and conclude that neuroscience may strengthen the results of psychiatric evaluations, thus reducing uncertainty in the forensic settings. We claim that besides the clinical diagnosis, the study of the brain allows a better understanding of the individual acts.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
- 1.
See Scarpazza et al. (2018a).
- 2.
See Scarpazza and De Simone (2016).
- 3.
See Orrù et al. (2012).
- 4.
- 5.
Kim et al. (2015).
- 6.
Reeves et al. (2003).
- 7.
See Scarpazza et al. (2018a).
- 8.
Reeves et al. (2003).
- 9.
Appelbaum (2015).
- 10.
Fornari and Galliani (2003).
- 11.
Scarpazza et al. (2016).
- 12.
- 13.
- 14.
- 15.
Scarpazza et al. (2018b).
- 16.
- 17.
- 18.
Camperio Ciani et al. (2019).
- 19.
Bogousslavsky and Boller (2005).
- 20.
Bogousslavsky and Boller (2005).
- 21.
Fazel et al. (2018).
- 22.
Ikram et al. (2016).
- 23.
MacNalty (1952).
- 24.
Chalmers and Chaloner (2009).
- 25.
Ikram et al. (2016).
- 26.
- 27.
Vernooij et al. (2007).
- 28.
- 29.
- 30.
- 31.
Wester (2008).
- 32.
Debnath et al. (2016).
- 33.
Scarpazza et al. (2018b).
- 34.
- 35.
- 36.
- 37.
Franzen and Iverson (2011).
- 38.
Hays et al. (2000).
- 39.
Vernooij et al. (2007).
References
Appelbaum PS (2015) Law & psychiatry: through a glass darkly: functional neuroimaging evidence enters the courtroom. Psychiatr Serv 1:21–23
Bahk WM, Pae CU, Chae JH, Jun TY, Kim KS (2002) A case of brief psychosis associated with an arachnoid cyst. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 56(2):203–205
Baquero GA, Molero P, Pla J, Ortuno F (2014) A schizophrenia-like psychotic disorder secondary to an arachnoid cyst remitted with neurosurgical treatment of the cyst. Open Neuroimag J 8:1–4
Baum ML (2013) The monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) genetic predisposition to impulsive violence: is it relevant to criminal trials? Neuroethics 6:287–306
Bogousslavsky J, Boller F (2005) Neurological disorders in famous artists. Frontiers of neurology and neuroscience. Karger, Basel
Camperio Ciani AS, Scarpazza C, Covelli V, Battaglia U (2019) Profiling acquired pedophilic behavior: retrospective analysis of 66 Italian forensic cases of pedophilia. Int J Law Psychiatry 67:101508. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijlp.2019.101508
Chalmers CR, Chaloner EJ (2009) 500 years later: Henry VIII, leg ulcers and the course of history. J R Soc Med 102(12):514–517
da Silva JA, Alves A, Talina M, Carreiro S, Guimaraes J, Xavier M (2007) Arachnoid cyst in a patient with psychosis: case report. Ann Gen Psychiatry 6:16
Debnath J, Ravikumar R, Sharma V, Senger KP, Maurya V, Singh G, Sharma P, Khera A, Singh A (2016) ‘Empty sella’ on routine MRI studies: an incidental finding or otherwise? Med J Armed Forces India 72(1):33–37
Duncan J, Seitz RJ, Kolodny J, Bor D, Herzog H, Ahmed A, Newell FN, Emslie H (2000) A neural basis for general intelligence. Science 289(5478):457–460
Farisco M, Petrini C (2012) The impact of neuroscience and genetics on the law: a recent Italian case. Neuroethics 5:317–319
Fazel S, Smith EN, Chang Z, Geddes JR (2018) Risk factors for interpersonal violence: an umbrella review of meta-analyses. Br J Psychiatry 213(4):609–614
Ferentinos PP, Kontaxakis VP, Havaki-Kontaxaki BJ, Paplos KG, Pappa DA, Soldatos CR (2007) Refractory psychosis and prominent cognitive deficits in a patient with mega-cisterna magna. Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 31(2):561–563
Fornari U, Galliani I (2003) Il caso giudiziario di Gianfranco Stevanin. Torino Centro Scientifico Editore
Forzano F, Borry P, Cambon-Thomsen A, Hodgson SV, Tibben A, de Vries P, van El C, Cornel M (2010) Italian appeal court: a genetic predisposition to commit murder? Eur J Hum Genet 18(5):519–521
Franzen MD, Iverson GL (2011) Detecting negative responses bias and diagnosis malingering: the dissimulation exam 26:81–88
Gilbert F, Focquaert F (2015) Rethinking responsibility in offenders with acquired paedophilia: punishment or treatment? Int J Law Psychiatry 38:51–60
Gjerde PB, Schmid M, Hammar A, Wester K (2013) Intracranial arachnoid cysts: impairment of higher cognitive functions and postoperative improvement. J Neurodev Disord 5(1):21
Gundersen H, Helland CA, Raeder MB, Hugdahl K, Wester K (2007) Visual attention in patients with intracranial arachnoid cysts. J Neurol 254(1):60–66
Hays JR, Emmons J, Stallings G (2000) Dementia and mental retardation markers on the Rey 15-item visual memory test. Psychol Rep 86(1):179–182
Hughes V (2010) Science in court: head case. Nature 464(7287):340–342
Husted DS, Myers WC, Lui Y (2008) The limited role of neuroimaging in determining criminal liability: an overview and case report. Forensic Sci Int 179(1):e9–e15
Ikram MQ, Sajjad FH, Salardini A (2016) The head that wears the crown: Henry VIII and traumatic brain injury. J Clin Neurosci 28:16–19
Kim J, Boytos A, Seong Y, Park K (2015) The influence of biomedical information and childhood history on sentencing. Behav Sci Law 33(6):815–826
Langarica M, Peralta V (2005) Psychosis associated to megacisterna magna. An Sist Sanit Navar 28(1):119–121
MacNalty AS (1952) Henry VIII: a difficult patient. Christopher Johnson Publishers, London
Mironov A, John S, Auerbach J, Jamaleddine G (2014) Acute onset of psychosis in a patient with a left temporal lobe arachnoid cyst. Case Rep Med. 204025
Mohnke S, Muller S, Amelung T, Kruger TH, Ponseti J, Schiffer B, Walter M, Beier KM, Walter H (2014) Brain alterations in paedophilia: a critical review. Prog Neurobiol 122:1–23
Orrù G, Pettersson-Yeo W, Marquand AF, Sartori G, Mechelli A (2012) Using support vector machine to identify imaging biomarkers of neurological and psychiatric disease: a critical review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 36(4):1140–1152
Pandurangi S, Pandurangi A, Matkar A, Shetty N, Patil P (2014) Psychiatric manifestations associated with mega cisterna magna. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci 26(2):169–171
Papazisis G, Mastrogianni A, Karastergiou A (2007) Early-onset schizophrenia and obsessive-compulsive disorder in a young man with Dandy-Walker variant. Schizophr Res 93(1–3):403–405
Reeves D, Mills MJ, Billick SB, Brodie JD (2003) Limitations of brain imaging in forensic psychiatry. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 31(1):89–96
Reznek L (2005) The Rey 15-item memory test for malingering: a meta-analysis. Brain Inj 19(7):539–543
Rigoni D, Pellegrini S, Mariotti V, Cozza A, Mechelli A, Ferrara SD, Pietrini P, Sartori G (2010) How neuroscience and behavioral genetics improve psychiatric assessment: report on a violent murder case. Front Behav Neurosci 4:160
Rojas-Burke J (1993) PET scans advance as tool in insanity defense. J Nucl Med 34(1):13N–16N, 25N–26N
Sartori G, Scarpazza C, Codognotto S, Pietrini P (2016) An unusual case of acquired pedophilic behavior following compression of orbitofrontal cortex and hypothalamus by a Clivus Chordoma. J Neurol 263(7):1454–1455
Scarpazza C, De Simone MS (2016) Voxel-based morphometry: current perspectives. Neurosci Neuroecon 5:19–35
Scarpazza C, Sartori G, De Simone MS, Mechelli A (2013) When the single matters more than the group: very high false positive rates in single case voxel based morphometry. Neuroimage 70:175–188
Scarpazza C, Tognin S, Frisciata S, Sartori G, Mechelli A (2015) False positive rates in voxel-based morphometry studies of the human brain: should we be worried? Neurosci Biobehav Rev 52:49–55
Scarpazza C, Nichols TE, Seramondi D, Maumet C, Sartori G, Mechelli A (2016) When the single matters more than the Group (II): addressing the problem of high false positive rates in single case voxel based morphometry using non-parametric statistics. Front Neurosci 10:6
Scarpazza C, Ferracuti S, Miolla A, Sartori G (2018a) The charm of structural neuroimaging in insanity evaluations: guidelines to avoid misinterpretation of the findings. Transl Psychiatry 8(1):227
Scarpazza C, Pellegrini S, Pietrini P, Sartori G (2018b) The role of neuroscience in the evaluation of mental insanity: on the controversies in Italy. Neuroethics 11:83–95
Scarpazza C, Pennati A, Sartori G (2018c) Mental insanity assessment of pedophilia: the importance of the trans-disciplinary approach. Reflections on two cases. Front Neurosci 12:335
Scurich N, Appelbaum PS (2017) Behavioral genetics in criminal court. Nat Hum Behav 1:772–774
Smith GP, Burger GK (1997) Detection of malingering: validation of the structured inventory of malingered symptomatology (SIMS). J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 25(2):183–189
Thompson PM, Cannon TD, Narr KL, van Erp T, Poutanen VP, Huttunen M, Lonnqvist J, Standertskjold-Nordenstam CG, Kaprio J, Khaledy M et al (2001) Genetic influences on brain structure. Nat Neurosci 4(12):1253–1258
Turan T, Besirli A, Asdemir A, Ozsoy S, Esel E (2010) Manic episode associated with mega cisterna magna. Psychiatry Investig 7(4):305–307
Turone F (2011) Medical tests help reduce sentence of woman accused of murder. Br Med J 343:d5761
Vakis AF, Koutentakis DI, Karabetsos DA, Kalostos GN (2006) Psychosis-like syndrome associated with intermittent intracranial hypertension caused by a large arachnoid cyst of the left temporal lobe. Br J Neurosurg 20(3):156–159
van Impelen A, Merckelbach H, Jelicic M, Merten T (2014) The structured inventory of malingered symptomatology (SIMS): a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Neuropsychol 28(8):1336–1365
Vernooij MW, Ikram MA, Tanghe HL, Vincent AJ, Hofman A, Krestin GP, Niessen WJ, Breteler MM, van der Lugt A (2007) Incidental findings on brain MRI in the general population. N Engl J Med 357(18):1821–1828
Wester K (2008) Intracranial arachnoid cysts–do they impair mental functions? J Neurol 255(8):1113–1120
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2020 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Sartori, G., Orrù, G., Scarpazza, C. (2020). The Methodology of Forensic Neuroscience. In: D’Aloia, A., Errigo, M.C. (eds) Neuroscience and Law. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-38840-9_22
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-38840-9_22
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-38839-3
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-38840-9
eBook Packages: Law and CriminologyLaw and Criminology (R0)