Abstract
Wenderoth and O’Connor (1987b) reported that, although matches to the straight edge of two triangles placed apex to apex revealed an apparent bending in the direction of the chevron formed by the hypotenuse pair (the Bourdon effect), no perceptual unbending of the bent chevron occurred. Using subjective contour figures, Walker and Shank (1988b) found large and approximately equal bending and unbending effects, consistent with two theories that they proposed. In Experiment 1, using adjustable chevron matching and subjective contours, we found that Bourdon effects, equivalent in magnitude to those reported by Walker and Shank, were 4–5 times larger than unbending effects. In Experiment 2, we used a variation of Walker and Shank’s measurement technique, in which subjects selected a matching angle from a graded series. We obtained Bourdon effects similar to those in Experiment 1, but much larger unbending effects. Nevertheless, Bourdon effects were significantly larger than unbending effects in one set of data; and in another, Bourdon test means were larger than unbending test means. In both data sets, there was a large and significant pretest bending effect, which enhanced the magnitude of unbending test minus pretest scores. These results were consistent with our theory but not the theories of Walker and Shank. The variance of unbending test matches, 3–4 times that of Bourdon test matches, reflected the task difficulty. We propose that subjective obtuse angle contraction that exceeds real obtuse angle contraction explains the fact that unbending effects are larger in subjective than in real contours.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Carpenter, R. H. S. &Blakemore, C. (1973). Interactions between orientations in human visionExperimental Brain Research,18, 287–303
Harris, J. P. &Calvert, J. E. (1985) The tilt after-effect. Changes with stimulus size and eccentricity.Spatial Vision,1, 113–129
Howard, I. P. (1982)Human visual orientation. New York: Wiley
O’toole, B. &Wenderoth, P. (1977) The tilt illusion Repulsion and attraction effects in the oblique meridian.Vision Research,17, 367–374.
Paradiso, M. A., Shimojo, S., &Nakayama, K. (1989) Subjective contours, tilt aftereffects, and visual cortical organizationVision Research,29. 1205–1213
Rozvany, G. I. N., &Day, R. H. (1980) Determinants of the Bourdon effectPerception & Psychophysics,28. 39–44
Vogels, R., &Orban, G. A. (1987) Illusory contour orientation determinationVision Research.27, 453–467.
Von Der Heydt, R., &Peterhans, S. (1989) Mechanisms of contour perception in monkey visual cortex I Lines of Pattern discontinuityJournal of Neuroscience,9, 1731–1748
Walker, J. T. &Shank, M. D. (1987) The Bourdon illusion in subjective contoursPerception & Psychophysics.42, 15–24
Walker, J. T., &Shank, M. D. (1988a) Interactions between real and subjective contours in the Bourdon illusionPerception & Psychophysics,43, 567–574
Walker J. T., &Shank, M. D. (1988b) Real and subjective lines and edges in the Bourdon illusionPerception & Psychophysics.43. 475–484
Wallace, G. K., &Crampin, D. J. (1969) The effect of background density on the Zollner illusionVision Research,9, 167–177.
Wenderoth, P. (1990)The basis of the Bourdon illusion Manuscript submitted for publication
Wenderoth, P., &Johnstone, S. (1987) Possible neural substrates for orientation analysis and perceptionPerception.16, 693–709
Wenderoth, P. &O’connor, T. (1987a) The effects of display and observer strategy variables on Bourdon assimilation illusionsPerception,16, 79–88
Wenderoth, P., &O’connor, T. (1987b) Outline-and solid-angle orientation illusions have different determinantsPerception & Psychophysics,41, 45–52
Wenderoth, P., O’connor, T., &Johnson, M. (1986a). Expansion and contraction of outline and solid acute angles: Effects of angle magnitude, type of display, and the nature of the matching taskPerception & Psychophysics,39, 261–266
Wenderoth, P., O’connor, T., &Johnson, M. (1986b). The tilt illusion as a function of the relative and absolute lengths of test and inducing lines.Perception & Psychophysics,39, 339–345
Wenderoth, P., &White, D. (1979). Angle-matching illusions and perceived line orientationPerception,8. 565–575.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
This research was supported by Australian Research Council Grant A78831871 to the first author.
The experimental program was based on one originally written by Tony O’Connor. Two unknown referees were extremely helpful in commenting on earlier versions of the manuscript; and Christopher Tyler suggested using subjective contour displays formed in concentric circles.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wenderoth, P., Criss, G. & Van Der Zwan, R. Determinants of subjective contour: Bourdon illusions and “unbending” effects. Perception & Psychophysics 48, 497–508 (1990). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03211594
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03211594