Abstract
The number of women in medicine is increasing. There is evidence that women practice in different ways than men; are interested in different aspects of medicine; work fewer hours; and receive less pay for equivalent hours than men. Women are also less likely to be represented in the higher echelons of power within academic medicine. Women’s carrers are adversely affected by pregnancy, childcare, family responsibilities, and gender role conflict although there is evidence that this does not need to be the case. This article reviews the current literature on gender differences in medicine and makes recommendations to ensure women have a voice to determine their place in medicine in the future. The positive changes that women bring to medicine are highlighted and the barriers for women in the profession are outlined.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Abele, A. E., & Nitzsche, U.. 2002. “A Scissors-Effect in Career Development of Female and Male Medical Doctors.” Dtsch Med Wochenschr 4., 127 (40): 2057–62.
American Medical Association. 1997. AMA Women in Medicine Data Source. Chicago, IL. and Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Center for Health Statistics.
Ariouni, A.J., & Rich, E.C., 2002. “Physician Gender and Patient Care.” Journal of Gender Specific Medicine, 6(1): 24–30.
Association of American Medical Colleges. 2003. “Women in U.S. Academic Medicine Statistics, 1998–1999.” Washington D.C.
Bianchi, S.M.. 2000. “Maternal Employment and Time with Children: Dramatic Change or Surprising Continuity?” Demography, 37 (4): 401–14.
Bickel, J., Clark, V., & Marshall, L.R.. 1999. “Women in U.S. Academic Medicine Statistics, 1998–1999.” Washington, D.C.:, Association of American Medical Colleges.
Bolton, G.. 2003. “Medicine, the Arts and the Humanities.” The Lancet, 362 (9378): 93–94.
Brody, H.. 1993. “Why Can't a Man be More Like a Woman?” Journal American Board of Family Practice 6(1): 82–83.
Cain, J.M., Schulkin, J., Parisi, V., Power, M.L., Holzman, G.B., & Williams, S. 2001. “Effects of Perceptions and Mentorship, on Pursuing a Career in Academic Medicine in Obstetrics and Gynecology.” Academic Medicine 76(6): 628–34.
Carling, P.C., Hayward, K., Coakley, E.H., & Wolf, A.M. 1999. “Part-Time Residency Training Internal Medicine: Analysis of a Ten-Year Experience.” Academic Medicine, 74: 282–84.
Carr, P.L., Ash, A., Friedman, R.H., Scaramucci, A., Barnett, R.C., Szalacha L., Palepu, A., & Moskowitz, M.A. 1998. “Relation of Family Responsibilities and Gender to the Productivity and Career Satisfaction of Medical Faculty.” Annals of Internal Medicine, 29(7): 532–38.
Carr, P.L., Ash, A.S., Friedman, R.H., Szalacha, L., Barnett, R.C., Palepu, A., & Moskowitz, M.A. 2000. “Faculty Perceptions of Gender Discrimination and Sexual Harassment in Academic Medicine.” Annals of Internal Medicine,” 132(11): 889–96.
Carr, P.L., Gareis, K.C., & Barnett, R.C. 2003. “Characteristics and Outcomes for Women Physicians Who Work Reduced Hours.” Journal of Women's Health 12(4): 399–405.
Carty, S.E., Colson, Y.L., Garvey, L.S., Schuchert, V.D., Schwentker, A., Tzeng, E., Corcoran, N.A., Simmons, R.L., Webster, M.W., & Timothy R. Billiar 2002. “Maternity Policy and Practice during Surgery Residency: How We Do It.” Surgery, 132: 682–88.
Charon, R., Greene, M., & Adelman, R. 1994. “Woman Readers, Women Doctors: A Feminist Read Response Theory for Medicine.” In More, E.S., & Mulligan, M.A. (eds) The Empathic Practitioner: Empathy, Gender, and Medicine. New Brunswick, NJ: University of Rutgers Press.
Cydulka, R.K., D'Onofrio, G., Schneider, S., Emerman, C.L., Sullivan, L.M., & the SAEM Women and Minorities Task Force 2000. “Women in Academic Emergency Medicine.” Academic Emergency Medicine, 7(9): 999–1007.
Cypress, B.K. 1983. “Patterns of Ambulatory Care in General and Family Practice: The National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey.” Department of Health and Human Services Publication no. (PHS) 83–1734.
Davison, H.K. 2002. “The Paradox of the Contented Female Worker: A Revision and Test of the Theories.” Dissertation-Abstracts-International: Section-B: The Sciences-and-Engineering, 62(9-B): 42–58.
Day, S.C., Norcini, J.J., Shea, J.A., & Benson, J.A.. 1989. “Gender Differences in the Clinical Competence of Residents in Internal Medicine.” Journal of General Internal Medicine, 4: 309–12.
de Arellano, Ramirez. 1990. “Pink-Collar” Medicine: Implications of the Feminization of the Profession. P R Health Sci. J. 9(1): 21–24.
Delgado, A., Lopez-Fernandez, L.A., & Luna, J.D. 1993. “Influence of the Doctor's Gender in the Satisfaction of the Users.” Medical Care Research and Review, 31: 795–800.
Dinnerstein, D. 1976. The Mermaid and the Minotaur: Sexual Arrangements and Human Malaise. New York: HarperCollins.
Dresler, C.M., Padgett, D.I., MacKinnon, S.E., & Patterson, A.G. 1996. “Experiences of Women in Cardiothoracic Surgender Comparison.” Archives of Surgery, 131(11): 1128–34.
Dufort, F., & Maheux, B., 1995. “When Female Medical Students Are the Majority: Do Numbers Really Make a Difference?” Journal American Medical Women's Association, 50(1): 4–6.
Eagly, A.H., & Karau, S.J. 2002. “Role Congruity Theory of Prejudice toward Female Leaders.” Psychological Review, 109: 573–98.
Finch, S.J., 2003. “Pregnancy during Residency: A Literature Review.” Academic Medicine, 78(4):418–28.
Frank, E., Brogan, D., & Schiffman, M. 1998. “Prevalence and Correlates of Harassment among Women Physicians.” Archives of Internal Medicine, 23(158): 352–58.
Frank, E., & Dingle, A.D. 1999. “Self-Reported Depression and Suicide Attempts among U.S. Women Physicians.” American Journal of Psychiatry, 156(12): 1887–94.
Frank, E., Harvey, L., & Elon, L. 2000. “Family Responsibilities and Domestic Activities of U.S. Women Physicians.” Arch Fam Med., 9: 134–40.
Frank, E., McMurray, J.E., Linzer, M., & Elon, L. 1999. “Career Statisfaction of U.S. Women Physicians: Results from the Women Physicians' Health Study. Society of General Internal Medicine Career Satisfaction Study Group.” Arch Intern Med. 12, 159 (13): 1417–26.
Fried, L.P., Francomano C.A., MacDonald, S.M., Wagner, E.M., E.J. Stokes, E.J., Carbone, K.M., Bias, W.B., Newman, M.M. & Stobod, J.D. 1996. “Career Development for Women in Academic Medicine: Multiple Interventions in a Department of Medicine.” JAMA, 2761: 898–905.
Fritz, N.E., & Lantos, J.D. 1991. “Pediatrician's Practice Choices: Differences between Full—and Part-Time Practice.” Pediatrics, 88: 764–69
Gjerberg, E. 2002. “Gender Similarities in Doctors' Preferences—and Gender Differences in Final Specialization.” Social Science and Medicine, 54(4): 591–605.
Hall, J.A., Irish, J.T., Roter, D.L., Ehrlich, C.M., & Miller, L.H.. 1994. “Gender in Medical Encounter: An Analysis of Physician and Patient Communication in a Primary Care Setting.” Health Psychology, 13(5): 384–92.
Hitchcock, M.A., Bland, C.J., Hekelmanand, F.P., & Blumenthal, M.G.. 1995. “Professional Networking: The Influence of Colleagues on the Academic Success of Faculty.” Academic Medicine 70: 1108–16.
Hojat, M., Gonnella, J.S., & Xu, G. 1995. “Gender Comparisons of Young Physicians' Perceptions of Their Medical Education, Professional Life, and Practice: A Follow-Up Study of Jefferson Medical College Graduates.” Academic Medicine, 70(4): 305–12.
Jones, B.J., Arnold, L., Xu, G., & Epstein, L.C.. 2000. “Differences in the Preparation and Practice of Male and Female Physicians from Combined Baccalaureate-MD Degree Programs.” Journal American Medical Women's Association, 55(1): 29–31.
Kamei, R., Chen, C., & Helen Loeser. 2004. “Residency is Not a Race: Our Ten-Year Experience with Flexible Residency Training Option.” Academic Medicine, 79: 447–52.
Klass, Perri. 1990. Other Women's Children. Random House.
Klebanoff, M.A., Shiono, P.H., & Rhoads, G.G.. 1990. “Outcomes of Pregnancy in a National Sample of Women Physicians.” New England Journal of Medicine, 323 (15): 1040–45.
— 1991. “Spontaneous and Induced Abortions among Resident Physicians.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 265: 2821–25.
Kletke, P.R., Marder, W.D., and Silberger, A.B.. 1990. “The Growing Proportion of Female Physicians: Implications for U.S. Physician Supply.” American Journal of Public Health 80(3): 300–04
Komaromy, M., Bindman, A.B., Haber, R.J., & Sande, M.A., 1993. “Sexual Harassment in Medical Education.” New England Journal of Medicine, 328(5): 322–26.
Levinson, W., Kaufman, K., & Bickel, J. 1993. “Part-Time Faculty in Academic Medicine: Present Status and Future Challenges.” Annals of Internal Medicine, 119: 220–25.
Levy-Shiff, R. 1999. “Fathers Cognitive Appraisals, Coping Strategies and Support Resources as Correlates of Adjustment to Parenthod.” Journal of Family Psychology, 13(4): 554–67.
Limacher, M., Zaher, C.A., Walsh, M.N., Wolf, W.J., Douglas, P.S., Schwartz, J.B., Wright, J.S., & Bodycombe, D.P. 1998. “The ACC Professional Life Survey: Career Decisions of Women and Men in Cardiology.” Journal of American College of Cardiology, 32: 827–35.
Lorber, J. 1984. Women Physicians: Career, Status, and Power New York, NY: Tavistock Publications.
Mayer, K. L., Ho, H.S., & Goodnight Jr., J.E. 2001. “Childbearing and Child Care in Surgery.” Archives of Surgery, 136(6): 649–55.
McGuire, L.K., Bergen, M.R., & Polan, M.L. 2004. “Career Advancement for Women Faculty in a U.S. School of Medicine: Perceived Needs.” Academic Medicine, 79: 319–25.
McMurray, J.E., Angus, G., Cohen, M., Gavel, P., Harding, J., Horvath, J., Paice, E.J., Schmittdiel, J., & Grumbach, K. 2002. “Women in Medicine: A Four-Nation Comparison.” Journal American Medical Women's Association, 57(4): 185–90.
McMurray, J.E., Linzer, M., Konrad, T.R., Douglas, J., Shugerman, R., & Nelson, K. 2000. “The Work Lives of Women Physicians.” Journal of General Internal Medicine, 15: 372–80.
Meeuwesen, L., Schaap, C., & Cees Van der Staak. 1991. “Verbal Analysis of Doctor-Patient Communication.” Social Science and Medicine, 32: 1143–50.
Mizgala, C.L., MacKinnon, S.E., Walters, B.C., Ferris, L.E., McNeill, I.Y., & Knighton, T. 1993. “Women Surgeons. Results of the Canadian Population Study.” Annals of Surgery, 218(1): 37–46.
Myerson, S. 1997. “Seven Women GP's Perception of Their Stresses and the Impact of These on Their Professional and Private Lives.” Journal of Management in Medicine, 11(1): 8–14.
Neittaanmaki, L., Gross, E.B., Virjo, I., Hyppola, H., & Kumpusalo, E. 1999. “Personal Values of Male and Female Doctors: Gender Aspects.” Social Science and Medicine, 48(4): 559–68.
Nora, L.M., McLaughlin, M.A., Fosson, S.E., Jacob, S.K., Schmidt, J.L., & Witzke, D.B. 1996. “Does Exposure to Gender Discrimination and Sexual Harassment Impact Medical Students' Specialty Choices and Residency Program Selections?” Academic Medicine, 71 (10): S22–24.
Nora, L.M., McLaughlin, M.A., Fosson, S.E., Stratton, T.D., Murphy-Spencer, A., Fincher, R.-M.E., German, D.C., Seiden, D., & Witzke, D.B. 2002. “Gender Discrimination and Sexual Harassment in Medical Education: Perspectives Gained by a 14-School Study.” Academic Medicine, 7(12): 1226–34.
Phelan, Jo. 1994. “The Paradox of the Contented Female Worker: An Assessment of Alternative Explanations.” Social Psychology Quarterly, 57(2): 95–107.
Potee, R.A., Berber, A.J., & Ickovics, J.R. 1999. “Medicine and Motherhood: Shifting Trends among Female Physicians from 1922 to 1999.” Academic Medicine 74(8): 911–19
Richman J.A., Flaherty, J., Rospenda, K.M., & Christensen, M.L. 1982. “Mental Health Consequences and Correlates of Reported Medical Student Abuse.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 267: 629–94.
Robinson, G.E. 2003. “Stresses on Women Physicians: Consequences and Coping Techniques.” Depress Anxiety, 17(3): 180–89.
Roter, D.L., & Hall, J.A. 1992. Doctors Talking with Patients/Patients Talking with Doctors: Improving Communication in Medical Visits. Westport: Auburn House.
—2004. “Physician Gender and Patient-Centered Communication: A Critical Review of Empirical Research.” Annual Rev Public Health, 25: 497–519.
Roter, D.L., Lipkin, M., & Korsgaard, A. 1991. “Gender Difference in Patient's and Physicians' Communication during Primary Care Medical Visits. Medical Care, 29: 1083–93.
Sandler, B.R., Silverberg, L.A., & Hall, R. 1995. “The Chilly Classroom Climate: A Guide to Improve the Education of Women.” Washington, D.C.: National Association of Women in Education.
Scadron, A., Witte, M.H., Axelrod, E.A., Greenberg, C.A., & Meitz, J.E.G. 1982. “Attitudes towards Women Physicians in Medical Academia.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 247: 2803–07.
Scherzer, E., & Freedman, J. 2000. “Physician Unions: Organizing Women in the Year.” JAMWA 55 (1): 16–19.
Seltzer, V.L. 1999. “Changes and Challenges for Women in Academic Obstetrics and Gynecology.” American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 180: 837–48.
Sheehan, K.H., Sheehan, D.V., White, K., Leibowitz, A., & Baldwin, D.C. 1990. “A Pilot Study of Medical Student ‘Abuse.’ Student Perceptions of Mistreatment and Misconduct in Medical School.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 263(4): 533–37.
Shelton, B.A. 1992. “Women, Men, and Time: Gender Differences in Paid Work, Housework and Leisure.” New York, NY: Greenwood Press.
Sidanius, J.H., & Pratto, F. 1999. “Social Dominance: An Intergroup Theory of Social Hierarchy and Oppression.” New York: Cambridge University Press.
Silver, H., & Glicken, A.D. 1990. “Medical Student Abuse: Incidence, Severity, and Significance.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 263(4): 527–32.
Slomski, A.J. 2000. “Parenting, the Hardest Happiest Job of All.” Medical Economics 9: 83–100.
Socolar, Rebecca R.S., & Kelman, L.S. 2004. “Part-Time Faculty in Academic Pediatrics, Family Medicine, and Surgery: The Views of the Chairs.” Ambulatory Pediatrics, 2(5): 406–413.
Socolar, R.R.S., Kelman, L.S., Lannon, C.M., & Lohr, J.A. 2000. “Institutional Policies of U.S. Medical Schools Regarding Tenure, Promotion, and Benefits for Part-Time Faculty.” Academic Med 75(8): 846–9.
Sonnert, G., & Holton, G. 1996. “Career Patterns of Women and Men in the Sciences.” American Scientist, 84: 63–71.
Taragin, M.I., Wilczek, A.P., Karns, E., Trout, R., & Carson, J.L. 1992. “Physician Demographics and the Risk of Medical Malpractice.” American Journal of Medicine, 93: 537–42.
Uhlenberg, P., & Cooney, T.M. 1990. “Male and Female Physicians: Family and Career Comparisons.” Social Science and Medicine, 30(3): 373–78.
Wallace, A.E., & Weeks, W.B. 2002. “Differences in Income between Male and Female Primary Care Physicians.” Journal American Medical Women's Association, 57(4): 180–84.
Warde, C., Allen, W., & Gelberg, L. 1996. “Physician Role Conflict and Resulting Career Changes. Gender and Generational Differences.” Journal of General Internal Medicine, 1(12): 729–35.
Wear, D., & Castellan, B. 2002. “Motherhood & Medicine: The Experience of Double Consciousness.” Annals of Behavioral Science and Medical Education, 8(2): 92–96.
Wenneras, C.H., & Wold, A. 1997. “Nepotism and Sexism in Peer Review.” Science, 341, 387.
Wood, W., & Eagly, A.H. 2002. “A Cross-Cultural Analysis of the Behavior of Women and Men: Implications for the Origins of Sex Differences.” PsychologicalBulletin 128: 699–727.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
She received her medical degree from Glasgow University and her psychiatric training in Edinburgh, Scotland; Kingston, Jamaica; and Brown University in Providence, Rhode Island. She may be reached at aheru@butler.org.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Heru, A.M. Pink-collar medicine: Women and the future of medicine. Gend. Issues 22, 20–34 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12147-005-0008-0
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12147-005-0008-0