Abstract
This paper outlines the general characteristics of customary sea tenure (CST) in Oceania and identifies areas in which these characteristics overlap with modern rights-based fisheries management systems such as ITQs and CDQs. It also examines the effectiveness of CST regimes at regulating marine resource use and access by focusing on a particular case from the Solomon Islands. The institutional robustness or vulnerability of CST is assessed by examining various performance criteria for two communities in the Roviana Lagoon, Western Solomons. These criteria include people’s (1) settlement patterns in relation to their property, (2) cultural consensus, (3) cultural attitudes with regard to governance and management, and (4) fishing efforts and yields. The results show that a number of historical processes have shaped CST systems into heterogeneous and dynamic institutions, and that CST regimes can vary even on small geographical scales. Understanding the circumstances in which CST regimes are more likely to be successful has facilitated the design and implementation of co-management fishery prescriptions (MPAs) for protecting particular species and habitats in the region. More generally, the paper proposes that by discerning the effectiveness of local governance institutions at regulating resource use and access – taking into consideration that these are embedded in particular historical and political contexts – we can better predict whether or not an introduced fishery management system will work. This knowledge can also assist in designing hybrid management schemes that cross-fertilize community-based management, modern rights-based fishery management (e.g., ITQs and CDQs), and other government regulations. This integration is particularly relevant when these policies are to be implemented in coastal communities that have or have had traditional rights-based fishery management systems of their own and/or are more socio-culturally homogeneous. Given the long history of failed fishery management, it is now of vital importance to design innovative fishery management prescriptions that integrate natural and social science research more comprehensively.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
J.M. Acheson (2003) Capturing the Commons: Devising Institutions to Manage the Maine Lobster Industry University Press of New England Layfayette, NH 320
J.M. Acheson R. Gardner (2004) ArticleTitleStrategies, conflict, and the emergence of territoriality: the case of the Maine lobster industry Am. Anthropol. 106 296–307 Occurrence Handle10.1525/aa.2004.106.2.296
J.M. Acheson J.A. Wilson (1996) ArticleTitleOrder out of chaos: the case for parametric fisheries management Am. Anthropol. 98 579–594
T.J. Adams (1998) ArticleTitleThe interface between traditional and modern methods of fishery management in the Pacific Islands Ocea. Coast. Man. 40 127–142
T.J. Adams P. Dalzell S. Roberts (1997) South Pacific Commission and Forum Agency Workshop on the Management of South Pacific Inshore Fisheries South Pacific Commission Noumea
T. Akimichi (1978) ArticleTitleThe ecological aspect of Lau (Solomon Islands) ethnoichthyology J. Polynes. Soc. 87 301–326
E.H. Allison (2001) ArticleTitleBig laws, small catches: global ocean governance and the fisheries crisis J. Int. Dev. 13 933–950 Occurrence Handle10.1002/jid.834
S. Aswani (1997) ArticleTitleTroubled waters in South-western New Georgia, Solomon Islands. Is codification of the commons a viable avenue for resource use regularisation? Trad. Mar. Res. Man. Know. Infor. Bull. 8 2–16
S. Aswani (1998) ArticleTitlePatterns of marine harvest effort in SW New Georgia, Solomon Islands: Resource management or optimal foraging? Ocea. Coast. Manage. 40 207–235
S. Aswani (1999) ArticleTitleCommon property models of sea tenure: a case study from Roviana and Vonavona Lagoons, New Georgia, Solomon Islands Hum. Ecol. 27 417–453 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1018727607651
S. Aswani (2000) ArticleTitleChanging identities: the ethnohistory of Roviana predatory headhunting Jour. Polynes. Soc. 109 39–70
S. Aswani (2002) ArticleTitleAssessing the effect of changing demographic and consumption patterns on sea tenure regimes in the Roviana Lagoon, Solomon Islands Ambio 31 272–284 Occurrence Handle12174597
S. Aswani P. Sheppard (2003) ArticleTitleThe archaeology and ethnohistory of exchange in pre-colonial and colonial Roviana: gift, commodities, and inalienable possessions Curr. Anthro. 44 51–78
S. Aswani R. Hamilton (2004a) ArticleTitleIntegrating indigenous ecological knowledge and customary sea tenure with marine and social science for conservation of bumphead parrotfish (Bolbometopon muricatum) in the Roviana Lagoon, Solomon Islands Environ. Conser. 31 69–83
S. Aswani R. Hamilton (2004b) ArticleTitleThe value of many small vs. few large marine protected areas in the Western Solomons Trad. Mar. Res. Man. Know. Infor. Bull 16 3–14
S. Aswani P. Weiant (2004) ArticleTitleScientific evaluation in women’s participatory management: monitoring marine invertebrate refugia in the Solomon Islands Hum. Org. 63 301–319
S. Aswani M. Lauer P. Weiant L. Geelen S. Herman (2004) The Roviana and Vonavona Marine Resource Management Project. Final Report 2000–2004 Department of Anthropology, University of California Santa Barbara, CA
F. Berkes (1985) ArticleTitleFishermen and “The tragedy of the commons” Environ. Conser. 12 199–206
H.R. Bernard (2000) Handbook of Methods in Cultural Anthropology Altamira Press Walnut Creek, CA 814
H.R. Bernard (2002) Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches Altamira Press Walnut Creek, CA
R. Bess (2001) ArticleTitleNew Zealand’s indigenous people and their claims to fisheries resources Mar. Poli. 25 23–32
D.W. Bromley (1992) ArticleTitleThe commons, common property, and environmental policy Environ. Res. Econ. 2 1–17
M.J. Casimir (1992) The dimensions of territoriality: an introduction M. Casimir A. Rao (Eds) Mobility and Territoriality. Social and Spatial Boundaries among Foragers, Fishers, Pastoralists, and Peripatetics St. Martin’s Press New York 1–26
J.C. Castilla O. Defeo (2001) ArticleTitleLatin-American benthic shellfisheries: emphasis on co-management and experimental practices Rev. Fish Biol. Fisher. 11 1–30
M. Chapman (1985) ArticleTitleEnvironmental influences on the development of traditional conservation in the South Pacific region Environ. Conser. 12 217–230
F.T. Christy (1982) Territorial Use Rights in Marine Fisheries: Problems and Definitions FAO Rome,
F.T. Christy (1996) ArticleTitleThe death rattle of open access and the advent of property rights regimes in fisheries Mar. Res. Eco. 11 287–304
P. Christie B. McCay M.L. Miller C. Lowe A.T. White R. Stoffle D.L. Fluharty L.T. McManus R. Chuenpagdee C. Pomeroy D.O. Suman B.G. Blount D. Huppert R.V. Eisma E. Oracion K. Lowry R.B. Pollnac (2003) ArticleTitleToward developing a complete understanding: a social science research agenda for marine protected areas Fisheries 28 22–26
Cinner, J. (2005) Socioeconomic factors influencing customary marine tenure in the Indo-Pacific. Eco. Soc. 10, 36 [online from URL: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/viewarticle. php?id=1364].
S.V. Ciriacy-Wantrup R.C. Bishop (1975) ArticleTitle“Common property” as a concept in natural resource policy Nat. Res. J. 15 713–727
A.J. Cooke N.V.C. Polunin K. Moce (2000) ArticleTitleComparative assessments of stakeholder management in traditional Fijian fishing grounds Environ. Conser. 27 291–299
Cordell J. (1989) Sea tenure. In: Cordell J. (ed.), A Sea of Small Boats Cultural Survival Report No. 26., Cambridge.
R. D’Andrade (1995) The Development of Cognitive Anthropology Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK 272
C. Dahl (1988) ArticleTitleTraditional marine tenure: a basis for artisanal fisheries management Mar. Pol. 12 40–48
T. Dietz E. Ostrom P.C. Stern (2003) ArticleTitleThe struggle to govern the commons Science 302 1907–1912 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1091015 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXps1amsLk%3D Occurrence Handle14671286
E.P. Durrenberger G. Palsson (1987) ArticleTitleOwnership at sea: fishing territories and access to sea resources Am. Ethnol. 14 508–522 Occurrence Handle10.1525/ae.1987.14.3.02a00060
R. Dyson-Hudson E.A. Smith (1978) ArticleTitleHuman territoriality: an ecological reassessment Am. Anthropol. 80 24–41 Occurrence Handle10.1525/aa.1978.80.1.02a00020
K. Foster J. Poggie (1993) ArticleTitleCustomary marine tenure and mariculture management in outlying communities of Pohnpei State, Federated States of Micronesia Ocea. Coast. Man. 20 1–21
T. Graham N. Idechong (1998) ArticleTitleReconciling customary and constitutional law: managing marine resources in Palau, Micronesia Ocea. Coast Man. 40 143–164
S. Hanna (1996) Social and economic path dependence in the construction of market-based fishery programs G. Palsson G. Petursdottir (Eds) Social Implications of Quota Systems in Fisheries Nordic Council Copenhagen 133–146
R. Hannesson (1991) ArticleTitleFrom common fish to rights based fishing Euro. Econ. Rev. 35 397–407
D. Holland N. Quinn (Eds) (1987) Cultural Models in Language and Thought Cambridge University Press Cambridge 400
E. Hviding (1989) All Things in Our Sea: the Dynamics of Customary Marine Tenure, Marovo Lagoon, Solomon Islands PNG, National Research Institute Boroko
E. Hviding (1996) Guardians of Marovo Lagoon: Practice, Place, and Politics in Maritime Melanesia University of Hawaii Press Honolulu, HI
D. Hyndman (1993) ArticleTitleSea tenure and the management of living marine resources in Papua New Guinea Pac. Stud. 16 99–114
S. Jentoft B.J. McCay D.C. Wilson (1998) ArticleTitleSocial theory and fisheries co-management Mar. Poli. 22 423–436
R.E. Johannes (1978) ArticleTitleTraditional marine conservation in Oceania and their demise Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 9 349–364 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.es.09.110178.002025
R.E. Johannes (1981) Words of the Lagoon. Fishing and Marine Lore in the Palau District of Micronesia University of California Press Berkeley, CA 245
R.E. Johannes (1998) ArticleTitleThe case for data-less marine resource management: example from tropical nearshore finfisheries Trends Ecol. Evol. 13 243–246 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0169-5347(98)01384-6
R.E. Johannes (2002) ArticleTitleThe renaissance of community-based marine resource management in Oceania Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 33 317–340 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.33.010802.150524
G. Leiva J.C. Castilla (2002) ArticleTitleA review of the world gastropod fishery: evolution of catches, management and the Chilean experience Rev. Fish Biol. Fisher. 11 283–300
H.B. Levine (1983) ArticleTitleControlling access: forms of “territoriality” in three New Zealand crayfishing villages Ethnology 23 89–100
P.M. Mace (1993) ArticleTitleWill private owners practice prudent resource management? Fisheries 18 29–31
D.G. Maloney P.H. Pearse (1979) ArticleTitleQuantitative rights as an instrument for regulating commercial fisheries J. Fish. Res. Boa. Can. 36 859–866
E. Mantjoro T. Akimichi (1996) ArticleTitleSea tenure and its transformation in the Sangihe Islands of North Sulawesi, Indonesia: the seke purse-seine fishery Senri Ethno. Stud. 42 121–146
M.B. Mascia (2003) ArticleTitleThe human dimension of coral reef marine protected areas: recent social science research and its policy implications Conserv. Biol. 17 630–632
B.J. McCay (1995) ArticleTitleSocial and ecological implications of ITQs: an overview Ocea. Coast. Man. 28 3–22
National Census (1999) Report on 1999 Population and Housing Census. Solomon Islands Government, Honiara, Statistics Office.
B. Nietschmann (1985) Torres Strait islanders sea resource management and sea rights K. Ruddle R.E. Johannes (Eds) The Traditional Knowledge and Management of Coastal Systems in Asia and the Pacific UNESCO Jakarta 125–156
M. Orbach (1996) Social science in the coastal zone J. Taussik J. Mitchell (Eds) Partnership in Coastal Zone Management, Proceedings of LITTORAL ’96, the Third International Conference of the European Coastal Association for Science and Technology Samara Publishing Limited Cardigan, UK 45–54
E. Ostrom (1990) Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK 280
G. Palsson A. Helgason (1995) ArticleTitleFiguring fish and measuring men: the individual transferable quota system in the Icelandic cod fishery Ocea. Coast. Man. 28 117–146
Peterson, N. and Rigsby, B. (eds.) (1998) Customary Marine Tenure in Australia. Oceania Monograph 48. Sydney, Australia.
E. Pinkerton (1989) Co-operative Management of Local Fisheries New Directions for Improved Management and Community Development University of British Columbia Press Vancouver, BC 312
R.B. Pollnac (1984) Investigating territorial use rights among fishermen K. Ruddle T. Akimichi (Eds) Maritime Institutions in the Western Pacific National Museum of Ethnology Osaka
N. Polunin (1984) Do traditional “reserves” conserve? A view of Indonesia and New Guinean Evidence K. Ruddle T. Akimichi (Eds) Maritime Institutions in the Western Pacific National Museum of Ethnology Osaka
K. Ruddle (1988) ArticleTitleSocial principles underlying traditional inshore fisheries management systems in the Pacific basin Mar. Res. Econ. 5 351–363
K. Ruddle (1996) Traditional management of reef fishing N.V.C. Polunin C.M. Roberts (Eds) Reef Fisheries Chapman and Hall London 315–335
K. Ruddle (1998) ArticleTitleThe context of policy design for existing community-based fisheries management systems in the Pacific Islands Ocea. Coast. Manage. 40 105–126
K. Ruddle T. Akimichi (1984) Sea tenure in Japan and the southwestern Ryukyus J.C. Cordell (Eds) A Sea of Small Boats: Customary Law and Territoriality in the World of Inshore Fishing Stanford University Press Stanford
L.M. Ruttan (1998) ArticleTitleClosing the commons: cooperation for gain or restraint? Hum. Ecol. 26 43–66 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1018744816814
D.K. Schreiber (2001) ArticleTitleCo-management without involvement: the plight of fishing communities Fish Fisher. 2 376–384
Shotton, R. (2000) Current property rights systems in fisheries management. In: Shotton, R. (ed.), Use of Property Rights in Fisheries Management. Proceedings of the FishRights99 Conference, Fremantle, Western Australia.
A. Smith (1991) ArticleTitleTraditional and the development of the marine resources and coastal management plan for Yap State, Federated States of Micronesia Res. Man. Opt. 18 155–156
R.L. Stanton J.D. Bell (1969) Volcanic and Associated Rocks of the New Georgia Group, British Solomon Islands Protectorate Her Majesty’s Stationary Office London
T.A. Steelman R.L. Wallace (2001) ArticleTitleProperty rights and property wrongs: why context matters in fisheries management Pol. Sci. 34 357–379
G.G. Stevenson (1991) Common Property Economics: A General Theory and Land Use Applications Cambridge University Press Cambridge
D.R. Stoddart (1969) ArticleTitleGeomorphology of the Marovo Lagoon elevated barrier reefs, New Georgia Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. B 255 388–402
K. Sudo (1984) Social organization and types of sea tenure in Micronesia K. Ruddle T. Akimichi (Eds) Maritime Institutions in the Western Pacific National Museum of Ethnology Osaka
P. Taurakoto (1984) Customary rights to reefs and landings P. Larmour (Eds) Land Tenure in Vanuatu University of the South Pacific Suva, Fiji
Toloa, F., Gillet, R. and Pelasio, M. (1991) Traditional marine conservation in Tokelau. Can it be adapted to meet today’s situation. Paper presented at the 23rd SPC Regional Technical Meeting on Fisheries, Noumea, New Caledonia.
F.R. Thomas (2001) ArticleTitleRemodeling marine tenure on the atolls: a case study from Western Kiribati, Micronesia Hum. Ecol. 29 399–423 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1013141804349
J. Wagner A. Davis (2004) ArticleTitleProperty as social relations: Rights of “kindness” and the social organization of lobster fishing among northeast Nova Scotian Scottish Gaels Hum. Org. 62 320–333
M.D. Young B.J. McCay (1995) Building equity, stewardship, and resilience into market-based property rights systems S. Hanna M. Munasinghe (Eds) Property Rights and the Environment: Social and Ecological Issues The World Bank Washington, DC 87–102
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Aswani, S. Customary Sea Tenure in Oceania as a Case of Rights-based Fishery Management: Does it Work?. Rev Fish Biol Fisheries 15, 285–307 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11160-005-4868-x
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11160-005-4868-x