Abstract
In this paper we demonstrate that the most commonly used mathematical measure of circularity—the Form Factor—is highly resolution dependent. Furthermore we show that despite the abundance of papers proposing measures of roundness, most of the new measures are mathematically equivalent to the Form Factor. Only four measures were found that were different. We then present two new measures, the first based on the theory of Mean Deviations and the second based on the mathematical definition of a circle. When compared in terms of resolution dependence, order of complexity, ease of calculation, and how well they match human perception, the two new measures are shown to be better overall than the previous measures. The two new measures are resolution independent in the sense that changing the resolution makes no change to the order of circularity of different shapes. That is, changing the resolution does not change whether one object would be considered more round than another on the basis of the measure. None of the other measures has this property.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Bacus, J., Belanger, M., Aggarwal, R., Trobaugh, F., Jr.: Image processing for automated erythrocyte classification. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 24(1), 195–201 (1976)
Bacus, J., Weens, J.: An automated method of differential red blood cell classification with application to the diagnosis of anemia. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 25(7), 614–632 (1977)
Bacus, J.: Quantative morphological analysis of red blood cells. Blood Cells 6, 295–314 (1980)
Robinson, R., Benjamin, L., Cosgriff, J., Cox, C., Lapets, O., Rowley, P., Yatco, E., Wheeless, L.: Textural differences between AA and SS blood specimens as detected by image-analysis. Cytometry 17, 167–172 (1994)
Wheeless, L., Robinson, R., Lapets, O., Cox, C., Rubio, A., Weintraub, M., Benjamin, L.: Classification of red-blood-cells as normal, sickle, or other abnormal, using a single image analysis feature. Cytometry 17, 159–166 (1994)
Pambuccian, S.E., Becker, R.L., Ali, S.Z., Savik, K., Rosenthal, D.L.: Differential diagnosis of Hürthle cell neoplasms on fine needle aspirates. Acta Cytol. 41, 197–208 (1997)
Dasgupta, A., Lahiri, P.: Digital indicators for red cell disorder. Curr. Sci. 78, 1250–1255 (2000)
Foresto, P., D’Arrigo, M., Carreras, L., Cuezzo, R., Valverde, J., Rasia, R.: Evaluation of red blood cell aggregation in diabetes by computarized image analysis. Med. B. Aires 60(5), 570–572 (2000)
LoPachin, R., Jortner, B., Reid, M., Das, S.: Gamma-diketone central neuropathy: quantitative morphometric analysis of axons in rat spinal cord white matter regions and nerve roots. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 193, 29–46 (2003)
Mohler, J.L., Partin, A.W., Epstein, J.I., Lohr, W.D., Coffey, D.S.: Nuclear roundness factor measurement for assessment of prognosis of patients with prostatic carcinoma. ii. standardization of methodology for histologic sections. J. Urol. 139, 1085–1090 (2008)
Giger, M., Doi, K., MacMahon, H.: Image feature analysis and computer aided diagnosis in digital radiography. 3. automated detection of nodules in peripheral lung fields. Med. Phys. 15(2) (1988)
Artacho-Pérula, E., Roldán-Villalobos, R., Martínez-Cuevas, J.F., López-Rubio, F.: Nuclear quantitative grading by discrimant analysis of renal cell carcinoma samples. a patient survival evaluation. J. Parasitol. 173, 105–114 (1994)
Landry, M.E., Blanchard, C.R., Mabrey, J.D., Wang, X., Agrawal, C.M.: Morphology of in vitro generated ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene wear particles as a function of contact conditions and material parameters. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. Part B, Appl. Biomater. 48(1), 61–69 (1999)
Breslow, N., Partin, A., Lee, B., Guthrie, K., Beckwith, J., Green, D.: Nuclear morphometry and prognosis in favorable histology Wilms’ tumor: A prospective reevaluation. J. Clin. Oncol. 17, 2123–2126 (1999)
Gordon, A., Cloman-Lerner, A., Chin, T.E., Benjamin, K., Yu, R.C., Brent, R.: Supplementary notes to: Single-cell quantification of molecules and rates using open-source microscope-based cytometry. Nat. Methods 4(2) (2007), p. 22 of the supplement
Nikolakakis, I., Kachrimanis, K., Malamataris, S.: Relations between crystallisation conditions and micromeritic properties of ibuprofen. Int. J. Pharm. 201, 79–88 (2000)
Cenens, C., Jenne, R., Impe, J.V.: Evaluation of different shape parameters to distinguish between flocs and filaments in activated sludge images. Water Sci. Technol. 45(45), 85–91 (2002)
Almeida-Prieto, S., Blanco-Mendez, J., Otero-Espinar, F.: Image analysis of the shape of granulated powder grains. J. Pharm. Sci. 93, 621–634 (2004)
Jayaraj, J., Fleury, E., Kim, K., Lee, J.: Globulization mechanism of the primary Al of Al-15Cu alloy during slurry preparation for rheoforming. Met. Mater. Int. 11, 257–262 (2005)
Moschakis, T., Murray, B., Dickinson, E.: Microstructural evolution of viscoelastic emulsions stabilised by sodium caseinate and xanthan gum. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 284, 714–728 (2005)
Clemens, J., Henriod, R., Bailey, D., Jameson, P.: Vegetative phase change in metrosideros: Shoot and root restriction. Plant Growth Regul. 28, 207–214 (1999)
Dell’Aquila, A.: Cabbage, lentil, pepper and tomato seed germination monitored by an image analysis system. Seed Sci. Technol. 32(1), 225–229 (2004)
Gardoll, S., Groves, D., Knox-Robinson, C., Yun, G., Elliott, N.: Developing the tools for geological shape analysis, with regional- to local-scale examples from the Kalgoorlie Terrane of Western Australia. Aust. J. Earth Sci. 47, 943–953 (2000)
Kanthathas, K., Willmot, D., Benson, P.: Differentiation of developmental and post-orthodontic white lesions using image analysis. Eur. J. Orthod. 27, 167–172 (2005)
Huff, P., Wilf, P., Azumah, E.: Digital future for paleoclimate estimation from fossil leaves? Preliminary results. Palaios 18, 266–274 (2003)
Springham, S., Lee, S., Moo, S.: Deuterium plasma focus measurements using solid state nuclear track detectors. Braz. J. Phys. 32, 172–178 (2002)
Cox, E.: A method of assigning numerical and percentage values to the degree of roundness of sand grains. J. Paleontol. 1(3), 179–183 (1927)
Nafe, R., Yan, B., Schlote, W., Schneider, B.: Application of different methods for nuclear shape analysis with special reference to the differentiation of brain tumors. Anal. Quant. Cytol. Histol. 28, 69–77 (2006)
Payne, C., Bjore, C., Jr., Cromley, D., Roland, F.: A comparative mathematical evaluation of contour irregularity using form factor and PERBAS, a new analytical shape factor. Anal. Quant. Cytol. Histol. 11, 341–352 (1989)
Bouwman, A., Bosma, J., Vonk, P., Wesselingh, J., Frijlink, H.: Which shape factor(s) best describe granules? Powder Technol. 146, 66–72 (2004)
Shen, H.: Regular form factor—a new concept and calculating method for quantitative form description. Anal. Quant. Cytol. Histol. 22, 453–458 (2000)
The American Society for Testing and Materials, Standard practice for characterization of particles (2005)
Richardson, L.F.: The problem of contiguity: An appendix to statistics of deadly quarrels. Gen. Syst. Yearbook 6, 139–190 (1961)
Hausner, H.H.: Characterization of the powder particle shape. Planseeber. Pulvermetall. 14, 75–84 (1966)
Blanco, A., Tomasi, F.D., Filippo, E., Manno, D., Perrone, M., Serra, A., Tafuro, A., Tepore, A.: Characterization of African dust over southern Italy. Atmos. Chem. Phys. 3, 2147–2159 (2003)
Diamond, D.A., Berry, S.J., Jewett, H.J., Eggleston, J.C., Coffey, D.S.: A new method to assess metastatic potential of human prostate cancer: Relative nuclear roundness. J. Urol. 128, 729–734 (1982)
Mandelbrot, B.: How long is the coast of Britain? statistical self-similarity and fractional dimension. Science 156, 636–638 (1967)
Dorst, L., Smeulders, A.: Length estimators for digitized contours. Comput. Vis. Graph. Image Process. 40, 311–333 (1987)
Bottema, M.: Circularity of objects in images. In: Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing (ICASSP ‘0O’), pp. 2247–2250. IEEE Press, New York (2000)
Hawkins, A.E.: The shape of powder-particle outlines. Meas. Sci. Technol., vol. 1 (1993)
Pentland, A.: A method of measuring the angularity of sands. In: Proceedings & Transactions of the Royal Society of Canada, vol. 21 (1927)
Toussaint, G.T.: Rotating calipers. Aug. 2006. http://www-cgrl.cs.mcgill.ca/%7Egodfried/research/calipers.html
Sunday, D.: The convex hull of a 2d point set or polygon. Aug. 2006. http://www.geometryalgorithms.com/Archive/algorithm_0109/algorithm_0109.htm
Ritter, N., Cooper, J.R.: Segmentation and border identification of cells in images of peripheral blood smear slides. In: Thirtieth Australasian Computer Science Conference (ACSC2007). Ballarat Australia, pp. 161–169. ACS, Washington (2007)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ritter, N., Cooper, J. New Resolution Independent Measures of Circularity. J Math Imaging Vis 35, 117–127 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10851-009-0158-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10851-009-0158-x