Abstract
This paper focuses on the 1986 Amendments to the False Claims Act of 1863, which offers whistle-blowers financial rewards for disclosing fraud committed against the U.S. government. This law provides an opportunity to examine underlying assumptions about the morality of whistle-blowing and to consider the merits of increased reliance on whistle-blowing to protect the public interest. The law seems open to a number of moral objections, most notably that it exerts a morally corrupting influence on whistle-blowers. We answer these objections and argue that the law is not objectionable on these grounds. Since there are no compelling moral objections to the law, it is appropriate and acceptable to judge the law in terms of its economic costs and benefits. We assess the most salient of these and conclude that the benefits outweigh the costs. We suggest that a mechanism similar to the Act should be considered for protecting stockholders’ interests in the private sector. We conclude by making several proposals for improving the existing legislation.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Aristotle. Martin Ostwald, translator: 1962, Nichomachean Ethics, (Bobbs-Merrill, Indianapolis)
Boatright J. R.: 1997, Ethics and the Conduct of Business, 2nd edition, (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
Bok S.: 1980, Whistleblowing and Professional Responsibility, New York University Education Quarterly, 11, (Summer), 2–7
Bowie N.: 1982, Business Ethics, (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
Bowie N., R. Duska: 1990, Business Ethics, 2nd edition, (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
Callahan E. S.: 1990, Employment at Will: The Relationship Between Societal Expectations and the Law, American Business Law Journal, 28(3), 455–484
Callahan E. S., T. M. Dworkin: 1992, Do Good and Get Rich: Financial Incentives for Whistleblowing and the False Claims Act: Villanova Law Review, 37, 273–336
Callahan E. S., T. M. Dworkin: 2000, The State of State Whistleblower Protection, American Business Law Journal, 38(1), 99–175
Chambers, M.: 1993, Sua Spont, National Law Journal, June 21, 15
DeGeorge R. T.: 1995, Business Ethics, (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
Doris J.: 2005, Lack of Character, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
Dworkin T. M., J. A. Near: 1997, A Better Statutory Approach to Whistle Blowing, Business Ethics Quarterly, 7(1), 1–16
Glazer M. P., P. M. Glazer: 1989, The Whistleblowers: Exposing Corruption in Government and Industry, (Basic Books, New York, NY)
Grant C.: 2002. Whistle Blowers: Saints of Secular Culture, Journal of Business Ethics, 39(4):391–399
Green R. M.: 1994, The Ethical Manager: A New Method for Business Ethics, (Macmillan, New York, NY)
Harman G.: 2000, Explaining Value, (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
Jos P. H., M. E. Tompkins, W. W. Hays: 1989, In Praise of Difficult People: A Portrait of the Committed Whistleblower. Public Administration Review, 49 (6), 552–561
Kaplan, C.: (Winter 2002–2003), “The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002—Employment Law Aspects – Whistleblower and Securities Analyst Protections,” http://www.thelenreid.com/articles/article/art_165_idx.htm (accessed January, 19 2003)
Larmer R. A.: 1992, Whistleblowing and Employee Loyalty Journal of Business Ethics, 11(2), 125–128
Maitland I.: 1997, Virtuous Markets: The Market as School of the Virtues, Business Ethics Quarterly, 7(1), 17–32
Meyer J. A.: 2003, Fighting Medicare Fraud: More Bang for the Federal Buck, (New Directions for Policy for Taxpayers Against Fraud Education Fund, Washington, D. C.)
Meyer J. A., S. E. Anthony: 2001, Reducing Health Care Fraud: An Assessment of the Impact of the False Claims Act. Executive Summary and Data Analysis, (New Directions for Policy for Taxpayers Against Fraud, Washington, D. C.), September
Miceli M. P., J. P. Near: 1984, The Relationship Among Beliefs, Organizational Position, and Whistle-Blowing Status: A Discriminate Analysis, Academy of Management Journal, 27 (4), 687–705
Miceli M. P., J. P. Near: 1992, Blowing the Whistle: The Organizational and Legal Implications for Companies and Employees, (Lexington Books, New York)
Miceli M. P., J. P. Near: 1994, Whistleblowing: Reaping the Benefits, Academy of Management Executive, 8(3), 65–72
Mill J.S.: 1979, Utilitarianism, (Hackett, Indianapolis)
Near J. P., M. P. Miceli: 1996, Whistle-Blowing: Myth and Reality, Journal of Management, 22(3), 507–526
Pacelle, M. and M. Schroeder: 2003, ‚Proposed SEC Rules Could Turn Lawyers Into Whistle-Blowers’, Wall Street Journal, January 9, (1), 3
Rothschild J., T.D. Miethe: 1999, Whistle-Blower Disclosures and Management Retaliation, Work and Occupations, 6(1), 107–128
Schmitt, R. B.: 1995, ‚Honesty Pays Off: John Phillips Fosters a Growing Industry of Whistle-Blowing’, Wall Street Journal, January 11, A1
Stringer, W. L.: n.d., The 1986 False Claims Act Amendments: An Assessment of Economic Impact, An Economic Study Commissioned by Taxpayers Against Fraud, (The Kalorama Consulting Group, Inc., Washington, D.C.)
Sun-Sentinel: August 22, 2001, Rat Out the Frauds, http://www.false-claims-act.net/press_ss0901.htm (accessed 1/20/03)
Testerman, J.: 2001, “Blowing the Whistle on Bosses Brings Them Millions,” St. Petersburg Times, March 25, http://www.flase-claims-act.net/press_spt.html (accessed 1/20/03)
U .S. Code, Public Law 99–562. 1986, 99th Congress, October 27, 3153–3169
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the Department of Justice Health Care Fraud and Abuse Control Program Annual Report for FY 2002 (available http://www.usdoj.gov/dag/pubdoc/hcfacreport2002.htm accessed 1/5/05)
U.S. Department of Justice: 2004b, Personal correspondence, Nov. 1
U.S. General Accounting Office: 1992, Whistleblower Protection: Determining Whether Reprisal Occurred Remains Difficult, (GPO, Washington, D.C)
U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board: 1993, Whistleblowing in the Federal Government: An Update. (GPO, Washington, D.C.)
U.S. Senate: 1985, False Claims Reform Act: Hearing before the Subcommittee on Administrative Practice and Procedure of the Committee on the Judiciary, Serial no. J-99–52, (GPO, Washington, D.C.)
U.S. Senate: 1986, The False Claims Act of 1985, Report 99–345, July 28, (GPO, Washington, D.C.)
Velasquez M. G.: 1998, Business Ethics: Concepts and Cases, (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ)
Westin A. F.: 1981, Whistle blowing! Loyalty and dissent in the corporation, (McGraw-Hill, New York, NY)
Yang, C. and M. France: 1987, ‚Whistle-Blowers on Trial’, Business Week, March 24, 172–174.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
The authors' names are listed in alphabetical order.
An earlier version of this paper was presented to the Society for Business Ethics August 2004.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Carson, T.L., Verdu, M.E. & Wokutch, R.E. Whistle-Blowing for Profit: An Ethical Analysis of the Federal False Claims Act. J Bus Ethics 77, 361–376 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9355-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9355-y