Summary
A brief review is presented of the Vester-Ulbricht β-decay Bremsstrahlen hypothesis for the origin of optical activity, and of subsequent experiments designed to test it. Certain of our experiments along these lines, begun in 1974 and involving the irradiation of racemic and optically active amino acids in a 61.7 KCi90Sr−90Y Bremsstrahlen source, have now been completed and are described. After 10.89 years of irradiation with a total Bremsstrahlen dose of 2.5×109 rads, crystallinedl-leucine, norleucine, and norvaline suffered 47.2, 33.6, and 27.4% radiolysis, respectively, but showed no evidence whatsoever of asymmetric degradation.d- andl-Leucine underwent about 48% radiolysis and showed 2.4–2.9% radioracemization. Other samples in solution were too severely degraded to analyze. Probable intrinsic reasons for the failure of the Vester-Ulbricht mechanism to afford asymmetric radiolysis in the present and related experiments involving β-decay Bremsstrahlen are enumerated.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Bernstein WJ, Calvin M, Buchardt O (1973) Absolute Asymmetric Synthesis. III. Hindered rotation about aryl-ethylene bonds in the excited states of diaryl ethylenes. Structural effects on the asymmetric synthesis of 2- and 4-substituted hexahelicenes. J Am Chem Soc 95:527–532
Bernstein WJ, Lemmon RM, Calvin M (1972) An investigation of the possible differential radiolysis of amino acid optical isomers by14C betas. In: Rolfing DL, Oparin A (eds) Molecular evolution, prebiological and biological. Plenum Press, New York, pp 151–155
Blair NE, Bonner WA (1980a) Quantitative determination of D ≠ L mixtures of optical enantiomers by gas chromatography. J Chromatogr 198:185–187
Blair NE, Bonner WA (1980b) The radiolysis of tryptophan and leucine with32P β-radiation. J Mol Evol 15:21–28
Bonner WA (1973) Enantiomeric markers in quantitative gas chromatographic analysis of optical isomers. Application to the estimation of amino acid degradation. J Chromatogr Sci 11:101–104
Bonner WA (1974) Experiments on the origin of molecular chirality by parity non-conservation during β-decay. J Mol Evol 4:23–29
Bonner WA, Van Dort MA, Flores JJ (1974) Quantitative gas chromatographic analysis of leucine enantiomers. A comparative study. Analyt Chem 46:2104–2107
Bonner WA, Flores JJ (1975) Experiments on the origin of optical activity. Origins of Life 6:187–194
Bonner WA, Van Dort MA, Yearian MR (1975) Asymmetric degradation of DL-leucine with longitudinally polarized electrons. Nature 258:419–421
Bonner WA, Van Dort MA, Yearian MR (1976) Asymmetric degradation of DL-leucine with longitudinally polarized electrons. Nature 264:197–198
Bonner WA, Van Dort MA, Yearian MR, Zeman HD, Li GC (1976/77) Polarized electrons and the origin of optical activity. Israel J Chem 15:89–95
Bonner WA, Lemmon RM (1978a) Radiolysis, racemization and the origin of molecular asymmetry in the biosphere. J Mol Evol 11:95–99
Bonner WA, Lemmon RM (1978b) Radiolysis, racemization and the origin of optical activity. Bioorg Chem 7:175–187
Bonner WA, Lemmon RM, Noyes HP (1978a) β-Radiolysis of crystalline14C-labeled amino acids. J Org Chem 43:522–524
Bonner WA, Van Dort MA, Yearian MR (1978b) Molecular chirality of life and intrinsic chirality of matter (Reply). Nature 271:186
Bonner WA, Blair NE (1979) Enantiomeric phases in analytical gas chromatography. J Chromatogr 169:153–159
Bonner WA, Blair NE, Flores JJ (1979a) Attempted asymmetric radiolysis of D,L-tryptophan with32P β Radiation. Nature 281:150–151
Bonner WA, Van Dort MA, Yearian MR (1979b) Degradation of DL-leucine with longitudinally polarized electrons (Reply). Nature 280:250–252
Bonner WA, Blair NE, Lemmon RM (1979c) The radioracemization of amino acids by ionizing radiation. Geochemical and cosmochemical implications. Origins of Life 9:279–290
Bonner WA, Blair NE, Lemmon RM (1979d) Racemization of isovaline by γ-radiation. Cosmological implications. J Am Chem Soc 101:1049
Bonner WA, Blair NE, Lemmon RM, Flores JJ, Pollock GE (1979e) The radioracemization of isovaline. Cosmochemical implications. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 43:1841–1846
Bonner WA, Lemmon RM, Conzett HE (1982) The radiolysis and racemization of leucine on proton irradiation. Origins of Life 12:51–54
Darge W, Lacsko I, Thiemann W (1976) Stereoselectivity of β irradiation of D,L-tryptophan in aqueous solution. Nature 261:522–524
Fronsdal C, Überall H (1958) Polarization of Bremsstrahlung from polarized electrons. Phys Rev 111:580–586
Garay AS (1968) Origin and role of optical isomery in life. Nature 219:338–340
Gol'danskii VI, Khrapov VV (1963) Comparison of the effect of electron irradiation on the optical activity of racemates and optical antipodes. Soviet Phys JETP 16:582–585
Goldhaber M, Grodzins L, Sunyar AW (1957) Evidence for circular polarization of Bremsstrahlung produced by beta rays. Phys Rev 106:826–828
Hodge LA, Dunning FB, Walters GK, White RH, Schroepfer Jr GJ (1979) Degradation of DL-leucine with longitudinally polarized electrons. Nature 280:250–252
Kagan H, Moradpour A, Nicoud JF, Balavoine G, Martin RH, Cosyn JP (1971) Photochemistry with circularly polarized light. II. Asymmetric synthesis of octa and nonahelicene. Tetrahedron Lett 27:2479–2482
Keszthelyi L (1976) Asymmetric degradation of DL-leucine with longitudinally polarized electrons. Nature 264:197
Keszthelyi L, Vincze I (1975) Absorption of circularly polarized γ-radiation in L- and D-amino acids. Rad Environ Biophys 12:181–185
Kuhn W, Braun E (1929) The photochemical origin of optically active substances. Naturwiss 17:227–228
Kuhn W, Knopf E (1930a) Preparation of optically active substances with the help of light. Z Physik Chem 7B:292–310
Kuhn W, Knopf E (1930b) Photochemical preparation of optically active substances. Naturwiss 18:183
Lee TD, Yang CN (1956) The question of parity conservation in weak interactions. Phys Rev 104:254–258
Lemmon RM, Conzett HE, Bonner WA (1981) Search for effect of longitudinally polarized protons on optically active amino acids. Origins of Life 11:337–341
McVoy KW (1957) Circular polarization of Bremsstrahlung from polarized electrons in Born approximation. Phys Rev 106:828–829
Noyes HP, Bonner WA, Tomlin JA (1977) On the origin of biological chirality via natural beta-decay. Origins of Life 8: 21–23
Schopper H, Galster S (1958) The circular polarization of internal and external Bremsstrahlung. Nuclear Phys 6:125–131
Ulbricht TLV (1959) Asymmetry: the non-conservation of parity and optical activity. Quart Rev Chem Soc 13:48–60
Ulbricht TLV, Vester F (1962) Attempts to induce optical activity with polarized β-radiation. Tetrahedron 18:629–637
Vester F (1957) Seminar at Yale University, Feb 7, 1957, New Haven, Connecticut
Vester F, Ulbricht TLV, Krauch H (1959) Optical activity and the parity violation in β-decay. Naturwiss 46:68
Walker DC (1976) Polarized Bremsstrahlung not the source of optical activity. Origins of Life 7:383–387
Wu CS, Ambler E, Hayward RW, Hoppes DD, Hudson RP (1957) Experimental test of parity conservation in β-decay. Phys Rev 105:1413–1415
Wyard SJ (1955) Radioactive-source corrections for Bremsstrahlung and scatter. Nucleonics 13:44–45
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bonner, W.A., Liang, Y. β-decay, Bremsstrahlen, and the origin of molecular chirality. J Mol Evol 21, 84–89 (1984). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02100632
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02100632