Abstract
Most contraceptive methods are associated with defined maternal risks. These risks can be balanced against the benefits, with individual users arriving at iformed decisions concerning propriety of using a given method. Physicians and patients alike have grown accustomed to benefits/risks analysis of this type.
More difficult to assess, however, would be fetal risks associated with contraceptive use. In the past decade, increasing attention has been given to allegations that various forms of contraception pose fetal risks. Sometimes risks are claimed as a result of exposure during pregnancy (teratogenesis). At other times long-term risks are claimed after discontinuation of the contraceptive agent. That is, there are risks due to exposure prior to pregnancy (mutagenesis).
In this communication we shall review the various allegations, attempt to define the more reasonable possibilities in order to suggest future studies assuring contraceptive safety, and provide information suitable for counseling of patients who inadvertently become pregnant while using contraception.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
SimpsonJ. L., GolbusM. S., MartinA. O. and SartoG. E. (1982).Genetics in Obstetrics and Gynecology. Grune & Stratton, New York
FraserF. C. and FainstatT. D. (1951). Production of congenital defects in the offspring of pregnant mice treated with cortisone.Pediatrics,8, 527
PhelanM. C., PollockJ. M. and NanceW. E. (1982). Discordant expression of fetal hydantoin syndrome in heteroplacental dizygotic twins.N. Engl. J. Med.,307, 99
Simpson, J. L. and Mills, J. L. (1985). Methodological problems in determining fetal loss rates: Relevance to chorionic villus sampling.Hum. Genet. (in press)
SimpsonJ. L. (1984). Mutagenicity and teratogenicity of injectable and implantable progestins: probable lack of effect.Long Acting Steroidal Contraception, G. I.Zatuchni, et al. eds., Lippincott, Philadelphia, p. 334
SmithellsR. W. and ChenE. R. (1965). The problem of teratogenicity.Practitioner,198, 104
Rice-WrayE., CorrenS. and GastelumH. (1966). Erfahrungen mit dem oralen Kontrazeptivum Anovlar.Med. Klin.,61, 24
PetersonW. F. (1969). Pregnancy following oral contraceptive therapy.Obstet. Gynecol.,34, 363
SpiraN., GoujardJ., HuelG. and Rumeau-RouquetteC. (1972). Etude teratogene des hormones sexuelles. Premiers resultats d'une enquete epidemiologique portant sur 20,000 femmes.Rev. Red. Fr.,41, 2683
HarlapS., PrywesR. and DaviesA. M. (1975). Birth defects and oestrogens and progesterones in pregnancy.Lancet,1, 682
KullanderS. and KällenB. (1976). A prospective study of drugs and pregnancy.Acta Obstet. Gynecol. Scand.,55, 221
Royal College of General Practitioners (1976). The outcome of pregnancy in former oral contraceptive users.Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol.,83, 608
GoujardJ. and Rumeau-RouquetteC. (1977). First trimester exposure to progestagen/estrogen and congenital malformations.Lancet,1, 482
HeinonenO. P., SloneD., MonsonR. R., HookE. B. and ShapiroS. (1976). Cardiovascular birth defects in antenatal exposure to female sex hormones.N. Engl. J. Med.,296, 67
HeinonenO. P., SloneD. and ShapiroS. (1977).Birth Defects and Drugs in Pregnancy. Pub. Sciences Group, Littleton, Mass.
NoraJ. J., NoraA. H., BlumJ., IngramJ., FountainA., PetersonM., LortscherR. H. and KimberlingW. J. (1978). Exogenous progestogen and estrogen implicated in birth defects.J. Am. Med. Assoc.,240, 837
TorfsC. P., MilkovichL. and Van DenBergB. J. (1981). The relatioship between hormonal pregnancy tests and congenital anomalies: a prospective study.Am. J. Epidemiol.,113, 563
GoujardJ., Rumeau-RouquetteC. and Saurel-CubizallesM. J. (1979). Tests hormonaux de grossesse et malformations congenitales.J. Gynecol. Obstet. Repr.,8, 489
VesseyM. P. (1979). Outcome of pregnancy in women using different methods of contraception.Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol.,86, 548
SavolainenE., SakselaE. and SaxenL. (1981). Teratogenic hazards of oral contraceptives analyzed in a national malformation register.Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.,140, 521
MichaelisJ., MichaelisH., GluckE. and KollerS. (1983). Prospective study of suspected associations between certain drugs administered during early pregnancy and congenital malformations.Teratology,27, 57
World Health Organization (1982). Facts about injectable contraceptives: Memorandum from a WHO meeting.Bull. WHO,60, 199
AarskogD. (1971). Maternal progestins as a possible cause of hypospadias.N. Engl. J. Med.,300, 75
MonteleoneR. N., CastillaE. E. and PazJ. E. (1981). Hypospadias: an epidemiologic study in Latin America.Am. J. Med. Genet.,10, 5
CzeizelA., TothJ. and ErodiE. (1979). Aetiological studies of hypospadias in Hungary.Hum. Hered.,29, 166
BrackenM. B., HolfordT. R., WhiteC. and KelseyJ. L. (1978). Role of oral contraception in congenital malformations of offspring.Int. J. Epidemiol.,7, 309
SweetR. A., SchrootH. G., KurlandR. and CulpO. S. (1974). Study of the incidence of hypospadias in Rochester, Minnesota, 1940–1970, and a case-control comparison of possible etiologic factors.Mayo Clin. Proc.,49, 52
AvellanL. (1977). On actiological factors in hypospadias.Scand. J. Plast. Reconstr. Surg.,11, 115
LevyE. P., CohenA. and FraserF. C. (1973). Hormone treatment during pregnancy and congenital heart disease.Lancet,1, 611
Nora, J. J. and Nora, A. H. (1973). Preliminary evidence for a possible association between oral contraceptives and birth defects.Teratology,7, A24
JanerichD. T., DuganJ. M., StandfastS. J. and StritsL. (1977). Congenital heart disease and prenatal exposure to exogenous sex hormones.Br. Med. J.,1, 1058
GreenbergG., InmanW. H. W., WeatherallJ. A. C., AdelsteinA. M. and HaskeyJ. C. (1977). Maternal drug histories and congenital abnormalities.Br. Med. J.,2, 853
Mulvihill, J. J., Mulvihill, C. C. and Neill, C. A. (1976). Prenatal sex-hormone exposure and cardiac defects in man.Teratology,9, A30
YasudaM. and MillerJ. R. (1975). Prenatal exposure to oral contraceptives and transposition of the great vessels in man.Teratology,12, 239
RothmanK. J., FylerD. C., GoldblattA. and KreidbergM. B. (1979). Exogenous hormones and other drug exposures of children with congenital heart disease.Am. J. Epidemiol.,169, 433
MatsunagaE. and ShiotoK. (1977). Threatened abortion, hormone therapy, and malformed embryos.Teratology,30, 469
JanerichD. T., PiperJ. M. and GlebatisD. M. (1974). Oral contraceptives and congenital limb-reduction defects.N. Engl. J. Med.,291, 697
NishimuraH., UwabeC. and SembaR. (1974). Examination of teratogenicity of progestogens and/or estrogens by observation of the induced abortuses.Teratology,10, 93
CalI., KirmanB. and SternJ. (1967). Hormonal pregnancy tests and neural tube defects.Nature,216, 83
LaurenceM., MillerM., VowlesM., EvansK. and CarterC. (1971). Hormonal pregnancy tests and neural tube defects.Nature,233, 495
OakleyG. P., FlyntJ. W. and FalekA. (1973). Hormonal pregnancy tests and congenital malformations.Lancet,2, 256
HarlapS. and EldorJ. (1980). Births following oral contraceptive failure.Obstet. Gynecol.,55, 447
NoraA. H. and NoraJ. J. (1975). A syndrome of multiple congenital anomalies associated with teratogenic exposure.Arch. Environ. Health,30, 17
LorberC. A., CassidyS. B. and EngelE. (1979). Is there an embryo-fetal exogenous sex steroid exposure syndrome (EFESSES)?Fertil Steril.,31, 21
DavidT. J. and O'CallaghanS. E. (1974). Birth defects and oral hormonal preparations.Lancet,1, 1238
WilsonJ. G. and BrentR. L. (1981). Are female sex hormones teratogenic?Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.,141, 567
World Health Organization (1981). The effect of female sex hormones on fetal development and infant health. World Health Organization (WHO) Technical Report Series 657. WHO, Geneva
GrayR. H. (1983). Progestins in therapy. Teratogenesis. In:Progestogens in Therapy, G.Benagiano et al., eds., Raven Press, New York, p. 109
LangR. and RedmanU. (1979). Non-mutagenicity of some sex hormones in the Ames salmonella/microsome mutagenicity test.Mutation Res. (Amsterdam),67, 361
CarrD. H. (1970). Chromosome studies in selected spontaneous abortions. 1. Conception after oral contraceptives.J. Can. Med. Assoc.,103, 343
BouéA. and BouéJ. (1973). Actions of steroid contraceptives on genetic material.Geburtsh. Frauenheilk.,32, 77
LauritsenJ. G. (1975). The significance of oral contraceptives in causing chromosome anomalies in spontaneous abortions.Acta Obstet. Gynecol. Scand.,64, 261
AlbermanE., CreasyM., ElliottM. and SpicerC. (1976). Maternal factors associated with fetal chromosomal anomalies in spontaneous abortions.Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol.,83, 261
DhardialR. K., MachinA. M. and TaitS. M. (1971). Chromosome anomalies in spontaneously aborted human fetuses.Lancet,2, 20
KlingerH. P., GlaserM. and KavaH. W. (1976). Contraceptives and conceptus: 1. Chromosome abnormalities of the fetus and neonate related to maternal contraceptive history.Obstet. Gynecol.,48, 40
BarrieH. (1976). Congenital malformation associated with intrauterine contraceptive device.Br. Med. J.,1, 488
LeightonP. C., EvansD. G. and WallisS. M. (1976). IUD and congenital malformations,Br. Med. J.,1, 959
BarlowS. M. and KnightA. F. (1983). Teratogenic effects of Silastic intrauterine devices in the rat with or without added medroxprogesterone acetate.Fertil. Steril.,39, 224
TatumH. J., SchmidtF. H. and JainA. K. (1976). Management and outcome of pregnancies associated with the Copper T intrauterine contraceptive device.Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.,126, 869
AlbertA. (1983). Study of pregnancies in women with intrauterine devices of copper.Reproduction,7, 35
SnowdenR. (1976). IUD and congenital malformation.Br. Med. J.,1, 770
GuillebaudJ. (1976). IUD and congenital malformations.Br. Med. J.,1, 1016
VesseyM., MeislerL. and FlavilR. (1979). Outcome of pregnancies in women using different methods of contraception.Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol.,86, 548
MishellD. (1978). Pregnancy-related complications and bleeding problems with IUDs. In.Risks, Benefits, and Controversies in Fertility Control, J. J.Sciarra et al., eds., Harper & Row, Hagerstown, p. 428
PerlmutterJ. F. (1978) Pregnancy and the intrauterine device.J. Reprod. Med.,20, 137
Stevens, J. D. and Fraser, I. S. (1974). The outcome of pregnancy after failure of an intrauterine contraceptive device.J. Obstet. Gynaecol. Br. Commonw., 282
LaydeP. M., GoldbergM. F., SafraM. J. and OakleyG. P.Jr. (1979). Failed intrauterine device contraception and limb reduction deformities: a case control study.Fertil. Steril.,31, 18
BrackenM. B. and VitaK. (1983). Frequency of non-hormonal contraception around conception and association with congenital malformations in offspring.Am. J. Epidemiol.,117, 281
JickH., WalkerA. M., RothmanK. J., HunterJ. R., HolmesL. B., WatkinsR. N., D'EwartD. C., DanfordA. and MadsenS. (1981). Vaginal spermicides and congenital disorders.J. Am. Med. Assoc.,245, 1329
SmithE. S. O., DafoeC. S. and MillerJ. R. (1977). An epidemiological study of congenital reduction deformities of the limbs.Br. J. Prev. Soc. Med.,31, 39
RothmanK. J. (1982). Spermicide use and Down's syndrome.Am. J. Publ. Health,72, 399
PolednakA. P., JanerichD. T. and GlebatisD. M. (1982). Birth weight and birth defects in relation to maternal spermicide use.Teratology,26, 27
MillsJ. L., HarleyE. E., ReedG. F. and BerendesH. W. (1982). Are spermicides teratogenic?.J. Am. Med. Assoc.,248, 2148
CorderoJ. F. and LaydeP. M. (1983). Vaginal spermicides, chromosomal abnormalities and limb reduction defects.Fam. Plan. Perspect.,15, 16
ShapiroS., SloneD., HeinonenO. P., KaufmanD. W., RosenbergL., MitchellA. A., HelmrichS. P. (1982). Birth defects and vaginal spermicides.J. Am. Med. Assoc.,247, 2381.
HugginsG., VesseyM. and FlavilR. (1982). Vaginal spermicides and outcome of pregnancy: findings of a large cohort study.Contracepiton,25, 219
Mills, J. L., Reed, G. F., Nugent, R. P., Harley, E. E. and Berendes, H. W. (1985). Are there adverse effects of periconceptional spermicide use?Fertil. Steril. (in press)
SchollT. O., SobelE., TanferK., SoeferE. F. and SaidmanB. (1983). Effects of vaginal spermicides on pregnancy outcome.Fam. Plan. Perspect.,15, 244
JickH., ShictaK., ShepardT. H., HunterJ., StergachisA., MadsenS. and PorterJ. B. (1979). Vaginal spermicides and miscarriage seen primarily in the emergency room.Teratogen. Carcinogen. Mutagen.,2, 205
SimpsonJ. L. (1978). Genetic consequences of aging sperm or aging ova: animal studies and relevance to humans. In:Risks, Benefits, and Controversies in Fertility Control, J. J.Sciarra et al., eds., Harper & Row, Hagerstown, p. 506
SoderwallA. L. and BlandauR. J. (1941). The duration of the fertilizing capacity of spermatozoa in the female genital tract of the rat.J. Exp. Zool.,88, 55
SoderwallA. L. and YoungW. C. (1940). Effect of aging in the female genital tract on the fertilizing capacity of guinea pig spermatozoa.Anat. Rec.,78, 19
MartinP. A. and ShaverE. L. (1972).Sperm aging in utero and chromosomal anomalies in rabbit blastocysts.Dev. Biol.,28, 480
YoungW. C. (1929). A study of the function of the epididymis. II. The importance of an aging process in sperm for the length of the period during which fertilizing capacity is retained by sperm isolated in the epididymis of the guinea pig.J. Morphol. Physiol.,48, 475
TeshJ. M. and GloverT. D. (1969). Aging of rabbit spermatozea in the male tract and its effects on fertility,J. Reprod. Fertil.,20, 287
Martin-De LeonP. A., ShaverE. L. and GammalE. B. (1973). Chromosome abnormalities in rabbit blastocysts resulting from spermatozoa aged in the male tract.Fertil. Steril.,24, 212
Martin-De LeonP. A. and BoiceM. L. (1982). Sperm aging in the male and cytogenetic anomalies: an animal model.Hum. Genet.,62, 70
PflügerE. (1882). Versuche der Befruchtung überreifer.Arch. Ges. Physiol.,26, 76
WitschiE. (1952). Overripeness of the eggs as a cause of twinning and teratogenesis. A review.Cancer Res.,12, 763.
WitschiE. and LaguensR. (1963). Chromosomal aberrations in embryos from overripe eggs.Dev. Biol.,7, 605
ChangM. C. and HuntD. M. (1968). Attempts to induce polyspermy in the rabbit by delayed insemination and treatment with progesterone.J. Exp. Zool.,167, 419
ThibaultC. (1967). Analyse comparée de la fécondation et de ses anomalies chez la brebis la vache et la lapine.Ann. Biol. Anim. Biochem. Biophys.,7, 5
ShaverE. L. and CarrD. H. (1969). The chromosome complement of rabbit blastocysts in relation to the time of mating and ovulation.Can. J. Genet. Cytol.,11, 287
AustinC. R. (1967). Chromosome deterioration in aging eggs of the rabbit.Nature (Lond.),213, 1018
BlandauR. J. and JordanE. S. (1941). The effects of delayed fertilization on the development of the rat ovum.Am. J. Anat.,68, 275
SoderwallA. L. and BlandauR. J. (1941). The duration of the fertilizing capacity of spermatozoa in the female genital tract of the rat.J. Exp. Zool.,88, 55
VickersA. D. (1969). Delayed fertilization and chromosomal anomalies in mouse embryos.J. Reprod. Fertil.,20, 69
DonahueR. P. (1975). Normal and abnormal chromosomal behavior in the meiotic divisions of mammalian oocytes. In:Aging Gametes: Their Biology and Physiology, S. Karger, Basel
YoungR. J. and BlandauR. J. (1936). Ovum age and the course of gestation in the guinea pig.Science,84, 270
HancockJ. L. (1959). Polyspermy of pig ova.Vet. Res.,70, 1200
YamamotoM. and IngallsT. H. (1972). Delayed fertilization and chromosomal anomalies in the hamster embryo.Science,176, 518
GermanJ. (1968). Mongolism, delayed fertilization, and human sexual behaviour.Nature (Lond.),217, 516
ShokierM. (1968). Coital frequency and Down's syndrome.Lancet,2, 1081
JongbloetP. H. (1968). Overripeness of the egg. Consideration of the etiology of Goldenhar's syndrome and related congenital dysplasias including chromosomal aberrations.Maandschr. Kindergeneeskd.,36, 352
JongbloetP. H. (1969). The intriguing phenomenon of gametopathy and its disastrous effects on the human progeny.Maandschr. Kindergeneeskd.,37, 261
JongbloetP. H. (1975). The effects of pre-ovulatory overripeness of human eggs on development. In.Aging Gametes: Their Biology and Physiology, S. Karger, Basel
JongbloetP. H. and ZwetsJ. H. J. (1976). Pre-ovulatory overripeness of the egg in the human subject.Int. J. Gynaecol. Obstet.,14, 111
JongbloetP. H. and VanErkelens-ZwetsJ. H. J. (1978). Rhythm methods: are there risks to the progeny? In:Risks, Benefits, and Coniroversies in Fertility Control, J. J.Sciarra et al., eds., Harper & Row, Hagerstown, p. 520
Milstein-MoscatiI. and BecakW. (1981). Occurrence of Down's syndrome and human sexual behavior.Am. J. Med. Genet.,9, 211
GuerreroR. and RojasO. I. (1975). Spontaneous abortion and aging of human eva and spermatozoa,N. Engl. J. Med.,293, 573
JamesW. H. (1968). Mongolism, delayed fertilization and sexual behaviour.Nature (Lond.),219, 279
HansmannI. (1983). Factors and mechanisms involved in nondisjunction and X-chromosome loss. In.The Cytogenetics of the Mammalian X-chromosome, A.Sandberg, ed., Liss, New York, p. 131
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Simpson, J.L. Relationship between congenital anomalies and contraception. Adv Contracept 1, 3–30 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01849140
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01849140