Abstract
Challenges the use by policy researchers of a model for comparing adolescent and adult decision making that is based on informed consent standards. An expanded decision-making framework designed to evaluate “judgment” in adults and adolescents can better test the empirical basis of paternalistic legal policies. The theoretical and empirical literature on the informed consent framework is critiqued and an alternative framework incorporating judgment factors is proposed. Three judgment factors—temporal perspective, attitude toward risk, and peer and parental influence—and their effects on decision making are explored. Finally, implications for future research are analyzed in several decision-making contexts.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Allen, J. P., Aber, J. L., & Leadbeater, B. J. (1990). Adolescent problem behaviors: The influence of attachment and autonomy.Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 13, 455–467.
Allen, J. P., Leadbeater, B. J., & Aber, J. L. (1990). The relationship of adolescents' expectations and values to delinquency, hard drug use, and unprotected sexual intercourse.Development and Psychopathology, 2, 85–98.
Ambuel, B., & Rappaport, J. (1992). Developmental trends in adolescents' psychological and legal competence to consent to abortion.Law and Human Behavior, 16, 129–154.
Appelbaum, P. S. (1987).Informed consent: Legal theory and clinical practice. New York: Oxford University Press.
Appelbaum, P. S., & Grisso, T. (1988). Assessing patients' capacities to consent to treatment.New England Journal of Medicine, 319, 1635–1638.
Appelbaum, P. S., & Hoge, S. K. (1986). The right to refuse treatment: What the research reveals.Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 4, 279–292.
Bauman, K. E. & Udry, J. R. (1981). Subjective expected utility and adolescent sexual behavior.Adolescence, 16, 527–535.
Bellotti v. Baird, 443 U.S. 622 (1979).
Belter, R. W., & Grisso, T. (1984). Children's recognition of rights violations in counseling.Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 15, 899–910.
Benthin, A. C., Slovic, P., & Severson, H. (1993). A psychometric study of adolescent risk perception.Journal of adolescence, 16, 153–168.
Berndt, T. J. (1979). Developmental changes in conformity to peers and parents.Developmental Psychology, 15, 608–616.
Beyth-Marom, R., Austin, L, Fischoff, B., Palmgren, C., & Quadrel, M. J. (1992). Perceived consequences of risky behaviors: Adults and adolescents.Developmental Psychology, 29, 549–563.
Bishop, D. M., Frazier, C. E., & Henretta, J. C. (1989). Prosecutorial waiver: Case study of a questionable reform.Crime and Delinquency, 35, 179–201.
Brittain, C. V. (1963). Adolescent choices and parent-peer cross-pressures.American Sociological Review, 28, 385–391.
Champion, D. J. (1989). Teenage felons and waiver hearings: Some recent trends, 1980–1988.Crime and Delinquency, 35, 577–585.
Chassin, L., Presson, C. C., Sherman, S. J., & Edwards, D. A. (1991). Four pathways to young-adult smoking status: Adolescent social-psychological antecedents in a midwestern community sample.Health Psychology, 10, 409–418.
City of Akron v. Akron Center for Reproductive Health, 462 U.S. 416 (1983).
Coleman, J. S. (1961).The adolescent society. New York: The Free Press.
Costanzo, P. R., & Shaw, M. E. (1966). Conformity as a function of age level.Child Development, 37, 967–975.
Cottle, T. J., Howard, P., & Pleck, J. (1969). Adolescent perceptions of time: The effect of age, sex and social class.Personality, 37, 636–650.
Cromer, B. A., & Tarnowski, K. J. (1989). Noncompliance in adolescents: A review.Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, 10, 207–215.
Crosby, C., & Reppucci, N. D. (1993). The legal system and adolescents. In P. Tolan and B. Cohler (Eds.),Handbook of clinical research and practice with adolescents (pp. 281–304). New York: Wiley.
Dake, K. (1991). Orienting dispositions in the perception of risk.Journal of Cross Cultural Psychology, 22, 61–82.
Dolgin, M. H., Katzer, S., & Doctors, S. R. (1986). Caregivers' perceptions of medical compliance in adolescents with cancer.Journal of Adolescent Health Care, 7, 22–27.
Dornbusch, S. M., Carlsmith, J. M., Bushwall, S. J., Ritter, P. L., Leiderman, H., Hastorf, A. H., & Gross, R. T. (1985). Single parents, extended households, and the control of adolescents.Child Development, 56, 326–341.
Dowie, M. (1993). Tough justice: When kids commit adult crimes, some say they should do adult time.California Lawyer, 13, 54–58, 119.
Eccles, J. S., Buchanan, C. M., Flanagan, C., Fuligni, A., Midgley, C., & Yee, D. (1991). Control versus autonomy during early adolescence.Journal of Social Issues, 47, 53–68.
Eccles, J. S., Midgley, C., Wigfield, A., Buchanan, C. M., Reuman, D., Flanangan, C., & MacIver, D. (1993). Development during adolescence: The impact of stage-environment fit on young adolescents' experiences in schools and families.American Psychologist, 48, 90–101.
Elkind, D. (1967). Egocentrism in adolescence.Child Development, 38, 1025–1034.
Finn, P., & Bragg, B. W. E. (1986). Perception of the risk of an accident by young and older drivers.Accident Analysis and Prevention, 18, 289–298.
Fischer, K. W., & Silvern, L. (1985). Stages and individual differences in cognitive development.Annual Review of Psychology, 36, 613–648.
Fischhoff, B. (1992). Risk taking: A developmental perspective. In J. F. Yates (Ed.),Risk-taking behavior (pp. 133–162). New York: Wiley.
Fischhoff, B., & Quadrel, M. J. (1991). Adolescent alcohol decisions.Alcohol Health and Research World, 15, 43–51.
Flaherty, E. W., Marecek, J., Olsen, K., & Wilcove, G. (1983). Preventing adolescent pregnancy: An interpersonal problem solving approach.Prevention in Human Services, 2, 49–64.
Flavell, J. H. (1985).Cognitive development. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Fuligni, A. J., & Eccles, J. S. (1993). Perceived parent-child relationships and early adolescents' orientation toward peers.Developmental Psychology, 29, 622–632.
Furby, L., & Beyth-Marom, R. (1992). Risk-taking in adolescence: A decision-making perspective.Development Review, 12, 1–44.
Gardner, W. (1992). A life span theory of risk taking. In N. Bell (Ed.),Adolescent and adult risk taking: The eighth Texas Tech symposium on interfaces in psychology. Newbury Park: Sage.
Gardner, W., & Herman, J. (1991). Adolescents' AIDS risk taking: A rational choice perspective. In W. Gardner, S. Millstein, & B. Wilcox (Eds.),Adolescents in the AIDS epidemic (pp. 17–34). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Gardner, W., Herman, J., & Wilfong, E. (1991). Developmental change in decision making. Unpublished manuscript.
Gardner, W., Scherer, D., & Tester, M. (1989). Asserting scientific authority: Cognitive development and adolescent legal rights.American Psychologist, 44, 895–902.
Garrison, E. (1991). Children's competence to participate in divorce custody decisions.Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 20, 78–87.
Ginzberg v. New York, 390 U.S. 629 (1968).
Gittler, J., Quigley-Rick, M. & Saks, M. (1990) Adolescent health care decision making: The law and public policy. Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development, Washington, DC.
Greene, A. L. (1986). Future-time perspective in adolescence: The present of things future revisited.Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 15, 99–113.
Grisso, T. (1980). Juveniles' capacities to waiveMiranda rights: An empirical analysis.California Law Review, 68, 1134–1166.
Grisso, T. (1981).Juveniles' waiver of rights: Legal and psychological competence. New York: Plenum.
Grisso, T., & Appelbaum, P. (1992). Manual for Understanding Treatment Disclosures. (Unpublished manuscript).
Grisso, T., & Vierling, L. (1978). Minors' consent to treatment: A developmental perspective.Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 9, 421–427.
Gudjonsson, G. H., & Singh, K. K. (1984). Interrogative suggestibility and delinquent boys: An empirical validation study.Personality and Individual Differences, 5, 425–430.
H. B. v. Wilkinson, 639 F. Supp. 952 (D. Utah 1986).
H. L. v. Matheson, 450 U.S. 398 (1981).
Hampson, S. E., Burns, W. J., Severson, H. H., & Slovic, P. (1992). Adolescent alcohol-related risk taking: Exploring structural relations among risk perceptions, personality, and risk taking. Unpublished manuscript.
Hartigan v. Zbaraz, Brief of Amicus curiae, American Psychological Association, in support of appellees, Zbaraz v. Hartigan, 484 U.S. 171 (1987) (No. 85-673).
Hill, J. P., & Holmbeck, G. N. (1986). Attachment and autonomy during adolescence.Annals of Child Development, 3, 145–189.
Hodgson v. Minnesota, 58 U.S.L.W. 4957 (U.S. July 26, 1990).
Huff, R. C. (1989). Youth gangs and public policy.Crime and Delinquency, 35, 524–537.
Inhelder, B., & Piaget, J. (1958).The growth of logical thinking from childhood to adolescence. New York: Basic.
Janz, N. & Becker, M. (1984). The health belief model: A decade later.Health Education Quarterly, 11, 1–47.
Jessor, R. (1993). Successful adolescent development among youth in high-risk settings.American Psychologist, 48, 117–126.
Johnson, B. B. (1991). Risk and culture research—Some cautions.Journal of Cross Cultural Research, 22, 141–149.
Kahneman, D., Slovic, P. & Tversky, A. (Eds.) (1982).Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Kaser-Boyd, N., Adelman, H. S., & Taylor, L. (1985). Minors' ability to identify risks and benefits of therapy.Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 16, 411–417.
Kaser-Boyd, N., Adelman, H. S., Taylor, L. & Nelson, P. (1986). Children's understanding of risks and benefits of psychotherapy.Clinical Child Psychology, 15, 165–171.
Katz, J., & Capron, A. (1975).Catastrophic diseases: Who decides what? New York: Russell Sage.
Korsch, B. M., Fine, R. N., & Negrete, V. F. (1978). Noncompliance in children with renal transplants.Pediatrics, 61, 872–876.
Kulbok, P. P., Earls, F. J., & Montgomery, A. C. (1988). Life style and patterns of health and social behavior in high-risk adolescents.Advances in Nursing Science, 11, 22–35.
Larson, L. E. (1972). The influence of parents and peers during adolescence: The situation hypothesis revisited.Journal of Marriage and the Family, 34, 67–74.
Lavery, B., Siegel, A. W., Cousins, J. H., & Rubovits, D. S. (1993). Adolescent risk-taking: An analysis of problem behaviors in problem children.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 55, 277–294.
Lee v. Weisman, 112 S. Ct 2649 (1992).
Lewis, C. C. (1981). How adolescents approach decisions: Changes over grades seven to twelve and policy implications.Child Development, 52, 538–544.
Lewis, C. C. (1980). A comparison of minors' and adults' pregnancy decisions.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 50, 446–453.
Matthews, M. L., & Moran, A. R. (1986). Age differences in male drivers' perception of accident risk: The role of perceived driving ability.Accident Analysis and Prevention, 18, 299–313.
Meisel, A. (1979). The “exceptions” to the informed consent doctrine: Striking a balance between competing values in medical decision making.Wisconsin Law Review, 1979, 413–488.
Melton, G. B. (1983a).Child advocacy: Psychological issues and intervention. New York: Plenum.
Melton, G. B. (1983b). Toward “presonhood” for adolescents: Autonomy and privacy as values in public policy.American Psychologist, 38, 99–103.
Monks, F. (1968). Future time perspective in adolescence.Human Development, 11, 107–123.
Moseley-Braun, C. (1994). March. Yes: Send a message to young criminals.American Bar Association Journal, 80, 46.
Mulvey, E. P. (1984). Judging amenability to treatment in juvenile offenders. In N. D. Reppucci, L. A. Weithorn, E. P. Mulvey & J. Monahan (Eds.),Children, mental health and the law (pp. 195–210) Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Mulvey, E. P., & Reppucci, N. D. (1988). The context of clinical judgment: The effect of resource availability on judgments of amenability to treatment in juvenile offenders.American Journal of Community Psychology, 16, 525–546.
Neel, E. U., Litt, I. F. & Jay, M. S. (1987). Side effects and compliance with low-and conventionaldose oral contraceptive among adolescents.Journal of Adolescent Health Care, 8, 327–329.
Nurmi, J. (1991). How do adolescents see their future? A review of the development of future orientation and planning.Developmental Review, 11, 1–59.
Ohio v. Akron Center for Reproductive Health, 58 U.S.L.W. 4979 (U.S. June 26, 1990).
Parham v. J. R., 422 U.S. 584 (1979).
Petersen, A. C., Compas, B. E., Brooks-Gunn, J., Stemmler, M., Ey, S., & Grant, K. E. (1993). Depression in adolescence.American Psychologist, 48, 155–168.
Petersen, G. W. (1986). Parent-youth power dimensions and the behavioral autonomy of adolescents.Journal of Adolescent Research, 1, 231–249.
Phelps, C. E. (1987). Risk and perceived risk of drunk driving among young drivers.Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 6, 708–714.
Planned Parenthood of Central Missouri v. Danforth, 428 U.S. 52 (1976).
Planned Parenthood of Kansas City, Missouri v. Ashcroft, 462 U.S. 476 (1983).
Poulos, T. M., & Orchowsky, S. (1994). Serious juvenile offenders: Predicting the probability of transfer to criminal court.Crime and Delinquency, 40, 3–17.
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1982).Making Health Care Decisions, Vol. 1. Washington, DC.
Quadrel, M. J., Fischhoff, B., & Davis, W. (1993). Adolescent (in) vulnerability.American Psychologist, 48, 102–116.
Regnery, A. S. (1989). Getting away with murder.Policy Review, 34, 65–69.
Roth, L. H., Meisel, A., & Lidz, C. W. (1977). Tests of competency to consent to treatment.American Journal of Psychiatry, 134, 279–284.
Ryan, R. M., & Lynch, J. H. (1989). Emotional autonomy versus detachment: Revisiting the vicissitudes of adolescence and young adulthood.Child Development, 60, 340–356.
Sanborn, J. B. (1994). Certification to criminal court: The important policy questions of how, when, and why.Crime and Delinquency, 40, 262–281.
Scherer, D. G. (1991). The capacities of minors to exercise voluntariness in medical treatment decisions.Law and Human Behavior, 15, 431–449.
Scherer, D. G., & Reppucci, N. D. (1988). Adolescents' capacities to provide voluntary informed consent: The effect of parental influence and medical dilemmas.Law and Human Behavior, 12, 123–141.
Scott, E. (1992). Judgment and reasoning in adolescent decision making.Vanderbilt Law Review, 37, 1607–1669.
Scott, E. (1992). Rational decision making about marriage and divorce.Virginia Law Review, 76, 9–94.
Scott, E., Reppucci, N. D., & Aber, M. (1988). The role of the child's preference in custody proceedings.Georgia Law Review, 22, 1035–1078.
Seigler, R. S. (1991),Children's thinking (2nd ed.), Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Shaklee, H. (1979). Bounded rationality and cognitive development: Upper limits on growth?.Cognitive Psychology, 11, 327–345.
Shaklee, H., & Fischhoff, B. (1990). The psychology of contraceptive surprise: Cumulative risk and contraceptive effectiveness.Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 20, 385–403.
Smetana, J. G. (1988). Adolescents' and parents' conceptions of parental authority.Child Development, 59, 321–335.
Sprinthall, N., & Collins, W. A. (1988).Adolescent psychology: A developmental view. New York: Random House.
Stanford v. Kentucky, 109 S. Ct. 2969 (1989).
Steinberg, L., & Silverberg, S. B. (1986). The vicissitudes of autonomy in early adolescence.Child Development, 57, 841–851.
Taylor, L., & Adelman, H. S. (1986). Facilitating children's participation in decisions that affect them: From concept to pratice.Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 15, 346–351.
Tester, M., Gardner, W., & Wilfong, E. (1987, August). Experimental studies of the development of decision-making competence. InChildren, risks and decisions: Psychological and legal implications. Symposium conducted at the Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, New York.
Thompson, D. W., & Jason, L. A. (1988). Street gangs and preventive interventions.Criminal Justice and Behavior, 15, 323–333.
Thornburgh v. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 476 U.S. 747 (1968).
Wald, P. (1974). Making sense out of the rights of youth.Human Rights, 4, 13–29.
Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, 57 U.S.L.W. 5023 (U.S. July 3, 1989).
Weithorn, L. A., & Campbell, S. A. (1982). The competency of children to make informed treatment decisions.Child Development, 53, 1589–1598.
Zabin, M., Kanter, J., & Ford, K. (1980).Sex and pregnancy in adolescence. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Zimring, F. E. (1982).The changing legal world of adolescence. New York: The Free Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Several of the ideas in this article were originally presented by the first author and were published as part of a symposium on competence (see Scott, 1992). The current article expands and refines these ideas, provides a more substantial research base, and suggests several future research directions. We thank Joseph Allen, Richard Bonnie, Baruch Fischhoff, William Gardner, John Monahan, Edward Mulvey, Richard Redding, Paul Slovic, and three anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments. Special thanks to Thomas Grisso for providing much constructive criticism and to Wendy Shang for outstanding research assistance. Finally, we would like to acknowledge the MacArthur Foundation, which supported this work in its early stages.
About this article
Cite this article
Scott, E.S., Reppucci, D. & Woolard, J.L. Evaluating adolescent decision making in legal contexts. Law Hum Behav 19, 221–244 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01501658
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01501658