Abstract
Over the last decades, the quality issues have received increased attention from top managers and academics. The international debate mainly focused on managerial and economical implications resulting from the implementation of TQM programs in large companies, thus not considering peculiarities that such investments present within small firms. As a matter of fact, many small firms have adopted quality based programs and, unfortunately, failed to achieve the planned results: a major reason of the failure of TQM initiatives is due to the lack of effective decisional tools aimed at identifying the most suitable quality related investments.
Hence, the objective of the paper is to define a model that supports managers of small firms in the identification of most effective quality related priorities: to this end, a contingent approach that identifies different contexts according to the environment where the company operates and to the relationships between the firm and its stakeholders is suggested. Guide-lines for choosing a specific decisional technique aimed at selecting the most effective choice among the identified feasible priorities are suggested, too.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Adler, Paul S., 1989, ‘When Knowledge is the Critical Resource, Knowledge Management is the Critical Task’, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management 36(2), May.
Aubrey, C. A., 1988, ‘Effective Use of Quality Cost Applied to Service’, ASQC Quality Congress Transaction.
Azzone, Giovanni and Gian Carlo Cainarca, 1993, ‘The Strategic Role of Quality in Small Size Firms’, Small Business Economics 5(1), 67–76.
Azzone, Giovanni and Giuliano Noci, 1994, ‘A Framework for Measuring Quality Related Performances’, Proceedings of First International Conference of the European Operations Management Association, Cambridge 27–29, June, 549–550.
Bartezzaghi, Emilio, Gian Luca Spina and Roberto Verganti, 1994, ‘Lead Time Models of Business Process’, International Journal of Operations and Production Management 14(5), 5–20.
Blauw, Jan N. and Willem E. During, 1990, ‘Adoption of an Organizational Innovation: Total Quality Control in Industrial Firms’, International Journal of Production Research 28(10), 1831–1846.
Bromwich, Michael and Al Bhimani, 1991, ‘Strategic Investment Appraisal’, Management Accounting, 72(9), 45–48.
Buss, M. D. J., 1983, ‘How to Rank Computer Projects’, Harvard Business Review 61(1), 118–125.
Campanella, Jack and Frank J. Corcoran, 1983, ‘Principles of Quality Costs’, Quality Progress 16(4), 16–22.
Canada, J. R., 1986, ‘Non Traditional Method for Evaluating CIM Opportunities: Assign Weight to Intangibles’, Industrial Engineering, March.
Carbonelli, Emanuele and Giuliano Noci, 1992, Qualità e certificazione: un approccio contingente ai problemi decisionali, Brescia: Associazione Italiana Studi sul Lavoro.
Ciambelli, Claudio and CorradoLo Storto, 1994, ‘Qualità e strategie nelle piccole e medie imprese elettromeccaniche napoletane’, Piccola Impresa/Small Business 3, 7–38.
Dale, B. G. and K. Lightburn, 1992, ‘Continuous Quality Improvement: Why Some Organizations Lack Commitment’, International Journal of Productions Economics 27, 57–67.
Davies, Paul, 1990, ‘TQM in Small Size Firms’, Total Quality Management, October, 251–252.
Eldridge, S. and B. G. Dale, 1989, ‘Quality Costing: the Lessons Learnt from a Study Carried Out in Two Phases’, Engineering Costs and Production Economics 18(1), 33–44.
Garvin, David A., 1988, Managing Quality, New York: The Free Press.
Godfrey, J. T. and W. R. Pasewark, 1988, ‘Controlling Quality Cost’, Management Accounting NAA 9(2), 84–89.
Goh, P. L. and K. Ridgway, 1994, ‘The Implementation of Total Quality Management in Small and Medium Sized Manufacturing Companies’, The TQM Magazine 6(2), 54–60.
Hagan, J. T., 1986, Quality Management Handbook, New York: Ed. Walsh, Wurster & Kimber.
Heagy, Cynthia D., 1991, ‘Determining Optimal Quality Cost by Considering Cost of Lost Sales’, Journal of Cost Management 5(3), 64–72.
Juran, Joseph M., 1988, Quality Control Handbook, New York: McGraw Hill.
Juran, Joseph M., 1993, ‘Why Quality Intiatives FALL’, Journal of Business Strategy 66(3) 35–38.
Kaplan, Robert S. and David P. Norton, 1992, ‘The Balanced Scorecard — Measures that Drive Performance’, Harvard Business Review 70(1), 71–79.
Lascelles, D. M. and B. G. Dale, 1990, ‘The Key Issues of a Quality Improvement Process’, International Journal of Production Research 28(1), 131–143.
Morse, Wayne J., 1983, ‘Measuring Quality Costs’, Cost and Management, July–August, 16–20.
Morse, Wayne J. and Kay Poston, 1986, ‘Accounting for Quality Costs — A Critical Component of CIM’, CIM Review, Fall, 53–60.
Nelson, C. A., 1986, ‘A Scoring Model for Flexible Manufacturing Systems Project Selection’, European Journal of Operational Research 24, 76–91.
Newall, D. and B. G. Dale, 1991, ‘The Introduction and Development of a Quality Improvement Process: A Study’, International Journal of Production Research 29(9), 1747–1760.
Noci, Giuliano, 1993, ‘Un approccio integrato per la valutazione delle strategie di investimento in qualità’, Workshop AiIG: innovazioni tecnologiche ed innovazioni gestionali: sinergie, problemi e prospettive, Pisa 1-2 luglio.
Noci, Giuliano, 1995, ‘Accounting and Non Accounting Measures of Quality Based Performances in Small Firms’, The International Journal of Operations and Production Management 15(7), forthcoming.
O'Neill, A., 1988, ‘Quality Costs in Continuous Improvement Out’, ASQC Quality Congress Transactions, Dallas.
Plunkett, J. J. and B. G. Dale, 1988, ‘Quality Costs: A Critique of Some “Economic Cost of Quality” Models’, International Journal of Production Research 26(11), 1713–1726.
Porter, Leslie J. and Paul Rayner, 1992, ‘Quality Costing for Total Quality Management’, International Journal of Production Economics 27, 69–81.
Porter, Michael, 1985, ‘Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance’, New York: The Free Press.
Saccani, Cesare, 1990, Qualità e certificazione, Milan: McGraw Hill.
Schaffer, Robert H. and Harvey H. Thomson, 1992, ‘Successful Change Programs Begin with Results’, Harvard Business Review 70(1), 80–89.
Son, Young K. and Lie-Fern Hsu, 1991, ‘A Method of Measuring Quality Costs’, International Journal of Production Research 29(9), 1785–1794.
Williams, Alin J. and William Smith, 1990, ‘Involving Purchasing in Product Development’, Industrial Marketing Management 19(4), 315–320.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Noci, G. Selecting quality based programs in small firms. Small Bus Econ 8, 431–447 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00390029
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00390029