Summary
Since the discovery of the coelacanth, Latimeria chalumnae, more than 50 years ago, paleontologists and comparative morphologists have debated whether coelacanths or lungfishes, two groups of lobe-finned fishes, are the closest living relatives of land vertebrates (Tetrapoda). Previously, Meyer and Wilson (1990) determined partial DNA sequences from two conservative mitochondrial genes and found support for a close relationship of lungfishes to tetrapods. We present additional DNA sequences from the 12S rRNA mitochondria gene for three species of the two lineages of lungfishes that were not represented in the first study: Protopterus annectens and Protopterus aethiopicus from Africa and Neoceratodus forsteri (kindly provided by B. Hedges and L. Maxson) from Australia. This extended data set tends to group the two lepidosirenid lungfish lineages (Lepidosiren and Protopterus) with Neoceratodus as their sister group. All lungfishes seem to be more closely related to tetrapods than the coelacanth is. This result appears to rule out the possibility that the coelacanth lineage gave rise to land vertebrates. The common ancestor of lungfishes and tetrapods might have possessed multiple morphological traits that are shared by lungfishes and tetrapods [Meyer and Wilson (1990) listed 14 such traits]. Those traits that seem to link Latimeria and tetrapods are arguably due to convergent evolution or reversals and not to common descent. In this way, the molecular tree facilitates an evolutionary interpretation of the morphological differences among the living forms. We recommended that the extinct groups of lobe-finned fishes be placed onto the molecular tree that has lungfishes and not the coelacanth more closely related to tetrapods. The placement of fossils would help to further interpret the sequence of morphological events and innovations associated with the origin of tetrapods but appears to be problematic because the quality of fossils is not always high enough, and differences among paleontologists in the interpretation of the fossils have stood in the way of a consensus opinion for the branching order among lobefinned fishes. Marshall and Schultze (1992) criticized the morphological analysis presented by Meyer and Wilson (1990) and suggest that 13 of the 14 morphological traits that support the sister group relationship of lungfishes and tetrapods are not shared derived characters. Here we present further alternative viewpoints to the ones of Marshall and Schultze (1992) from the paleontological literature. We argue that all available information (paleontological, neontological, and molecular data) and rigorous cladistic methodology should be used when relating fossils and extant taxa in a phylogenetic framework.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Anderson S, Bankier AT, Barrell BG, de Bruijn MHL, Coulson AR, Drouin J, Eperon IC, Nierlich DP, Roe BA, Sanger F, Schreier PH, Smith AJH, Staden R, Young IG (1981) Sequence and organization of the human mitochondrial genome. Nature 290:457–465
Bemis WE (1987) Feeding systems of living dipnoi: anatomy and function. J Morphol Suppl 1:249–275
Benton MJ (1990) Phylogeny of the major tetrapod groups: morphological data and divergence dates. J Mol Evol 30:409–424
Burggren WW, Johansen K (1987) Circulation and respiration in lungfishes (Dipnoi). J Morphol Suppl 1:217–236
Campbell KSW, Barwick RE (1987) Paleozoic lungfishes—a review. J Morphol Suppl 1:93–131
Chang MM, Yu X (1984) Structure and phylogenetic significance of Diabolichthys speratus gen. et sp. nov., a new dipnoan-like form from the Lower Devonian of eastern Yunnan, China. Proc Linn Soc NSW 107:171–184
Cloutier R (1991) Patterns, trends, and rates of evolution within the Actinistia. In: Musick JA, Bruton MN, Balon EK (eds) The biology of Latimeria chalumnae and evolution of coelacanths. Kluwer, Hingham MA, pp 23–58
Coates MI, Clark JA (1991) Fish-like gills and breathing in the earliest known tetrapod. Nature 352:234–236
Donoghue MJ, Doyle JA, Gauthier J, Kluge AG, Rowe T (1989) The importance of fossils in phylogenetic reconstruction. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 20:431–460
Felsenstein J (1985) Confidence limits on phylogenies: an approach using the bootstrap. Evolution 39:783–791
Forey PL (1980) Latimeria: a paradoxical fish. Proc R Soc Lond B 208:369–384
Forey PL (1987) Relationships of lungfishes. J Morphol Suppl 1:75–91
Forey PI (1988) Golden jubilee for the coelacanth Latimeria chalumnae. Nature 336:727–732
Forey PL (1991a) Blood lines of the coelacanth. Nature 351: 347–348
Forey PL (1991b) Latimeria chalumnae and its pedigree. In: Musick JA, Bruton MN, Balon EK (eds) The biology of Latimeria chalumnae and evolution of coelacanths. Kluwer, Hingham MA, pp 75–97
Fritzsch B (1987) Inner ear of the coelacanth fish Latimeria has tetrapod affinities. Nature 327:153–154
Gardiner BG (1980) Tetrapod ancestry: a reappraisal. In: Panchen AL (ed) The terrestrial environment and the origin of land vertebrates. Academic Press, New York, pp 177–185
Gardiner BG (1984) The relationships of the palaeomiscid fishes, a review based on new specimens of Mimia and Moythomasia from the Upper Devonian of western Australia. Bull Br Mus Nat Hist Geol 37:173–428
Gauthier J, Kluge AG, Rowe T (1988) Amniote phylogeny and the importance of fossils. Cladistics 4:105–209
Gee H (1990) Fossil fishes and fashion. Nature 348:194–195
Gorr T, Kleinschmidt T, Fricke H (1991) Close tetrapod relationships of the coelacanth Latimeria indicated by haemoglobin sequences. Nature 351:394–397
Hedges BS, Moberg KD, LR Maxson (1990) Tetrapod phylogeny inferred from 18S and 28S ribosomal RNA sequences and a review of the evidence for amniote relationships. Mol Biol Evol 7:607–633
Hillis DM, Dixon MT (1989) Vertebrate phylogeny: evidence from 28S ribosomal DNA sequences. In: Fernholm B, Bremer K, Jornvall H (eds) The hierarchy of life. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 355–367
Holmes EB (1985) Are lungfishes the sister group of tetrapods? Biol J Linn Soc 25:379–397
Kocher TD, Thomas WK, Meyer A, Edwards SV, Paabo S, Villablanca FX, Wilson AC (1989) Dynamics of mitochondrial DNA evolution in animals: amplification and sequencing with conserved primers. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86:6196–6200
Lagios MD (1982) Latimeria and the Chondrichthyes as sister taxa. Copeia 1982:942–948
Lovtrup S (1977) The phylogeny of vertebrata. Wiley, London
Maeda N, Zhu D, Fitch WM (1984) Amino acid sequences of lower vertebrate parvalbumins and their evolution. Mol Biol Evol 1:473–488
Maisey JG (1986) Heads and tails: a chordate phylogeny. Cladistics 2:201–256
Marshall CR (1987) Lungfish: phylogeny and parsimony. J Morphol Suppl 1:151–162
Marshall CR, Schultze H-P (1992) Relative importance of molecular, neontological and paleontological data in understanding the biology of the vertebrate invasion of land. J Mol Evol 34:93–101
Meyer A, Wilson AC (1990) Origin of tetrapods inferred from their mitochondrial DNA affiliation to lungfish. J Mol Evol 31:359–364
Meyer A, Wilson AC (1991) Coelacanth's relationships. Nature 353:219
Meyer A, Kocher TD, Basasibwaki P, Wilson AC (1990) Monophyletic origin of Lake Victoria cichlid fishes suggested by mitochondrial DNA sequences. Nature 347:550–553
Miles RS (1977) Dipnoan (lungfish) skulls and the relationships of the group: a study based on new species from the Devonian of Australia. Zool J Linn Soc 61:1–328
Mindell DP, Honeycutt RL (1990) Ribosomal RNA in vertebrates: evolution and phylogenetic applications. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 21:541–566
Miyamoto MM, Boyle SM (1989) The potential importance of mitochondrial DNA sequence data to eutherian mammal phylogeny. In: Fernholm B, Bremer K, Jornvall H (eds) The hierarchy of life. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 437–450
Normark BB, McCune AR, Harrison RG (1991) Phylogenetic relationships of neopterygian fishes, inferred from mitochondrial DNA sequences. Mol Biol Evol 8:819–834
Northcutt RG (1987) Lungfish neural characters and their bearing on sarcopterygian phylogeny. J Morphol Suppl 1:277–297
Panchen AL, Smithson TR (1987) Character diagnosis, fossils and the origin of tetrapods. Biol Rev 62:341–438
Patterson C (1980) Origin of tetrapods: historical introduction to the problem. In: Panchen AL (ed) The terrestrial environment and the origin of land vertebrates. Academic Press, New York, pp 159–175
Patterson C (1981) Significance of fossils in determining evolutionary relationships. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 12:195–223
Roe BA, Ma D-P, Wilson RK, Wong JF-H (1985) The complete nucleotide sequence of the Xenopus laevis mitochondrial genome. J Biol Chem 260:9759–9774
Romer AS (1966) Vertebrate paleontology, ed 3. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Rosen DE, Forey PL, Gardiner BG,Patterson C (1981) Lungfishes, tetrapods, paleontology, and plesiomorphy. Bull Am Mus Nat Hist 167:159–276
Sanderson MJ, Donoghue MJ (1989) Patterns of variation in levels of homoplasy. Evolution 43:1781–1795
Schultze H-P (1987) Dipnoans as sarcopterygians. J Morphol Suppl 1:39–74
Schultze H-P (1991) CT scan reconstruction of the palate region of Latimeria chalumnae. In: Musick JA, Bruton MN, Balon EK (eds) The biology of Latimeria chalumnae and evolution of coelacanths. Kluwer, Hingham MA, pp 183–192
Schultze H-P, Arsenault M (1985) The panderichthyid fish Elpistostege: a close relative of tetrapods? Palaeontology 28: 293–309
Schultze H-P, Campbell KSW (1987) Characterization of the Dipnoi, a monophyletic group. J Morphol Suppl 1:25–37
Sharp PM, Lloyd AT, Higgins DG (1991) Coelacanth's relationships. Nature 353:218–219
Smith JLB (1939) A surviving fish of the order Actinistia. Nature 143:455–456
Smith JLB (1953) The second coelacanth. Nature 171: 99–101
Stock D, Moberg KD, Maxson LR, Whitt GS (1991) A phylogenetic analysis of the 18S ribosomal RNA sequence of the coelacanth Latimeria chalumnae. In: Musick JA, Bruton MN, Balon EK (eds) The biology of Latimeria chalumnae and evolution of coelacanths. Kluwer, Hingham MA, pp 99–117
Stock DW, Swofford DL (1991) Coelacanth's relationships. Nature 353:217–218
Swofford DL (1991) PAUP: phylogenetic analysis using parsimony, version 3.OrB l. Illinois Natural History Survey, Champaign IL
Thomson KS (1991) Living fossil: the story of the coelacanth. Norton, New York
Vorobjeva El (1980) Observations on two rhipidistian fishes from the Upper Devonian of Lode, Latvia (Lode). Zool J Linn Soc 70:191–201
Wahlert G von (1968) Latimeria and die Geschichte der Wirbeltiere. Fischer, Stuttgart, West Germany
Wiley EO (1979) Ventral gill arch muscles and the interrelationships of gnathostomes, with a new classification of the Vertebrata. Zool J Linn Soc 67:149–179
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Offprint requests to: Axel Meyer
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Meyer, A., Dolven, S.I. Molecules, fossils, and the origin of tetrapods. J Mol Evol 35, 102–113 (1992). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00183221
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00183221