Abstract
Several recent reports have claimed that adaptive mutants in bacteria and yeast are induced by selective conditions. The results of these reports suggest that mutants can arise nonrandomly with respect to fitness, contrary to what has been widely accepted. In several cases that have received careful experimental reexamination, however, the detection of seemingly nonrandom mutation has been explained as an experimental artifact. In the remaining cases, there is no evidence to suggest that cells have the capacity to direct or choose which genetic variants will arise. Instead, current models propose processes by which genetic variants persist as mutations only if they enable cell growth and DNA replication. Most of these models are apparently contradicted by experimental data. One model, the hypermutable state model, has recently received limited circumstantial support. However, in this model the origin of adaptive mutants is random; the apparent nonrandomness of mutation is merely a consequence of natural selection. The critical distinction between the origin of genetic variation (mutation) and the possible consequence of that variation (selection) has been neglected by proponents of directed mutation.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Benson SA (1988) Is bacterial evolution random or selective? Nature 336:21–22
Benson SA, Decloux AM, Munro J (1991) Mutant bias in nonlethal selections results from selective recovery of mutants. Genetics 129: 647–658
Benson SA, Occi JL, Sampson BA (1988) Mutations that alter the pore function of the OmpF porin of Escherichia coli K12. J Mol Biol 203:961–970
Boe L (1990) Mechanism for induction of adaptive mutations in Escherichia coli. Mol Microbiol 4:597–601
Cairns J, Foster PL (1991) Adaptive reversion of a frameshift mutation in Escherichia coli. Genetics 128:695–701
Cairns J, Overbaugh J, Miller S (1988) The origin of mutants. Nature 335:142–145
Cavalli-Sforza LL, Lederberg J (1956) Isolation of pre-adaptive mutants in bacteria by sib selection. Genetics 41:367–381
Chao L, Cox EC (1983) Competition between high and low mutating strains of Escherichia coli. Evolution 37:125–134
Chao L, Vargas C, Spear BB, Cox EC (1983) Transposable elements as mutator genes in evolution. Nature 303:633–635
Charlesworth D, Charlesworth B, Bull JJ (1988) Origin of mutants disputed. Nature 336:525
Cox EC (1976) Bacterial mutator genes and the control of spontaneous mutation. Annu Rev Genet 10:135–156
Cox EC, Gibson TC (1974) Selection for high mutation rates in chemostats. Genetics 77:169–184
Davis BD (1989) Transcriptional bias: a non-Lamarckian mechanism for substrate-induced mutations. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86:5005–5009
Demassey B, Fayet O, Kogoma T (1984) Multiple origin usage for DNA replication in sdr (rnh) mutants of Escherichia coli K12: initiation in the absence of oriC. J Mol Biol 128:227–236
Dijkmans R, Kreps S, Mergeay M (1994) Poisson-like fluctuation patterns of revertants of leucine auxotrophy (leu-500) in Salmonella typhimurium caused by delay in mutant cell division. Genetics 137: 353–359
Drake JW (1991a) A constant rate of spontaneous mutation in DNA-based microbes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 88:7160–7164
Drake JW (1991b) Spontaneous mutation. Annu Rev Genet 25:125–146
Eshel I (1973) Clone selection and the evolution of modifying features. Theor Pop Biol 4:196–208
Foster PL (1992) Directed mutation: between unicorns and goats. J Bacteriol 174:1711–1716
Foster PL (1993) Adaptive mutation: the uses of adversity. Ann Rev Microbiol 47:467–504
Foster PL, Cairns J (1992) Mechanisms of directed mutation. Genetics 131:783–789
Foster PL, Cairns J (1995) The occurrence of heritable Mu excisions in starving cells of Escherichia coli. EMBO J (in press)
Foster PL, Trimarchi JM (1994) Adaptive reversion of a frameshift mutation in Escherichia coli by simple base deletions in homopolymeric runs. Science 265:407–409
Gillespie JH (1981a) Mutation modification in a random environment. Evolution 35:468–476
Gillespie JH (1981b) Evolution of the mutation rate at a heterotic locus. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 78:2452–2454
Hall BG (1988) Adaptive evolution that requires multiple spontaneous mutations. I. Mutations involving an insertion sequence. Genetics 120:887–897
Hall BG (1990) Spontaneous point mutations that occur more often when advantageous than when neutral. Genetics 126:5–16
Hall BG (1991) Adaptive evolution that requires multiple spontaneous mutations: mutations involving base substitutions. Proc Natl Acad USA 88:5882–5886
Hall BG (1992) Selection-induced mutations occur in yeast. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89:4300–4303
Hall BG (1993) The role of single-mutant intermediates in the generation of trpAB double revertants during prolonged selection. J Bacteriol 175:6411–6414
Hall BG (1994) On alternatives to selection-induced mutation in the bgl operon of Escherichia coli. Mol Biol Evol 11:159–168
Harris RS, Longerich S, Rosenberg SM (1994) Recombination in adaptive mutation. Science 264:258–260
Holsinger K, Feldman MW (1983) Modifiers of mutation rate: evolutionary optimum with complete selfing. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 80:6772–6784
Ishii K, Matsuda H, Iwasa Y, Sasaki A (1989) Evolutionarily stable mutation rate in a periodically changing environment. Genetics 121:163–174
Kimura M (1960) Optimum mutation rate and degree of dominance as determined by the principle of minimum genetic load. J Genet 57:21–34
Kimura M (1967) On the evolutionary adjustment of spontaneous mutation rates. Genet Res Camb 9:23–34
Koch AL (1982) Mutation and growth rates from Luria-Delbrück fluctuation tests. Mutat Res 95:129–143
Kondrashov AS (1988) Deleterious mutations and the evolution of sexual reproduction. Nature 336:435–440
Lederberg J, Lederberg EM (1952) Replica plating and indirect selection of bacterial mutants. J Bacteriol 63:399–406
Leigh EG (1970) Natural selection and mutability. Am Nat 104:301–305
Leigh EG (1973) The evolution of mutation rates. Genetics (Suppl)73: 1–18
Lenski RE (1989) Are some mutations directed? Trends Ecol Evol 4:148–150
Lenski RE, Mittler JE (1993) The directed mutation controversy and neo-darwinism. Science 259:188–194
Lenski RE, Slatkin M, Ayala FJ (1989) Mutation and selection in bacterial populations: alternatives to the hypothesis of directed mutation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86:2775–2778
Levins R (1967) Theory of fitness in a heterogeneous environment. VI. The adaptive significance of mutation. Genetics 56:163–178
Lincoln RJ, Boxshall GA, Clark PF (1982) A dictionary of ecology, evolution and systematics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Luria SE, Delbrück M (1943) Mutations of bacteria from virus sensitivity to virus resistance. Genetics 28:491–511
MacPhee DG (1993a) Is there evidence for directed mutation in bacteria? Mutagenesis 8:3–5
MacPhee DG (1993b) Directed mutation: paradigm postponed. Mutat Res 285:109–116
Maenhaut-Michel G, Shapiro JA The roles of starvation and selective substrates in the emergence of araB-lacZ fusion clones. EMBO J (in press)
Milder JE, Lenski RE (1990) New data on excisions of Mu from E. coli MCS2 cast doubt on directed mutation hypothesis. Nature 344: 173–175
Milder JE, Lenski RE (1992) Experimental evidence for an alternative to directed mutation in the bgl operon. Nature 356:446–448
Moxon ER, Rainey PB, Nowak MA, Lenski RE (1994) Adaptive evolution of highly mutable loci in pathogenic bacteria. Curr Biol 4:24–33
Painter PR (1975) Clone selection and the mutation rate. Theor Pop Biol 8:74–80
Rosenberg SM, Longerich S, Gee P, Harris RS (1994) Adaptive mutation by deletions in small mononucleotide repeats. Science 265: 405–407
Shapiro JA (1984) Observations on the formation of clones containing araB-lacZ cistron fusions. Mol Gen Genet 194:79–90
Shapiro JA, Leach D (1990) Action of a transposable element in coding sequence fusions. Genetics 126:293–299
Smith KG (1992) Spontaneous mutagenesis: experimental, genetic and other factors. Mutat Res 277:139–162
Stahl FW (1988) A unicorn in the garden. Nature 355:112–113
Stahl FW (1992) Unicorns revisited. Genetics 132:865–867
Steele DF, Jinks-Robertson S (1992) An examination of adaptive reversion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Genetics 132:9–21
Stewart FM, Gordon DM, Levin BR (1990) Fluctuation analysis: the probability distribution of the number of mutants under different conditions. Genetics 124:175–185
Stewart FM (1994) Fluctuation tests: how reliable are the estimates of mutation rates? Genetics 137:1139–1146
Sturtevant AH (1937) Essays on evolution. I. On the effects of selection on mutation rate. Q Rev Biol 12:467–477
Symonds N (1989) Anticipatory mutagenesis? Nature 337:119–120
Tessman I (1988) Origin of mutants disputed. Nature 336:527
Thaler DS, Stahl FW (1988) DNA double-chain breaks in recombination of phage λ and of yeast. Annu Rev Genet 22:169–197
Tröbner W, Piechocki R (1984a) Competition between isogenic mutS and mut + populations of Escherichia coli K12 in continuously growing cultures. Mol Gen Genet 198:175–176
Tröbner W, Piechocki R (1984b) Selection against hypermutability in Escherichia coli during long term evolution. Mol Gen Genet 198: 177–178
Witkin E, Kogoma T (1984) Involvement of the activated form of RecA protein in SOS mutagenesis and stable DNA replication in Escherichia coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 81:7539–7543
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sniegowski, P.D. The origin of adaptive mutants: Random or nonrandom?. J Mol Evol 40, 94–101 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00166600
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00166600