Abstract
We discuss an elementary derivation of variational symmetries and corresponding integrals of motion for the Lagrangian systems depending on acceleration. Providing several examples, we make the manuscript accessible to a wide range of readers with an interest in higher-order Lagrangians and symmetries. The discussed technique is also applicable to the Lagrangian systems with higher-order derivatives.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
There are many reasons why physicists and mathematicians are interested in studying Lagrangian systems with higher-order derivatives. The history of such theories dates back to the study of instabilities due to Ostrogradsky [1]. Since then, theories with higher-order derivatives have been studied by many authors from various view points.Footnote 1
In [6] (see also [7, 8]) authors presented an elementary derivation of the variational symmetries and the integrals of motion associated with them. In this paper, we will consider an extension of this idea to the Lagrangian systems with higher-order derivatives, especially in the case when the Lagrangian depends on generalized acceleration. Essentially, we give a derivation of the equation that determines variational symmetries and then obtain integrals of motion for some systems. To our knowledge, this technique is the simplest way to obtain integrals of motion for the Lagrangian systems with higher-order derivatives. It should be stressed that all computations presented here rely heavily on group-theoretical studies of differential equations [9,10,11,12].
The paper is organized as follows. The variational symmetries and the relevant techniques are discussed in Sects. 2 and 3. Then we present some examples in Sect. 4, where we mainly focus on the Lagrangians with second-order derivatives. In Sect. 5, we shortly discuss higher orders.
2 Variational symmetries for second-order lagrangians
The Euler-Lagrange equation for the Lagrangian depending on second derivatives of generalized coordinates \(L=L(\textbf{x},\dot{\textbf{x}},\ddot{\textbf{x}};t)\) has the following form,
This is a fourth-order ordinary differential equationFootnote 2. We are going to construct variational symmetries for this Lagrangian system by solving some corresponding differential equations.
Consider an action \(S=\int L(\textbf{x},\dot{\textbf{x}},\ddot{\textbf{x}};t) \; \textrm{d}t\) which is invariant under the invertible s-parametric transformations \(x'_i=x'_i(\textbf{x},t,s)\) and \(t'=t'(\textbf{x},t,s)\). These transformations form a one-parameter group (with the parameter s). The corresponding infinitesimal transformations for a system with n degrees of freedom are
where the functions \(\eta _i\) and \(\xi\) are given by
The invariance of the action under these transformations (in order to obtain the same equations of motion) implies that
where we added the total derivative term to the Lagrangian. If the Lagrangian transforms under the transformations (2.2–2.3) as in expression (2.6) then the corresponding symmetry is called a variational symmetry of Lagrangian. By differentiating the last expression with respect to the parameter s and by setting \(s=0\) one obtains
For the terms inside the square brackets, we used the following expressions
where we just used the chain rule for \(\dot{x}_i'=\dfrac{\textrm{d}x_i'}{\textrm{d t}}\dfrac{\textrm{d}t}{\textrm{d}t'}\), rest follows from the definitions (2.2) and (2.3). Similarly, for acceleration one gets
and the gauge function \(G(\textbf{x},\dot{\textbf{x}};t)\) is defined as
Now by using the Euler-Lagrange Eq. (2.1) in the expression (2.7), one ends up with the following expression
The expression in the bracket is conserved, i.e. it is integral of motion under the time evolution [6, 13]. This expression is an analog of the Rund-Trautman identityFootnote 3 [15,16,17].
Now let us compute variational symmetries for some Lagrangian systems with the second-order derivatives. Using the expression (2.7) one can easily derive integrals of motion for relatively simple systems.
2.1 Spinning particle
We begin with the most familiar example of the second-order Lagrangian systems, namely with the Lagrangian of the classical spinning particle (for simplicity we set the dimensional parameters to 1)
The Euler-Lagrange equation for this system is the following fourth-order differential equation which describes a particle rotating around its translating center
This system was discussed in many works, the integrals of motion and related symmetries can be found, e.g. in [18]. Inserting the Lagrangian of the spinning particle into the expression (2.7) yields
Since the gauge function \(G(x,\dot{x};t)\) is not a function of \(\ddot{x}\) coefficients of \(\ddot{x}^2\) and \(\ddot{x}\) terms should vanish. As a result, we obtain the following differential equations
In some sense, these equations have the same complexity as the Euler-Lagrange equations, here the idea is to find symmetries and corresponding integrals of motion. The Eq. (2.15) implies that \(\xi (x;t)\) is not a function of x and moreover \(\eta (x;t)\) can be found as
where A(t) is a function of time only. If we insert the expression for \(\eta\) in the expressions (2.16–2.17), we obtain the following equations for the partial differentials of the gauge function \(G(x,\dot{x};t)\)
By comparing them one obtains the following four ordinary differential equations
One can straightforwardly solve these differential equations, and find that
Therefore \(\eta (x;t)\) has the form
where \(c_2\), \(c_3\), \(c_4\) and \(c_5\) are arbitrary constants. It is easy to compute the gauge function \(G(x,\dot{x};t)\)
Now by inserting \(\eta\), \(\xi\) and G into the (2.11) one ends up with the following expression
Since \(c_1\), \(c_2\), \(c_3\), \(c_4\) and \(c_5\) are arbitrary constants, terms within the parenthesis are integrals of motion with the following symmetry generators
Note that in the two-dimensional case, i.e. if the Lagrangian of the spinning particle has a form
we will get one more integral of motion (the third component of the angular momentum)
As one can see, we constructed the infinitesimal transformations by solving corresponding differential equations.Footnote 4
3 Cyclic coordinates
If we have a one-parameter symmetry group of the action, then we can discard one of the coordinates and consider the parameter s as a new coordinate. Then the coordinate s turns out to be cyclic (ignorable) and the corresponding momentum is conserved. Actually, this is an idea of Noether’s theorem.
We would like to show that for \(L(\textbf{x},\dot{\textbf{x}},\ddot{\textbf{x}};t)\), there exists a coordinate system \(({\textbf{x}}', t')\) such that for a fixed k the momentum conjugate corresponding to \({x_k}'\) is conserved.
Under coordinate transformations \(x_i= x_i({\textbf{x}}',t')\) and \(t = t({\textbf{x}}',t')\), Lagrangian transforms as;
In order to simplify this expression, we make the following definitions and follow the same method used in Sect. 2,
Note that the definitions for the functions \(\xi\) and \(\eta\) correspond directly to their definitions in (2.5–2.4), but now the parameter s is the cyclic coordinate \(x'_k\). Then the corresponding momentum takes the following form
One can also consider the case where \(x'_k\) is not necessarily cyclic. If,
then from the Euler-Lagrange equations (2.1),
In the extended configuration space, the expression (3.7) corresponds to
Hence the conserved quantity takes the form given in the expression (2.11).
It is still possible to write an equivalent Lagrangian \(\tilde{L}'\) where \(x_k'\) is a cyclic coordinate. For that reason we define a function \(F(\textbf{x}', \dot{\textbf{x}}'; t')\) as follows
Now, it is easy to see that defining a new Lagrangian as \(\tilde{L'}= L '+\dfrac{\textrm{d} F}{\textrm{d} t'}\) will result in an equivalent Lagrangian with a cyclic coordinate \(x'_k\) since
The definition made for the Gauge function \(G(\textbf{x}', \dot{\textbf{x}}'; t')\) is the same as in (2.10), except the sign difference that arises as now the total derivative is added to the transformed Lagrangian.
4 Examples
4.1 Higher-derivative harmonic oscillator
As an elementary example, we will consider the following second-order Lagrangian
This system was studied as a toy model in [19, 20]. We need to find variational symmetries satisfying the condition (3.5). Substituting the above Lagrangian into the Eq. (3.5), we obtain
where the gauge function \(G(x,\dot{x};t)\) is a function of t, x and \(\dot{x}\). Following the same method that we have explained in our previous example, we can express our functions as follows
Corresponding symmetry generators and integrals of motion are
In order to simplify the problem of finding a Lagrangian with a cyclic coordinate, we will consider the case where \(c_i\)’s are all equal to zero except \(c_2\) which equals to 1. Then
The coordinate transformations satisfying these equations are
Under these transformations, the Lagrangian (4.1) transforms as
The Lagrangian \(\tilde{L}'\) where \(x'\) is a cyclic coordinate is given by
where \(F(x, \dot{x}, t)\) is defined as in (3.10). After expressing \(G(x,\dot{x},t)\) and \(F(x, \dot{x}, t)\) in terms of primed coordinates, we simply follow the definition and \(\tilde{L}'\) takes the following form,
where \(x'\) is clearly cyclic. The momentum conjugate corresponding to the coordinate x is
Returning to our initial coordinate system, the conserved quantity corresponds to,
which is also given by (2.11).
4.2 An illustrative example
Now, we would like to move on to a slightly more complicated case. As a next example, consider a system with the following Lagrangian
The Euler-Lagrange equation for this system is the following ordinary differential equation
By applying (2.7) we obtain the following partial differential equation
from which one can easily find that \(\xi =\xi (t)\). Then
Therefore \(\eta (x;t)\) has the form \(\eta =\dfrac{3}{4}x\dfrac{\textrm{d}\xi }{\textrm{d}t}+\dfrac{A(t)}{x}\).
The partial differential equations involving derivatives of the gauge functions are
By solving these equations one finds \(\xi\) and A as
and the gauge function \(G(x,\dot{x};t)\) as
Therefore the symmetry generators and corresponding integrals of motion are
In order to pass into primed coordinates where \(x'\) is a cyclic coordinate, for simplicity we set \(c_1 = 1\) and other constants to zero. Then we make a suitable coordinate transformation,
The gauge function \(G(x,\dot{x};t)\) in old coordinates is given by the expression
and
From the Eq. (3.11) the new Lagrangian \(\tilde{L}'\) gives to the desired result
Here \(x'\) is a cyclic coordinate and the corresponding conserved momentum gives the expression (4.26).
4.3 Free particle with a Chern-Simons-like term
Now let us examine a system with two degrees of freedom. We consider the following Lagrangian system introduced by Lukierski, Stichel, and Zakrzewski [21]
where m stands for the mass, and \(\lambda\) is some parameter. Since the latter parameter labels the central extension [21] and has interesting properties, we especially keep the parameters m and \(\lambda\). The Euler-Lagrange equations are
Since in general \(\eta _1\), \(\eta _2\) and \(\xi\) depend on x, y, and t using our prescription one obtains the following three partial differential equations
By solving these equations, one finds infinitesimal transformations and the gauge function as
Then the integrals of motion with the corresponding symmetry generators are
From the form of the Lagrangian (4.37), it can be seen that x and y are cyclic coordinates. We will pursue the same method to find the Lagrangian \(\tilde{L}'\), where the momentum conjugate corresponding to \(x'\) is given by (2.11). Consider the case in which \(c_2=1\) is the only constant that does not equal to zero. Then
It is clear that these symmetries correspond to the transformation to polar coordinates
After calculating the first and second derivatives of the primed coordinates, we can rewrite our Lagrangian as
Obviously, \(x'\) is a cyclic coordinate and the corresponding conserved quantity to the symmetry is as follows
which is also given by (4.48).
5 Variational symmetries for high-order lagrangians
Finally, let us generalize what we have done in the previous sections for Lagrangian systems with Nth order derivatives
Using the same procedure one find the generalized version of the Eq. (2.7)
The generalized form of the Eq. (2.11) can be written as follows [2]
As an example let us consider the system with the following Lagrangian
The Euler-Lagrange equation of the system is the sixth order ordinary differential equation
Substituting the Lagrangian into the expression (5.2) we obtain the following result
Using these expressions we find symmetry generators and integrals of motion
6 Conclusions
This paper dealt with an elementary derivation of integrals of motion for higher-order Lagrangian systems based on the variational symmetries technique. The methods used here to compute variational symmetries and related integrals of motion are an extension of those used in [6] and [7]. We provided variational symmetries of higher-order Lagrangian systems which are well-known in the literature and studied from different viewpoints.
The symmetries discussed here can be useful also in the context of the quantization of the higher derivative Lagrangian systems. Another possible direction is the derivation of symmetries for field theories with higher-derivative terms.
Data availability
No Data associated in the manuscript.
Notes
Assuming we have a non-degenerate system, i.e. \(\det \left( \dfrac{\partial ^2\,L}{\partial \ddot{x}_i\partial \ddot{x}_j}\right) \ne 0.\)
In the literature, sometimes this expression is called Noether-Bassel-Hagen identity, see e.g. [14].
Of course, if one knows the symmetries in advance, then it is easier to use the Noether theorem to obtain the integrals of motion.
References
M. Ostrogradsky, Memoires l’acad. imperiale sci. st, Petersbourg, IV 385 (1850)
R.P. Woodard, Ostrogradsky’s theorem on Hamiltonian instability. Sch. Ser. 10(8), 32243 (2015). https://doi.org/10.4249/scholarpedia.32243. arXiv:1506.02210 [hep-th]
M. de León, D.M. de Diego, Symmetries and constants of the motion for higher-order lagrangian systems. J. Math. Phys. Ser. 36(8), 4138–4161 (1995)
F. Çağatay Uçgun, O. Esen, H. Gümral, Reductions of topologically massive gravity i: hamiltonian analysis of second order degenerate lagrangians. J. Math. Phys. 59(1), 013510 (2018)
M. Cruz, R. Gómez-Cortés, A. Molgado, E. Rojas, Hamiltonian analysis for linearly acceleration-dependent lagrangians. J. Math. Phys. Ser. 57(6), 062903 (2016)
G. Torres del Castillo, C. Andrade Mirón, R. Bravo Rojas, Variational symmetries of lagrangians. Revista mexicana de física E 59(2), 140–147 (2013)
G.T. del Castillo, I. Rubalcava-García, Variational symmetries as the existence of ignorable coordinates. Eur. J. Phys. Ser. 38(2), 025002 (2017)
G. Arutyunov, Liouville integrability, In Elements of Classical and Quantum Integrable Systems, pp. 1–68. Springer, (2019)
N.H. Ibragimov, CRC handbook of Lie group analysis of differential equations, vol. 3 (1995)
N.K. Ibragimov, Group analysis of ordinary differential equations and the invariance principle in mathematical physics (for the 150th anniversary of sophus lie). Russ. Math. Surv. Ser. 47(4), 89 (1992)
G. Bluman, S. Anco, Symmetry and integration methods for differential equations, vol. 154 (Springer Science & Business Media, 2008)
P.J. Olver, Applications of Lie groups to differential equations, vol. 107 (Springer Science & Business Media, 2000)
A. Deriglazov, Classical Mechanics (Springer, 2016)
R. Leone, On the wonderfulness of noether’s theorems, 100 years later, and routh reduction, arXiv preprint arXiv:1804.01714 (2018)
A. Trautman, Noether equations and conservation laws. Commun. Math. Phys. Ser. 6(4), 248–261 (1967)
D.E. Neuenschwander, Emmy Noether’s wonderful theorem (JHU Press, 2017)
T. Gourieux, R. Leone, Noether’s theorem, the rund-trautman function, and adiabatic invariance. Eur. J. Phys. Ser. 42(3), 035009 (2021)
M. Crâşmăreanu, A noetherian symmetry for 2d spinning particle. Int. J. Non-Linear Mech. 35(5), 947–951 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0020-7462(99)00072-4
A.V. Smilga, Ghost-free higher-derivative theory. Phys. Lett. B Ser. 632, 433–438 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2005.10.014. arXiv:hep-th/0503213
N. Boulanger, F. Buisseret, F. Dierick, O. White, Higher-derivative harmonic oscillators: stability of classical dynamics and adiabatic invariants. Eur. Phys. J. C 79(1), 60 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1140/epjc/s10052-019-6569-y. arXiv:1811.07733 [physics.class-ph]
J. Lukierski, P.C. Stichel, W.J. Zakrzewski, Galilean-invariant (2+1)-dimensional models with a chern-simons-like term and d = 2 noncommutative geometry. Ann. Phys. 260(2), 224–249 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1006/aphy.1997.5729
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank all the participants of the seminar series on “Higher-derivative systems” held at Bogazici University in the summer of 2020. The work of Ilmar Gahramanov is partially supported by the Bogazici University Research Fund under grant number 20B03SUP3. Ege Çoban and Dilara Kosva are supported by the 2209-A TUBITAK National/International Research Projects Fellowship Programme for Undergraduate Students under grant number 1919B012000987.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Coban, E., Gahramanov, I. & Kosva, D. Variational symmetries of Lagrangian systems with second-order derivatives. Eur. Phys. J. Plus 138, 605 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1140/epjp/s13360-023-04241-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjp/s13360-023-04241-5