Abstract
Intelligence Studies, as with all fields of enquiry in the social sciences and humanities, is replete with individuals seeking to develop concepts and models that will allow the specific to illuminate the universal. In short, one might be said to require a unifying theory of intelligence. This chapter argues that it is futile to seek a grand theory; instead, a better understanding and cognition of ‘intelligence’ should be sought.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
- 1.
In 2006 John Ferris similarly noted that ‘Fundamentally, intelligence is a human action and so is inherently ambiguous and provides no certainties; actions based on it are gambles’ (Treverton et al. 2006: 11–20).
- 2.
The debates surrounding the revelations by the Church inquiry in the 1970s in the US were intense and widely discussed in the media but the ongoing debates in a number of countries, including the US, the UK and Germany, are arguably unique in their width and policy impact.
- 3.
Gill suggests six areas for research on intelligence: governance, process, structures, cooperation, actors/ethics and oversight. (Gill 2010: 47).
- 4.
For some commonalities between Intelligence Studies and Terrorism Studies, see Phythian (2009: 66–67).
- 5.
The early works on intelligence, most notably the pioneering Strategic Intelligence for American World Policy by Sherman Kent, outlined the intelligence mission. From these foundations, scholars of intelligence have become intimately acquainted with a three-cornered model: with key functions of intelligence being collection, information assessment and policy-input. Associated with this is ‘a fourth, operational function of intelligence, incorporating such activities as propaganda, covert operations and paramilitary conflict…this paradigm will continue to be debated and refined, as scholars seek the boundaries of the concept of ‘intelligence’ and attempt to reassess the range of intelligence functions’ (Wark 1993: 4–5, quote at 5).
- 6.
Though this might sound like an obvious point, Agrell (2014: 133) is surely right in stating that ‘our inability to take into account fundamental changes, even though history is made up of them, is sometimes stunning.’
- 7.
On this, see Hughes/Stoddart (2014).
- 8.
Metadata is data about data. Structural metadata is concerned with the repositories of data; descriptive metadata is concerned with the content of said data depositaries.
- 9.
Hansard, House of Commons Official Report, Parliamentary Debates, volume 601/4, column 969, 4 November 2015.
- 10.
In December 1971, British Home Secretary Reginald Maudling notoriously declared that the situation in Northern Ireland at that time amounted to ‘an acceptable level of violence’. (Chartres 1971). Subsequently, and to this day, Maudling’s phrase was widely regarded as a crass verbal error.
Bibliography
Agrell, Wilhelm (2014) ‘The next 100 years? Reflections on the future of intelligence’ In Duyvesteyn, Isabelle/De Jong, Ben/Van Reijn, Joop (eds), The Future of Intelligence: Challenges in the 21st Century, London: Routledge.
Amy Zegart (2009) Spying Blind: The CIA, the FBI, and the Origins of 9/11, California: Princeton University Press.
Arcos, Ruben/Pherson, Randolph eds (2015) Intelligence Communication in the Digital Era: Transforming Security, Defence and Business, Basingstoke: Palgrave Pivot.
Betts, Richard K. (1978) ‘Analysis, War, and Decision: Why Intelligence Failures Are Inevitable,’ World Politics 31/1, 61–89.
Betz, David J./Stevens, Tim (2011) Cyberspace and the State: Toward a Strategy for Cyber-Power, London: International Institute for Strategic Studies.
Boone, J.V./Peterson, R. R. (2009 [2000]) Sigsaly: The Start of the Digital Revolution, Washington, DC: NSA.
Buzan, Barry/Wæver, Ole/De Wilde, Jaap (1998) Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Chartres, J. (1971) ‘Home Secretary says IRA may never be totally eliminated’, The Times, 16 December.
Chesterman, Simon (2008) ‘We Can’t Spy…If We Can’t Buy!’: The Privatization of Intelligence and the Limits of Outsourcing ‘Inherently Governmental Functions,’ European Journal of International Law 19/5, 1055–1074.
Chrisafis, Angelique (2015) ‘France passes new surveillance law in wake of Charlie Hebdo attack’, The Guardian, 5 May.
Clausewitz, C. von (1976 [1832–34]) On War (Howard, Michael/Paret, Peter (trans. and ed.)), Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Clegg, Nick (2015) ‘The surveillance bill is flawed but at last we have oversight’, The Guardian, 5 November.
Cole, Chris (2015) ‘Drones aren’t just toys that cause a nuisance: They’re still killing innocent people’, The Guardian, 20 March.
Cole, David (2014) ‘We kill people based on metadata’, New York Review of Books, 10 May.
Crenshaw, Martha (2001) ‘Theories of Terrorism: Instrumental and Organizational Approaches’ In Rapoport, David C. (ed.), From Inside Terrorist Organizations, 2nd edn, London: Frank Cass.
Danermark, Berth/Ekstrom Mats/Jakobsen, Liselotte/Karlsson, Jan Ch. (2002) Explaining Society: Critical Realism in the Social Sciences, London: Routledge.
Davies, Graeme/Johns, Robert (2012) ‘British Public Confidence in MI6 and Government Use of Intelligence: The Effect on Support for Preventive Military Action,’ Intelligence and National Security 27/5, 669–688.
Davies, Philip H. J. (2002) ‘Intelligence, information technology, and information warfare,’ Annual Review of Information Science and Technology 36/1, 313–352.
Davies, Philip H. J. (2009) ‘Theory and intelligence reconsidered’ In Gill, P/Marrin, S./Phythian, M. (eds), Intelligence Theory: Key Debates and Questions, Abingdon/New York: Routledge.
Duyvesteyn, Isabelle, De Jong, Ben/Van Reijn, Joop eds (2014) The Future of Intelligence: Challenges in the 21st Century, London: Routledge.
Enemark, Christian (2013) Armed Drones and the Ethics of War: Military Virtue in a Post-Heroic Age, London: Taylor & Francis.
Enemark, Christian (2014) ‘Drones, Risk, and Perpetual Force,’ Ethics and International Affairs 28/3, 365–381.
Fry, Michael G./Hochstein, Miles. (1993) ‘Epistemic Communities: Intelligence Studies and International Relations,’ Intelligence and National Security 8/3, 14–28.
Gill, Peter (2009) ‘Theories of Intelligence: Where we are, where should we go and how might we proceed?’ In Gill, Peter/Marrin, Stephen/Phythian, Mark (eds), Intelligence Theory: Key Questions and Debates, Abingdon: Routledge.
Gill, Peter (2010) ‘Theories of Intelligence’ In Johnson, Loch (ed), The Oxford Handbook of National Security Intelligence, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Handel, Michael ed. (1990) Intelligence and Military Operations, London: Frank Cass.
Hegel, Georg W. F. (1956 [1837]) The Philosophy of History, New York: Dover.
Her Majesty’s Government [HMG] (2010) A Strong Britain in an Age of Uncertainty: The National Security Strategy, Presented to Parliament by the Prime Minister by Command of Her Majesty, October 2010, Cm 7953. ‘Foreword’ by Cameron, David/Clegg, Nick.
Herman, M. (1996) Intelligence Power in Peace and War, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hope, Christopher (2015) ‘Spies should be able to monitor all online messaging, says David Cameron’, Daily Telegraph, 12 January.
Hughes, David (2015) ‘Jeremy Corbyn claims RAF drone strike in Syria was “legally questionable”’, The Independent, 17 September.
Hughes, R. Gerald (2008) ‘Of Revelatory Histories and Hatchet Jobs: Propaganda and Method in Intelligence History,’ Intelligence and National Security 23/6, 842–877.
Hughes, R. Gerald (2014) ‘Strategists and intelligence’ In Dover, Robert/Goodman, Michael/Hillebrand, Claudia (eds), Routledge Companion to Intelligence Studies, New York: Taylor & Francis.
Hughes, R. Gerald/Heley, Jesse (2015) ‘Between Man and Nature: The enduring wisdom of Sir Halford J. Mackinder,’ Journal of Strategic Studies 38/6, 898–935.
Hughes, R. Gerald/Scott, Len (2008) ‘“Knowledge is never too dear”: Exploring intelligence archives’ In Hughes, R. Gerald/Jackson, Peter/Scott, Len (eds), Exploring Intelligence Archives: Enquiries into the Secret State, London and New York: Studies in Intelligence.
Hughes, R. Gerald/Stoddart, Kristan (2014) ‘Intelligence since 9/11’ In Johnson, Loch/Wirtz, James (eds), Intelligence: The Secret World of Spies: An Anthology, 4th edn, New York: Oxford University Press.
Iggers, George G. (1997) Historiography in the Twentieth Century: From Scientific Objectivity to the Postmodern Challenge, Hanover, NH: Wesleyan University Press.
James, Paul (2006) Globalism, Nationalism, Tribalism: Bringing Theory Back In, London: Sage Publications.
Johnson, Loch K. (2003) ‘Bricks and Mortar for a Theory of Intelligence,’ Comparative Strategy 22/1, 1–28.
Johnson, Loch K. (2009) ‘Sketches for a theory of strategic intelligence’ In Peter Gill, Marrin, Stephen/Phythian, Mark (eds), Intelligence Theory: Key Questions and Debates, Routledge: Abingdon.
Kahn, David (2001) ‘An Historical Theory of Intelligence,’ Intelligence and National Security 16/3, 79–92.
Kahn, David (2006) ‘The Rise of Intelligence,’ Foreign Affairs 85/5, 125–134.
Kent, Sherman (1949) Strategic Intelligence for American World Policy, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Knorr, Klaus (1964) Foreign Intelligence and the Social Sciences, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Laqueur, Walter (1985) A World of Secrets: The Uses and Limits of Intelligence, New York: Basic Books.
Liberty (2014) Liberty’s submission to the Reviewer of Terrorism’s Investigatory Powers Review, London: Liberty.
Liberty (2015a) ‘Tracking, hacking and lip-service to safeguards: Liberty’s analysis of the Draft Investigatory Powers Bill’, press release, 4 November.
Liberty (2015b) ‘Safe and Sound: Protecting security, defending privacy’, https://www.liberty-human-rights.org.uk/campaigning/safe-and-sound.
Lord, Jonathan (2015) ‘Undercover Under Threat: Cover Identity, Clandestine Activity, and Covert Action in the Digital Age,’ International Journal of Intelligence and Counterintelligence 28/4, 666–691.
National Intelligence Strategy of the United States of America (NIS) (2005) Office of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI). ‘Foreword’ by John D. Negroponte.
Obama, Barack (2014) ‘Remarks by the President on Review of Signals Intelligence’, Department of Justice, 17 January. The White House, Washington DC, Office of the Press Secretary. https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/01/17/remarks-president-review-signals-intelligence%3E.
Olson, James M. (2006) Fair Play: The Moral Dilemmas of Spying, Washington, DC: Potomac Books.
Omand, David (2010a) Securing the State, London: Hurst.
Omand, David (2010b) ‘Securing the State: A Question of Balance’, Chatham House, transcript of speech, 8 June.
Omand, David (2014) ‘The future of intelligence: What are the threats, the challenges and the opportunities?’ In Duyvesteyn, Isabelle/De Jong, Ben/Van Reijn, Joop (eds), The Future of Intelligence: Challenges in the 21st Century, London: Routledge.
Orwell, George (1945) ‘Notes on Nationalism’, Polemic, May.
Phythian, Mark (2009) ‘Intelligence theory and theories of international relations’ In Gill, Peter/Marrin, Stephen/Phythian, Mark (eds), 2009, Intelligence Theory: Key Questions and Debates, Abingdon: Routledge, 54–72.
Richelson, Jeffrey T. (2009) ‘Technical collection in the post 9/11 world’ In Treverton, Gregory F./Agrell, Wilhelm (eds), National Intelligence Systems: Current Research and Future Prospects, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Scott, Len (2012) ‘Reflections on the Age of Intelligence,’ Intelligence and National Security 27/5, 617–624.
Scott, Len/Hughes, R. Gerald (2011) ‘The Future of Intelligence: Seeking Perfection in an Imperfect World?’ Scott, Len/Hughes, R Gerald/Alexander, Martin S. (eds), Intelligence and International Security: New Perspectives and Agendas, London: Taylor & Francis.
Scott, Richard/Barker, Jay (2004) Legends of Alabama Football, New York: Sports Publishing Books.
Shields, Patricia M. (1998) ‘Pragmatism as a Philosophy of Science: A Tool for Public Administration’ In White, Jay D. (ed.), Research in Public Administration, Volume 4, Bingley (UK): Emerald.
Sifry, Micah L. (2011) WikiLeaks and the Age of Transparency, New York: OR Books.
Sims, Jennifer (2009) ‘A Theory of Intelligence and International Politics’ In Treverton, Gregory F./Agrell, Wilhelm (eds), National Intelligence Systems: Current Research and Future Prospects, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Strachan, Hew (2007) Carl von Clausewitz’s On War: A Biography, London: Atlantic.
Svendsen, Adam (2012) Understanding the Globalization of Intelligence, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Travis, Alan/Wintour, Patrick/MacAskill, Ewen (2015) ‘Theresa May unveils UK surveillance measures in wake of Snowden claim’, The Guardian, 4 November.
Treverton, Gregory F./Agrell, Wilhelm (2009) ‘Introduction’ In Treverton, Gregory F./Agrell, Wilhelm (eds), National Intelligence Systems: Current Research and Future Prospects, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Treverton, Gregory F., Jones, Seth G./Boraz, Steven/Lipscy, Phillip eds (2006) Toward a Theory of Intelligence: Workshop Report, Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation.
Treverton, Gregory F. (2009) Intelligence for an Age of Terrorism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tzu, Sun (1963) The Art of War, trans. Samuel B. Griffith New York: Oxford University Press.
Vogel, Kathleen/Knight, Christine (2015) ‘Analytical Outreach for Intelligence: Insights from a Workshop on Emerging Biotechnology Threats,’ Intelligence and National Security 30/5, 686–703.
Wark, Wesley K. (1993) ‘The Study of Espionage: Past, Present, Future?’ Intelligence and National Security 8/3, 1–13.
Warner, Michael. (2007) ‘Wanted: A Definition of Intelligence,’ Studies in Intelligence 46/3, 15–22.
Warner, Michael (2009a) ‘Intelligence as risk shifting’ In Gill, Peter/Marrin, Stephen/Phythian, Mark (eds), Intelligence Theory: Key Questions and Debates, Abingdon: Routledge
Warner, Michael (2009b) ‘Building a Theory of Intelligence Systems,’ In Treverton, Gregory F./Agrell, Wilhelm (eds), National Intelligence Systems: Current Research and Future Prospects, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Warner, Michael (2014) The Rise and Fall of Intelligence: An International Security History, Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Waterman, Shaun (2013) ‘Boston bombing investigation reveals intelligence failures’, Washington Times, 23 April.
Watt, Donald Cameron (1988) ‘Intelligence Studies: The Emergence of a British School,’ Intelligence and National Security 3/2, 338–342.
Watt, Donald Cameron (1990) ‘Intelligence and the Historian,’ Diplomatic History 14/2, 199–205.
Weber, Max (1978 [1925]) Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology, Roth, Guenther/Wittich, Claus (eds), Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Weber, Max (2009) From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, Herth H. H./Mills, C. Wright eds and intro.; preface by Turner, Bryan S., London: Routledge.
Zegart, Amy B. (2007) Spying Blind: The CIA, the FBI, and the Origins of 9/11, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 2017 The Author(s)
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Hillebrand, C., Hughes, R.G. (2017). The Quest for a Theory of Intelligence. In: Dover, R., Dylan, H., Goodman, M. (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Security, Risk and Intelligence. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-53675-4_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-53675-4_1
Published:
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-137-53674-7
Online ISBN: 978-1-137-53675-4
eBook Packages: Political Science and International StudiesPolitical Science and International Studies (R0)