Abstract
Empirical and anecdotal evidence point to the advantages of a process orientation from an organizational perspective but do not explicitly consider the potential disadvantages or the employee’s perspective. However, to be able to profit from a process orientation, organizations undergoing a transformation of their organizational structure must ensure that employees adopt a process orientation in their daily work. The purpose of this study is to show the employees’ perspectives on potential (dis)advantages of a process orientation. We surveyed employees in the financial services sector (N = 1,101) with an exploratory design that uses open questions on the main advantages and disadvantages of process orientation. Based on the survey data, we observe advantages that extend beyond those reported by prior research. Additionally, we find that employees partly perceive a process orientation as disadvantageous; this perception, in turn, may lead to the resistance of employees in times of organizational transformations. The findings can serve as a guideline for managers when introducing process orientation in highlighting which disadvantages should be mitigated and which advantages should be emphasized.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Note that although most of the research regarding process management does not explicitly talk about the disadvantages of a process orientation, it indirectly acknowledges that a process-oriented organizational design might not be solely advantageous (e. g., by referring to the advantages in certain circumstances of role-oriented or product-based design). We thank an anonymous reviewer for emphasizing this restriction to the basic assumption of our work.
Please note that the questionnaire additionally contained quantitative questions (e. g., related to design components associated with implementing a process-oriented design, operational performance, innovation ability) that we partly use for another study that answers a different research question.
References
Ambrosini, Véronique, and Cliff Bowman. 2001. Tacit knowledge. Some suggestions for operationalization. Journal of Management Studies 38:811–829.
Artstein, Ron, and Massimo Poesio. 2008. Inter-coder agreement for computational linguistics. Association for Computational Linguistics 34:555–596.
Babić-Hodović, Vesna, Eldin Mehić, and Maja Arslanagić. 2012. The influence of quality practices on BH companies’ business performance. International Journal of Management Cases 14:305–316.
Bamford, David, Paul Forrester, Benjamin Dehe, and Rebecca Georgina Leese. 2015. Partial and iterative lean implementation. Two case studies. International Journal of Operations & Production Management 35:702–727.
Böhrs, Hermann. 1963. Organisation des Industriebetriebes. Wiesbaden: Springer.
Bronzo, Marcelo, Paulo T.V. de Resende, Marcos P.V. de Oliveira, Kevin McCormack, Paulo R. de Sousa, and Reinaldo L. Ferreira. 2013. Improving performance aligning business analytics with process orientation. International Journal of Information Management 33:300–307.
Chen, Haozhe, Yu. Tian, and Patricia J. Daugherty. 2009. Measuring process orientation. The International Journal of Logistics Management 20:213–227.
Ebbers, Joris J., and Nachoem M. Wijnberg. 2009. Organizational memory. From expectations memory to procedural memory. British Journal of Management 20:478–490.
Fließ, Sabine. 2006. Prozessorganisation in Dienstleistungsunternehmen. Stuttgart: Kohlhammer.
Forsberg, Torbjorn, Lars Nilsson, and Antoni Marc. 1999. Process orientation. The Swedish experience. Total Quality Management 10:540–547.
Gaitanides, Michael. 1983. Prozeßorganisation. Entwicklung, Ansätze und Programme prozeßorientierter Organisationsgestaltung. München: Vahlen.
Gaitanides, Michael. 2012. Prozessorganisation. Entwicklung, Ansätze und Programme des Managements von Geschäftsprozessen, 3rd edn., München: Vahlen.
Gustafsson, Anders, Lars Nilsson, and Michael D. Johnson. 2003. The role of quality practices in service organizations. International Journal of Service Industry Management 14:232–244.
Hammer, M. 2007. The process audit. Harvard Business Review 85:111–123.
Hammer, Michael, and James Champy. 1993. Reengineering the corporation. A manifesto for business revolution. New York: HarperCollins.
Hellström, A., and H. Eriksson. 2013. Among fumblers, talkers, mappers and organizers. Four applications of process orientation. Total Quality Management and Business Excellence 24:733–751.
Hennig, Karl Wilhelm. 1934. Einführung in die betriebswirtschaftliche Organisationslehre. Berlin: Julius Springer.
Kohlbacher, Markus, and Stefan Gruenwald. 2011. Process orientation. Conceptualization and measurement. Business Process Management Journal 17:267–283.
Kohlbacher, Markus, and Hajo A. Reijers. 2013. The effects of process-oriented organizational design on firm performance. Business Process Management Journal 19:245–262.
Kosiol, Erich. 1934. Organisation und Betriebswirtschaft. Die Betriebswirtschaft 27:81–85.
Kumar, Uma, Kayvan Miri-Lavassani, Bahar Movahedi, and Vinod Kumar. 2011. Champions in transition. The role of process orientation. The TQM Journal 23:326–342.
Küng, Peter, and Hagen Claus. 2007. The fruits of business process management. An experience report from a Swiss bank. Business Process Management Journal 13:477–487.
Leyer, Michael, and Jutta Wollersheim. 2013. How to learn process-oriented thinking. An experimental investigation of the effectiveness of different learning modes. Schmalenbachs Business Review 65:454–473.
Liebert, Thomas. 2012. Prozessorientierung in der Unternehmensorganisation. Eine empirische Untersuchung in deutschen Industrieunternehmen. Wiesbaden: Springer Gabler.
McCormack, Kevin P. 2001. Business process orientation. Do you have it? Quality Progress 34:51–58.
Miles, Matthew B., and Michael A. Huberman. 2004. Qualitative data analysis. An expanded sourcebook, 2nd edn., Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
Nilsson, Lars, Michael D. Johnson, and Anders Gustafsson. 2001. The impact of quality practices on customer satisfaction and business results. Product versus service organizations. Journal of Quality Management 6:5–27.
Nippa, Michael. 1995. Anforderungen an das Management prozeßorientierter Unternehmen. In Prozeßmanagement und Reengineering. Die Praxis im deutschsprachigen Raum, ed. Michael Nippa, Arnold Picot, 39–60. Frankfurt am Main: University of Rostock.
Nordsieck, Fritz. 1931. Aufgabenverteilung und Instanzenbau im Betrieb. Grundprobleme und Grundprinzipien der Organisation des Betriebsaufbaus II. Die Betriebswirtschaft 24:204–210.
Nordsieck, Fritz. 1934. Grundlagen der Organisationslehre. Stuttgart: Poeschel.
Nordsieck, Fritz. 1961. Betriebsorganisation. Betriebsaufbau und Betriebsablauf. Stuttgart: Poeschel.
Osterloh, Margit, and Jetta Frost. 1996. Prozeßmanagement als Kernkompetenz. Wiesbaden: Gabler.
Osterloh, Margit, and Jetta Frost. 2006. Prozessmanagement als Kernkompetenz, 5th edn., Wiesbaden: Gabler.
Parker, Sharon K. 2003. Longitudinal effects of lean production on employee outcomes and the mediating role of work characteristics. Journal of Applied Psychology 88:620–634.
Picot, Arnold, Helmut Dietl, and Egon Franck. 1997. Organisation. Eine ökonomische Perspektive. Stuttgart: Schäffer Poeschel.
Picot, Arnold, Helmut Dietl, Egon Franck, Marina Fiedler, and Susanne Royer. 2015. Organisation. Theorie und Praxis aus ökonomischer Sicht, 7th edn., Stuttgart: Schäffer Poeschel.
Piercy, Niall, and Nick Rich. 2009. Lean transformation in the pure service environment. The case of the call service centre. International Journal of Operations & Production Management 29:54–76.
Reijers, Hajo A. 2006. Implementing BPM systems. The role of process orientation. Business Process Management Journal 12:389–409.
Rohner, Peter. 2012. Achieving impact with clinical process management in hospitals. An inspiring case. Business Process Management Journal 18:600–624.
Schmelzer, Hermann J., and Wolfgang Sesselmann. 2001. Geschäftsprozessmanagement in der Praxis. München Wien: Hanser.
Schmelzer, Hermann J., and Wolfgang Sesselmann. 2013. Geschäftsprozessmanagement in der Praxis. Kunden zufrieden stellen – Produktivität steigern – Wert erhöhen, 8th edn., München: Hanser.
Tang, Jing, L.G. Pee, and Junichi Iijima. 2013. Investigating the effects of business process orientation on organizational innovation performance. Information & Management 50:650–660.
Wollersheim, Jutta, Michael Leyer, and Matthias Spörrle. 2016. When more is not better. The effect of the number of learning interventions on the acquisition of process-oriented thinking. Management Learning 47:137–157.
Zarei, Behrouz, Yahya Chaghouee, and Amir H. Ghapanachi. 2014. Investigating the relationship between business process orientation and social capital. Knowledge and Process Management 21:67–77.
Škrinjar, Rok, V. Bosilj-Vuksin, and M. Indihar-Stemberger. 2008. The impact of business processs orientation on financial and non-financial performance. Business Process Management Jornal 14:738–754.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
M. Leyer and J. Stumpf-Wollersheim contributed equally to this work and should be considered co-first authors.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Leyer, M., Stumpf-Wollersheim, J. & Kronsbein, D. Stains on the Bright Side of Process-Oriented Organizational Designs: an Empirical Investigation of Advantages and Disadvantages. Schmalenbach Bus Rev 18, 29–47 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s41464-016-0020-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41464-016-0020-9