Abstract
Maintaining wellbore stability is the basis and prerequisite for efficient methane production from offshore gas hydrates. Nevertheless, owing to the invasion and disturbance by drilling mud, gas hydrates around wellbore gradually dissociate, resulting in the rapid reduction of sediment strength, thereby the borehole collapse. Accurate design of mud density based on appropriate strength criterion is a feasible measure to avoid this case, but the traditional Mohr–Coulomb (MC) criterion was commonly used now. Herein, the self-designed low temperature triaxial experimental equipment was set up to explore the strength of sediment with different saturation of hydrate, and a new strength criterion was developed. Moreover, impact law and mechanism of several critical factors on the lower limit of the safe mud weight window (abbreviated as MDlow value) was then investigated. The investigation results showed that the MDlow value calculated by the new criterion is higher (or more conservative), which is more conducive for prevention of borehole collapse. Further analysis reveals that the increase of cohesion or hydrate saturation enhances the reservoir strength, resulting in the smaller MDlow value. In this way, the wider window is more conducive to reasonable mud density design. Furthermore, the safe mud weight window for hydrate reservoir is temperature sensitive, and it varies obviously when the drilling fluid temperature is between 288.14 K and 288.45 K. Finally, the investigation in this study also shows that the MDlow value was still affected by stress difference. The preferred design strategy is to orient the azimuth of wellbore axis at 90° if horizontal wellbore is drilled for hydrate development.
Article highlights
-
The Modified Mohr–Coulomb (MMC) strength criterion suitable for hydrate deposits is established.
-
Determination method for MDlow value required for drilling in the hydrate reservoir is obtained.
-
Factors affecting the MDlow value are also investigated to provide reference for the engineering application of hydrate development.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.References
Aadnoy BS, Chenevert ME (1987) Stability of highly inclined boreholes. SPE Drill Eng 2(4):364–374
Åstrand GJ (2015) Borehole stability: comparing the deviation sensibility of different failure criteria. Dissertation, Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Birchwood R, Noeth S, Hooyman P, Winters W, Jones E (2005) Wellbore Stability Model for Marine Sediments Containing Gas Hydrates. In: Proceedings of AADE 2005 National Technical Conference and Exhibition, San Antonio
Bradley WB (1979) Failure of inclined boreholes. J Energy Res Technol 101(4):232–239
Cha Y, Yun TS, Kim YJ, Lee JY, Kwon T (2016) Geomechanical, hydraulic and thermal characteristics of deep oceanic sandy sediments recovered during the second Ulleung basin gas hydrate expedition. Energies 9(10):775
Chaturvedi E, Patidar K, Srungavarapu M, Laik S, Mandal A (2018) Thermodynamics and kinetics of methane hydrate formation and dissociation in presence of calcium carbonate. Adv Powder Technol 29(4):1025–1034
Chen D, Yao Y, Fu G, Meng H, Xie S (2016) A new model for predicting liquid loading in deviated gas wells. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 34:178–184
Chen L, Feng Y, Okajima J, Komiya A, Maruyama S (2018) Production behavior and numerical analysis for 2017 methane hydrate extraction test of Shenhu, South China Sea. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 53:55–66
Fereidounpour A, Vatani A (2014) An investigation of interaction of drilling fluids with gas hydrates in drilling hydrate bearing sediments. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 20:422–427
Fereidounpour A, Vatani A (2015) Designing a Polyacrylate drilling fluid system to improve wellbore stability in hydrate bearing sediments. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 26:921–926
Fitzgerald GC, Castaldi MJ (2013) Thermal stimulation based methane production from hydrate bearing quartz sediment. Ind Eng Chem Res 52(19):6571–6581
Freij-Ayoub R, Tan C, Clennell B, Tohidi B, Yang JH (2007) A wellbore stability model for hydrate bearing sediments. J Petrol Sci Eng 57:209–220
Gai X, Sánchez M (2017) A geomechanical model for gas hydrate-bearing sediments. J Environ Geotech 4(2):143–156
Halliday W, Clapper DK, Smalling M (1998) New Gas Hydrate Inhibitors for Deepwater Drilling Fluids. In: Proceding of IADC/SPE Drilling Conference, Dallas.
Hao SQ (2011) A study to optimize drilling fluids to improve borehole stability in natural gas hydrate frozen ground. J Petrol Sci Eng 76(3):109–115
Hong H, Pooladi-Darvish M (2005) Simulation of depressurization for gas production from gas hydrate reservoirs. J Can Pet Technol 44(11):39–46
Jiang X, Li S, Zhang L (2012) Sensitivity analysis of gas production from Class I hydrate reservoir by depressurization. Energy 39(1):281–285
Klar A, Uchida S, Soga K, Yamamoto K (2013) Explicitly coupled thermal flow mechanical formulation for gas-hydrate sediments. SPE J 18(2):196–206
Klar A, Soga K, Ng MYA (2017) Coupled deformation–flow analysis for methane hydrate extraction. Géotechnique 60(10):765–776
Li G, Moridis GJ, Zhang K, Li XS (2011) The use of huff and puff method in a single horizontal well in gas production from marine gas hydrate deposits in the Shenhu Area of South China Sea. J Petrol Sci Eng 77(1):49–68
Li G, Li XS, Zhang KN, Li B, Zhang Y (2013) Effects of Impermeable Boundaries on Gas Production from Hydrate Accumulations in the Shenhu Area of the South China Sea. Energies 6(8):4078–4096
Li Q, Wang YL, Wang FL, Ning X, Zhang CB, Zhang JY, Zhang CL (2021) Factor analysis and mechanism disclosure of supercritical CO2 filtration behavior in tight shale reservoirs. Environ Sci Pollut Res. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-021-17045-w
Li QC, Cheng YF, Ansari U, Han Y, Liu X, Yan CL (2022) Experimental investigation on hydrate dissociation in near-wellbore region caused by invasion of drilling fluid: ultrasonic measurement and analysis. Environ Sci Pollut Res. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-021-18309-1
Li QC, Cheng YF, Li Q, Ansari U, Liu YW, Yan CL, Lei C (2018) Development and verification of the comprehensive model for physical properties of hydrate sediment. Arabian Journal of Geosciences 11(12),325: 1–16
Liu M, Yan J, LuY, et al (2016a) A Wellbore Stability Model for a Deviated Well in a Transversely Isotropic Formation Considering Poroelastic Effects. Rock Mech Rock Eng 49(9):3671–3686
Liu X, Zeng W, Liang L et al (2016b) Wellbore stability analysis for horizontal wells in shale formations. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 31:1–8
Luo M, Wang H, Yang S, Chen D (2013) Research advancement of natural gas hydrate in South China Sea. Bull Mineral Petrol Geochem 32:56–69 ((In Chinese))
Matsuda H, Yamakawa T, Sugai YC, Sasaki K (2016) Gas production from offshore methane hydrate layer and seabed subsidence by depressurization method. Engineering 8:353–364
McConnell DR, Zhang ZJ, Boswell R (2012) Review of progress in evaluating gas hydrate drilling hazards. Mar Pet Geol 34:209–223
Merey S (2016) Drilling of gas hydrate reservoirs. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 35:1167–1179
Moridis GJ, Reagan MT (2007) Strategies for gas production from oceanic class 3 hydrate accumulations. In: Proceding of Offshore Technology Conference, Houston
Ning FL, Zhang KN, Wu NY, Zhang L, Li G, Jiang GS, Yu YB, Liu L, Qin YH (2013) Invasion of drilling mud into gas-hydrate-bearing sediments. Part I: effect of drilling mud properties. Geophys J Int 193(3):1370–1384
Putra AEE, Nomura S, Mukasa S, Toyota H (2012) Hydrogen production by radio frequency plasma stimulation in methane hydrate at atmospheric pressure. Int J Hydrogen Energy 37(21):16000–16005
Qiu KB, Yamamoto K, Birchwood RA, Chen YR (2015) Well integrity evaluation for methane hydrate production in the deepwater Nankai trough. SPE Drill Complet 30(1):52–67
Rutqvist J, Moridis GJ (2007) Numerical studies on the geomechanical stability of hydrate-bearing sediments. SPE J 14(2):267–282
Rutqvist J, Moridis GJ, Grover T et al (2009) Geomechanical response of permafrost-associated hydrate deposits to depressurization-induced gas production. J Petrol Sci Eng 67(1–2):1–12
Sakamoto Y, Kakumoto M, Miyazaki K, Tenma M, Komai T, Yamaguchi T (2009) Numerical study on dissociation of methane hydrate and gas production behavior in laboratory-scale experiments for depressurization: part 3-numerical study on estimation of permeability in methane hydrate reservoir. Int J Offshore Polar Eng 19(2):124–134
Shi X, Cai W, Meng Y et al (2015) Wellbore stability analysis based on a new strength criterion. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 27:1005–1015
Sloan ED (1998) Clathrate hydrates of natural gases. Marcel Decker Inc, New York
Srungavarapu M, Patidar KK, Pathak AK, Mandal A (2018) Performance studies of water-based drilling fluid for drilling through hydrate bearing sediments. Appl Clay Sci 152:211–220
Su Z, Moridis GJ, Zhang KN, Yang R, Wu NY (2010) SS—gas hydrate: numerical investigation of gas production strategy for the hydrate deposits in the Shenhu area. In: Proceding of Offshore Technology Conference, Houston
Su Z, Huang L, Wu NY, Yang SX (2013) Effect of thermal stimulation on gas production from hydrate deposits in Shenhu area of the South China Sea. Sci China Earth Sci 56(4):601–610
Sun ZM, Zhang J, Liu CL, Zhao SJ, Ye YG (2013) On the determination of methane hydrate saturation and mechanical properties of sediments containing methane hydrate. J Exp Mech 28(6):747–754
Tang X, Sheng B, Zhang G et al (2014) Geothermal characteristics and hydrocarbon accumulation of the northern marginal basins, South China Sea. Chin J Geophys 57(1):64–78
Uchida S, Soga K, Yamamoto K (2012) Critical state soil constitutive model for methane hydrate soil. J Geophys Res 117(B3):3209–3221
Wang XJ, Lee MW, Wu SG, Yang SX (2012) Identification of gas hydrate dissociation from wireline-log data in the Shenhu area, South China Sea. Geophysics 77:125–134
Wang XJ, Lee M, Collett T, Yang SX, Guo YQ, Wu SG (2014a) Gas hydrate identified in sand-rich inferred sedimentary section using downhole logging and seismic data in Shenhu area, South China Sea. Mar Pet Geol 51:298–306
Wang X, Lee M, Collett T, Yang S, Guo Y, Wu S (2014b) Corrigendum to “gas hydrate identified in sand-rich inferred sedimentary section using downhole logging and seismic data in Shenhu area, South China Sea.” Mar Pet Geol 51(2):298–306
Wan Z, Xu X, Wang X, Xia B, Sun Y (2017) Geothermal analysis of boreholes in the shenhu gas hydrate drilling area, northern south china sea: influence of mud diapirs on hydrate occurrence. J Petrol Sci Eng 158:424–432
Wu SG, Wang JL (2018) On the China’s successful gas production test from marine gas hydrate reservoirs. Chin Sci Bull 63(1):2–8
Xu X, Wan Z, Wang X, Sun Y, Xia B (2016) The characteristics of heat flow in the Shenhu gas hydrate drilling area, northern South China Sea. Mar Geophys Res 37(4):1–11
Yan CL, Cheng YF, Li ML, Han ZY, Zhang HW, Li QC, Teng F, Ding JP (2017) Mechanical experiments and constitutive model of natural gas hydrate reservoirs. Int J Hydrogen Energy 42(31):19810–19818
Yan CL, Ren X, Cheng YYF, Song BJ, Li Y, Tian WQ (2020) Geomechanical issues in the exploitation of natural gas hydrate. Gondwana Res 81:403–422
Yang SX, Zhang M, Liang JQ, Lu JA, Zhang ZJ, Holland M, Sha ZB (2015) Preliminary results of China’s Third Gas Hydrate Drilling Expedition: A critical step from discovery to development in the South China Sea. Fire Ice 15(2):1–6
Zhang H, Lu HL, Liang JQ, Wu NY (2016) The methane hydrate accumulation controlled compellingly by sediment grain at Shenhu, northern South China Sea. Chin Sci Bull 61:388–397 ((in Chinese))
Zhao J, Sun Y, Guo W, Xu H, Wang Q, Chen C, Li G, Jia R (2010) Design and experimental study of a gas hydrate mud cooling system. Energy Explor Exploit 28(5):351–364
Zhao JF, Wang JQ, Liu WG, Song YC (2015) Analysis of heat transfer effects on gas production from methane hydrate by thermal stimulation. Int J Heat Mass Transf 87:145–150
Zhao X, Qiu ZS, Zhao C, Xu JG, Zhang YB (2019) Inhibitory effect of water-based drilling fluid on methane hydrate dissociation. Chem Eng Sci 199:113–122
Zhao X, Qiu ZS, Zhang Z, Zhang YB (2020) Relationship between the gas hydrate suppression temperature and water activity in the presence of thermodynamic hydrate inhibitor. Fuel, 264: 116776
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by Program for the National Key Research and Development Program (Grant No. 2016YFC0304005) and the Postdoctoral Program of Henan Polytechnic University (Grant No. 712108/210).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
LQ: simulation, programing and data analysis. WJ: original draft preparation and manuscript revision.
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
On behalf of all authors, they declare that there is no conflict of interests.
Appendix A: Derivation method for determining function of f(P m )
Relationship between σj, σi and σr mentioned in Eqs. (11) may exhibits three possibilities: σj > σi > σr, σj > σr > σi or σr > σi > σj. Accordingly, derivation method for determining function of f(Pm) was discussed in the following three cases.
(1) When the case of σj > σi > σr occurs, σ1 and σ3 can be expressed as:
The final form of f(Pm) was obtained in this case by substituting Eqs. (A-1) into Eqs. (13):
Taking the first derivative of f(Pm) function, we can get:
In Eqs. (A-3), the six variables A, B, C, D, E and F were written as
(2) When the case of σj > σr > σi occurs, σ1 and σ3 can be expressed as:
Function f(Pm) and its first derivative can be written as Eqs. (A-6) and Eqs. (7) respectively.
(3) When the case of σr > σi > σj occurs, σ1 and σ3 can be expressed as:
Similarly, function f(Pm) and its first derivative can be written as Eqs. (A-9) and Eqs. (10) respectively.
Based on the function f(Pm) and its first derivative derived above, the Newton–Raphson iteration was obtained.
where, Pm0 is the pre-assumed fluid pressure in MPa. Pm1 is the calculated result in MPa. Moreover, in order to facilitate readers to understand the role of each function in these Matlab codes submitted as “Supplementary Material”, Fig. A-1 gives the corresponding structure diagram.
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by Program for the National Key Research and Development Program (Grant No. 2016YFC0304005) and the Postdoctoral Program of Henan Polytechnic University (Grant No. 712108/210).
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Li, Q., Wu, J. Factors affecting the lower limit of the safe mud weight window for drilling operation in hydrate-bearing sediments in the Northern South China Sea. Geomech. Geophys. Geo-energ. Geo-resour. 8, 82 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40948-022-00396-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40948-022-00396-0